Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Well Lookie Here...


Recommended Posts

Posted

Clearly establishing dominance. Hasan confirmed beta-male.

CMPlP.jpg?1

Not A Real Name
Posted

http://youtu.be/Qn977W9HjWM

Basilisa Marie
Posted

Yes - I kept hoping he would start making a new point or exploring his main point in a new way, but that didn't happen, so I ended up skimming until near the end when he did his conclusion. 

 

And while I'm not opposed to the idea that there may be some level of divine providence at work when two people get married, that idea's been thoroughly used and abused to the point where even bringing it up sparks a chain of connotations in peoples' minds that does more harm than good. I'd rather teach teens and young people that marriage (and all Vocation, really) is about making a choice. Sure, some options might be fundamentally easier for you than others, but it's ultimately about us making a commitment to live our lives following God in a particular way. 

 

Anywho. I thought that since most of the time I absolutely despise Matt Walsh's opinions and the way he presents them, it was only fair that I point out when I thought he did something right. :) Maybe if his posts like these get enough traffic, he'll quit being such a jerk.  Well, I can dream, I guess. 

PhuturePriest
Posted

Yes - I kept hoping he would start making a new point or exploring his main point in a new way, but that didn't happen, so I ended up skimming until near the end when he did his conclusion. 

 

And while I'm not opposed to the idea that there may be some level of divine providence at work when two people get married, that idea's been thoroughly used and abused to the point where even bringing it up sparks a chain of connotations in peoples' minds that does more harm than good. I'd rather teach teens and young people that marriage (and all Vocation, really) is about making a choice. Sure, some options might be fundamentally easier for you than others, but it's ultimately about us making a commitment to live our lives following God in a particular way. 

 

Anywho. I thought that since most of the time I absolutely despise Matt Walsh's opinions and the way he presents them, it was only fair that I point out when I thought he did something right. :) Maybe if his posts like these get enough traffic, he'll quit being such a jerk.  Well, I can dream, I guess. 

 

I must ask: Who in your eyes is closer to Satan: Matt Walsh, or Michael Voris?

Posted

We are now accepting applications for FP's hype man. A shortlist of the ten most promising candidates will be permitted to audition.

PhuturePriest
Posted

Michael Voris. His handling of the March for Life was a terrible embarrassment. (http://theleadingedgeblog.com/michael-voris-tries-to-create-divisons-at-the-march-for-life/ for anyone who missed that drama.)

 

I see nothing wrong with pointing out that supposedly "pro-life" people are in favor of stopping life from happening. I don't see the need for the outrage.

 

And I would very much like to remind you that we are to speak charitably of others, and saying Michael Voris is close to Satan because he exposed how anti-life many pro-lifers are is anything but charitable. Dare I say even a sin.

Posted

Veritas can audition as FP's hype man if she dresses up as bro-Elsa.

PhuturePriest
Posted

Veritas can audition as FP's hype man if she dresses up as bro-Elsa.

 

My hype man has to like Voris. It's my only standard, and I'm not willing to lower it.

 

(And yes, I am aware that greatly shortens the list of candidates Phatmass has to offer.)

Posted

My hype man has to like Voris. It's my only standard, and I'm not willing to lower it.

 

(And yes, I am aware that greatly shortens the list of candidates Phatmass has to offer.)

Everyone has their price.

Hype-men's prices are known to be quite low.

PhuturePriest
Posted

Everyone has their price.

Hype-men's prices are known to be quite low.

 

Scratch that: I'm willing to take on a non-Vorisite (That's what I affectionately term myself and others who are fans of Voris) so long as they worship the ground I walk on and are thus easily manipulated into liking him eventually.

veritasluxmea
Posted

I see nothing wrong with pointing out that supposedly "pro-life" people are in favor of stopping life from happening. I don't see the need for the outrage.

 

And I would very much like to remind you that we are to speak charitably of others, and saying Michael Voris is close to Satan because he exposed how anti-life many pro-lifers are is anything but charitable. Dare I say even a sin.

I wanted to address your joke without saying "no omgosh stop comparing people to Satan and putting BM on the spot like that, it's rude" so I pretended to roll with it. I apologize if I actually did come off as comparing him with Satan. For the record, I disprove of the way people tend to get angry and emotional about Michael Voris, including the tone of the article I posted. I respect him as a fellow Catholic and I'm sure there's much we can agree on. 

