Gabriela Posted November 11, 2015 Posted November 11, 2015 (edited) Maybe this should go in the Debate Table. I dunno. I hope it won't wind up there, but here goes: I've always (since I've been a Catholic) felt this conflict between trying to live a simpler, poorer life and trying to ensure that I don't support companies that abuse their employees or the planet. At home, I try to buy from local farmers rather than megachain grocery stores, and I'm careful not to buy brands of personal care products that use environment-unfriendly ingredients. I like to find clothes and shoes that were manufactured in places that don't use the modern equivalent of slave labor. Etc. But I've noticed that many religious communities just shop at WalMart, because that's the cheapest, "simplest" option, and they see it as a way of living holy poverty. Of course, much of what's in WalMart is not ethically produced. So... dilemma. The more you look behind the scenes of this problem, the harder the problem gets: What makes items cheap and so amenable to a poor, simple lifestyle is the outsourcing to other nations where labor laws are lax or non-existent, the (over)use of materials that taxes the environment, etc. But to do "real social justice", we'd all have to buy at local boutique shops and the like, which stock the most expensive stuff, because these days, ethical stuff is expensive. So, what do you do? Buy "luxurious" because that's what's ethical, or buy unethical because that's what's "poor"? Edited November 11, 2015 by Gabriela
Sponsa-Christi Posted November 11, 2015 Posted November 11, 2015 I definitely appreciate your concern here, and I've considered these questions myself at different points. I don't have any answers, but a few thoughts: 1. Economics can be really, really complicated, and it's hard to determine direct cause and effect in advance. For example, I one read about an anti-child labor advocate who argued that while boycotts of specific brands can be helpful in some cases, in general simply shutting down factories was not the right way to go about ending child labor, because many of the children who had been employed in factories might then find themselves in even worse situations. Likewise, it's not a simple matter of "evil robots running big factory farms vs. virtuous families who grow local produce." It's good to support local businesses, but at the same time even big corporations employ people with families to support, etc. 2. I think in some ways, evangelical poverty is more about attitudes and intentions rather than line-by-line price comparisons. E.g., all else being equal, buying the functional clothing you need without trying to be excessive or flashy is I think a more central consideration than whether you buy cheaper items from big-box stores vs. expensive but quality items from a local source. 3. When one is actually poor, you shop where you can! I think the reason that a lot of religious go to stores like Wal-Mart is not because they are deliberately trying to buy cheaper things to make a statement, but rather because they do need to run their convents on a shoestring. I think the virtue there is not shopping at discount stores per se, but rather that they are choosing to spend themselves in God's service for little material pay.
beatitude Posted November 11, 2015 Posted November 11, 2015 I don't view goods that were mass-produced in sweatshops as cheap. They carry the same cost as ethically produced items - it's just that the price is paid by the pain and suffering of another human being, instead of my money. So I don't think buying cheap stuff that you know was made in unjust conditions is living poverty; it's just helping to inflict destitution on someone else. Secondly, if you focus too much on getting all your things as cheaply as you can, there is a risk that poverty just becomes a money-saving exercise instead of being a generous and openhearted way of life. I know that there are many people (including religious) who honestly can't afford to shop in places other than Wal-Mart. But there are also many who could afford to make different choices, but they don't. Taking a vow of holy poverty is unfortunately not a guarantee that you will live it. This reminds me of what the late Fr Benedict Groeschel wrote in one of his books: "In my life, I've known dumb Jesuits, confused Dominicans, proud Capuchins, rich Franciscans, and Salesians who can't stand small children. I've known merciless Sisters of Mercy and uncharitable Missionaries of Charity and foolish Daughters of Wisdom. I am, regrettably, a Franciscan of the Renewal who has a long way to go before becoming renewed." There are plenty of people who profess poverty but do not live it, or at least not as fully as they could. I don't think there is any deliberate cruelty or malice in it: most of us are so used to being able to buy what we want whenever we want it that we take the things on the supermarket shelves for granted, without pausing to consider how they got there at that price and what life is like for the workers. It's not even on our radar. Currently I live on a fairly small PhD stipend. I buy most of my things second-hand, from eBay or from shops like Oxfam, as if they're not from an ethical company this is much less harmful than buying them new and it is good basic stewardship, preventing waste. It is also a very good antidote to pride, especially where clothes are concerned - I want shiny new things! Buying second-hand is a nice prompt to pray for the item's previous owner, as well. (Because of this, I find poverty to be like one of those Russian dolls. When you start practising it, there is always something new to discover inside, whether a pride antidote or an impulse to prayer or something else entirely. Or maybe a better analogy would be unlocking new levels on a video game. ) If I really need something new, I save until I have the money to buy it from an ethical supplier. Saving up for something makes me appreciate the item more, whatever it is. Where I live, ethical stuff is pricier than Wal-Mart equivalents, but still not boutique-level pricey. You could have a look for ethical products on the Internet and see if you can find anything more affordable than it is in your area. Finally, since I began my year of not buying things unless absolutely necessary, I have realised that when the year is up I will still go on asking myself, "Do I really need this?" before I buy anything. The answer is usually 'no'. Once you start asking yourself that, you realise that you need less than you thought.
