Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Balance - Is it a thing?


Recommended Posts

Posted

Red's post and this thread reminds me of @Ice_nine

's thread  regarding the need for "Likes" or props on Facebook etc. to affirm you matter.   I think it's about a need to be noticed as worthwhile in the milieu of the vast online world of superficial connections.  Srsly, I can't imagine 200 people following me on Facebook or Instagram.   How could I hope to matter to those people?   Am I narcissistic because I know I won't be interested in following 200 people?  Am I anti-social in our current society?   I dunno.   I have enough life to live in my analog world, Lol.  

PhuturePriest
Posted

I think a lot of people aren't interested in balance. They aren't interested in seeing the other side(s) of an idea, theory, politics, religion, etc. They are only interested in knowing "their side" and not having that be challenged, and have "yes" friends ("Yes I agree!!" or "You got that straight" etc etc). I guess this is why I keep interesting people and pages on my Facebook feed, even if I don't necessarily agree with them, because I want to be challenged in my world views and try to see from another perspective. 

I only have about 125 friends on Facebook though because I refuse to share my "life" with people who don't need to know who kept sending me friend requests (random relatives, phatmassers, former high school friends, etc)

​https://sp.yimg.com/ib/th?id=HN.608053226585393654&pid=15.1&P=0

PhuturePriest
Posted

Red's post and this thread reminds me of @Ice_nine

's thread  regarding the need for "Likes" or props on Facebook etc. to affirm you matter.   I think it's about a need to be noticed as worthwhile in the milieu of the vast online world of superficial connections.  Srsly, I can't imagine 200 people following me on Facebook or Instagram.   How could I hope to matter to those people?   Am I narcissistic because I know I won't be interested in following 200 people?  Am I anti-social in our current society?   I dunno.   I have enough life to live in my analog world, Lol.  

​I have friends with four hundred to over a thousand Facebook friends, and all I can think is "How do you even know that many people?" It also seems like a great waste. It's just hundreds of people you barely know and don't care about filling your Facebook wall with statuses you don't want to see.

Posted

Red's post and this thread reminds me of @Ice_nine

's thread  regarding the need for "Likes" or props on Facebook etc. to affirm you matter.   I think it's about a need to be noticed as worthwhile in the milieu of the vast online world of superficial connections.  Srsly, I can't imagine 200 people following me on Facebook or Instagram.   How could I hope to matter to those people?   Am I narcissistic because I know I won't be interested in following 200 people?  Am I anti-social in our current society?   I dunno.   I have enough life to live in my analog world, Lol.  

​Well, I do have a blog with a fair amount of followers across social media, but that's a separate entity, I think…it isn't as personal. It's more like a business. 

PhuturePriest
Posted

​I never click on your image links. You should do better at making images show up in your posts.

​I don't know how. They never work. The "insert other media" thing never works, either.

Posted

So I gave up facebook for lent. It was actually enjoyable and not much of a struggle in the desert. However the thought would nudge me from time to time "am I missing out?"

So when I got back on I felt slightly weird. There was no real way to see if I missed anything because notifications expire after 7 days. I had a message about a friend's wedding (she needed my address to send an invite, I obviously didn't get the message but she has my number). So you might not be missing out on MUCH but since most people in my generation use it as their primary social tool (well maybe it's secondary to texting I don't know), you really fall off the face of the earth if you don't use social media.

Also, like FH, I really like the people I'm friends with online (I only have about 100 or so friends, most are family), but seeing the things they write . . . my goodness. It's not a condemnation on them becasue I know I sound like an unhinged keyboard warrior sometimes too, but really it just seems to bring out the worst in people. Hardly any of it is edifying and there's always something to argue about.

And yet I still have a compulsive need to check it everyday even though I am super bored and under enthused when I do. Go figure. I so wish I could live off the grid but I wouldn't survive half a day. Probably get eaten by a bear or something.

veritasluxmea
Posted (edited)

And yet I still have a compulsive need to check it everyday even though I am super bored and under enthused when I do. 

​I just realized I feel that way AFTER being on facebook. Hum. You're right it's so compulsive, but it's the only way I can keep up (via messaging) with some people. E-mail just doesn't do the same thing. 

