Ice_nine Posted July 21, 2015 Posted July 21, 2015 No, this is Phatmass. Never on any other website have I ever encountered such psychoanalyzation of every single detail, nor people feeling such liberty to just change a topic because they didn't like the way someone said something. These are things completely special to Phatmass, in my experience. On Facebook, if people disagree with something they heard, they'll say something like "Well, I'm not quite sure what you mean by that. Did you mean x, or was that my misunderstanding?" (if they're reasonable people, anyway. Others are just trolling.) Here, you can expect that someone or many will just begin by openly disagreeing with you without first making sure what you said is what you meant or without second thought as to whether it would be appropriate to turn the topic into a debate in the first place. I put this in Open Mic, not the Debate Table. There are two distinct boards for a reason. You don't have control over people's reactions. If you want to whinge about that, be my guest. A forum is a place for discussion. There are formats more suited to "just letting people know about an event" than an internet forum, but since you wanted to let the people of phatmass know . . . well you got a discussion where you didn't *want* one. And now we're having an even more ridiculous discussion. Started by YOU. It's ironic in way, is it not?
Tab'le De'Bah-Rye Posted July 21, 2015 Posted July 21, 2015 That is a British or Commonwealth term. I live in England, but I am American. So.... I'm right, you're wrong... hahahahahahahaha I hope you do know I'm just kidding there. I couldn't resist. goodie goodie gum drops. sorry couldn't resist. You don't have control over people's reactions. If you want to whinge about that, be my guest. A forum is a place for discussion. There are formats more suited to "just letting people know about an event" than an internet forum, but since you wanted to let the people of phatmass know . . . well you got a discussion where you didn't *want* one. And now we're having an even more ridiculous discussion. Started by YOU. It's ironic in way, is it not? I don't think FP has his knickers tied in a knott, is this that you are assuming? Or are you trying to give him a wedgie that has already obviously been administered, by the way people wedgies are so immature and childish.
Tab'le De'Bah-Rye Posted July 21, 2015 Posted July 21, 2015 (edited) Let go and loose control phatmass, in other words let go and let god. Don't try and control everyone and everything, don't try and dominate the conversations, that's the sense i get anyway from my discussions here, relax really. But anyhow i don't hate phatmass, and it isn't me trying to control the situation just backing up FP whom i'm sure as he has stated is tired of this, but also i understand it is up to dUSt and the Mediators of Meh as to what is and what isn't and i am just a chummy commoner but will back up anyone that seems to be getting stomped, and yes even if you are a habitual stomper i will let go of my bias for the friendlies and say hey. I am not judging any of you just something i have noticed that seems to happen quiet frequently and causes a lot of tension, perhaps not for the few that do this because obviously this has happened to you and you feel it to be normal perhaps, or your just cheeky monkeys that like to lets use a nice word, stir the pot, just be careful when your stiring the pot not to spill the guts of the meal all over the floor cause it creates a terrible mess. No pun intended and yes obviously i could be terribly wrong. And no ice nine this whole comment is not directed directly at you. And again yes i have no authority here and this is just a personal observation that could be wrong and please remember people that if you are indeed catholic that there are many other people watching you here that are catholics searching and people that know nothing about catholicism, please remeber you are representing the Love of Jesus Christ here in Faith, hope and charity(and charity in word not just money), because that is what Catholics are supposed to do right? Onward christian souls. GodblesS. Jesus is LORD! P.s. I absolutely love everyone here even if i don't like the attitude at times, and that attitude is not always present but seems to raise its ugly head all to often even if it's only sometimes, i don't know the stats i'm not here that often. And by no means am i saying that your not trying your best and by know means am i trying to put you in a box where you can not grow and flourish but there are general rules in life that keep all safe and free and in the spirit of charity. Edited July 21, 2015 by Tab'le De'Bah-Rye typo
Lilllabettt Posted July 21, 2015 Posted July 21, 2015 Sounds like you have it all figured out Almost, but the idea in the "I dont know" camp is that you withhold judgement and categorization because you realize that we dont understand the whole picture yet. If you believe you current view of sexuality is complete and you know 100% that there is nothing new to learn, then go ahead and judge away. You can form your little categories of people based on the clothes they wear and start sorting people. Im not sure what you mean by viewing transgenderism critically...Id rather think I view it pretty non critically in that I have little opinion on it at all. Id say your camp of conservatives view things extremely critically because you reject peoples notions of individuality if they do not coincide with an outdated, impervious view of the world. There's nothing wrong with saying "I don't know." Unfortunately most people do not praise the courage and wisdom of saying "I don't know" until they have been caught talking out of their bottoms. About theology of the body, or feminism, for example. Just as most people are very sure they have opened their minds right up until the moment they realize they have substituted one form of unthinking dogmatism for another.