Gabriela Posted November 11, 2015 Author Posted November 11, 2015 I don't view goods that were mass-produced in sweatshops as cheap. They carry the same cost as ethically produced items - it's just that the price is paid by the pain and suffering of another human being, instead of my money. So I don't think buying cheap stuff that you know was made in unjust conditions is living poverty; it's just helping to inflict destitution on someone else. Secondly, if you focus too much on getting all your things as cheaply as you can, there is a risk that poverty just becomes a money-saving exercise instead of being a generous and openhearted way of life. This is really beautiful and sums up a lot of my concerns much better than I did!
Anomaly Posted November 11, 2015 Posted November 11, 2015 Real poor is saving up to shop at Walmart. Frugal is Goodwill, Salvation Army, St V DePaul, and other second hand places. Then there are garage sales. Food banks for food. Though the employees at Walmart would rather keep their job. They're more likely to be affected by your boycott than one of the W heirs.
CatherineM Posted November 11, 2015 Posted November 11, 2015 I get around a lot of this by not buying much. I'm poor. I buy for poor people.
Peace Posted November 11, 2015 Posted November 11, 2015 Are all Christians called to be (materially) poor? I am not exactly the Wolf of Wall Street, but I have a nice place. I have a nice car. I buy nice things. I have fun and go on nice vacations with the money that I make. Is that wrong? I also donate an amount to church and some charities that I am comfortable with, and I think I have been generous as far as helping my family out too. But I can't say I have ever really felt a calling to be materially poor.
Era Might Posted November 11, 2015 Posted November 11, 2015 (edited) I don't think your personal actions are "social justice." They don't change social structures. Which is not to say you shouldn't do what you see is right, but might help resolve your dilemma if you don't look at it as social justice, but solidarity, which is not measured by legalistic yardsticks but by love and intent. Edited November 11, 2015 by Era Might
xSilverPhinx Posted November 11, 2015 Posted November 11, 2015 We don't have Walmart in Brazil, where I live, but we do have other chain supermarkets that belong to the same group. If only my budget would allow me to buy from other places and more ethically. I definitely appreciate your concern here, and I've considered these questions myself at different points. I don't have any answers, but a few thoughts: 1. Economics can be really, really complicated, and it's hard to determine direct cause and effect in advance. For example, I one read about an anti-child labor advocate who argued that while boycotts of specific brands can be helpful in some cases, in general simply shutting down factories was not the right way to go about ending child labor, because many of the children who had been employed in factories might then find themselves in even worse situations. Likewise, it's not a simple matter of "evil robots running big factory farms vs. virtuous families who grow local produce." It's good to support local businesses, but at the same time even big corporations employ people with families to support, etc. That's a good point. When I was visiting Egypt many years ago with my family I entered a carpet factory where they employed children. I don't know how much they made, but they were there to help their families, which were very poor and also depended on them as well. It's a tricky situation for sure. Simply not buying from these places or banning these children from working to help their families means there's less food on the table and would not tackle the root of the problem. I'm not advocating for child labour here. I just wanted to mention that in some places of the world 'childhood' and 'adolescence' as ages for development, play and learning are recent phenomena. For many people living in the third world, where many of the multinational factories are located, the right to childhood and schooling just isn't a reality.
