Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Guilt after a party where friends smoked a lot


Recommended Posts

Posted

it is possible to drink in moderation. one can drink without getting drunk.

it is impossible to smoke weed in moderation. one smokes in order to get high. that's the point.

I don't do either. the price of excellence is discipline. 

"Drunk" is rather arbitrary is it not? Whether you have one drink or 10 I think the basic effect on the body is the same. The only difference is one of degree, right? I am not sure how 1 drink versus 10 drinks is all that different than 1 joint versus 10 joints.

I dunno very many weed heads but I dunno if they necessarily smoke weed because they want to go flying off to the land of pink unicorns. . . maybe they just have 1 joint to relax, just like people have 1 drink to relax. I don't do it, but I have thought about trying it now that it is legal in a lot of places. It wouldn't be because I want to go to la-la land. I would probably try it for the same reason I have a drink. Just to relax or help me mellow out a bit after some stress . . .

Weed also has some legitimate medical uses, and from what some folks say, is actually less damaging to the body than booze.

It just seems a bit arbitrary to me that one should be a sin and the other should not . . . we can drink booze which is a poison. We can smoke tobacco which gives us cancer. But if someone lights up some green stuff instead it becomes a sin?  Dunno about that.

Posted

I'm tired. Here's an article that goes over both sides: http://www.ncregister.com/daily-news/to-puff-or-not-to-puff/

I think its a sin. I think smoking tobacco is a sin. not a mortal you're going to hell thing, but a fault, certainly. 

 

Maybe smoking is a sin. But I would think that being overweight, not eating right, not getting enough exercise, working too much, etc. would have to be as well (if your rationale is that tobacco causes harm to the body).

Nihil Obstat
Posted

I do not think that smoking tobacco could possibly be considered a sin, unless one does it for the express purpose of damaging his body.

Posted

I do not think that smoking tobacco could possibly be considered a sin, unless one does it for the express purpose of damaging his body.

What about smoking with the knowledge that it likely will cause damage? 

Posted

Not all faults are sinful. 

That's true. I think smoking is a fault that is a sin. If its a deliberate choice, full consent of the will - the usual conditions in other words.

A balanced diet can include some junk food. Even the worst food has some nutritive value. Being obese might be a sin, if it is a result of deliberate choices to commit overeating and omit being active. It is one of the worst things you can do for your health.

Smoking is one of the most damaging  things you can do to your body, and most people who do it, know that, and they do it anyway.

Tobacco, like marijuana, cannot be smoked in moderation, in my opinion. There is no healthy routine that can include smoking. You can drink moderate amounts of alcohol without risking serious harm to your health. I do not believe you can smoke any amount without risking serious harm to your health.

We are forbidden from being reckless and endangering our lives for the "fun" of it.

The risks associated with a smoking habit are dire. There are no steps that can be taken to redress that serious risk; forget "light" cigarettes. Therefore smoking falls into the category of things we must not do for recreation.

My sweetie smokes, and if he does not quit, I will not marry him. Every time he smokes a cigarette, he is choosing them despite the serious risk that they will mean a shorter life with me and the other people he is responsible for. Nope. Find another way to relax.

 

 

 

 

 

 

Posted

I do not think that smoking tobacco could possibly be considered a sin, unless one does it for the express purpose of damaging his body.

So that includes just about nobody?

 

I think, if you look at the history of drug use and the church, it seems to me that alcohol and stimulants are more or less given a free pass (nicotine, caffeine, coca leaves) whereas all other drugs are bad bad scary things unless a doctor prescribes them to you.

And the idea that one cannot use mj in moderation, or that it is unequivocally dangerous, is silly to me, but I don't want to debate this as it's been done before and I don't think anyone is ready to change their mind.

Posted

That's true. I think smoking is a fault that is a sin. If its a deliberate choice, full consent of the will - the usual conditions in other words.

A balanced diet can include some junk food. Even the worst food has some nutritive value. Being obese might be a sin, if it is a result of deliberate choices to commit overeating and omit being active. It is one of the worst things you can do for your health.

Smoking is one of the most damaging  things you can do to your body, and most people who do it, know that, and they do it anyway.