 

As for the March for Life, I still stand by the critiques in the article (despite the tone). The March for Life includes many non-Catholics, most notably Protestants but I have also walked with Atheists and even a Pagan. People of those beliefs tend to fall for the lie of contraception, which is anti-life. However, even they understand that abortion is murder and harmful for everyone involved. (That's pretty obvious, while without the guidance of the Church contraception can easier to miss.) The March for Life is against abortion, not contraception. The fact that most non-Catholics who are against abortion accept contraception does not invalidate their stand against abortion.

 

I would love to see a stronger stand against contraception in our culture, and I have seen anti-contraception materials at various Marches, but it is designed to politically and socially address abortion, not contraception. Pointing out that contraception leads to an abortion mentality and is anti-life is one thing, but claiming that anti-abortion but pro-contraception people are completely anti-life is flawed. Unfortunately, Michael Voris did the latter and handled the March poorly. Is the entire March anti-life because it doesn't address contraception and works with people who believe in it? No, the March is very pro-life, although it addresses only one issue; it addresses it well. 

Posted

Scratch that: I'm willing to take on a non-Vorisite (That's what I affectionately term myself and others who are fans of Voris) so long as they worship the ground I walk on and are thus easily manipulated into liking him eventually.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OdZ0r5-70X0&feature=youtu.be&t=1h39m28s

PhuturePriest
Posted

I wanted to address your joke without saying "no omgosh stop comparing people to Satan and putting BM on the spot like that, it's rude" so I pretended to roll with it. I apologize if I actually did come off as comparing him with Satan. For the record, I disprove of the way people tend to get angry and emotional about Michael Voris, including the tone of the article I posted. I respect him as a fellow Catholic and I'm sure there's much we can agree on. 

 

As for the March for Life, I still stand by the critiques in the article (despite the tone). The March for Life includes many non-Catholics, most notably Protestants but I have also walked with Atheists and even a Pagan. People of those beliefs tend to fall for the lie of contraception, which is anti-life. However, even they understand that abortion is murder and harmful for everyone involved. (That's pretty obvious, while without the guidance of the Church contraception can easier to miss.) The March for Life is against abortion, not contraception. The fact that most non-Catholics who are against abortion accept contraception does not invalidate their stand against abortion.

 

I would love to see a stronger stand against contraception in our culture, and I have seen anti-contraception materials at various Marches, but it is designed to politically and socially address abortion, not contraception. Pointing out that contraception leads to an abortion mentality and is anti-life is one thing, but claiming that anti-abortion but pro-contraception people are completely anti-life is flawed. Unfortunately, Michael Voris did the latter and handled the March poorly. Is the entire March anti-life because it doesn't address contraception and works with people who believe in it? No, the March is very pro-life, although it addresses only one issue; it addresses it well. 

 

I watched the video when it came out, and he asks them specifically if they are Christian.

 

The issue is that, as Pope Paul VI said, contraception leads to abortion. You'll never get rid of abortion if people aren't against contraception. The March for Life is but a mere social spectacle that will never accomplish anything if its attendants aren't against contraception as well as abortion.

Posted

The best way to break through a castle wall is by repeatedly smashing it with trebuchet fire, and let's be honest, the cultural dogma that we all have one special person we're supposed to marry is a very thick castle wall.

Leave other people's castles alone.

veritasluxmea
Posted

I watched the video when it came out, and he asks them specifically if they are Christian.

Christian, not Catholic. Key words here that were misused in the video.

 

The issue is that, as Pope Paul VI said, contraception leads to abortion. You'll never get rid of abortion if people aren't against contraception. The March for Life is but a mere social spectacle that will never accomplish anything if its attendants aren't against contraception as well as abortion.

 Yes, contraception leads to abortion. I think we will have to agree to disagree on the bolded. The March can- and does- have amazing success on a political and social level. From lowering abortion rates and helping pass laws restricting abortion, to touching thousands of people on a personal level and saving over a hundred babies (that we know of) each year through 40 Days for Life, to being instrumental in the closing of abortion clinics most notably in Texas, and to helping form the most pro-life generation of youth we've seen in a while, the March and 40 Days go beyond being a mere spectacle to actually making a difference in the right direction. (Both movements work with people who accept contraception. Again, that does not invalidate their pro-life stand on abortion, although I would agree they are not completely pro-life.) Does not addressing contraception hinder their efforts against abortion? Probably yes. Are they still successful in addressing abortion? Very. I wouldn't be surprised if it eventually led to the banning of abortion in America. 

