Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Is It Just Me, Or Is Phatmass...


Recommended Posts

Credo in Deum
Posted

I have noticed that things are a bit dead around here.

Maybe some of the nastiness is from "cabin fever". Basically the same old stuff gets rehashed over and over because there is nothing new to talk about. Hmmm...

I think there also needs to be some charitable fraternal correction as well.

 

I've noticed it's been really dead around here as well.   :(

 

 

On the upside I look at the dysfunctionality exhibited on this site as a sign that we are a real phamily.  

 

 

http://youtu.be/BgXDYiHhp5Y

Basilisa Marie
Posted

Maybe it'd help if threads full of debate actually got moved to the debate table? Clear the air in places like Open Mic and let the people who want to argue, argue? 

 

I've also noticed a lot of snark and unkindness lately. Again, nothing quite up to the level of a personal attack, but a lot of nasty insinuations on all sides. Who someone seems to be on Phatmass isn't the whole story of who they are in real life.  

veritasluxmea
Posted

All good points. I second moving threads that have morphed into debates to the debate table. I'm new but when I joined phatmass wasn't this... flat. I didn't know if I was just over thinking things so I didn't want to say anything, but I'm glad to see I'm not the only one who things things are off.

 

I have seen personal attacks on some people and just plain rudeness in some areas. Last month someone stated something along the lines of "as if we're supposed to believe you read the bible," which I reported but last I checked it hadn't been taken down. It was really uncalled for. Fortunately the other person was polite about it, but wow. I agree that what people post online isn't the whole story and when people explain where they're coming from debates are a whole lot more charitable.

Posted

Yes, off.   These days I am happy enough to just post in my walking and book reading threads in lame board and do a few acts of charity when I can in other areas.  I've pretty much written the site off other than that.  Too much lack of charity, too much of a lot of stuff.  God has better things for me to do with my life... and I think a lot of people have gotten to that point.  I read a few threads, but usually just don't say anything any more.  Truly sad, but yes, it has gotten to that point.  MAY do the Advent thread, but just not sure.   

puellapaschalis
Posted

There was a much more vibrant and much less heterodox Catholic atmosphere before (my hiatus was five years long, though).

 

On the other hand, the whole Church is in flux: 'conservatism' is not surviving and the battle is between the 'libs' and the 'trads'. I remember the vitality being mainly that of the 'conservatives', so it does not surprise me that discussions here are also mainly between 'libs' and 'trads' and that the 'cons' have fallen away. The 'no intra-Catholic debate' rule just can't survive (and as dUSt pointed out a while back, such debate is rampant), because it has become very necessary for Catholics to debate because of the current situation.

 

It's very unpleasant, but I think it's unavoidable.

Credo in Deum
Posted

I blame that Credo fella!

Posted

Yes, off.   These days I am happy enough to just post in my walking and book reading threads in lame board and do a few acts of charity when I can in other areas.  I've pretty much written the site off other than that.  Too much lack of charity, too much of a lot of stuff.  God has better things for me to do with my life... and I think a lot of people have gotten to that point.  I read a few threads, but usually just don't say anything any more.  Truly sad, but yes, it has gotten to that point.  MAY do the Advent thread, but just not sure.   

 

Oh my gosh! But you HAVE to do the Advent thread! I've been looking forward to the saint and virtue drawing for months now!!!

PhuturePriest
Posted

I blame that Credo fella!

 

He's always struck me as an untrustable weasel type of guy, if you ask me.

Credo in Deum
Posted

That sounds like complete garbage!

veritasluxmea
Posted

There was a much more vibrant and much less heterodox Catholic atmosphere before (my hiatus was five years long, though).

 

On the other hand, the whole Church is in flux: 'conservatism' is not surviving and the battle is between the 'libs' and the 'trads'. I remember the vitality being mainly that of the 'conservatives', so it does not surprise me that discussions here are also mainly between 'libs' and 'trads' and that the 'cons' have fallen away. The 'no intra-Catholic debate' rule just can't survive (and as dUSt pointed out a while back, such debate is rampant), because it has become very necessary for Catholics to debate because of the current situation.

