Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

veritasluxmea
Posted (edited)

 It's very easy to simply say "The right decision is to ditch the pig!", 

Unfortunately in their culture, she couldn't leave even if she wanted to. She has been raised and trained to rely on a man in her life (first their father, then their husband) for everything- food, shelter, living. She has no college education or means of supporting herself and her children. Her cultural mentality is the man in her life will take care of her- so how could she possibly leave him? Her family would shun her, a form of disowning, if she asked them for help in a separation. Leaving her husband would require leaving her culture, religious beliefs, family, children, everything, and she would start out with nothing. Quiverfull culture is a cult. 

Edited by veritasluxmea
Posted

I'm just sick of hearing about this croutons. But I clicked on the thread so it's my fault.

veritasluxmea
Posted

It's a work and prayer camp, not a certified rehab or whatever program. :(

Typical. Very sad about this whole situation. God save us from protestant heresies. 

Posted

Her family would shun her, a form of disowning, if she asked them for help in a separation. Leaving her husband would require leaving her culture, religious beliefs, family, children, everything, and she would start out with nothing. Quiverfull culture is a cult. 

I don't know if the wife is from a quiverful family. From her brother's comments it seems like at least part of her family would support her decision to leave.

 

Posted

The pastor at the church where the Duggars attend gave a sermon where he blamed Josh's wife for his affair. 

"If a husband or wife fails to keep his or her partner happy sexually they are opening themselves up to the attack of the enemy. And that enemy is going to take your spouse away from you."

 
He added, "Both men and woman have their sexual needs met by someone, somewhere, somehow."
 
Wow, this is messed up and is making the situation worse.

 

Posted

Unfortunately in their culture, she couldn't leave even if she wanted to. She has been raised and trained to rely on a man in her life (first their father, then their husband) for everything- food, shelter, living. She has no college education or means of supporting herself and her children. Her cultural mentality is the man in her life will take care of her- so how could she possibly leave him? Her family would shun her, a form of disowning, if she asked them for help in a separation. Leaving her husband would require leaving her culture, religious beliefs, family, children, everything, and she would start out with nothing. Quiverfull culture is a cult. 

The pastor at the church where the Duggars attend gave a sermon where he blamed Josh's wife for his affair. 

"If a husband or wife fails to keep his or her partner happy sexually they are opening themselves up to the attack of the enemy. And that enemy is going to take your spouse away from you."

 
He added, "Both men and woman have their sexual needs met by someone, somewhere, somehow."
 
Wow, this is messed up and is making the situation worse.

 

Amazing. Honestly I'm not surprised with this at all. I did not like the way they handled the last scandal at all. It made me sick to my stomach to watch it all unfold. The men are always blameless and the women get nothing what so ever. @tinytherese was there an article where you read this from?

Archaeology cat
Posted

I don't know if the wife is from a quiverful family. From her brother's comments it seems like at least part of her family would support her decision to leave.

 

Her family is Quiverfull, but some of the siblings have left the movement.

PhuturePriest
Posted

The pastor at the church where the Duggars attend gave a sermon where he blamed Josh's wife for his affair. 

"If a husband or wife fails to keep his or her partner happy sexually they are opening themselves up to the attack of the enemy. And that enemy is going to take your spouse away from you."

 
He added, "Both men and woman have their sexual needs met by someone, somewhere, somehow."
 
Wow, this is messed up and is making the situation worse.

 

To some extent, this is true -- for instance, if your spouse decides that sex once every six months is sufficient, that will cause major strain in the marriage. 

However, that does not excuse cheating or watching pornography, and it is irrelevant in this situation anyway, because he had been involved in this stuff before the marriage. 

Posted

I read this morning that only 3 zip codes in the U.S.  didn't have any Ashley clients. Two were remote Inuit villages in Alaska and one a remote place in New Mexico that didn't have internet access. 

<1% of the female accounts were real, so don't put any stock in that little factoid. :coffee:

Posted

I don't know if the wife is from a quiverful family. From her brother's comments it seems like at least part of her family would support her decision to leave.

Her family is Quiverfull, but some of the siblings have left the movement.

Interesting, Ive never heard of that term before.

IgnatiusofLoyola
Posted

Typical. Very sad about this whole situation. God save us from protestant heresies. 

I doubt that these kind of programs or ways of dealing with sexual scandal are limited to Protestants. The problems the Catholic Church has faced due to trying to cover up child abuse by priests should have taught us that sexual issues can even affect Roman Catholic men who have chosen to devote their lives to God, sad as that is.

Any time we try to present ourselves as more Godly and righteous than someone else, there are potential problems ahead.

 

 

veritasluxmea
Posted

I doubt that these kind of programs or ways of dealing with sexual scandal are limited to Protestants. The problems the Catholic Church has faced due to trying to cover up child abuse by priests should have taught us that sexual issues can even affect Roman Catholic men who have chosen to devote their lives to God, sad as that is.

Any time we try to present ourselves as more Godly and righteous than someone else, there are potential problems ahead.

 

 

Quiverfull culture/cult/religion, which the Duggars are a part of, is a very ugly side of Protestantism. The whole movement/belief/culture was what I was referring to when I posted about heresies, not the "rehab" program. (Probably should have been clearer.) I still stand by my statement. The Duggar's religion is very damaging to the whole person... and they way the Duggars are handling it is typical to their beliefs and subculture. :( 

I could just never be a show of a show glorifying this religion.Yuk. 

