Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

I Really Struggle To Find Anything Good About False Religion


Recommended Posts

Posted

philosophy needs to be taught once more in schools.

 

Oh, AMEN!

Posted

i like to keep in mind that the key element in true religion*  is ego-denial and self-sacrifice. Human beings are not born equipped knowing how to do that. A religion, even if it not a revealed religion, can teach them how. And a whole lot of good comes from that.

 

*(I am using the phrase "true religion" here to refer to authentic expressions of the religious impulse universal in mankind, not "the" truly revealed religion, of which I believe there is only one.) 

 

can't give you enough props.

 

for the op, for a 'false' religion, islam sure does teach a lot of good things and produce a lot of good people.

 

ego denial and self-sacrifice, imitating our lord on the cross, crucifying our selfish desires and dying to our absurd, ever-hungry self, belongs to islam too.

Ash Wednesday
Posted

Overgeneralizing stuff like that just tick me off. (That is not directed at you, OP, but in particular the anti-religion/secular humanist crowd that create arguments like that.)

 

You could take a picture of cruel testing on animals and humans and juxtapose it with a picture of Mother Teresa at a soup kitchen for the same result. It's just a childish way of making a statement in my mind.

 

At the very least, I've never been a fan of pitting science against religion, and vice versa. To me they are both valuable but intended to answer different sets of questions about the universe and human condition.

 

pg-34-pope-getty.jpg

 

"Why can't we have both?"

 

I, too, struggle a great deal with Islam. Not going to lie. It's something I'd probably be interested in discussing with some Muslims that I do know, but haven't yet discerned the right time and place.

 

That said, it's not fair when people make generalizations about Catholicism because of pedophile priests, so looking at it from their perspective, while I find many aspects of Islam problematic, it's just not constructive to make sweeping generalizations about Islam or its adherents.

Posted (edited)

Yea I made this post out of anger yesterday when they beheaded another victim. I wanted to put Islam in the title but chickened out. And to Kia what good things does Islam teach? From what I know it teaches to oppress the hell out of women. It teaches to kill people if they won't convert. And if you want to leave it teaches to murder you too. This alone makes it real tough for me to see how it has any good thing to offer. Sure we have the old testament but when God actually did come He wouldn't even pick up a sword. Actions speak louder then words and that's good enough for me to put the allegorical label on a bunch of it and give me peace of mind. As for Islam I would be happy if we saved the trees and never made another koran.

Edited by Guest
Posted (edited)

I think the meme would of been better if it said Islam. Most religion I think is ok. Like Mormonism for example. I think it's really ridiculous but it teaches some good things. And they aren't going around murdering people and trying to take the world over. And for any atheist reading this I know you think Catholicism is just as ridiculous. But it's the true religion so chill. Ok everyone have a good day.

Edited by Guest
Posted (edited)

Overgeneralizing stuff like that just tick me off. (That is not directed at you, OP, but in particular the anti-religion/secular humanist crowd that create arguments like that.)

You could take a picture of cruel testing on animals and humans and juxtapose it with a picture of Mother Teresa at a soup kitchen for the same result. It's just a childish way of making a statement in my mind.

At the very least, I've never been a fan of pitting science against religion, and vice versa. To me they are both valuable but intended to answer different sets of questions about the universe and human condition.

pg-34-pope-getty.jpg

"Why can't we have both?"

I, too, struggle a great deal with Islam. Not going to lie. It's something I'd probably be interested in discussing with some Muslims that I do know, but haven't yet discerned the right time and place.

That said, it's not fair when people make generalizations about Catholicism because of pedophile priests, so looking at it from their perspective, while I find many aspects of Islam problematic, it's just not constructive to make sweeping generalizations about Islam or its adherents.

Agreed except for the end. I don't think it's a sweeping generalization. Sure there are cool Muslims but their religion and it's ideology is toxic. Edited by Guest
Oremus Pro Invicem
Posted

How to Compare World Religion

 

http://youtu.be/XA6aIhHzXkw

Ash Wednesday
Posted

Okay I'm not sure why the Phorum Guidlines are only pinned on the Debate Table but just a general reminder before this thread turns into a gas station on fire, use some discretion when discussing other religions.  If offering critique, remember to keep it constructive.