beatitude Posted November 11, 2015 Posted November 11, 2015 Real poor is saving up to shop at Walmart. Frugal is Goodwill, Salvation Army, St V DePaul, and other second hand places. Then there are garage sales. Food banks for food. Though the employees at Walmart would rather keep their job. They're more likely to be affected by your boycott than one of the W heirs. If you can afford to buy your own food, it is not an act of poverty to go to a food bank and take resources that someone else really needs. That's just posturing. I think Gabriela was talking about poverty in the spiritual sense, as an evangelical counsel, and not what it objectively means to live below the poverty line. In this climate, one way to persuade companies to be more ethical is to create an incentive for them to be. Several companies have already recognised that there is a market for Fair Trade and environmentally friendly goods, even notorious chains like Primark. Mostly they try to weasel out of their obligations, but they recognise that there is a customer demand and they are trying to appease those customers. Arguing that not buying from Wal-Mart will only hurt the employees seems like a cop-out to me ("I'm sure these exploited people would rather have that job than nothing at all, and those garment-makers who burned to death in Bangladesh would only have died in the sewer if they hadn't died crammed like sardines into an unsafe factory, so I'll buy whatever I want - it's not like I can do anything.") It's also not very logical - people deciding to shop elsewhere is apparently powerful enough to cause loss of livelihood among employees, yet not powerful enough to cause a shift in company policy? Making different consumer choices is not the only action we need to take on this, but it's still a part. I find the argument about low-paid employees disconcerting for another reason, because you could say it about people trapped in many unethical industries - the arms trade, for example. I won't be supporting that any time soon, and it feels like blackmail to suggest that we should stop pressuring people to abandon their investments in the trade because it might make some poor guy working on a weapons assembly line lose his job. If people do lose their jobs en masse because of such actions, that's the time when we open up our houses and help to support them through, in addition to advocating for a just political answer. But we need to make it clear to these companies that there is no excuse for exploitation, especially not when it kills people. Are all Christians called to be (materially) poor? I am not exactly the Wolf of Wall Street, but I have a nice place. I have a nice car. I buy nice things. I have fun and go on nice vacations with the money that I make. Is that wrong? I also donate an amount to church and some charities that I am comfortable with, and I think I have been generous as far as helping my family out too. But I can't say I have ever really felt a calling to be materially poor. I recommend Jim Forest's The Ladder of the Beatitudes for a very good and thorough discussion of poverty in the lives of Christians. His basic criteria for holy poverty are detachment (do you cling to your stuff?) and availability (do you give from your treasure, or, like the rich people in last Sunday's Gospel, just donate what you have left over?). For me St Teresa of Avila illustrates it well: she was materially poor, but on one occasion when she was a guest in someone else's home, she ate the rich meal they put in front of her with enjoyment and without regret. When someone rebuked her for it, she said, "There is a time for penance and a time for partridges." If she had pushed away the partridge that her hosts had given her, that would have been the extravagant act; she would have been showing off. Part of poverty means being at home and humble in the situation in which you find yourself, which includes being able to enjoy the present moment - it's not a sin to enjoy good things. Holy poverty is not the same as destitution. However, we often use this reasoning as an excuse to be self-indulgent. "I'm not called to be St Francis, and it's OK to have nice things, so I'll buy this and this." This is like the way we sometimes excuse our sins with "Nobody's perfect." Not everyone is called to be St Francis, true, but we're all called to imitate Christ and each of us is challenged to find our own way of imitating him in his poverty. Often that will be difficult and demanding. If our Christian lives are too comfy, it's probably a sign that we're doing it wrong - it's not possible to follow Jesus without leaving some things behind. I will give an example from my personal life: a while back I received a prize for research, quite a substantial cash prize, worth over a quarter of my yearly studentship. I decided to save it for after my PhD. Occasionally I would daydream about what I would do with the money. I had sensible plans for most of it, but I thought it would stretch to a short holiday as well, somewhere I'd never been. I was looking forward to it, and there is nothing wrong with that. But then a friend got into trouble. His elderly mum had been diagnosed with cancer. They have no other relatives in the country where they live and she needed him to help her. He's self-employed and if he doesn't work he can't pay his rent and bills. He was impulsive in the past and is in a lot of debt, so he had no savings to cover time away from work. It was very clear to me what I had to do. A person who was really objectively poor would have had no means to help them. I had that sum sitting in the bank, so I couldn't be considered poor in the material sense - for me the choice to embrace poverty was in sacrificing my own plans and wants in order to look after someone whose need was greater. Poverty also means recognising that what you own is not your own; it is a loan from God. You are the custodian. How are you using what he has entrusted you with? After the initial pang of disappointment, I started to feel that I was only passing on to my friend and his mother what was rightfully theirs - the right to have time together without worry when she was very sick. I don't think of that as my prize or my money any more. It's hard to keep this attitude. You have to work at it constantly. But I think this is the hallmark of holy poverty, as opposed to making sure you only spend X amount each month and you don't live in anything bigger than a shed.
