Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

Hotpink, serious question -- you're not Catholic, so why do you care?

The pope did not tell anyone to stop focusing on hot button issues. The message he wanted to get across was that so-called hot button issues weren't all that the Church cared about.

 

​amen, this is exactly why I was irritated at what hotpink said.

Posted

Had another idea... I recently saw a "Top Ten Reasons people leave the church" list somewhere. What if we made a video series addressing each of these reasons?

franciscanheart
Posted

Had another idea... I recently saw a "Top Ten Reasons people leave the church" list somewhere. What if we made a video series addressing each of these reasons?

​Like this,

 

Also, would prefer to see something with "you're doing it wrong" in the title, just for laughs.

Posted

​amen, this is exactly why I was irritated at what hotpink said.

​Well I guess you can preach to the choir...if you want.  But again, I'm the non-catholic here.  And I'm sorry but if you produce videos and start with only hot button issues then you are appearing only to care about them.

Posted

Mass: Keeping it Real

Posted

Transubstantiation

Posted

I know: Let's make a video about hotpink's attitude.

Posted

I know: Let's make a video about hotpink's attitude.

​Not called for.

Posted

​Not called for.

​I dunno. I weighed it and thought, ultimately, "someone needs to say something".

Posted

Let's make a video from this: http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/topic/137650-were-you-raised-catholic-or-a-convert/

One for reverts, one for converts, one for cradle Catholics. Personally, I've found the best evangelization tool to be just telling your own story. That's not "offensive" or "aggressive", and often people see some similarity to their own lives that gets them thinking, "Hm, I wonder if that could be me."

Posted

I know: Let's make a video about hotpink's attitude.

​

​I dunno. I weighed it and thought, ultimately, "someone needs to say something".

​Oh yeah, because I only suggested a video learning about mass.  Please, charge me with one of your imaginary crimes.  I'd loved to see what you come up with.  Maybe, just maybe, having a video teaching about oooooh one of the central parts of the entire faith is a good idea.

IgnatiusofLoyola
Posted

C'mon hotpink, you called Gabriela's ideas "horrible." They weren't horrible--they were just different from yours.

I don't think you should have been called a "troll," but when a thread is simply brainstorming ideas, you can't call someone else's ideas "horrible" without getting some flack over it. 

Posted

C'mon hotpink, you called Gabriela's ideas "horrible." They weren't horrible--they were just different from yours.

I don't think you should have been called a "troll," but when a thread is simply brainstorming ideas, you can't call someone else's ideas "horrible" without getting some flack over it. 

​I do feel it's horrible that the Catholic peoples can't seem just to get over the hot button issues already.  I think it's horrible that we get bashed on every forum and in every place possible for what I believe and what Catholics should believe.  I think it's horrible that so many people from Lifeteen to Dioceses have spent time, money and energy to yet again yipe at the heels hot issues and accomplish nothing.  Catholics have so many positive and cool things, its like they absoutely loose their marbles when it comes to social stuff tho...and only focus on that.

It's like there's some person that believes it's their sole duty to keep all the evil people in check by posters and vidios and songs and whatenot.  Maybe, just maybe if you lead with the stuff that is amazing about the church, rather than the mucky nasty stuff that we're all tired of hearing about, more people would be intersted.

Could someone's mind be change by a youtube video?  Sure.  Someone posted a video on here about what a man was teaching his toddler son about Santa and it swayed me.  But my mind wasn't made up.  At this point I think very few people don't have their mind made up about homosexual "marriage" or abortion or women priests or married priests or whatever.

I mean being Catholic can be cool.  It should be something you want to be a part of.  Like that french youth group that made "Catholic Style" out of Gangham Style.  I'd totally move to France if I knew french and be a part of THAT organization. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-5kobTBfAdk  Why?  Because they are happy and having fun and totally LOVING Who they are.  Not obsessed with issues.

Posted

we should do the phattest loser again.

Posted

we should do the phattest loser again.

​this actually happened??

Posted

​I do feel it's horrible that the Catholic peoples can't seem just to get over the hot button issues already.  I think it's horrible that we get bashed on every forum and in every place possible for what I believe and what Catholics should believe.  I think it's horrible that so many people from Lifeteen to Dioceses have spent time, money and energy to yet again yipe at the heels hot issues and accomplish nothing.  Catholics have so many positive and cool things, its like they absoutely loose their marbles when it comes to social stuff tho...and only focus on that.

It's like there's some person that believes it's their sole duty to keep all the evil people in check by posters and vidios and songs and whatenot.  Maybe, just maybe if you lead with the stuff that is amazing about the church, rather than the mucky nasty stuff that we're all tired of hearing about, more people would be intersted.

Could someone's mind be change by a youtube video?  Sure.  Someone posted a video on here about what a man was teaching his toddler son about Santa and it swayed me.  But my mind wasn't made up.  At this point I think very few people don't have their mind made up about homosexual "marriage" or abortion or women priests or married priests or whatever.

