Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

In my parish, where the Mass is reverently said in the Ordinary Form, the choir chants the Kyrie Eleison, the Gloria, the Sanctus, and the Agnus Dei. The organist provides accompaniment, and the parishioners join in the chant if they want.

We also sing a wide selection of hymns, usually older ones. Most of the parishioners prefer traditional hymns. Once, during a transitional period after our choir director left, the vocalist sang "I Am the Bread of Life," and many of the parishioners were not pleased.  :hehe:

On special occasions, the choir and organist are joined by musicians from a local music school, so we'll have trumpet and string accompaniment. For example, on the Easter Vigil last year, they performed selections from Mozart's "Sparrow Mass."

Overall I am pleased with our liturgical music. I don't really like when the vocalist sings "O Divine Redeemer" in operatic tones while I'm trying to pray after Communion, but that's a minor quibble.

Posted

As a child I really loved 'Here, I Am Lord'. I remember being six or seven and sitting in church and hearing that sung and just being awed by the love of God and the sense that anything is possible for God, that I was wanted by God, that I had a purpose. My musical tastes have changed a lot since then, and I prefer more traditional music for Mass, but I haven't lost that memory and it means I don't have the same near-allergic reaction to contemporary church music that some people have. Basically, I'm happy anywhere people really sing. I hate it when almost the entire congregation is standing there with hymn books shut and all you can hear is the organ - so depressing.

Posted

As a child I really loved 'Here, I Am Lord'.

Heh. Punctuated like that it sounds like contemporary church music in a nutshell. :hehe:

Posted

Heh. Punctuated like that it sounds like contemporary church music in a nutshell. :hehe:

 

Oops...  :hehe2:  Still, you get my basic point.

Posted

How does the liturgical music get written, picked, weeded out over time?

Posted

How does the liturgical music get written, picked, weeded out over time?

Through the magic of copyright law, incompetence, irreverence, and apathy.

 

We are still talking about contemporary church music, right? ;)

Not The Philosopher
Posted

I go to the Cathedral, which typically has decent-ish hymns, gregorian chant and sometimes polyphony for the Mass I attend.

Posted

How does the liturgical music get written, picked, weeded out over time?

 

There are 5 major publishers of Catholic hymnals, some of which also publish non-Catholic hymnals. 4 of the 5 are quite "modern" publishers. Check out the Musica Sacra forum to learn all about this: http://forum.musicasacra.com/forum/

 

FYI: I am conducting a study this semester that will map the lyrical content of Catholic hymns over the centuries. We are looking for a rise in egoism in hymns written post-1960. I'll let you know once the numbers are in.

Posted

FYI: I am conducting a study this semester that will map the lyrical content of Catholic hymns over the centuries. We are looking for a rise in egoism in hymns written post-1960. I'll let you know once the numbers are in.

 

That sounds fascinating! :)  Now that I think about it, a lot of the post-1960 hymns that I know often use the first person singular ("I Am the Bread of Life"). Meanwhile, many older hymns with which I'm familiar ("Faith of Our Fathers" and "Immaculate Mary," for example) use the first person plural or avoid the first person. I'm sure there are exceptions, but it's really interesting to consider! 

Posted

I'll be waiting with bated breath to read what the results are. To me it seems pretty obvious that there is a rise in egoism, at least in use of 'I' instead of 'we', including the hymn I mentioned in the OP. It's funny because when I visited masses and heard the hymns, it always made me think, what is it that's making this sound so Protestant? Eventually I realised it was that all the modern hymns seemed to be about 'me and the Lord' rather than 'we the people of God'.

Posted

Which is, I guess, what I was getting at when I asked if there is any liturgical music that's not in Latin but still very theologically rich and sound?

Posted

Which is, I guess, what I was getting at when I asked if there is any liturgical music that's not in Latin but still very theologically rich and sound?


The Simple English Propers are quite good.
Posted

The Simple English Propers are quite good.

 

They actually are! I've been listening to them for the past couple of days. Thanks for introducing me!

MarysLittleFlower
Posted

Most old hymns in English (the ones I know) tend to be pretty good, and they are about God or Our Lady not us :). I think what bothers me about some modern hymns is that they are not only about our response to God (which could work even if it days 'i') but they tend to have a 'horizontal' approach about us gathering, etc, when the number 1 thing for me about the Mass is God being there and the Sacrifice. If we came to Calvary we wouldn't be thinking so much of ourselves IMO... Maybe this emphasis comes from people forgetting the Sacrifice aspect of the Mass. Of course it is other things too and God does want to draw everyone to Him, I'd just rather concentrate on the Blessed Sacrament when I come into the Church and sing something to Him... Just my perspective!

Posted (edited)

Most old hymns in English (the ones I know) tend to be pretty good, and they are about God or Our Lady not us :). I think what bothers me about some modern hymns is that they are not only about our response to God (which could work even if it days 'i') but they tend to have a 'horizontal' approach about us gathering, etc, when the number 1 thing for me about the Mass is God being there and the Sacrifice. If we came to Calvary we wouldn't be thinking so much of ourselves IMO... Maybe this emphasis comes from people forgetting the Sacrifice aspect of the Mass. Of course it is other things too and God does want to draw everyone to Him, I'd just rather concentrate on the Blessed Sacrament when I come into the Church and sing something to Him... Just my perspective!

 

Got it in one - that's the feeling I've been trying to articulate!

Edited by marigold
Iudica_Me_Deus
Posted

I live in CA so the local parish is quite ummm not so traddie. You'll hear the typical OCP hymns - Here I am Lord, I Am the Bread of Life, Pan de Vida, All are Welcome, etc... lol... But I sing for the TLM 40 mins away from where I live. :)

Posted

This one isn't bad:

 

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1drtim65OA0

 

Most of these hymns sound like Christmas carols to me! I guess because Christmas carols/hymns are the only western liturgical music I'm really familiar with. It's an odd feeling... 

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...