NadaTeTurbe Posted November 11, 2015 Posted November 11, 2015 Thank you for asking these questions, Gabriela. The answers are very interesting. Two little reflexions : There's a religious community in my city. There's a lot of problems with it, but what bother me is that they seems to be very rich (the "shepherd" of the community always have very nice phone, the laypeople members of the community are whealthy, etc...) but still, they get their food from a food bank and receive the CMU - a sum of monney from the governement, who is normally for very poor people. It really bother me, specially the food bank. They have explained to me that it is because of poverty. Still, I feel like they are taking from the real poors - people who really need a food bank to eat. Secondly, I've seen in my city a lot of things done to make organic food accessible to poorest. It's really a positive evolution.
Gabriela Posted November 11, 2015 Author Posted November 11, 2015 If you can afford to buy your own food, it is not an act of poverty to go to a food bank and take resources that someone else really needs. That's just posturing. I think Gabriela was talking about poverty in the spiritual sense, as an evangelical counsel, and not what it objectively means to live below the poverty line. Exactly. Let me just clarify: I don't judge anyone who shops at WalMart because they can't afford to shop elsewhere. Objective, material poverty is a completely different thing from what I'm talking about. As beatitude points out, I'm talking about spiritual poverty. Essentially, what I'm asking is: Is it more important to embrace spiritual poverty (and so sacrifice things we consider necessities, but which are really luxuries) or to embrace "social justice" (or solidarity, as Era Might puts it better). Because they seem to be in conflict these days. I agree, @NadaTeTurbe, that the answers have been very interesting so far. Thank you all for contributing!
Peace Posted November 11, 2015 Posted November 11, 2015 I recommend Jim Forest's The Ladder of the Beatitudes for a very good and thorough discussion of poverty in the lives of Christians. His basic criteria for holy poverty are detachment (do you cling to your stuff?) and availability (do you give from your treasure, or, like the rich people in last Sunday's Gospel, just donate what you have left over?). For me St Teresa of Avila illustrates it well: she was materially poor, but on one occasion when she was a guest in someone else's home, she ate the rich meal they put in front of her with enjoyment and without regret. When someone rebuked her for it, she said, "There is a time for penance and a time for partridges." If she had pushed away the partridge that her hosts had given her, that would have been the extravagant act; she would have been showing off. Part of poverty means being at home and humble in the situation in which you find yourself, which includes being able to enjoy the present moment - it's not a sin to enjoy good things. Holy poverty is not the same as destitution. However, we often use this reasoning as an excuse to be self-indulgent. "I'm not called to be St Francis, and it's OK to have nice things, so I'll buy this and this." This is like the way we sometimes excuse our sins with "Nobody's perfect." Not everyone is called to be St Francis, true, but we're all called to imitate Christ and each of us is challenged to find our own way of imitating him in his poverty. Often that will be difficult and demanding. If our Christian lives are too comfy, it's probably a sign that we're doing it wrong - it's not possible to follow Jesus without leaving some things behind. I will give an example from my personal life: a while back I received a prize for research, quite a substantial cash prize, worth over a quarter of my yearly studentship. I decided to save it for after my PhD. Occasionally I would daydream about what I would do with the money. I had sensible plans for most of it, but I thought it would stretch to a short holiday as well, somewhere I'd never been. I was looking forward to it, and there is nothing wrong with that. But then a friend got into trouble. His elderly mum had been diagnosed with cancer. They have no other relatives in the country where they live and she needed him to help her. He's self-employed and if he doesn't work he can't pay his rent and bills. He was impulsive in the past and is in a lot of debt, so he had no savings to cover time away from work. It was very clear to me what I had to do. A person who was really objectively poor would have had no means to help them. I had that sum sitting in the bank, so I couldn't be considered poor in the material sense - for me the choice to embrace poverty was in sacrificing my own plans and wants in order to look after someone whose need was greater. Poverty also means recognising that what you own is not your own; it is a loan from God. You are the custodian. How are you using what he has entrusted you with? After the initial pang of disappointment, I started to feel that I was only passing on to my friend and his mother what was rightfully theirs - the right to have time together without worry when she was very sick. I don't think of that as my prize or my money any more. It's hard to keep this attitude. You have to work at it constantly. But I think this is the hallmark of holy poverty, as opposed to making sure you only spend X amount each month and you don't live in anything bigger than a shed. Thank you. This was helpful.
