Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

The Hymnal Study: Pre- and Post-VII Hymns


Recommended Posts

Nihil Obstat
Posted

I didn't know that! I go to FSSP also

I started attending more or less exclusively around 2010. As soon as I had regular access to a vehicle. These days I go to the Novus Ordo maybe five or six times a year, if that.

puellapaschalis
Posted

Propers can be chanted in the Novus Ordo. They never are. I go to a Fraternity Mass. It is a parish shared with the diocese though.

I can think of at least five parishes (where I've been present) on two continents that do, and that's before at least one religious congregation.

Posted (edited)

Same here :) the men sing the propers and the general choir sings everything else. 

What type of parish do you attend - diocesan or something like FSSP?

I'm guessing its EF based on the fact that they have Communion Propers? I'm not sure if OF Masses do that ever. I've only heard hymns. Are propers not done in the OF?

The parishes around here all recently started saying the Communion propers. The priest says them before distributing. They're not chanted, though.

Oh, and they're all NO.

I started attending more or less exclusively around 2010. As soon as I had regular access to a vehicle. These days I go to the Novus Ordo maybe five or six times a year, if that.

:sad:

Why not me, Lord?! Why not me?!

Edited by Gabriela
Nihil Obstat
Posted

Move to Calgary, Gabriela. You will love our group of young people too. ;)

Posted

Move to Calgary, Gabriela. You will love our group of young people too. ;)

Right. I'll just find me a job there tomorrow and come right up.

(It would be nice to not have to lock my doors. ;) )

Nihil Obstat
Posted

 

Right. I'll just find me a job there tomorrow and come right up.

(It would be nice to not have to lock my doors. ;) )

Eh. Do still lock the doors. Calgary is a big city with its share of crime. More jobs than Murica though. ;) Ask @truthfinder how great it is here.

Posted

 

Eh. Do still lock the doors. Calgary is a big city with its share of crime. More jobs than Murica though. ;) Ask @truthfinder how great it is here.

Do they hire laypeople to teach preaching in seminaries up there? Cuz they fired 'em all down here.

AveMariaPurissima
Posted

I looked at the article quickly and I'm finding it quite fascinating -- I look forward to reading it more in depth at some point. :)

 

Oh, and at my predominantly NO parish, we usually have a cantor chant the Communion antiphon (including the verses!), then the organist plays an instrumental while the congregation receives Communion.  Sometimes the choir will sing a hymn, or we'll do a congregational hymn toward the end of Communion (once nearly everyone has received.)

Nihil Obstat
Posted

Do they hire laypeople to teach preaching in seminaries up there? Cuz they fired 'em all down here.

No idea, actually. I know more about the Fraternity seminary than I do about the more local one. @CatherineM might know though.

truthfinder
Posted (edited)

Do they hire laypeople to teach preaching in seminaries up there? Cuz they fired 'em all down here.

Oh it's a lovely place :) I don't think there's a seminary at all in Calgary, just the one in Edmonton, which Nihil has rightly said to consult CatherineM.  There is, however, a Catholic university that does hire lay people.

Oh, and the door-locking thing is a myth. I wouldn't in a thousand years leave my door unlocked; I've even returned home to check them.  I'm sure I could leave my doors unlocked, but why chance it.  (Unless of course you find yourself in Churchill, where people are supposed to keep their car doors unlocked in case they need to quickly hide from polar bears).

Edited by truthfinder
Nihil Obstat
Posted

The thing they say about locked doors... They keep honest people honest. Not much more than that.

Posted

 (Unless of course you find yourself in Churchill, where people are supposed to keep their car doors unlocked in case they need to quickly hide from polar bears).

!!!!  I did not know this! :|

Not that I have to know it but it is still interesting none the less

 

Posted

(Unless of course you find yourself in Churchill, where people are supposed to keep their car doors unlocked in case they need to quickly hide from polar bears).

:|

He is Risen!
Posted

I remember an excellent article in This Rock magazine about this subject and it mentioned singing about yourself and speaking in the place of God.  I usually attend an FSSP parish with decent music, except when the warbley soprano is in the choir, (oh my gosh, I just want to take her out) It's amazing how distracting that can be (yep I'm a huge snob, I'm working on this) Charity...charity...charity, ugh

CountrySteve937
Posted

Propers and no hymns at Mass, and then Vespers every (Sun)day with the proper hymn :)

Yes!

Posted

I remember an excellent article in This Rock magazine about this subject and it mentioned singing about yourself and speaking in the place of God.

You wouldn't happen to remember the title, or a portion thereof, or the author, or the approximate date this article came out, would you?

He is Risen!
Posted

I'll see if I can find it, I'm thinking it was from 2008 or 2009.  I don't have any of the old mags but I feel like they may be archived online somewhere.  It was such a great article, my house had a subscription to This Rock and I remember making a photocopy of it for some of my church musician friends.

Posted

Great article!  I particularly loved the paragraph early on where you said you can guess the time period the song was written before even looking at the footnotes in the hymnal because I do the exact same thing.  I don't have as much of a problem with the style of music we sing at the N.O. mass as I do with the lyrics.  This might be splitting hairs but I just feel like the old hymns were so much more lyrically beautiful and poetic.  And of course as the article mentions, much less divine self-referencing occurred (aka "I am the Bread of Life") 

Ok maybe I misspoke.  I do have a problem with the style of music.  I can't help but feel frustrated and saddened when we sing "O Sacred Head Surrounded" during Holy Week and very few parishioners know the song to sing along.  It just seems to me that the older hymns were much more about adoration of God and veneration of the Blessed Mother and more modern songs tend to be vague and less focused on specific Catholic dogmas as opposed to generic Christian sentiment.  Music can have such a powerful effect on people and it's no wonder catechesis is so poor these days when we even eliminate it from our hymns.  Ok end rant.

*This is probably one of my less diplomatic posts here but I have to be honest because I feel like too many people overlook what the Holy Sacrifice of the Mass is and that the music should be more reflective of that.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...