Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

I Really Struggle To Find Anything Good About False Religion


Recommended Posts

Posted

This looks like something from one of those Richard Dawkins-style atheists who think that religion is something fundamentally awful, backwards, and destructive while science has always been progressive and neutral and has never powered any murders (eugenics, anyone?). A lot of atrocities have been committed through science (Nagasaki and Hiroshima were greeted as a scientific triumph, for example) because it's only as pure as the people who use it. The same is true of religion.

 

I try not to get into arguments like this any more, as they often seem to be about one group of people attempting to make themselves feel superior at the expense of another group. If "all have sinned and fallen short of the glory of God", as St Paul tells us, then such discussions are pointless anyway.

Posted

I said false religions and should of just come out and said Islam. Another beheading just reported.

Posted (edited)

I know little about science and don't even know about the stuff you referenced. Will google it. Thought the comet thing was really cool this week. And I am really sick of Islam. I agree with the atheist like Maher and Harris when they talk about it. Anyhow God bless.

Edited by Guest
Oremus Pro Invicem
Posted

Science on the other hand...

...has nothing to do with religion, so why it's brought up in a discussion about religion is odd. Science deals with physical realities not spiritual realities. The picture provided in the OP is one which promotes a false view of science in that it should be compared with religion and that one can either be scientific or religious, but not both. This view stunts our growth has humans beings who are made both body and soul and who are capable of a two types of knowledge, that of matter and of persons.
Posted (edited)

I think science deals with spiritual realities. Consciousness. The Big Bang.

Edited by Guest
Posted (edited)

Sure there's more.

Edited by Guest
Posted (edited)

Josh, I see in you something that I used to see in myself: The news gets you very upset. When I noticed that reading/watching news was really throwing my mood and preventing me from living a happy, positive life, I stopped reading/watching.

 

I still don't read/watch news, because it still really upsets me.

 

Maybe you should try a news fast for a month and see how it goes? Instead of reading/watching news, read/watch nature documentaries that increase your wonder of God and His creation. Read the Bible. Watch EWTN. Anything but the news!

Edited by Gabriela
Posted

I haven't owned a tv in 5 years. Just see the stuff on Facebook mostly. You're right it does anger me. I agree with what you say about a news fast. And I used to like watching EWTN some good stuff on there. Thanks for the reply and have a great Sunday. God bless!

Posted

Josh, I see in you something that I used to see in myself: The news gets you very upset. When I noticed that reading/watching news was really throwing my mood and preventing me from living a happy, positive life, I stopped reading/watching.

 

I still don't read/watch news, because it still really upsets me.

 

Maybe you should try a news fast for a month and see how it goes? Instead of reading/watching news, read/watch nature documentaries that increase your wonder of God and His creation. Read the Bible. Watch EWTN. Anything but the news!

 

I think this is really good advice. It's not good to be ignore what's happening in the world but TV and newspaper websites aren't always the best way to find out about it, and if they're causing you to get upset or to be less than charitable then they're certainly not worthwhile. I stopped reading the comments on news articles for the same reason. I do follow the press, but I always pray beforehand for a kind heart in reading, and I remind myself that there is no human crime so great that God's mercy and love are not greater.

Oremus Pro Invicem
Posted

I haven't owned a tv in 5 years. Just see the stuff on Facebook mostly. You're right it does anger me. I agree with what you say about a news fast. And I used to like watching EWTN some good stuff on there. Thanks for the reply and have a great Sunday. God bless!


I just recently deactivated my Facebook account in order to take a break from all of the negativity that is constantly posted. Some of the things and comments I've read on Facebook make me want to weep for the future.
Posted

I think this is really good advice. It's not good to be ignore what's happening in the world but TV and newspaper websites aren't always the best way to find out about it, and if they're causing you to get upset or to be less than charitable then they're certainly not worthwhile. I stopped reading the comments on news articles for the same reason. I do follow the press, but I always pray beforehand for a kind heart in reading, and I remind myself that there is no human crime so great that God's mercy and love are not greater.

 

This is a really good idea. Many sisters "pray the news": i.e., they pray before they open a newspaper, and then they open it with the express purpose of finding things to pray about, and then they close it once they've got some ideas. The point is not to find out what's going on in the world, but to help the world. I think that could be a good practice for you, Josh, if you can't bear the idea of reading news at all.

 

Also, I do get some exposure to what's happening in the world via news parody programs: I listen to "Wait! Wait! Don't tell me!" every week and check in on the Onion and sometimes Jon Stewart and Stephen Colbert. Listening to the news in a humorous way helps me to keep perspective on things, so that I don't get totally overwhelmed by it.

 

But praying is probably better. ;)

Posted

The second picture is identical to pictures from WW2 of the actions of the Einsatzgruppen. 

Posted

i like to keep in mind that the key element in true religion*  is ego-denial and self-sacrifice. Human beings are not born equipped knowing how to do that. A religion, even if it not a revealed religion, can teach them how. And a whole lot of good comes from that.

 

*(I am using the phrase "true religion" here to refer to authentic expressions of the religious impulse universal in mankind, not "the" truly revealed religion, of which I believe there is only one.) 

PhuturePriest
Posted (edited)

From a purely scientific viewpoint, the Final Solution (The official term the Nazis called the atrocities of Auschwitz) was very scientifically impressive, especially given the technology at the time. The atom bomb is also quite ingenious, as are mustard gas bombs. Obviously, not everything ingenious and made from science is good, and it is incredibly dangerous that mainstream scientists claim it is. There would be no World War II without ships, planes, missiles, and guns, and there would be no Holocaust without the industrial revolution to plant the seeds for the machinery used to systematically slaughter 2,000-3,000 Jews per hour at Auschwitz. Science is morally neutral, not inherently good, and I find it deeply troubling that self-important idiots like Richard Dawkins preach it is inherently a moral good. This is why philosophy needs to be taught once more in schools.

Edited by PhuturePriest

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...