Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

Hi Kiel,

Surely, you wouldn't disagree that blasphemy is just as serious, if not more serious, than murder? My example of the movie's portrayal of the Virgin Mary is just one example. The movie also pokes fun at indulgences (in addition to completely misconstruing the practice), expresses a somewhat pluralistic view of religion, is very sexual in nature, and presents God as a female. Do you think that the Catholic religion is something that should be laughed at in these ways? To me, Catholicism is way too sacred to mock in these ways.

In the article I posted, Ebert is quoted as saying that this film presents Catholic theology literally. Imagine a Protestant Christian going to see this movie -- i.e., a Protestant who is ignorant of the truths of Catholicism and perhaps has some prejudice against Catholicism. This, of course, does not apply to all Protestants, but I can only imagine a Protestant saying, "Aha! I knew indulgences were false. It's so funny how this movie makes fun of those falsities." As a matter of fact, you should read the reviews this movie got at [url="http://www.thefilmforum.com/"]The Film Forum: Christian Movie Commentary[/url]. [url="http://www.christiananswers.net/spotlight/movies/pre2000/dogma.html"]This review[/url], also written from a Protestant Christian perspective, thought that the movie was biblically accurate.

While this movie might not hurt the faith of faithful Catholics, I don't think it'd help the situation with under catechized Catholics, who might take the "theology" portrayed in the movie to be factual. And for faithful, orthodox Catholics, laughing at the expense of God, the Church, and the Virgin Mary wouldn't exactly strengthen one's faith. If anything, I think it'd help to inoculate people against attacks against the faith, and I don't think that tolerating blasphemy is a good thing.

God bless,

Jennifer

crusader1234
Posted

Hmm, a Priest I know liked this movie. Maybe only Catholics who are well versed in apologetics should be allowed to watch it? :rolling:

Posted

somebody else has said this already but let me repeat it... this movie is not to be taken seriously... the very first thing on the screen is a disclamer that says not to take it seriously... and saying that the movie is blasphemy i think might be taking the movie way to seriously... so the movie doesnt present a factually accurate persentaion of catholisim and its views... where did it say it was a documentary? its a work of fiction and people know that... and catholisism is sacred but because something is sacred doesnt mean that its somethign that we can laugh at when its presented in a comical and fictional way... the great thing about this movie is that it lets us laugh at ourselves... and if you look at it the whole theme of the movie is that people take religion too seriously and it causes trouble... not saying that faith and religion are bad... just saying that everyone should lighten up... thats what its saying...

Archbishop 10-K
Posted

Sadly, a lot of people take this movie seriously (the same way people do with The Da Vinci Code.) People will use Dogma to say "Aha! I knew it all along! The Catholic religion is [insert an anti-Catholic blurb here.]" Frankly, I'd like to see at least one movie (besides The Passion) which portrays Catholicism in a POSITIVE aspect. Is that really too much to ask?

Posted

Beenaboba - I think everything you said was right on, and it is sad that people can watch this film and be mislead about the Catholic church or it's teachings. But the fact is this movie isnt blasphemous because it is fiction and is supposed to be taken as fiction, and for pure entertainment. Now I would agree to a statement that this movie is unacceptable if it were claiming to be preaching truth, but that is not the case.

OwNeD_byGoD
Posted

to all-
it is usually hard to depict something as it is so i shall use a comparison to lighten the burden and make it more clearly understood. If i were to make a movie about the holocaust and i was making it against jews, i could easily put a warning in the beginning of the movie, saying: lighten up jews, dont be offended we arent really trying to offend you we're just making a satire about what you guys went through and your beliefs, but all is well dont take it too seriously. That is what Kevin is doing in this film, whether his intentions are truly to write a comedic ensamble or to really bash on catholics, i honestly have no idea what his purpose was with this film. But, like it has been said it can also be compared to the da vinci code in a sense, and i can tell you that many people i know believed the da vinci code to be true and so questioned their faith, if we are willing to support something that leads catholics to question their faith in a response saying that only some catholics should view it, when they clearly know that it is open to all not just the strong catholics, then i feel saddened.

Posted

Excellent post, OwNeD! I was going to write something along those lines, but you wrote it for me. :)

God bless,

Jen

cmotherofpirl
Posted

I find it disturbing and funny at the same time.

Posted

[quote name='Enda' date='Jun 13 2004, 05:57 PM'] What are guys talking about? Dogma is onee of the most anti-Catholic movies Hollywood's ever made! I mean, an atheist getting the stigmata? What a bunch of hoopla! And as I remeber it didn't the preist eventually leave the Church or something? IT'S AWFUL EVERYONE!!!! [/quote]
You're descriving Stigmata, not Dogma. Stigmata WAS anti-Catholic, and it tried heavily to push the Gnostic Gospel of St. Thomas.

Dogma was made by Kevin Smith, who claims to still be a practicing Catholic. The problem with the movie, though, is that it makes no sense. ;) Smith uses an indulgence as if it were Confession; in the movie, it provides forgiveness of sins, not the removal of temporal punishment (so the whole plot falls there).

As for the knock on Mary's Virginity, anyone read the Da Vinci Code? That's much worse, and I know plenty of Catholics who have read that.

It was meant to poke fun at Catholics who didn't understand their faith. However, his message that "It's not what you have faith in, just that you HAVE faith" was bogus anti-Christian. It also slammed pretty hard against organized religion as a whole.

Jake Huether
Posted

I will spend the money I would have used to see Dogma to see the Passion again. Why waste your money? For laughs? If you want to laugh, why not rent the Three stooges, or watch Ace Ventura, or any other comedy which doesn't push the envelope on blasphemy / heresy? Just doesn't make sense to me.