Edited by veritasluxmea
Credo in Deum
Posted (edited)

I left Facebook and haven't looked back.  Those who I want to keep in touch with I still do via e-mail, text, phone calls, and good old fashioned face to face get-togethers.  I haven't written a letter yet but I plan on doing so to a friend of mine in the seminary.  

For me, leaving Facebook was a positive change in my life and I'm happy for it.  Now it's time to work on throwing away my t.v. and continuing on from there! 

 

Edited by Credo in Deum
Posted

​If I give you a like, don't get any feeling of satisfaction from it! It'll only feed into the unhealthy posting-for-approval malaise :P

I was thinking that becoming a friend is process of unknowing. I met someone the other day and when we become facebook friends, I had access to years of her photos, her statuses, her likes and dislikes etc. Do I need to know this? I know more about someone who I met relatively briefly than someone I've known for ages. What would it be like to unknow a person, as time goes by, for that person to remain more and more a mystery to me?

Posted

There's also something about social media that encourages our worst tendencies. How many bar tabs do I have open at the moment? Why can't I just concentrate on one? Isn't this flitting about from one to another, keeping the possibilities open, the direct opposite of what prayer is? Prayer, isn't that the most pure form of attention, to paraphrase Simone Weil?

franciscanheart
Posted

I left Facebook and haven't looked back.  Those who I want to keep in touch with I still do via e-mail, text, phone calls, and good old fashioned face to face get-togethers.  I haven't written a letter yet but I plan on doing so to a friend of mine in the seminary.  

For me, leaving Facebook was a positive change in my life and I'm happy for it.  Now it's time to work on throwing away my t.v. and continuing on from there! 

​I don't have a television, but I do use Facebook. I don't know that I'll ever get rid of it completely, but I think it's amesome that you did.

​If I give you a like, don't get any feeling of satisfaction from it! It'll only feed into the unhealthy posting-for-approval malaise :P

I was thinking that becoming a friend is process of unknowing. I met someone the other day and when we become facebook friends, I had access to years of her photos, her statuses, her likes and dislikes etc. Do I need to know this? I know more about someone who I met relatively briefly than someone I've known for ages. What would it be like to unknow a person, as time goes by, for that person to remain more and more a mystery to me?

​I really dislike the mystery Facebook takes away. I'm always disappointed to learn that a friend has "Facebook-stalked" their new love interest; I feel they rob themselves when they do that. Mystery is half the fun.

Posted

​I don't have a television, but I do use Facebook. I don't know that I'll ever get rid of it completely, but I think it's amesome that you did.

​I really dislike the mystery Facebook takes away. I'm always disappointed to learn that a friend has "Facebook-stalked" their new love interest; I feel they rob themselves when they do that. Mystery is half the fun.

​Well, I gave up my television set years ago but I do watch programs online - mainly movies and news but I do watch the occasional TV show on network TV if they have it on their website. I gave up Facebook about 7 years ago and haven't missed it since. My family is scattered around the globe but we got around the contact problem by setting up our own family website where we can post stories, family news, recipes, photos, videos etc. We also rely on email a lot. I just don't like FB - never really have, although I know some people really lov eit.

IcePrincessKRS
Posted
So you might not be missing out on MUCH but since most people in my generation use it as their primary social tool (well maybe it's secondary to texting I don't know), you really fall off the face of the earth if you don't use social media.

​I've considered deleting my facebook account off and on but this is one of the primary reasons I keep it around. As I noted in my other post I only have about 200 friends, and most of them are family--family that we get to see once or twice a year, at best. Facebook/instagram/google+ fills the gap and allows easy communication and updates with the people that I care about. My mother and mother in law may only get to see my children a couple of times each year but they can log on facebook and see photos and stories of all their shenanigans whenever they want. I can share a whole album of vacation pictures on facebook much easier than I can via email. We tried the family website thing with my husband's side of the family and it never flourished. In the end I just can't convince myself to completely cut out facebook and other social media.