Era Might Posted November 11, 2015 Posted November 11, 2015 Are all Christians called to be (materially) poor? I am not exactly the Wolf of Wall Street, but I have a nice place. I have a nice car. I buy nice things. I have fun and go on nice vacations with the money that I make. Is that wrong? I also donate an amount to church and some charities that I am comfortable with, and I think I have been generous as far as helping my family out too. But I can't say I have ever really felt a calling to be materially poor. I would change the question around, not whether it's wrong, but whether it's boring. I'd be curious to know what "nice place" means to you. The writer Walker Percy referred to the city he chose to live in, in Louisiana, as a "pleasant nonplace," a suburb where he was not quite misplaced but also not hopelessly placed, a nonplace where he could tread water in life. That idea of "place" was something he wrote about, how in American culture we easily become anyone anywhere and no one nowhere. Vacations are a strange thing too, we vacate ourselves for a week or so in order to have an experience planned for us by others, kind of like going to the movies, seeing life acted out by others validates our existence. So, that's a long way of suggesting that your question is not really a spiritual or moral question...you're more or less asking whether your culture, your being-in-the world, is worthwhile, whether to give it up would be a real loss to your existence or just a sacrifice for those who do not share in your economic and social reality. IOW, do your things and your car and your vacations say anything about you? If an archaeologist were digging around the ruins of your life in 10,000 years, would they learn anything from the fact that you owned a make and model of a car that millions of other people owned, or that you had a brief trip to the pyramids of Egypt and took a selfie in front of the Golden Gate Bridge? Does that reveal anything about YOU? idk...
tinytherese Posted November 11, 2015 Posted November 11, 2015 Are all Christians called to be (materially) poor? I am not exactly the Wolf of Wall Street, but I have a nice place. I have a nice car. I buy nice things. I have fun and go on nice vacations with the money that I make. Is that wrong? I also donate an amount to church and some charities that I am comfortable with, and I think I have been generous as far as helping my family out too. But I can't say I have ever really felt a calling to be materially poor. http://jimmyakin.com/2012/08/what-is-the-best-way-to-help-the-poor.html
Peace Posted November 11, 2015 Posted November 11, 2015 I would change the question around, not whether it's wrong, but whether it's boring. I'd be curious to know what "nice place" means to you. Well. To me it means a place that is safe, quiet, a place that is spacious, a place that is fairly new, where everything (heat, water, appliances, etc.) work without any problem, a place that is aesthetically pleasing to the eye, and that has good amenities (a nice pool, lounge, gym, etc). When I said "nice place" that is what I had in mind for the most part. The writer Walker Percy referred to the city he chose to live in, in Louisiana, as a "pleasant nonplace," a suburb where he was not quite misplaced but also not hopelessly placed, a nonplace where he could tread water in life. That idea of "place" was something he wrote about, how in American culture we easily become anyone anywhere and no one nowhere. Vacations are a strange thing too, we vacate ourselves for a week or so in order to have an experience planned for us by others, kind of like going to the movies, seeing life acted out by others validates our existence. Hmm. That is interesting. But when I go on vacation I don't have an experience planned out for me by others. I usually plan what what I want to do and then do it. I would say that I am acting out life myself more so than having someone else act it out for me. So, that's a long way of suggesting that your question is not really a spiritual or moral question...you're more or less asking whether your culture, your being-in-the world, is worthwhile, whether to give it up would be a real loss to your existence or just a sacrifice for those who do not share in your economic and social reality. IOW, do your things and your car and your vacations say anything about you? If an archaeologist were digging around the ruins of your life in 10,000 years, would they learn anything from the fact that you owned a make and model of a car that millions of other people owned, or that you had a brief trip to the pyramids of Egypt and took a selfie in front of the Golden Gate Bridge? Does that reveal anything about YOU? idk... Well. This is interesting too. I think it is a bit different than the question I asked, honestly, but perhaps I just do not see quite what you are getting at. The question I tried to ask, more or less, was the extent to which we should sacrifice things that bring us pleasure (such as having a nice place or a nice car) in order to be good Christians. In other words, do I really have to take a vow of poverty and eat nothing but bread and rice, or is it OK to have steak every once in a while? But to answer your question - I think that my things and my car, and my vacations, etc. do say things about me. I am a person with real interests. I like certain things as opposed to other things, and I have unique preferences, likes and dislikes, etc. An archaeologist might not find them particularly significant, but I think that all of those things are part of who I am, and are part of the person that God made me. What do you think?
