Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

The Hymnal Study: Pre- and Post-VII Hymns


Recommended Posts

Posted

I've been thinking about this a lot since you posted it, and comparing it with hymnography that I know, both eastern and western, modern and ancient... and I'm not sure it's just us-focus. Much, perhaps even most pre-modern prayer and hymnography uses the perspective of the worshipping body talking to God - from the Lord's prayer on down. To say it's just us-focus is only half the point. I think the difference is that it moves away from referring to ourselves as sinners. Cf. 'We are sign, we are wonder' etc. that you quoted in the article. What does that even mean? There's a shift away from our lowliness in relation to God's glory, towards our amesomeness which may or may not have anything to do with God, depending on which hymn you look at...

There's a lot I could say about the watering down of theology in contemporary hymnography, but that's another post.

Posted (edited)

I've been thinking about this a lot since you posted it, and comparing it with hymnography that I know, both eastern and western, modern and ancient... and I'm not sure it's just us-focus. Much, perhaps even most pre-modern prayer and hymnography uses the perspective of the worshipping body talking to God - from the Lord's prayer on down. To say it's just us-focus is only half the point. I think the difference is that it moves away from referring to ourselves as sinners. Cf. 'We are sign, we are wonder' etc. that you quoted in the article. What does that even mean? There's a shift away from our lowliness in relation to God's glory, towards our amesomeness which may or may not have anything to do with God, depending on which hymn you look at...

There's a lot I could say about the watering down of theology in contemporary hymnography, but that's another post.

Yeah, I agree. A pronoun study is very limited. The point of it is to launch deeper analyses, precisely of the type you mention, which would require what's called "thematic analysis". That's much more complex and involved and tedious, hence the simple study to get us started.

I think that lack of poetic language/linguistic skill and banalization (I made that up, but you know what I mean) of the music itself are also issues post-VII.

Edited by Gabriela
Posted

Yeah, I agree. A pronoun study is very limited. The point of it is to launch deeper analyses, precisely of the type you mention, which would require what's called "thematic analysis". That's much more complex and involved and tedious, hence the simple study to get us started.

I think that lack of poetic language/linguistic skill and banalization (I made that up, but you know what I mean) of the music itself are also issues post-VII.

Yes. Is it the fact that we are more lukewarm in the faith than the great hymnographers of times past? That we are not as well catechised and are used to swimming in shallow theological waters? Is it the birth of the hymnbook industry into the gameplay, as you mentioned in the article's comments, which encourages volume and new material over musical and theological excellence? I think it might be elements of all of these...?

I appreciate the work that you put in, even though you recognise it's only a beginning. I find it fascinating, and a little self-reflection in the arena of liturgical music is a good thing, I think.

Posted

Yes. Is it the fact that we are more lukewarm in the faith than the great hymnographers of times past? That we are not as well catechised and are used to swimming in shallow theological waters? Is it the birth of the hymnbook industry into the gameplay, as you mentioned in the article's comments, which encourages volume and new material over musical and theological excellence? I think it might be elements of all of these...?

I think it is all of the above, as well as other things we have not mentioned: Embrace of secular culture has made it seem okay to import secular melodies into sacred songs. The decline of education in America makes it difficult to find lyricists with real linguistic talent. A trend of "self-expression" as the primary goal of art among all artists has led to a total disregard for the effects that various musical products have on the congregation. Etc.

In short: Yeah, it's a trainwreck. But we still have hope. :) 

  • 3 weeks later...
Posted

No idea, actually. I know more about the Fraternity seminary than I do about the more local one. @CatherineM might know though.

lay people don't teach preaching at our school and lay people don't take the class. 

Posted

lay people don't teach preaching at our school and lay people don't take the class. 

Are you at Notre Dame? I've heard it's like that there.

Posted

Are you at Notre Dame? I've heard it's like that there.

Newman Theological next to St. Joseph's Seminary in Edmonton. I officially start work on my Master's thesis today. 

Posted

Newman Theological next to St. Joseph's Seminary in Edmonton. I officially start work on my Master's thesis today. 

Congatulations! And good luck! :like2:

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...