CrossCuT Posted July 21, 2015 Posted July 21, 2015 There's nothing wrong with saying "I don't know." Unfortunately most people do not praise the courage and wisdom of saying "I don't know" until they have been caught talking out of their bottoms. About theology of the body, or feminism, for example. Just as most people are very sure they have opened their minds right up until the moment they realize they have substituted one form of unthinking dogmatism for another. Id like to take you out someday and show you a good time. Maybe we can work on untwisting those panties a bit. <3
Gabriela Posted July 22, 2015 Posted July 22, 2015 (edited) Id like to take you out someday and show you a good time. Maybe we can work on untwisting those panties a bit. <3 Oh no you did not just... Oh wait. You're female. Okay! Edited July 22, 2015 by Gabriela
PhuturePriest Posted July 22, 2015 Author Posted July 22, 2015 (edited) Oh no you did not just... Oh wait. You're female. Okay! I'm calling a double-standard here. Edited July 22, 2015 by PhuturePriest
Lilllabettt Posted July 22, 2015 Posted July 22, 2015 Id like to take you out someday and show you a good time. Maybe we can work on untwisting those panties a bit. <3 I sure have gotten some super weird suggestions on phatmass. I mean between this and Norseman's idea that I offer myself up as a bride to a gay man. everyone on phatmass leave my panties alone O.K.
Credo in Deum Posted July 22, 2015 Posted July 22, 2015 (edited) @PhuturePriest: congrats on your article! Edited July 22, 2015 by Credo in Deum
CrossCuT Posted July 22, 2015 Posted July 22, 2015 Maybe that sounded a little creepier than intended...
Gabriela Posted July 22, 2015 Posted July 22, 2015 Maybe that sounded a little creepier than intended... Maybe, yeah. I'm calling a double-standard here. Yeah, those exist. But I initially thought it was an aggressive sexual advance, which is what shocked me. Then I realized CrossCut is female and it just seemed rude. Which is better than an aggressive sexual advance. Hence the "Okay".
Anomaly Posted July 22, 2015 Posted July 22, 2015 I sure have gotten some super weird suggestions on phatmass. I mean between this and Norseman's idea that I offer myself up as a bride to a gay man. everyone on phatmass leave my panties alone O.K. Well played. Ten points for Ravenclaw.
MarysLittleFlower Posted July 22, 2015 Posted July 22, 2015 I'm not a conservative. I am a radical feminist (albeit an unusual one, as I'm Catholic), and I wrote 'critique of gender', not 'critique of transgenderism'. I know people who are transgender, I respect that I can't understand their experiences, and I don't want to make harsh judgments on them as people for trying to make themselves feel more at home in their bodies. But I do have a critical view of the concept of gender itself, viewing it as primarily a tool of control, and the thing that frustrates me about most liberal feminists is that they will also say that gender is narrow, constricting, harmful - but then when someone turns round and says he has always known he was a girl because he liked to play with dolls as a child and he was emotionally sensitive, they accept this reasoning unquestioningly. They accept it even though it's harmful to women, reinforcing as it does the idea that female = pink and fluffy. I don't think I'm rejecting people's individuality when I state that boys can enjoy playing with dolls and it's OK for them to show emotion - if anything, I'm encouraging it. But is it fostering individuality to suggest that these things are inherently 'girly', and that a boy who plays will dolls may really be a girl? Isn't this just a way of categorising and sorting people on the same restrictive gender lines? Radical feminists and others influenced by second-wave thinking argue that gender is something people are socialised into based on their physical sex. For example, when I was fifteen years old my school nurse made a disgusted comment about my hairy legs, shaming me into shaving for them for the first time in my life. She did that because I was female, and her expectation was that I should want to remove my hair because, in her reply to my objection, "it's a girly thing to do". People who suggest that gender is something you can simply opt out of are ignoring this whole socialisation process. If I stood up and declared myself to be a man, this wouldn't prevent people from making all kinds of assumptions about me (emotional, bad at reading maps, should shave legs...) based on my female body. Supporting the idea that gender is innate instead of externally imposed does not help women who are trying to break free of these assumptions. i don't consider myself any type of feminist, liberal or radical, and my views on gender are different than theirs, but I don't agree with some things that women are told to do to be "girly". Forexample makeup and shaving legs. I think those things came more from fashions than any femininity. In fact women in the West did not shave legs until it was advertised to do so last century. However I wouldn't be classified as a feminist in thinking this way because my view of gender is different and some things I do see as more applicable to a gender. But I think other things are just fashions that don't mean anything. I just tend to look at Our Lady for an example of femininity perfectly applied and balanced. So this makes my views different from both feminism and the worldly views of being a woman.
Socrates Posted July 26, 2015 Posted July 26, 2015 I hold to the common-sense, but un-pc notion that a certain amount of traditional sex roles and difference between the sexes is good and natural. I'll just say that there's a lot more to being a man or being a woman than simply having certain body parts, but neither are those body parts irrelevant (contrary to the assertions of certain moronic but fashionable current ideologies.)
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now