I mean being Catholic can be cool.  It should be something you want to be a part of.  Like that french youth group that made "Catholic Style" out of Gangham Style.  I'd totally move to France if I knew french and be a part of THAT organization. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-5kobTBfAdk  Why?  Because they are happy and having fun and totally LOVING Who they are.  Not obsessed with issues.

​So, after you've lured people into the Faith by showing them how "cool" it is to be Catholic, at what point would you tell them that Catholics disapprove of artificial birth control, abortion, remarriage without an annulment, and premarital and homosexual sex?

I don't entirely disagree with you. I think we need a balance. And just being who we are—happy Catholics—is a great evangelization tool. But I also think that the Church's positions on "hot-button issues" are important and need to be understood correctly, especially by people considering conversion.

And I don't think that Catholics should worry about appearing "cool" and "fun". That caters to the world's values, not Catholic values. When people are called to join the Church, they're called OUT of the world. To present to people nothing but "cool, fun" Catholicism is therefore deceptive and manipulative.

It's important to remember, also, that ultimately, Catholicism is a Faith that challenges us. Again, then, presenting it as all "cool" and "fun" makes it look misleadingly easy. In the circles I move in, people today are talking about how youth especially, but also people of all ages, are no longer looking for something easy. They're looking for challenges. Our Faith should challenge us, and Catholicism certainly does, and that in and of itself is an attraction of our Faith that ought to be put out there.

PhuturePriest
Posted (edited)

​So, after you've lured people into the Faith by showing them how "cool" it is to be Catholic, at what point would you tell them that Catholics disapprove of artificial birth control, abortion, remarriage without an annulment, and premarital and homosexual sex?

I don't entirely disagree with you. I think we need a balance. And just being who we are—happy Catholics—is a great evangelization tool. But I also think that the Church's positions on "hot-button issues" are important and need to be understood correctly, especially by people considering conversion.

And I don't think that Catholics should worry about appearing "cool" and "fun". That caters to the world's values, not Catholic values. When people are called to join the Church, they're called OUT of the world. To present to people nothing but "cool, fun" Catholicism is therefore deceptive and manipulative.

It's important to remember, also, that ultimately, Catholicism is a Faith that challenges us. Again, then, presenting it as all "cool" and "fun" makes it look misleadingly easy. In the circles I move in, people today are talking about how youth especially, but also people of all ages, are no longer looking for something easy. They're looking for challenges. Our Faith should challenge us, and Catholicism certainly does, and that in and of itself is an attraction of our Faith that ought to be put out there.

​The Church is growing very strong in the youth, coincidentally. People of my generation are taking the faith far more seriously than the previous generations of cultural Catholics. I know a fair share of cultural Catholics my age, of course, but the most devout Catholics I know are generally between the ages 16-26.

It was noted by a young guest on Church Militant recently that millenials are a very polarized generation: You're either zealous one way or the other, there are very few in-between. You're either on fire for the culture or on fire for the Church, and apathy and lukewarmness are rarely seen. That is certainly a positive thing, but it also means that our window of easy conversions are over. This next generation is going to be a very tough nut to crack, and we need to be very well versed in our faith if we want to have a fighting chance.

Edited by PhuturePriest
HopefulHeart
Posted

Video idea:  Epic Gregorian chant battles of church history. Like epic rap battles, but more Catholic.

Posted

​So, after you've lured people into the Faith by showing them how "cool" it is to be Catholic, at what point would you tell them that Catholics disapprove of artificial birth control, abortion, remarriage without an annulment, and premarital and homosexual sex?

I don't entirely disagree with you. I think we need a balance. And just being who we are—happy Catholics—is a great evangelization tool. But I also think that the Church's positions on "hot-button issues" are important and need to be understood correctly, especially by people considering conversion.

And I don't think that Catholics should worry about appearing "cool" and "fun". That caters to the world's values, not Catholic values. When people are called to join the Church, they're called OUT of the world. To present to people nothing but "cool, fun" Catholicism is therefore deceptive and manipulative.

It's important to remember, also, that ultimately, Catholicism is a Faith that challenges us. Again, then, presenting it as all "cool" and "fun" makes it look misleadingly easy. In the circles I move in, people today are talking about how youth especially, but also people of all ages, are no longer looking for something easy. They're looking for challenges. Our Faith should challenge us, and Catholicism certainly does, and that in and of itself is an attraction of our Faith that ought to be put out there.

​The problem is that these hot button topics should be handled one on one, not in a youtube video.  Their is so much hate, negativity and "bad" good theology.  The first thing is to energize.  The love of the Eucharist must take over.  Logic will never win if it is applied alone.

Posted

Video idea:  Epic Gregorian chant battles of church history. Like epic rap battles, but more Catholic.

​If I could prop this 10,000 times, I would.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...