beatitude Posted November 11, 2015 Posted November 11, 2015 http://jimmyakin.com/2012/08/what-is-the-best-way-to-help-the-poor.html I am very uncomfortable with Jimmy Akin's article, because its basic premise is that poverty is caused by people not having work. Gabriela opened this thread by speaking about factories with unethical labour practices. Sweatshop workers are desperately poor and they are often working sixteen-hour days, even sleeping in the factory, with hardly any days off. This is widespread. Saying "Give a man a fish and he eats for a day, teach a man to fish and he eats for life" in response to that isn't just condescending - poor people actually do have marketable skills, they're not poor just because we haven't opened their eyes to fishing techniques - but harmful. The issue here isn't unemployment, but unethical employment. I also think Akin has a naive view of poverty and its impact if he see the prevalence of mobile phones and TVs as an indicator that things aren't as bad as they were. The price for our ubiquitous technology is currently being paid in the Democratic Republic of the Congo. The trade in conflict minerals is one of the bloodiest in the world and it means sheer horror and misery for the millions of people caught up in it, especially the miners and people living in the vicinity of mines. I notice that Akin talks about helping poor people to fight "their" kleptocratic governments as though oppression is something happening somewhere else, nothing to do with us - we're the good guys, the kind people who are here to teach these poor unfortunates to fish and make sure they have jobs by buying what they make. 5.4 million people have died in the conflict in the DRC and the number is rising. There is torture. There is rape. It's got the highest death toll of any conflict since WWII. The blood of those people is on my computer keys, and Akin's too, because it wouldn't be possible for butchery to continue on this scale if it weren't for the insatiable demand for smartphones and tablets. That demand is a major reason why the DRC wars have been under-reported. We want our gadgets, we want those minerals at cheap prices. Their poverty isn't just the result of their government, but multinational electronics companies and the choices we make to buy from them without considering the cost. Additionally, having a TV (which these days can often be bought more cheaply than two weeks' groceries) isn't an indicator that you are not poor. I remember giving a talk about life in one particular refugee camp and someone pointing out (as if to say "Gotcha") that one of the refugees in my photos was speaking on a mobile phone. There still seems to be a perception that if you're not living in a mud hut with no electricity then you're some kind of fraud, not really suffering, and it bothers me when the people making that judgment call have so much more than the people they're judging as quite well-off really. How would they manage if they were called on to trade places? I live in a poor inner-city area at the moment, where there are few green spaces, lots of people living in apartment blocks and terraced houses with barely any room to turn round, and huge educational inequalities. In the suburbs there are leafy parks. Maybe the residents there might see someone from my area with a music player and think, "Oh, he can't have it that bad" - without pausing to imagine what it would be like to have no park to stroll in and few entertainment activities that can be afforded. TV and music players are pretty much the only relaxation the kids near me can get, and for some of them it's a way of blocking out life - gang problems, bullying. We take what we have so much for granted that we don't even think what it must be like to live without it, so the only poverty we recognise is starvation. This is a problem.