HopefulHeart
Posted

I have never joined Facebook specifically because I think it would have a negative impact on my personal outlook and productivity. I feel it would be a major distraction and would invite me to make unhealthy comparisons with other people. I think I am at a good balance with my current means of social communication (texting, email, face-to-face chats, etc.). Someday that balance might shift to include Facebook, but I am happy with where I am for now. :) (Note that I am not trying to disparage fb or those who use it. I just don't think it would be a good choice for me at the present.)

franciscanheart
Posted (edited)

I have never joined Facebook specifically because I think it would have a negative impact on my personal outlook and productivity. I feel it would be a major distraction and would invite me to make unhealthy comparisons with other people. I think I am at a good balance with my current means of social communication (texting, email, face-to-face chats, etc.). Someday that balance might shift to include Facebook, but I am happy with where I am for now. :) (Note that I am not trying to disparage fb or those who use it. I just don't think it would be a good choice for me at the present.)

​I see where that could be very wise. rachael convinced me to join back in the day and I've disliked her for it more days than not. :hehe:

Edited by franciscanheart
Posted

So, I  gave up twitter for Lent, best idea ever. When I went back, I got super annoyed with it, so I went back to giving it up. Twitter is  a message board on steroids, you have all of this information coming at you at once, all these contacts, etc and it gets quite overwhelming, but at the same time addicting. I was annoyed with both of these things so that's why I left.. again.  My account is somewhat anonymous (you might be able to find it, if you do, congrats) so It is kind of neat to have the whole mystery thing Fran mentioned.  Only a small handful know my real name.

 

Now facebook is a whole different ball game. if I add you on facebook, (or try), that means I want to keep in touch with you years in advance.  Now there could only be contact every 1, 2,3,6 months, even a year, but facebook gives you an efficient way of doing just that, and it takes seconds out of your day. I thought that was the whole point?

Posted

So, I  gave up twitter for Lent, best idea ever. When I went back, I got super annoyed with it, so I went back to giving it up. Twitter is  a message board on steroids, you have all of this information coming at you at once, all these contacts, etc and it gets quite overwhelming, but at the same time addicting. I was annoyed with both of these things so that's why I left.. again.  My account is somewhat anonymous (you might be able to find it, if you do, congrats) so It is kind of neat to have the whole mystery thing Fran mentioned.  Only a small handful know my real name.

 

Now facebook is a whole different ball game. if I add you on facebook, (or try), that means I want to keep in touch with you years in advance.  Now there could only be contact every 1, 2,3,6 months, even a year, but facebook gives you an efficient way of doing just that, and it takes seconds out of your day. I thought that was the whole point?

​That's funny because I hate FB but I still have Twitter, but it is a limited account. I follow some news feeds so I know what's happening in the world, but I don't follow any individuals and I don't have any followers. For me it is mainly to get all my news in one place.

Posted

I've noticed lately a lot of negative posts about people or issues or articles or.. whatever.. across all social media platforms. I feel like so much of my newsfeed or timeline or whatever is about how people are wrong and not how people are beautiful. Selfies, pictures of kids, memes making fun of people, news articles being mocked, more babies, maybe a kitten...

Where's the balance? I try to use my Facebook account to build people up -- to celebrate life and have something to look back on when I'm feeling blue. How did it become so negative? When did it turn into the FOMO-inducing monster that it is? Has it always been that way?

Is balance possible in social media? Can we both point out why people are wrong AND supply two or three times as many pieces about how people are right? Or better yet, point out things that are beautiful or uplifting or enriching? I hesitate to say never but I very often do not see good book excerpts being shared or saint lives being honored. Lots of HERE'S MAH FOOD or MURICA posts but not much else.

Before you say I have the wrong friends, remember that many of you are friends with me on Facebook. ;) And a lot of the negative comes from my Christian friends.

There are a few that are always such a light in my feed, and for them I am grateful. But I wonder -- if my friends who post criticisms of things are not doing anything wrong, how can I (or we) encourage the other end of things -- the lighter, happier, more positive and encouraging things?

 

I'm rambling. I'll shut up.

​Here's how I cheer myself up about the state of humanity. I always used to read the 'random acts of kindness' section in the back of the London Metro growing up, and the habit followed me online when I moved away: http://art.tfl.gov.uk/actsofkindness

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...