Tobacco, like marijuana, cannot be smoked in moderation, in my opinion. There is no healthy routine that can include smoking. You can drink moderate amounts of alcohol without risking serious harm to your health. I do not believe you can smoke any amount without risking serious harm to your health.

We are forbidden from being reckless and endangering our lives for the "fun" of it.

The risks associated with a smoking habit are dire. There are no steps that can be taken to redress that serious risk; forget "light" cigarettes. Therefore smoking falls into the category of things we must not do for recreation.

My sweetie smokes, and if he does not quit, I will not marry him. Every time he smokes a cigarette, he is choosing them despite the serious risk that they will mean a shorter life with me and the other people he is responsible for. Nope. Find another way to relax.

Hm. Disagree. But frankly, I don't really care for this debate. I've had it plenty of times, with plenty of people. Having it on phatmass isn't going to convince me to change my position, and I doubt I could change yours. We could argue in circles, but I don't really think anyone would gain from that.  

Posted

Hm. Disagree. But frankly, I don't really care for this debate. I've had it plenty of times, with plenty of people. Having it on phatmass isn't going to convince me to change my position, and I doubt I could change yours. We could argue in circles, but I don't really think anyone would gain from that.  

OK, agree to disagree.

If you smoke tobacco, each cigarette you finish takes 11 minutes off the average lifetime.  I am much less versed on the effects of smoking marijuana plants as opposed to tobacco plants. But God did not design human lungs to repeatedly breath in smoke from burning organic material.

There are many, many ways to relax  that do not shorten life. There are many ways to have fun that do not have significant irremediable health risks.  Especially for people who have responsibilities in life (elderly parents, spouses, children,) the decision to smoke a cigarette, knowing that by doing so they run a signification risk of shaving minutes from their lifetime, is a moral question.

 

 

 

Posted

I don't have advice on this debate. I don't smoke (anymore... okay, I smoked between my 15 and 17, maybe), but sometimes I feel like I'm the only catholic who don't smoke. In my catholic college, everybody smoke. I think smoking is an unnecessary risk and waste of monney. Also, I saw reportage on the tobacco industry, and I don't want to give them any of my monney, urg. And about marijuana... Outside of the effect on the body, that I saw on my sister, the marijuana that smoke my friends, we don't know where it come from, but it's likely that it come from human trafficking. Enough for me. When we consume something, we need to ask ourselves, not only "what effect does it have on my body ?", but also "what effect does it have on society ?" 

Anyway, today I was lucky to be able to go to confession, with an unknown priest. He gave me great advice and penance, and I feel so much better now. He gave me a lot of "oraison jaculatoire" (i don't know how to translate... it's little sentences, often from the Bible, that you say all day... like "Lord, save me", "Sacred Heart of Jesus, I trust you" "You are the way, the truth, the life") to say all day, even when I'm with friend, so I never forget to put Jesus first :) 

Posted

I don't have advice on this debate. I don't smoke (anymore... okay, I smoked between my 15 and 17, maybe), but sometimes I feel like I'm the only catholic who don't smoke. In my catholic college, everybody smoke. I think smoking is an unnecessary risk and waste of monney. Also, I saw reportage on the tobacco industry, and I don't want to give them any of my monney, urg. And about marijuana... Outside of the effect on the body, that I saw on my sister, the marijuana that smoke my friends, we don't know where it come from, but it's likely that it come from human trafficking. Enough for me. When we consume something, we need to ask ourselves, not only "what effect does it have on my body ?", but also "what effect does it have on society ?" 

Anyway, today I was lucky to be able to go to confession, with an unknown priest. He gave me great advice and penance, and I feel so much better now. He gave me a lot of "oraison jaculatoire" (i don't know how to translate... it's little sentences, often from the Bible, that you say all day... like "Lord, save me", "Sacred Heart of Jesus, I trust you" "You are the way, the truth, the life") to say all day, even when I'm with friend, so I never forget to put Jesus first :) 

Ejaculatory prayer. :) And you make great points. Most of the people I know who use marijuana would consider themselves all for equality and social justice but don't seem to have any concern or consideration for how that drug is getting to them.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...