Peace Posted November 11, 2015 Posted November 11, 2015 I am very uncomfortable with Jimmy Akin's article, because its basic premise is that poverty is caused by people not having work. Global poverty is caused by the inefficient allocation of resources. It is caused by inefficient economic systems like communism, war, political instability, lack of education. I think that most economists will tell you this. They aren't going to tell you that it is caused by greed or a desire for cellular phones. Gabriela opened this thread by speaking about factories with unethical labour practices. Sweatshop workers are desperately poor and they are often working sixteen-hour days, even sleeping in the factory, with hardly any days off. This is widespread. Saying "Give a man a fish and he eats for a day, teach a man to fish and he eats for life" in response to that isn't just condescending - poor people actually do have marketable skills, they're not poor just because we haven't opened their eyes to fishing techniques - but harmful. The issue here isn't unemployment, but unethical employment. OK. But how do you solve the problem of sweatshops? Let's say you pass a law that says company XYZ has to pay its workers in countries ABC a certain salary that you deem just. Maybe at that price level the company no longer makes a profit, or the profit it makes is less than it would be if the company engaged in some other activity (such as bringing the jobs back home to the US). Then what happens? The factory shuts down and the folks who had a job now have nothing. That is a bit of an oversimplified example, of course. But you have to look at the issues and make assessments about their overall economic impact on a community. We could try to set up some socialistic/communistic utopia where the government allocates to each person a share that is deemed "fair" but we have seen what those types of systems produce - massive poverty well above and beyond what is produced in free market economies. Sweatshops are not pretty of course, but it seems that almost every developed country (including the USA) has had them during the course of their industrialization. And that industrialization is an important part of producing wealth for large numbers of people. They do produce jobs and they do produce a benefit for the people working in them. If they did not - then they would not work in them in the first place. I also think Akin has a seriously naive view of poverty and its impact if he honestly feels that the prevalence of mobile phones and TVs is an indicator that things aren't as bad as they were. I don't know about cell phones but I think it is fairly clear that we have made great strides in combating global poverty and that it continues to decrease. http://www.economist.com/news/leaders/21578665-nearly-1-billion-people-have-been-taken-out-extreme-poverty-20-years-world-should-aim The price for our ubiquitous technology is currently being paid in the Democratic Republic of the Congo. The trade in conflict minerals is one of the bloodiest in the world and it means sheer horror and misery for the millions of people caught up in it, especially the miners and people living in the vicinity of mines. I notice that Akin talks about helping poor people to fight "their" kleptocratic governments as though oppression is something happening somewhere else, nothing to do with us - we're the good guys, the kind people who are here to teach these poor unfortunates to fish and make sure they have jobs by buying what they make. 5.4 million people have died in the conflict in the DRC and the number is rising. There is torture. There is rape. It's the most vicious conflict since World War II. The blood of those people is on my computer keys, and Akin's too, because it wouldn't be possible for butchery to continue on this scale if it weren't for the insatiable demand for smartphones and tablets. That demand is a major reason why the DRC wars have been under-reported. We want our gadgets, we want those minerals at cheap prices. Their poverty isn't just the result of their government, but multinational electronics companies and the choices we make to buy from them without considering the cost. It seems to me that men have been pretty crappy to each other throughout history. That predates the industrial revolution and modern forms of capitalism. I think the evidence is fairly clear that free markets have produced much more wealth for more people worldwide than any other system in human history. Is it perfect? Of course it is not. But what would you replace it with? What exactly is your solution? Be less greedy? Buy less cellular phones? Additionally, having a TV (which these days can often be bought more cheaply than a week's groceries) isn't an indicator that you are not poor. I remember giving a talk about life in one particular refugee camp and someone pointing out (as if to say "Gotcha") that one of the refugees in my photos was speaking on a mobile phone. There still seems to be a perception that if you're not living in a mud hut with no electricity then you're some kind of fraud, not 'really' poor, and it bothers me when the people making that judgment call have so much more than the people they're judging as quite well-off really. How would they manage if they were called on to trade places? I live in a poor inner-city area at the moment, where there are few green spaces, lots of people living in apartment blocks and terraced houses with barely any room to turn round, and huge educational inequalities. In the suburbs there are leafy parks. Maybe the residents there might see someone from my area with a music player and think, "Oh, he can't have it that bad" - without pausing to imagine what it would be like to have no park to stroll in and few entertainment activities that can be afforded. TV and music players are pretty much the only relaxation the kids near me can get, and for some of them it's a way of blocking out life - gang problems, bullying. We take what we have so much for granted that we don't even think what it must be like to live without it, so the only poverty we recognise is starvation. This is a problem. There are different levels of poverty, and many people who would be considered poor in the US would be considered relatively well off in many third world countries. I am from the inner city. I own a house in the inner city. I am from a single parent household, I lived in the projects and my family was on welfare for a good time when I was young. So I think I know what it is like "not to have a park". But there is still a huge difference between that and people who live in some third world countries who literally live on a dollar or two a day. They are not comparable. Poverty - both in the US and in other, less well off, countries is still a major problem that we should be addressing. But I do not think we need to deny that the spread of democracy and free markets has resulted in progress. I think that we can stay the course, rather than implement some radical change the ultimate consequences of which are unknown.