 

http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/topic/81147-phorum-guidelines/

Posted

I understand your feelings Josh.

Bro fist. 

Ash Wednesday
Posted

Yep I crossed the line. Thanks for the reminder.

 

To be fair I'm not sure the guidelines are always immediately apparent to people and probably should be more visible because not everyone visits the Debate Table. Unless I got dropped too many times as a baby, I didn't see them posted elsewhere.

Posted (edited)

Yea I made this post out of anger yesterday when they beheaded another victim. I wanted to put Islam in the title but chickened out. And to Kia what good things does Islam teach?

 

Josh, the man who was beheaded was a Muslim. He was a convert who added the name Abdul-Rahman ('Servant of the Merciful One' in Arabic) to his own and wanted to devote his life to helping others as an aid worker. A former cellmate said this about him: "Peter told me about how important Islam was to him, how much it helped to overcome his situation in captivity. And he was a very dedicated Muslim. He gave me the impression that he was a bit fragile, but that Islam was strengthening him."

 

I don't think you should take lessons in anyone's religion from Sam Harris or Bill Maher. You would not appreciate it if someone used them as a source for information on Christianity. They're no more accurate when it comes to Peter Abdul-Rahman Kassig's faith, which should be allowed to speak for itself. I think that's the best mark of respect we can pay him now he's gone.

 

Also, the soldiers currently fighting IS and risking horrific things if they're captured are Muslim too. I think a common mistake when people are very upset is to generalize and oversimplify things too much.

Edited by beatitude
Posted (edited)

Sam Harris and Bill Maher are really knowledgeable about Islam as well as other things. Just because they're atheist doesn't mean they don't know what they are talking about. Obviously I don't agree with their opinion about God but I do agree with other stuff.

Edited by Guest
Posted

But plenty of people would say, "Sam Harris and Bill Maher are really knowledgeable about Christianity as well as other things." What makes you think they're knowledgeable on this?

 
I don't think they're knowledgeable because I live in a Muslim-majority city in the Middle East, have been an aid worker in Muslim-majority societies, and also have an advanced degree in theology and comparative religion, and what they say goes against what I have learnt academically, professionally, and personally. Where belief in God is concerned, they are polemicists, and they whip up anger - very successfully too.
 
I'm part of a secular institute founded in the spirituality of Bl. Charles de Foucauld, whose own reversion to Catholicism from atheism was inspired by the simplicity and purity of the faith he witnessed among Tuareg Muslims in the Sahara desert, where he went as a French explorer and soldier. Later, as a monk and a priest, he decided to return to the Sahara and dedicate his life to the service of those people. The two communities founded in his spirituality - Little Sisters of Jesus and Little Brothers of Jesus - are constitutionally obliged to maintain a strong presence in Muslim countries and to pray for Muslim people. The LSJs are just down the road from me here. We meet and pray together often, and their little convent (known as a 'fraternity') is almost always overflowing with Muslim friends and neighbours who appreciate them very much. Those neighbours are remarkably ordinary people, of the standard variety you find on this planet, and for many of them their faith is central in trying to lead a better life.
 
I think the measure of how right someone is the love that they generate. Are their words loving and do they inspire others to love, to be better people, holier people? I look at the Little Sisters and I can see them doing this through their lives of prayer and service, especially where they are in Iraq. Bl. Charles said "Cry the Gospel with your life" and they are doing that. I hear vicious and spiteful-sounding rants from celebrity atheists, and while I'm sure they're also contributing some good to the world, it isn't through their words when they talk like that. Love in speech is a good measure of how much truth is being spoken.
Posted (edited)

They are knowledgeable on Christianity. They think it's ridiculous and a fairly tale. That's their right. The core doctrine of Islam is to take over the world and murder whoever won't covert. I don't see why Catholics feel obliged to defend it. Especially when everyday there are new murders and more oppression of people all in the name of allah. I'm sorry but I agree with the atheist on this one. They are speaking logically and making perfect sense.

