Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Is It Just Me, Or Is Phatmass...


Recommended Posts

veritasluxmea
Posted (edited)

acting mean/weird lately? 

 

I'm new, so I don't know what to call it, but it's been... meh. and not the good kind of meh. The bad kind. The "lose interest and leave because of users" meh. Frankly, I can think of at least one person who needs to change the way they're currently posting. Sure, there's been some good stuff lately and interesting things to think about, but I'm not going to be a pollyanna. I'm not going to flag anything or report anything because it's more of a general attitude, but it needs to change. 

 

idk, whatever. Where have all the cool people gone. /rant

Edited by veritasluxmea
Posted

 

idk, whatever. Where have all the cool people gone. /rant

I dunno about anyone else, but I'm stepping back for a few days until things settle down.

Not A Mallard
Posted

All the cool people are playing hide-and-seek.  They still don't know that I've given up.

Posted

Setting certain posters on ignore might help.

Posted

I guess I might be more of a drama llama than I thought.  There have been some insulting things said, but unless I've missed something (which is highly possible), it's been par for the course.  But I probably tend to lurk a lot more than others.

Posted

acting mean/weird lately? 

 

I'm new, so I don't know what to call it, but it's been... meh. and not the good kind of meh. The bad kind. The "lose interest and leave because of users" meh. Frankly, I can think of at least one person who needs to change the way they're currently posting. Sure, there's been some good stuff lately and interesting things to think about, but I'm not going to be a pollyanna. I'm not going to flag anything or report anything because it's more of a general attitude, but it needs to change. 

 

idk, whatever. Where have all the cool people gone. /rant

 

Oh, honey! You ain't seen nothin' yet!

 

I'd say it's been remarkably quiet around here lately, especially given that the midterm elections are upon us. We used to have knock-down-drag-out rumbles on this board! I think pholks have been working very hard to restrain themselves. 

 

For which I am eternally grateful. 

veritasluxmea
Posted

I dunno about anyone else, but I'm stepping back for a few days until things settle down.

Good idea.

 

It just kind of bothers me that people can openly disagree with Church Teaching- not opinions, teaching- and still remain Catholics in good standing. I'm new to phatmass, but I get the sense these kinds of discussions are typical so I'm just going to pull back a bit. The internet's a big place, anyways. And most people here are great, even ones I whom I disagree with. 

 

Just wondering, if you put a user on ignore, do you see other people's responses to their posts? 

PhuturePriest
Posted (edited)

Good idea.

 

It just kind of bothers me that people can openly disagree with Church Teaching- not opinions, teaching- and still remain Catholics in good standing. I'm new to phatmass, but I get the sense these kinds of discussions are typical so I'm just going to pull back a bit. The internet's a big place, anyways. And most people here are great, even ones I whom I disagree with. 

 

Just wondering, if you put a user on ignore, do you see other people's responses to their posts? 

 

I assure you that such a thing was not the case when I first came on here several years ago, and it was not the case when this site was created. There has been a very large influx of modernists and dissidents slowly creeping in in the past few years, and I assure you the fact that you can get ridiculed for defending Church teaching and praised for opposing it is just as alarming to me and some others as it is to you.

Edited by FuturePacker
Posted

People talk about Phatmass going through cycles. That is clearly true, IMO. But I think the cycles are getting closer together and more severe.

Posted

Just wondering, if you put a user on ignore, do you see other people's responses to their posts? 

 

Yes. And if you've blocked Phatmasser X, but Phatmasser Z quotes him, you'll see that, too.

Basilisa Marie
Posted (edited)

I assure you that such a thing was not the case when I first came on here several years ago, and it was not the case when this site was created. There has been a very large influx of modernists and dissidents slowly creeping in in the past few years, and I assure you the fact that you can get ridiculed for defending Church teaching and praised for opposing it is just as alarming to me and some others as it is to you.

 

That's funny because I've been feeling a rather vocal presence of hardlined traditionalists, and the so-called "modernists" and "liberals" are lurking more. Heck, even the moderates are lurking more. 

Edited by Basilisa Marie
PhuturePriest
Posted

That's funny because I've been feeling a rather vocal presence of hardlined traditionalists, and the so-called "modernists" and "liberals" are lurking more. Heck, even the moderates are lurking more. 

 

The presence of traditionalists has been in response to people such as Superblue, Blazeingstar, and Benedictus.

Basilisa Marie
Posted

The presence of traditionalists has been in response to people such as Superblue, Blazeingstar, and Benedictus.

 

Lol I wasn't going to call people out here, because I don't see it as a response to "liberal types."  What I see happening are traditionalists talking to traditionalists and starting lots of threads that are very, uh, traditionalist friendly, mostly in response to the synod and stuff related to it.  Sure, that could be remedied by non-traditionalists making their own posts and threads. But at least for me, all the synod talk is starting to turn into another topic like homosexuality. In fact, it has. Homosexuality has become the Godwin's Law of Phatmass. 