Even if it was remotely "okay", why even do it? There are other ways to reach the end (be it a good laugh or a good time). Why use a questionable means. And at the expense of your own faith...

Posted

The reason this is acceptiona;;y funny to me is that I can relate to it on a personal level...Dont twist my words here. Let me explain. I am very passionate about my Catholic faith, so if I see that presented in a comedic way, if it is not intended to do harm, I find it super funny. Like when you watch a roast on comedy central or something of that nature. Not everything said about the individual is accurate or true, and the person getting roasted knows that, as does the audience. That is what makes it more funny to me than say Ace Ventura or the three stooges. I can relate, it's like my faith getting roasted, but it's all in comedic fun.


-Kiel

Posted

right on point 5 thats exactly what i think

OwNeD_byGoD
Posted (edited)

hi kiel,

i see where you are coming from, i understand that it is like if a youth group were making a skit of the catholic church and having the theme as a parody, i understand however this movie isnt just a little joke, it is blown out of proportion and like i stated above, it saddens me to see that we support things that take "comedy" to the level of hindering weaker catholic's faith

Edited by OwNeD_byGoD
Posted

This whole hindering weaker Catholics faith is a valid argument, but I dont buy into it fully. Where do we draw the line. The statment at the biggining of the movie explains it is pure fiction and for comedic expression. You start off laughing with the platypus line. I realize weaker Catholics can get turned away by this movie, but that will not make me condemn it or stop watching it. Weaker Catholics leave the church every day due to a couple of out of context scripture verses by an anti-Catholic, or die hard protestant...weaker Catholics leave the church because of the publicised sex scandals. If someone is not gonna embrace their faith, and can allow a pure fiction movie, intended to make people laugh sway their personal beliefs, I ask what personal beliefs did they have in the first place. Nothing they researched on their own, they prolly just believe what anyone tells them. They are Catholic cause there parents were, or someone said it was the true church, then they see a movie or talk to a protestant who disagree, and all of the sudden they are believing something else????Doesn't seem like they had a belief in the firstplace, just an impriont of an impression someone else made on them. Sorry if that came off harsh...I'm bitter about a test I have to study for LOL.... I love everyone here, and Dogma, and my bulldog Mollie.

-Kiel aka Moses the Black (check the avitar!)

crusader1234
Posted

Hey, its been a while since I have posted in this thread and there are a lot of good comments, just a few I'd like to talk about:

As for making a Holocaust Comedy, thats a bit different. First of all, the subject matter is much more tender because it is so recent and so many people were murdered, rather than insulted. Also, Dogma was made by a Catholic, and you are not a Jew. The movie was not saying Ha Ha Catholics! Take a Joke! It was a Catholic taking a funny look at some parts of the faith he didn't fully understand.

Now I know some parts are insulting, but sometimes people need to learn to laugh at themselves. I know some priests who found this funny. I said 'Dont you think it totally misrepresents us' and he said 'Well yeah but its a comedy, its not trying to pretend its a Gospel or anything.' Which I totally agree with.

If you dont want to laugh at yourself or your faith, then don't go see this movie. As far as it hindering weaker Catholic's faith, it made me question my faith and go figure out what it was that Catholics believe, and sure enough, I agreed with the Church doctrine so this movie really only made me stronger.

But again, if you dont want to see it, dont see it, just dont pretend like its the devil.

Peace,

Rich

Posted

Pretend its the devil: hahahaha You are to funny.

On a side note you are correct that this movie can also cause a weaker Catholic to search for truth about hteir faith, and that is a good thing. In the end jsut go with your conscience on this one. Mine says watch it again and laugh. I think I will!

-Kiel

ps this board and the Musik lounge need more life in them...Im trying, but sometimes Nobody posts on a topic for like 3 days?????

DemonSlayer
Posted

It was just too blasphemous, I couldn't watch anymore of it half way through.

Posted

[quote name='DemonSlayer' date='Jun 17 2004, 06:19 AM'] It was just too blasphemous, I couldn't watch anymore of it half way through. [/quote]
The thing with Dogma is that if you don't watch the whole thing you can't understand the first part. It's like an episode of South Park, there is a message, but you have to watch the "off-color" parts first. I bet if people watched the last five or ten minutes of the movie they would be a bit confused, but they wouldn't agree with what was said. Try it out.

Posted

Hi Kiel,

I realize that the movie was only made in jest, but still. There is a line between comedy and blasphemy, and I think it was crossed in this movie. Humor can be used in strange ways, and even though Smith claims this movie was made in good fun, many portrayals in the movie were pretty darn irreverant. Why would someone want to make a movie that, while funny, completely misconstrues his religion? I, for one, would never make a movie that mocked Our Lady's virginity. I would think that that'd be crossing the line, as it is. It's like saying, "I'm going to make a comedy about your miscarriage, but it's okay, because I'm going to do so jokingly." If something is very important (or if something is sacred), it just shouldn't be mocked.

God bless,

Jennifer

Posted

[quote name='crusader1234' date='Jun 17 2004, 12:29 AM'] As for making a Holocaust Comedy, thats a bit different.  First of all, the subject matter is much more tender because it is so recent and so many people were murdered, rather than insulted.  Also, Dogma was made by a Catholic, and you are not a Jew.  The movie was not saying Ha Ha Catholics!  Take a Joke!  It was a Catholic taking a funny look at some parts of the faith he didn't fully understand. [/quote]
Hi Rich,

Like I said in one of my previous posts, blasphemy is probably a more serious sin than murder. Yes, the Holocaust was recent in history, but blasphemy is probably even more recent in that it is done quite frequently.

Do you think Jews would mind less if a Holocaust comedy was made by a Jew? I don't think that that would make it any better.

God bless,

Jen

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...