Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

​That is what they want you to think. A large portion of martial arts, especially 'traditional' ones, is quackery and pseudoscience. Most of what you hear is legend at best, and straight up lies at worst.

​I don't think it's all legend and pseudoscience as you say, I think some of these techniques were the craft of possessed men. We hear it often in various cultures that certain skills were taught by fallen spirits, and based on what people have reported to me who are deeply involved in Akido, it's also true for this. One even senses 'them' as they progress in the discipline.

Posted

​You can take the combat out of the man. Once you have them down, if you continue to deliver strikes, then you can be charged with a crime. 

​Again, you are correct, Winchester.  An individual can only act in self defense in response to what is happening--not what might happen.  If you continue with force (after the perpetrator is incapacitated)--you will, indeed, be charged.  The burden of proof (for a self-defense case) shifts then, to you.  Interestingly, this is true in both civilian and military courts. 

I still recommend a basic self-defense course for Beatitude--and always being aware of one's surroundings.

Nihil Obstat
Posted

​I don't think it's all legend and pseudoscience as you say, I think some of these techniques were the craft of possessed men. We hear it often in various cultures that certain skills were taught by fallen spirits, and based on what people have reported to me who are deeply involved in Akido, it's also true for this. One even senses 'them' as they progress in the discipline.

We will agree to disagree then. I think you are totally out to lunch on this one, but as your opinions are not falsifiable we do not really have much left to discuss. :P 

I have reached a rather high level in Shotokan karate, and there is not nor has there ever been a spiritual dimension. That I can guarantee on my honour as a Catholic.

Posted

We will agree to disagree then. I think you are totally out to lunch on this one, but as your opinions are not falsifiable we do not really have much left to discuss. :P 

I have reached a rather high level in Shotokan karate, and there is not nor has there ever been a spiritual dimension. That I can guarantee on my honour as a Catholic.

Can't speak on that discipline, but Akido definitely has a preternatural dimension.

 

Winchester
Posted

Leprechauns definitely wear green hats.

PhuturePriest
Posted

I hear you're not much taller than them. Are you one of their descendants?

PhuturePriest
Posted

Can't speak on that discipline, but Akido definitely has a preternatural dimension.

 

​Believe what you will. I know people who practice Aikido who in no way have any sort of religious connotations with it. Were there religious connotations at the beginning? Certainly. But claiming you can't separate the two is quite the claim, and unfortunately it's a matter that we can only argue on the front of the people we personally know, which is by no means proper grounds for an effective debate.

Posted

​Believe what you will. I know people who practice Aikido who in no way have any sort of religious connotations with it. Were there religious connotations at the beginning? Certainly. But claiming you can't separate the two is quite the claim, and unfortunately it's a matter that we can only argue on the front of the people we personally know, which is by no means proper grounds for an effective debate.

I took "karate" lessons when I was younger but I realized as I got older that I didn't really learn genuine Karate. This was more of an Americanized commercial product than the genuine Korean discipline. And so I would say if you friend's sensei is himself not imbued with the kami, then he is not a genuine sensei :P

PhuturePriest
Posted

I took "karate" lessons when I was younger but I realized as I got older that I didn't really learn genuine Karate. This was more of an Americanized commercial product than the genuine Korean discipline. And so I would say if you friend's sensei is himself not imbued with the kami, then he is not a genuine sensei :P

​I take traditional karate. We've got all the discipline, respect, and unpleasantness characteristic of a traditional dojo without all the weird spirituality. Now I do also know a black belt who, despite being a Christian, accepts some of the weird eastern spirituality stuff, up to and including auras of people and being able to sense them in the dark due to their spiritual aura. I know the difference between a guy like that and the people I work with regularly. 

"Sensei" does not mean religious figure, it means teacher. And a teacher can choose not to teach some things and still be a genuine teacher.