Edited by Guest
Posted

My anger doesn't come from what Bill and Sam say about islam. It comes from all the murder that is unending with this religion.

Posted

They are knowledgeable on Christianity. They think it's ridiculous and it's a fairly tale and that's their right. The core doctrine of Islam is to take over the world and murder whoever won't covert. I don't see why Catholics feel obliged to defend it. Especially when everyday there are new murders and more oppression of people all in the name of allah. I'm sorry but I agree with the atheist on this one. They are speaking logically and making perfect sense.

 

I disagree with you on their knowledge of Christianity. I've read stuff they've written and it's not that they're simply saying it's a fairytale and ridiculous - they don't represent Christian theology as I understand it, at any rate.

 

What you present as a core belief of Islam is not what most Muslims would agree to be a core belief of Islam. I don't feel obliged to defend any religion; I just feel that we should try to relate to the followers of every faith on a human level, and to listen to what they tell us about how they believe and practise rather than relying on Sam Harris or Bill Maher to speak for them.

 

There have been multiple Islam debates on Phatmass and it's not really a subject I'm interested in pursuing any more. I've said all I can on this topic.

KnightofChrist
Posted

There are good Catholics and bad Catholics, there are good Muslims and bad Muslims. But there is no good thing in Islam or any other false religion. Yes there are some good truths in false religions, just like there can be good ingredients in a poisoned cake. Some truths do not make a false religion good or true, just as some good ingredients do not make a poisoned cake good. When truths are mixed with error the truths become error just as when good ingredients are mixed with poison they become bad. However just because a person may eat of a poisoned cake doesn't make them a bad person, and just because someone belongs to a religion that is false does not make them a bad person. Such people are not evil but sick and in need of a physician. The Physician. Our Lord Jesus Christ, and His one and only true bride Holy Mother Church.

 

 

Posted (edited)

I disagree with you on their knowledge of Christianity. I've read stuff they've written and it's not that they're simply saying it's a fairytale and ridiculous - they don't represent Christian theology as I understand it, at any rate.

What you present as a core belief of Islam is not what most Muslims would agree to be a core belief of Islam. I don't feel obliged to defend any religion; I just feel that we should try to relate to the followers of every faith on a human level, and to listen to what they tell us about how they believe and practise rather than relying on Sam Harris or Bill Maher to speak for them.

There have been multiple Islam debates on Phatmass and it's not really a subject I'm interested in pursuing any more. I've said all I can on this topic.

You're right Bill and Sam don't represent the theology correctly. They take the easy route and go after the Bible beating fundamentalist more often then not. They are blinded and don't see God even though He's so easy to see if He's pursued. I see what you are saying about most Muslims not thinking world domination and murdering whoever won't convert is a core belief. I don't know if I agree with the word "most" but whatever. And props to you for wanting to show the love of Christ to these people. I commend you for it and that's what we're called to do. I just don't think there is any reason to sugar coat the religion and what it teaches. I would feel the same way about Christianity if Christians were going around murdering everyone and oppressing humans using the Old Testament as justification. Mabey they used to but I haven't seen it in my 33 years. And I'm only Catholic Christian because of Jesus the Prince Of Peace. He refused to even pick up a sword. Anyhow God bless and have a good day. Edited by Guest
Posted

There are good Catholics and bad Catholics, there are good Muslims and bad Muslims. But there is no good thing in Islam or any other false religion. Yes there are some good truths in false religions, just like there can be good ingredients in a poisoned cake. Some truths do not make a false religion good or true, just as some good ingredients do not make a poisoned cake good. When truths are mixed with error the truths become error just as when good ingredients are mixed with poison they become bad. However just because a person may eat of a poisoned cake doesn't make them a bad person, and just because someone belongs to a religion that is false does not make them a bad person. Such people are not evil but sick and in need of a physician. The Physician. Our Lord Jesus Christ, and His one and only true bride Holy Mother Church.

Amen.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...