 

Frankly, until I see each of the critiques raised in the article properly addressed, I will stand by the position that this particular issue was mishandled by his video. I don't know about the rest of his videos and I'm not trying to dis Michael Voris in general, I just want to address this video in particular. The rest of his videos may be amazing and he does have a point about needing to be against contraception, but this video and March was handled poorly. 

Basilisa Marie
Posted

I must ask: Who in your eyes is closer to Satan: Matt Walsh, or Michael Voris?

 

I refuse to answer that question. :)

 

Lately I have more patience for Walsh than I do for Voris, so if you're trying to ask which one I 'prefer,' I'd say Walsh. Voris is just... I can't even. Walsh is abrasive and self-righteous, Voris is abrasive and self-righteous while spreading hatred for people within the Church. So. Yeah. *shrug*

 

I have yet to see Voris produce anything comparable to this article, where I could say "Hey, this one is good!" 

PhuturePriest
Posted (edited)

 

Christian, not Catholic. Key words here that were misused in the video.

 

 Yes, contraception leads to abortion. I think we will have to agree to disagree on the bolded. The March can- and does- have amazing success on a political and social level. From lowering abortion rates and helping pass laws restricting abortion, to touching thousands of people on a personal level and saving over a hundred babies (that we know of) each year through 40 Days for Life, to being instrumental in the closing of abortion clinics most notably in Texas, and to helping form the most pro-life generation of youth we've seen in a while, the March and 40 Days go beyond being a mere spectacle to actually making a difference in the right direction. (Both movements work with people who accept contraception. Again, that does not invalidate their pro-life stand on abortion, although I would agree they are not completely pro-life.) Does not addressing contraception hinder their efforts against abortion? Probably yes. Are they still successful in addressing abortion? Very. I wouldn't be surprised if it eventually led to the banning of abortion in America. 

 

Frankly, until I see each of the critiques raised in the article properly addressed, I will stand by the position that this particular issue was mishandled by his video. I don't know about the rest of his videos and I'm not trying to dis Michael Voris in general, I just want to address this video in particular. The rest of his videos may be amazing and he does have a point about needing to be against contraception, but this video and March was handled poorly. 

 

 

A Christian who adheres to contraception is on a slippery slope. Again, as Pope Paul VI said, contraception and abortion go hand in hand. Contraception inevitably and irrevocably leads to the other, no matter how devout and Christian you are.

 

I'm not saying it hasn't done good. I'm saying it will never abolish abortion in America because most of the people in the pro-life movement support and use something which inherently leads to abortion. It's like saying you're against one side of the coin but support the other.

 

I in no way see how his video was "divisive". He pointed out a contradiction in many people in the pro-life movement. That's not divisive, that's stating facts. If the facts divide you, that's your problem, not his. You're basically upset at the messenger because he informed everyone that the house was on fire. It's not logical.

Edited by PhuturePriest
PhuturePriest
Posted

I refuse to answer that question. :)

 

Lately I have more patience for Walsh than I do for Voris, so if you're trying to ask which one I 'prefer,' I'd say Walsh. Voris is just... I can't even. Walsh is abrasive and self-righteous, Voris is abrasive and self-righteous while spreading hatred for people within the Church. So. Yeah. *shrug*

 

I have yet to see Voris produce anything comparable to this article, where I could say "Hey, this one is good!" 

 

You should watch one of his talks. Many only know him from The Vortex, but they don't realize what he actually does full-time is go around the world and do talks everywhere from America, Africa, the Philippines, and the UK. All of them are online to watch for free on the website. He almost completely changes character from when he's on The Vortex; he's generally very lighthearted and laughs a lot. I spent a week with a Brother who used to work with him, and he said Michael in person is one of the most friendly and nice people you'll ever meet. He simply gets very serious when he does The Vortex, and he's very blunt and to the point, which I understand is not everyone's style.

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
×
×
  • Create New...