 

It'll be nice when something else happens in Catholic World. :P

PhuturePriest
Posted

Lol I wasn't going to call people out here, because I don't see it as a response to "liberal types."  What I see happening are traditionalists talking to traditionalists and starting lots of threads that are very, uh, traditionalist friendly, mostly in response to the synod and stuff related to it.  Sure, that could be remedied by non-traditionalists making their own posts and threads. But at least for me, all the synod talk is starting to turn into another topic like homosexuality. In fact, it has. Homosexuality has become the

 

Oh, I knew you weren't, but I was. :P

 

Yeah, that was my point I was making. A lot of things happen behind the lines, and I can verify that all of these threads are happening in response to the growing openness about not being in line with Church teaching.

Basilisa Marie
Posted

But where, exactly, have there been Catholics who openly and flagrantly oppose Church teaching? Maybe I haven't been reading close enough, but aren't we supposed to report posts of Church Militant people that blatantly promote heresy? I've seen some people getting close, but nothing obvious.  I'm not looking for examples, I'm just worried it's going to turn into a witch hunt of people who don't do Catholicism exactly the way I do Catholicism.  

PhuturePriest
Posted

But where, exactly, have there been Catholics who openly and flagrantly oppose Church teaching? Maybe I haven't been reading close enough, but aren't we supposed to report posts of Church Militant people that blatantly promote heresy? I've seen some people getting close, but nothing obvious.  I'm not looking for examples, I'm just worried it's going to turn into a witch hunt of people who don't do Catholicism exactly the way I do Catholicism.  

 

A very good reminder to keep such things tempered and level.

 

As far as I am aware, none of the people who are making questionable statements are Church Militants. However, if someone is phishy, they should be labeled as such, regardless if they are a Church Militant right now.

Posted

I saw a Church Militant supporting heresy. I didn't report it, but I think someone else did, because I called it out publicly.

 

I do agree with Nihil that Phatmass goes through cycles. I had a little outburst once when Phatmass got REALLY mean (like, exponentially meaner than it was when you started this thread). I haven't been around long enough (2 years? 3? I don't remember...) to notice whether the cycles are getting closer together. But yeah, sometimes it is definitely necessary to step back for a while, and I have a whopping four people blocked, just because I find them to be pretty much always nasty.

 

IMO, though, Phatmass these days is just DEAD. I mean geez, there is really NOTHING going on in here! (Hence my uncustomary presence in the Lame Board!)

 

I will say that, when I first saw nastiness on Phatmass, I was totally shocked. I think when one joins a Catholic forum, one expects better. But part of Phatmass is evangelizing the lost, and we let the lost become members, too. So after a few "pull-backs" from Phatmass, and returns, I eventually just accepted that Catholics are like anyone else and sometimes they just get awful. I honestly feel like being a member of Phatmass has helped me to accept people's limitations, to stay charitable even in REALLY challenging interactions (not that I always succeed!), and to try to just go on loving my fellow Christians even when they're being doofuses.

 

All of which, I think, are good things! :)

Posted

I have noticed that things are a bit dead around here.

Maybe some of the nastiness is from "cabin fever". Basically the same old stuff gets rehashed over and over because there is nothing new to talk about. Hmmm...

I think there also needs to be some charitable fraternal correction as well.

 

Posted

One thing I have noticed is an increasing lack of basic kindness and empathy. I always try to remember what St Dorotheos of Gaza wrote (I know I've posted this quotation before, but it's so good it bears repeating):

 

I heard of one person that when he came to one of his friends and found the room in disarray and even dirty, he would say to himself: "Blessed is this person, because having deferred his concerns for earthly cares, he has concentrated his mind that much toward Heaven, that he doesn’t even have time to tidy up his room." But when he came to another friend’s place and found his room tidy and neat, he would say to himself; "The soul of this person is as clean as his room, and the condition of the room speaks of his soul." And he never judged another that he was negligent or proud, but through his kind disposition, saw good in everyone and received benefits from everyone. May the good Lord grant us the same kind disposition, so that we too may receive benefits from everyone and so that we never notice the failings of others.

 

 

I think it would make a wonderful difference if we all tried to do that, for everyone.

 

Sometimes I catch myself not wanting to do it for certain people and thinking to myself, "There is absolutely no positive way to look at what they've just done." If I'm honest with myself, it's because at these times I prioritise being in the right far more than I prize being kind, and when I get into this mindset, the excuses are easy - I am defending the truth, truth is important, I can't let this pass, etc., etc. But that's all they are - excuses.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...