 

It's very unpleasant, but I think it's unavoidable.

I didn't even know there was such a rule. 

 

But how would you define conservative, trad, or liberal? Even the graph below doesn't cover it, because radical traditionalists aren't good Catholics, and I know people who are loyal to the beliefs of the Church but are involved with charismatic renewal and like praise and worship music. 

 

spectrum1.jpg

Posted

acting mean/weird lately? 

 

I'm new, so I don't know what to call it, but it's been... meh. and not the good kind of meh. The bad kind. The "lose interest and leave because of users" meh. Frankly, I can think of at least one person who needs to change the way they're currently posting. Sure, there's been some good stuff lately and interesting things to think about, but I'm not going to be a pollyanna. I'm not going to flag anything or report anything because it's more of a general attitude, but it needs to change. 

 

idk, whatever. Where have all the cool people gone. /rant

 

oooh, what drama have I missed meow?

Posted

 

spectrum1.jpg

 

This is hilarious. Thanks for posting it!

 

Did anyone notice the END end points?

veritasluxmea
Posted

This is hilarious. 

I have seen this graphic used with all seriousness to clarify those terms. 

Posted

I have seen this graphic used with all seriousness to clarify those terms. 

 

I'm not sure if that's sad, or even more funny...

Posted

I'm pretty sure it IS intended seriously.... :(

puellapaschalis
Posted

Perhaps the rule was done away with whilst I was in meatspace, though I recall dUSt mentioning it on the mod board not so long ago.

 

I used those terms because any terms I use would be problematic, and at least these, whilst horribly political and thus out of context, conjure up the intended groupings. I'm wary of the graphic above, but then I'm wary of anything external anyone tries to use to understand the point I'm making (or worse, put words into my mouth).

 

Alongside the doctrinal factors, I think there is an enormous social factor at play. There are people here who have known each other for a very long time, and they have been posting on Phatmass for a very long time.

 

There are two things I've noticed as a result of this. First, they give each other a pass, on-board, in terms of orthodoxy. For the majority I don't think this is intentional; after all they're dossing with their mates online. But it gives a shady impression of the "T" part of the name (and thus the "HA") to those who stumble on Phatmass from elsewhere. Secondly, they can be incredibly cliquey, to the point of a perceived exclusion of everyone else. Both of these mean that the "P" is taken much less seriously.

 

Phatmass is less vibrant, as I mentioned before. I do not remember such a small group of people who proportionally were responsible for the most posts. People move on, of course, but that Phatmass has not attracted such a large second or third generation who are vocally doctrinally sound and clear shows that the "Pham" had cliquey, elite (in the negative sense) tendencies even way back then.

 

 

veritasluxmea
Posted

I can't add much to Puella's comment. 

 

As for the graphic, I think it's useful in the sense it kind of gives a broad overview to what a lot of people mean when they use those terms. It does show that there is a lot of variety in Catholicism. However, it doesn't really address doctrinal loyalty, which is the main issue when those terms are used, and it isn't completely accurate- people don't fall so easily into any one category. 

CountrySteve937
Posted (edited)

Yes, off.   These days I am happy enough to just post in my walking and book reading threads in lame board and do a few acts of charity when I can in other areas.  I've pretty much written the site off other than that.  Too much lack of charity, too much of a lot of stuff.  God has better things for me to do with my life... and I think a lot of people have gotten to that point.  I read a few threads, but usually just don't say anything any more.  Truly sad, but yes, it has gotten to that point.  MAY do the Advent thread, but just not sure.   

 

Kind of off point of the thread, but I hope you do your  virtue and continent you must pray for for a year thread,  I really enjoyed that one. 

 

 

May we all learn the virtue of mercy

 

Kyrie Elesion. 

Edited by CountrySteve21
Posted

AnneLine but but we NEED the advent thread. Goodness knows courage and meekness were something I had to work on developing this year...

Posted

Ok, ok, praying about it.

 

Lil Red is the go-to person for the Saints; all I do is virtues & continents.

 

What ya think, Red, do you think Phatmass -- and we -- are up for another year of this?

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...