Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

Props to Stephen. I totally get it.

You agree with him?
Posted

You agree with him?

 

More or less, yeah. It makes sense to me. 

Posted (edited)

More or less, yeah. It makes sense to me.

I see his argument. Yet I don't believe God is evil. That's the implications he's making. That God likely exist and he is evil. Edited by Guest
Posted

Well, you can probably say he is. 

 

I mean, if God is all powerful an can do anything..then why didnt he just make us perfect and enlightened to his will? 

 

He wanted us to CHOOSE him CC!!

 

Well yes, I get that...but why? Just create beings that dont care. If he knows we will be happy with him then just do that! Dont put us through this little mouse maze where our entire outlook was decided for us by random naked morons who effed it up. Just fix it God. Make it better!

Posted (edited)

Einstein believed in God but thought he wasn't involved in personal affairs.That makes more sense to me then God being purposely evil.I believe that God is involved personally with us.That doesn't leave me without questions. I don't think I could ever be pushed so far to believe God is evil.That pretty much just equals knowing God is there but hating him as you believe he hates you. Sorta like being in Job's situation but going all the way with it and concluding in your mind and soul that God truly is evil. Therefore wanting nothing to do with him.

Edited by Guest
Posted (edited)

Well, you can probably say he is.

I mean, if God is all powerful an can do anything..then why didnt he just make us perfect and enlightened to his will?

He wanted us to CHOOSE him CC!!

Well yes, I get that...but why? Just create beings that dont care. If he knows we will be happy with him then just do that! Dont put us through this little mouse maze where our entire outlook was decided for us by random naked morons who effed it up. Just fix it God. Make it better!

Yea I hear what you are saying. It also makes it more complicated when Adam and Eve could be allegorical. Not saying that's the case. Edited by Guest
Posted (edited)

Just fix it God. Make it better!

Also he sorta does. Eternity is forver. This life is like a grain of sand, if that compared to it. So He sorta does fix it and make it better. Edited by Guest
Posted (edited)

If reincarnation were true then I would conclude God is evil. I wouldn't hesitate. Not that an evil god would care what a tiny spec of dust like me thought.

Edited by Guest
Posted

Also he sorta does. Eternity is forver. This life is like a grain of sand, if that compared to it. So He sorta does fix it and make it better.

 

He didnt have to do any of this. Create a reality where choosing things doesnt matter. Just make us happy in heaven with him. He can do that cause he is God.

Posted (edited)

He didnt have to do any of this. Create a reality where choosing things doesnt matter. Just make us happy in heaven with him. He can do that cause he is God.

Could there still be free will this way? Edited by Guest
Posted

Could there still be free will this way?

 

Who needs it? GOd can just create a reality where there is no concept of free will. Who cares! We dont need free will if he never creates free will! Do you see what I mean? Like, God can jsut do whatever he wants. Literally. Anything. If he doesnt want our lack of free will to be a detriment, he can change it. He can make it so that we can have free will and still be born perfect and live with him forever. I dont know why we have to pick and choose. He is god.

Posted

Who needs it? GOd can just create a reality where there is no concept of free will. Who cares! We dont need free will if he never creates free will! Do you see what I mean? Like, God can jsut do whatever he wants. Literally. Anything. If he doesnt want our lack of free will to be a detriment, he can change it. He can make it so that we can have free will and still be born perfect and live with him forever. I dont know why we have to pick and choose. He is god.

 

 

so you would prefer to be a robot programmed to experience pleasure, rather than a free being capable of actual love.

 

earth to Morpheus, this one wants the blue pill!

Posted

You make it sound like a bad thing. God can make it a good thing. Being a robot wont have a negative connotation if God says so. He can make being a robot the culmination of everything that is awesome.

Posted

No, God cannot just "make" it a good thing. God can't act in a way that is contrary to His nature. If we agree that programming a bunch of robots to worship you and experience pleasure is a weird messed up thing to do, that's not something You (capital y as in God) could do.  Of course you seem to think that kind of thing would be a-okay. 

 

thats just icky to me. like ick. i do not understand takers of the blue pill. 

 

 

veritasluxmea
Posted (edited)

You make it sound like a bad thing. God can make it a good thing. Being a robot wont have a negative connotation if God says so. He can make being a robot the culmination of everything that is amesome.

That's like saying God could make a square circle. He can't. 

 

Edited to add: (Assuming animals are in heaven) He did do that for animals in heaven. Would you really rather be an animal in heaven than an human on earth? Or, as I think Aristotle put it, would you rather be a happy pig or an unhappy human? 

Edited by veritasluxmea
Posted (edited)

When I think about personal suffering the Scripture passage that always comes to mind is 2 Corininthians 4:

 

16 So we do not lose heart. Though our outer nature is wasting away, our inner nature is being renewed every day. 17 For this slight momentary affliction is preparing for us an eternal weight of glory beyond all comparison, 18 because we look not to the things that are seen but to the things that are unseen; for the things that are seen are transient, but the things that are unseen are eternal.

 
(please read the whole chapter!)
 

I believe that God transforms suffering into a good thing, he turns a curse into a blessing. Because suffering entered in to the world the possibility of never-ending bliss and glory is that much greater.  It serves God's purpose and the good of mankind. This is why the Church rejoices in Easter, “O happy fault of Adam that merited for us such a great Redeemer!"

 

Does it make sense to finite minds like ours? No. The suffering still hurt? Yes. It is still very much a mystery that we must approach in faith.

Edited by Seven77
Posted

always take the red pill y'all. 

Posted

Suffering is a mystery primarily possibly why Jesus died the shocking death that He did.  But in the context of the Passion of Jesus, personal sufferings fall into place : "Take up your cross and follow me".  And The Church teaches that personal sufferings united to those of Jesus are redemptive.

Posted

always take the red pill y'all. 

 

Dont talk to me about reality when you base your whole world view on an invisible man.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...