Nihil Obstat
Posted

I took "karate" lessons when I was younger but I realized as I got older that I didn't really learn genuine Karate. This was more of an Americanized commercial product than the genuine Korean discipline. And so I would say if you friend's sensei is himself not imbued with the kami, then he is not a genuine sensei :P

Karate is Japanese. Taekwondo is Korean. 

​

"Sensei" does not mean religious figure, it means teacher. And a teacher can choose not to teach some things and still be a genuine teacher.

Sense comes from the Chinese word xiansheng. Two characters which translate literally to "born before". In Chinese it is used more as a respectful "mister" or "sir" whereas in Japan it gradually took on its meaning as a title for teachers and doctors.

It has nothing whatsoever to do with kami or qi and carries no implication of spiritual development.

 

PhuturePriest
Posted

Karate is Japanese. Taekwondo is Korean. 

Sense comes from the Chinese word xiansheng. Two characters which translate literally to "born before". In Chinese it is used more as a respectful "mister" or "sir" whereas in Japan it gradually took on its meaning as a title for teachers and doctors.

It has nothing whatsoever to do with kami or qi and carries no implication of spiritual development.

 

23a2a6ee998024ea1820e89bcfe35745639f63e4

Nihil Obstat
Posted

I was on my phone when I typed it up, but the characters are 先生。

Word Decomposition
先turtle.gif xiān early; prior; former; in advance; first
生turtle.gif shēng to be born; to give birth; life; to grow; raw; uncooked; student
Posted

To beatitude and all my fellow ladies on here, this video is part of a series and you can watch them all on youtube.  yes they are old but his advice stands the test of time.  Sorry the audio has a bit of a ticking noise.

 

Posted

There are likely many more up to date videos on youtube talking about self defense for women, so if this one seems lame at least watch something else  that can provide you with tips you can use today while you wait to take classes and such. 

Posted

Karate is Japanese. Taekwondo is Korean. 

Sense comes from the Chinese word xiansheng. Two characters which translate literally to "born before". In Chinese it is used more as a respectful "mister" or "sir" whereas in Japan it gradually took on its meaning as a title for teachers and doctors.

It has nothing whatsoever to do with kami or qi and carries no implication of spiritual development.

​Nihil is speaking of the word "Sensei" in its general context and etymology, and in this sense he is absolutely correct, however in specific use within Akido, a Sensei most certainly is connected with spiritual development and Kami. In genuine Akido, the spiritual aspect and discipline are inseparable. 

Winchester
Posted (edited)

Could y'all take your weaboo fight elsewhere?

Edited by Winchester
PhuturePriest
Posted

Could y'all take your weaboo fight elsewhere?

​Phatmass is strong when weaboo fights are rampant. 

Nihil Obstat
Posted

​Nihil is speaking of the word "Sensei" in its general context and etymology, and in this sense he is absolutely correct, however in specific use within Akido, a Sensei most certainly is connected with spiritual development and Kami. In genuine Akido, the spiritual aspect and discipline are inseparable. 

​Then Aikido is the exception, while the actual usage of 先生 is the rule. Your argument is basically the same as saying that since Satanists call their leaders priests and priestesses, that the word priest is inherently linked with Satanism. You are getting it backwards. "Genuine Aikido" (which is frankly a pretty nebulous concept to begin with, as with all Eastern martial arts) is the outlier in this sense.

IgnatiusofLoyola
Posted (edited)
 

​Could y'all take your weaboo fight elsewhere?

​I think the detailed discussion of the spiritual aspect of the martial arts has strayed pretty far from the original topic. FP--I know that you have gotten frustrated in the past when you felt that your posts (I remember one in VS) have expanded to cover topics beyond the intent of the original post, so I'm sure you understand how it might feel to other readers.

That's not to say that the spiritual aspect of the martial arts is not a legitimate topic for Phatmass, but perhaps it warrants its own thread, so that those who are not interested will know they can skip the thread.

Later note: For some reason, the reply function quoted Winchester's comment instead of FP's. (I DID post my reply to FP's post.) FP's post stated: Phatmass is strong when weaboo fights are rampant.

Edited by IgnatiusofLoyola

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...