Interesting, Ive never heard of that term before.

Worldwide, there are only about a couple thousand people identifying with the movement, and it's very new, starting around the 1980's. It's really only due to the internet blogs from ex-members (and the Duggar family) that it's gaining awareness. 

Ash Wednesday
Posted

I've seen many Catholics praise the Duggars to the sky but their belief system doesn't share the same admiration for Catholicism. It's my understanding that like other Christian fundamentalists, the Quiverfull beliefs involve a very negative view of Catholicism and the Church, one that goes beyond mainline Protestants of the polite sort who disagree on doctrine and whatnot.

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/femail/article-2703428/Jessa-Duggars-Christian-boyfriend-Ben-Seewald-deletes-anti-Catholic-Facebook-rant.html

Jessa Duggar's boyfriend/husband/whatever wants us to be "saved" from our "deadly" errors. 

Posted

Honestly, is this garbage worthy of 13 pages of discussion?  Does endlessly discussing the Duggar's sins and failings do anybody here and positive good?

How about some prayers for all involved, then move on?

Posted

Honestly, is this garbage worthy of 13 pages of discussion?  Does endlessly discussing the Duggar's sins and failings do anybody here and positive good?

How about some prayers for all involved, then move on?

I think it's very worthwhile.  Lots to learn.  The dangers of flirting with extreme hypocrisy. Does partial failure wipe out the possible good? Is it possibly similar how the Catholic Church was damaged by the failure of a few?  My heart certainly feels sorrow for the pain his family must endure now. It is a cautionary tale, especially for those who watched the show and felt like they knew these people to some degree.   Did you watch the shows?

puellapaschalis
Posted

In a culture massively ignorant of authentic Christianity, a relatively media-heavy presence like the Duggars, Bates, and others in the Quiverfull/ATI/Gothard/IBLP movement demands refutation. That necessitates those (including us) able to do the refuting understanding the ins and outs of the movement's thinking, and yes, that means talking about when things go wrong and how the upbringing factors in things like sexual molestation, adultery, and use of pornography.

There are too many people who admire the Duggars (et al) as honest Christians doing their best and who as such should be left alone. But (imo) all these alarm bells that ring when people read about Quiverfull are symptoms of errors like sola scriptura. They should be studied and discussed as such.

blazeingstar
Posted

I doubt that these kind of programs or ways of dealing with sexual scandal are limited to Protestants. The problems the Catholic Church has faced due to trying to cover up child abuse by priests should have taught us that sexual issues can even affect Roman Catholic men who have chosen to devote their lives to God, sad as that is.

Any time we try to present ourselves as more Godly and righteous than someone else, there are potential problems ahead.

 

 

In Mass yesterday I was trying to figure out why this didn't sit right with me.  Why I couldn't seem to grasp why I am made more anxious by the actions of a few, fringe protestants than I am by evil priests.

As the priest did a homily about what God wants and what what the will of God is---to help us grow--it dawned on me.  The true evil in this is that the actions of the Church were sinful, hypocratic and evil.  And we knew it.  Priests and Bishops answered evil with more sin and everyone knew it was wrong.  They all knew what they were doing was bad but they did it anyway.

With the Duggers, Bates, with the Penningtons and so many others in these rapidly growing "fringe" Christian groups they do NOT acknowledge evil for what it is.  They blame toddlers on masterbating as a reason that a teenage boy molested them, they blame a wife who's had 4 kids in nearly as many years of marriage as a reason why a husband would stray---obviously she's sexually underperforming.  They don't give women the chance to have a good education, and any education past highschool for women is considered suspect and we've even seen crazy protestants publish reasons why.  And people agreed!!!  (not regular people, but many in these sects).  They also harm the young men, turning them from providers (who provide love and support) into paychecks and the reason and cause a family may not be doing well (gospel of prosperity).   If you pay attention to christian music today there's hints comeing through in some of the songs like "Lead me" and others.

And so the worthwhileness of the thread is that we should be alerted to this trend.  We should be aware of our suffering Christian brothers and sisters.  We should have our anteni go up when we hear about that "wierd christian school" where all the girls where skirts and the boys are courting so they can get married upon graduation.  We should participate in homeschool circles with christians where we see educational neglect of women.  We should, when possible, make loud noise about cases of parents holding their children's identities hostage which is a problem almost exclusive to these christian networks.

And yes, there is far worse in the world.  What priests did to children is abhorrent.  We have human trafficing that's a bigger issue.  We have mommy bloggers who've been convicted of murder.  But these religions are growing, are dangerous and are something we will have to continue to face and rebut.

God desires good for all His Children.  He wants them to grow and thrive.  He has given women the capacity for so much more than popping out babies.  He has given men the capacity to do more than bring home a pay check.  These religions do go against the dignaty of the human.  They aren't simply dealing with a case of sin and evil, they, at their core, are teaching evil.  How to deal with that...I'm not sure...other than being a presence in their community and really letting them know that we are not evil.

 

 

 

 

 

Posted

Hi blaze, haven't seen you in a while. :wave:Good post.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...