Era Might Posted November 11, 2015 Posted November 11, 2015 Well. To me it means a place that is safe, quiet, a place that is spacious, a place that is fairly new, where everything (heat, water, appliances, etc.) work without any problem, a place that is aesthetically pleasing to the eye, and that has good amenities (a nice pool, lounge, gym, etc). When I said "nice place" that is what I had in mind for the most part. Hmm. That is interesting. But when I go on vacation I don't have an experience planned out for me by others. I usually plan what what I want to do and then do it. I would say that I am acting out life myself more so than having someone else act it out for me. Well. This is interesting too. I think it is a bit different than the question I asked, honestly, but perhaps I just do not see quite what you are getting at. The question I tried to ask, more or less, was the extent to which we should sacrifice things that bring us pleasure (such as having a nice place or a nice car) in order to be good Christians. In other words, do I really have to take a vow of poverty and eat nothing but bread and rice, or is it OK to have steak every once in a while? But to answer your question - I think that my things and my car, and my vacations, etc. do say things about me. I am a person with real interests. I like certain things as opposed to other things, and I have unique preferences, likes and dislikes, etc. An archaeologist might not find them particularly significant, but I think that all of those things are part of who I am, and are part of the person that God made me. What do you think? Thanks for expanding on your perspective. I don't doubt you have preferences and and dislikes, but my dislike for modernity and industrial culture probably shapes my perspective differently. I guess what I was trying to get at was what culture is. To me, the idea of a nice, new, clean, safe, quiet place with a pool and laundry room is hell. I like trash in the street and drunks on the corner. I don't like them for themselves, but to me they keep me alive in a sanitized society where everything is clean and orderly. The happiest place I've ever been to was a mountain in Central America where the man I was visiting had no electricity, no bathroom, just a latrine outside. But it was heaven, he had a coffee finca, animals, a gendered culture of cooking, working, etc. It wasn't perfect, especially because it was hard getting the coffee to market. The modern vision would be to integrate that family into "developed" society, but the basis of real culture is then lost...culture is the ways in which create self-supporting autonomy, like gendered work or rites of passage. In modern society our culture is sanitized and displaced...our rite of initiation is going to college and getting wasted for 4 years, then working a meaningless job to afford a "nice place" that keeps reality out. I guess my overall point was that the problem the poor face is not really a problem of humanity. The poor are great at building self-sustaing culture, but they now exist in a world of industrialized poverty, where culture has been taken over by goods and services. I guess I think that asking about a Christian's "obligation" to the poor, what's more urgent than whether you give up something is whether the life your living has any spiritual value. What the poor need is a human society, something that I dont think modern civilization is able to create, though it's good at creating suburbs and plumbing and institutions for mass man. Anyway, don't take any of this as a personal critique of your life, just as questions that I ask from where I'm standing. My father is from Central America but the world he grew up in was healthy poverty...the world of Central America today is violence and ugliness...this is the price they're paying for "development" (I disliked Jimmy Akin's article especially for glorifying this inhuman idea of development).
NadaTeTurbe Posted November 11, 2015 Posted November 11, 2015 Era, do you know about "degrowth" ? It's an economic/social movement against consumerism. According to wikipedia : " Degrowth thinkers and activists advocate for the downscaling of production and consumption—the contraction of economies—arguing that overconsumption lies at the root of long term environmental issues and social inequalities. Key to the concept of degrowth is that reducing consumption does not require individual martyring or a decrease in well-being.[3]Rather, 'degrowthists' aim to maximize happiness and well-being through non-consumptive means—sharing work, consuming less, while devoting more time to art, music, family, culture and community." Maybe it can interest you. My parents are close to this movement.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now