Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

I think this movie is hilarious! And on top of that... has a pretty good message...





OK...READY>>SET>> DISCUSS!

Posted

I love it...watched it two days ago again.

crusader1234
Posted

From a movie standpoint, it was amazing. SOO funny.

From a theological standpoint, it was a mess. The reason for that is the guy's reason for making the movie was that his mind was in a theological mess and he used it to sort things out (he was Catholic).

I especially liked the part with 'the muse'

Posted

i thought it was hooooorrrrible :mad:

Posted

what did you not like about it lifeteener?

Posted

What are guys talking about? Dogma is onee of the most anti-Catholic movies Hollywood's ever made! I mean, an atheist getting the stigmata? What a bunch of hoopla! And as I remeber it didn't the preist eventually leave the Church or something? IT'S AWFUL EVERYONE!!!!

Posted

I haven't seen the movie, but from what I've heard about it... it smells of elderberries.

Posted

ahh kevin smith...

i guess if it doesn't make you think then its not worth making...?

or should hollywood just stop making films that have faith issues all together...?

hmm...
that would make me sad.

crusader1234
Posted

its a comedy, its not trying to pass itself off as the gospel of kevin!

Posted

I haven't seen this movie, but from what I've heard, it's pretty anti-Catholic. Regardless of the fact that it's just a comedy, it still was pretty irreverent towards Catholicism. I can't be likin' that.

Sarah -- I have no problem with Hollywood making movies about faith, but I do have a problem when films about faith mock the faith they're trying to portray.

The thing is, though, that this movie isn't the least bit challenging or thought-provoking. I doubt those involved with the film would describe it as some kind of highbrow "think piece."

God bless,

Jennifer

Posted

[quote name='BeenaBobba' date='Jun 13 2004, 11:54 PM']I haven't seen this movie...


this movie isn't the least bit challenging or thought-provoking...

[/quote]
?

high brow? i don't think i'd consider it 'high brow' either.
and i can't think of a 'high brow' film at the moment...too late i guess. :)

but dogma did make me think twice about some things.
whether it was kevin smith's intention to lead others to christ by making dogma - i have no idea, i'm not kevin smith (thank goodness.) ;) whether or not you think he had that intention is a different discussion entirely. i don't agree with everything he's made/said etc, but i do believe he exposed himself and his faith by making this film, which is hard for anyone to do.

also just a reminder for those who have seen it and for those who haven't - the following is ksmith's "disclaimer" that rolls at the beginning of the film. take what you want from it.

"Though it'll go without saying ten minutes or so into these preceedings,
View Askew would like to state that this film is from start to finish a
work of comedic fantasy, not to be taken seriously. To insist that any of
what follows is incendiary or inflammatory is to miss our intention and
pass judgement; and passing judgement is reserved for God and God alone
(this goes for you film critics too...just kidding).
So please before you think about hurting someone over this trifle of a
film, remember: even God has a sense of humor. Just look at the Platypus.
Thank you and enjoy the show.
P.S. We sincerely apologize to all Platypus enthusiasts out there who are
offended by that thoughtless comment about Platypi. We at View Askew
respect the noble Platypus, and it is not our intention to slight these
stupid creatures in any way.
Thank you again and enjoy the showAfter the end credits, Jay's line "So... does that mean Bethany's... part
black?" line is repeated."Dogma" is the culmination of lifetime's worth of disparate spiritual and
satirical influences, which owes a debt to sundry storytellers and
word-smiths these authors and instigators I humbly thank in no particular
order...
Saint Mathew Saint Mark Saint Luke
Saint John Sam Kinison George Carlin
Elaine Pagels John Milton Cervantes
Martin Scorsese Alan Moore Thomas Moore
Spike Lee Douglas Adams Robert Bolt
Quentin Tarantino Nikos Kazantzakis Dennis Arcand
Neil Gaiman Grant Morrison Matt Wagner
Howard, Robin, Jackie, Fred, Gary, and everyone at the Howard Stern Show
and Sister Theresa from 8th grade."

crusader1234
Posted

Thanks for posting that!

I was trying to remember that part.

Posted

I wouldn't say that because the movie uses the catholic church for comedy it is anti-catholic....if this were its intention I do not feel it succeded...if I were to make an anti-catholic movie it would look nothing like Dogma!


-Kiel

crusader1234
Posted
:sweat: True. Any movie bashing Catholocism would have involved Jesuits. :rolling:
Posted

Hey! Half of my family attended Jesuit schools... oh wait... i think that explains everything!

Posted (edited)

I am not a big Jay and Silent Bob Fan...

Some of it was filmed in Pittsburgh....I am from Pittsburgh, so ya.

Otherwise, I prefer Science videos and Kid's movies... :pokeball:

Edited by peach_cube
lilac_angel
Posted

Yay for kids' movies and science videos!

:wub: :wub: :wub:

:kiss: :kiss: :kiss:

Posted

I just can't tolerate a movie that mocks Our Lady's perpetual virginity. To do so mockingly is blasphemous. Do you think people would be laughing if someone made a comedy about the Holocaust? I just don't see how blasphemy is funny, being that blasphemy is more serious a sin than murder, perhaps.

You might want to read [url="http://www.decentfilms.com/commentary/dogma-article.html"]this article[/url].

God bless,

Jennifer

Posted

Lets not compare their views of Mary to the holocaust. First this movie wasn't really about Mary, they just decided to throw a comedic twist about the Virgin, and there are many (uninformed) people who feel Mary did not remain a virgin...I wouldnt say that is enough to condemn the movie. If blasphemy was what the movie was all about and that was it's theme then maybe we could compare it to a holocaust movie. Having an open mind and being able to laugh at others comedic art is not a sin, unless it affects you and your spiritual walk with the Lord.

-Kiel

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...