Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Petition to Cancel Anti-Catholic Sit-Com


Recommended Posts

Winchester
Posted

It's a mistake to silence opposition. Let them speak, then respond. 

Not A Mallard
Posted

This is reminding me of how everybody reacts to modesty topics...

Winchester
Posted

Well, it's another moral busybody topic, so...

PhuturePriest
Posted

Let's be honest, I'm not making you scrupulous, you're making yourself scrupulous. When these feelings start controlling your behavior it's time to reach out to a health professional. 

​"Let's be honest, I'm not making you clinically depressed, you're making yourself clinically depressed." 

See how stupid and offensive that was? Because that's what you did but with scrupulosity. Scrupulosity is a mental issue, and blaming it on the person is so disgusting that I'm quite honestly speechless right now.

Posted

​"Let's be honest, I'm not making you clinically depressed, you're making yourself clinically depressed." 

See how stupid and offensive that was? Because that's what you did but with scrupulosity. Scrupulosity is a mental issue, and blaming it on the person is so disgusting that I'm quite honestly speechless right now.

I'm not blaming. Just like nobody on the Internet (or in real life) can "make" you clinically depressed with a sad conversation, nobody on the Internet (or in real life) can "make" you scrupulous with a discussion about sin.

True scrupulosity (as opposed to simply being hyper aware of the possibility of sin) is essentially an anxiety disorder. It is an internally produced phenomenon, if it was situational anxiety "caused" by an external someone or something, it wouldn't be as intractable or as devastating.

I know of what I speak dude. Especially because it's common to combine anxiety problems with avoidance, it can be hard to come to terms with the fact your brain is messing things up for you. Instead one is tempted to rearrange the world around you to accommodate the OCD... Because then the anxiety will "go away" owaitno. 

#offtopic

#sofatsosorry

PhuturePriest
Posted

I'm not blaming. Just like nobody on the Internet (or in real life) can "make" you clinically depressed with a sad conversation, nobody on the Internet (or in real life) can "make" you scrupulous with a discussion about sin.

True scrupulosity (as opposed to simply being hyper aware of the possibility of sin) is essentially an anxiety disorder. It is an internally produced phenomenon, if it was situational anxiety "caused" by an external someone or something, it wouldn't be as intractable or as devastating.

I know of what I speak dude. Especially because it's common to combine anxiety problems with avoidance, it can be hard to come to terms with the fact your brain is messing things up for you. Instead one is tempted to rearrange the world around you to accommodate the OCD... Because then the anxiety will "go away" owaitno. 

#offtopic

#sofatsosorry

​I never said you were making him scrupulous. I said telling him that he's making himself scrupulous is a ridiculous assertion. It's one thing to recommend seeing someone, but to tell a person that their anxiety problem is their fault is wrong.

Posted

​I never said you were making him scrupulous. I said telling him that he's making himself scrupulous is a ridiculous assertion. It's one thing to recommend seeing someone, but to tell a person that their anxiety problem is their fault is wrong.

Can you highlight where I said his anxiety problem is his fault? Kthanx. 

Not A Mallard
Posted

Can you highlight where I said his anxiety problem is his fault? Kthanx. 

​

Let's be honest, I'm not making you scrupulous, you're making yourself scrupulous.

​

Not A Mallard
Posted (edited)

And what's wrong with using scrupulosity to inform Catholics about a show that's making fun of them? If I need to see a health professional for acting upon my feelings to do something that I think is right, than anybody who acts upon his/her feelings to do something right needs to see a health professional.

Edited by Not A Mallard
PhuturePriest
Posted

Can you highlight where I said his anxiety problem is his fault? Kthanx. 

​

Let's be honest, I'm not making you scrupulous, you're making yourself scrupulous.

You can say you misspoke, which you probably did. We can only assume that Not A Mallard did as well when he said you were making him scrupulous. Having dealt with scrupulosity, I know that what he meant was "Your talk of this is making my anxiety go full-blast and making me worry if I'm in mortal sin now, so please stop talking about it," not "Thanks to you I think I'm in mortal sin."

Posted

While not touted as a family show, you all do know that there's a show about the EXACT SAME THING that's been on for over a year called "The Mc Carthy's"  Good Irish Catholic family that has a gay son, a sporty son, an airhead daughter, a "Fr. Hyprocacy".  I think Boston is cool so I watched the pilot but it was way over the top "gay dilemma" stupidity so i didn't watch more.

The petition is already getting tons of media for the show.  I really don't get why it's that bad all shoved in the middle of the Goldbergs and Modern Family and all the other stupid shows out there.  It really isn't *that* special and there's no evidence that its against the Catholic Church besides exaggerating stereotypes.  The woman on the show comes from "Raising Hope" which was a sitcom that made tons of jokes about poor and mentally ill people.  It was often offensive.  Considering "Off the Boat" and "Blackish" are running, why do white people seem to feel they have a corner on the satire market these days?

That and have all the Catholics forgotten that IT IS NOT WRONG to be gay.  Not at all.  There's nothing in the preview for this show that indicates that there will be anything but some slapstick surrounding the gay son.  The fact that he refused to have sex--even with his gayness--is actually a good thing, isn't it?

Posted

I think it's pretty obvious that changing the definition of "family" would change the definition of "Disney".

I remember back when what's-her-face went riding naked on a wrecking ball, everyone got their panties all in a bunch that MTV had shown a naked lady. But if you watched MTV in the early 90s, you knew it was just a matter of time. Half-naked ladies lead to mostly naked ladies. And mostly naked ladies lead to all-naked ladies. Like, so duh.

Same thing.

Posted

I think it's pretty obvious that changing the definition of "family" would change the definition of "Disney".

I remember back when what's-her-face went riding naked on a wrecking ball, everyone got their panties all in a bunch that MTV had shown a naked lady. But if you watched MTV in the early 90s, you knew it was just a matter of time. Half-naked ladies lead to mostly naked ladies. And mostly naked ladies lead to all-naked ladies. Like, so duh.

Same thing.

​Its really funny that you mention Disney as "family" since for the first 40 years they made movies the mothers died...or fathers or whatnot.  Alot of orphans...so hardly ideal family

Posted

Everybody needs to stop watching all television. It makes viewers stupid. 

The government is not Big Brother. TELEVISION is Big Brother. 

(Am I being clear and forceful enough?)
 

​Proof that I'm on the right track (thus, implicitly, you should follow my advice) - Pope Francis hasn't watched television since 1990!

http://www.aol.com/article/2015/05/26/pope-reveals-he-hasnt-watched-tv-since-1990/21187109/?icid=maing-grid7|main5|dl9|sec3_lnk3%26pLid%3D1894390560

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...