beatitude Posted November 11, 2015 Posted November 11, 2015 Global poverty is caused by the inefficient allocation of resources. It is caused by inefficient economic systems like communism, war, political instability, lack of education. I think that most economists will tell you this. They aren't going to tell you that it is caused by greed or a desire for cellular phones. I am completing my doctorate in humanitarian practice and conflict response and I worked in the humanitarian sector; I've studied political economy enough to know different theories on causes of poverty. Saying things like "war causes poverty" is a truism, because what causes war? In the example I gave (the DRC) a major cause is resources, their allocation, and a desire to profiteer. So yes, greed is a factor. I think there is a tendency to try and make the cause of poverty something abstract, something that seems far removed from our personal lives - after all, if it's "political instability" that causes it, it's fine for me to buy what I want, it's not me, I can't change anything anyway. I struggle to understand how Catholics can deploy this reasoning: we understand the havoc that sins such as greed can wreck in our private lives, but suddenly we don't want to recognise that it can exist on a public level? That greed can have global ramifications? I don't have time to respond to your post in full as it's late here, but there is one thing I want to highlight: your comment that the USA used to have sweatshops as part of its industrialisation process. There is no "used to" about it. The global north/developed world still has sweatshops; it's just that they are located in other countries now. We have outsourced sweatshop labour. Most of the things in those factories are consumed by the global north. (In fact, the same could be said of resources generally, not just things made in sweatshops - the USA alone has 5% of the world's population but consumes roughly 25% of the world's energy, to give one example.) It's not putting an end to sweatshops and slavery if you simply relocate them and then try to pass them off as the natural growing pains of a developing economy. This is a useful tool that brings it home. Politically my closest fit is with the Catholic Worker movement, but even if you wanted to approach the sweatshop problem from a capitalist perspective, claiming that passing laws to protect sweatshop workers would result in more suffering for them because companies "wouldn't make a profit" shows that the issue is exacerbated by consumers. If they were willing to pay more for that dress or smartphone, companies could still profit (although I think it's entirely reasonable to say that they should settle for less - no CEO "needs" to be a billionaire in order for his/her time on this planet to be worthwhile). But that willingness is not there, partly through ignorance - you are right that lack of education is a major part of poverty. That includes lack of education in the global north, about what poverty is and how intimately we're connected to it. As for a world without sweatshops being an impossible utopia - the kingdom of heaven as Jesus describes it might sound utopian to some, but that's exactly what we're called to work for. We're in his vineyard. I don't think we can watch others bearing our lives on their backs and say, "That's just the way it is, if they didn't have these jobs they'd have nothing!" and then face him.
Gabriela Posted November 11, 2015 Author Posted November 11, 2015 @Peace: I was going to answer you, but I think beatitude did a much better job. I'll just say this: Basically, to me, your view kinda' sums up to, "Well, okay, it's bad, but what can we do about it?" If everyone says that, who takes responsibility? Is really no one responsible? Can no one change this? Also: The fact that unethical employment has always been a part of industrialization of nations in the past doesn't mean it has to continue that way. Why can't we find a better way to industrialize?
Peace Posted November 11, 2015 Posted November 11, 2015 Beatitude - I am not a huge conservative, just so you know. Just ask Socrates if you do not believe me. I generally support things like public assistance, minimum wage laws, universal heath care, etc. I even support things like the guaranteed minimum income (at least in countries like here in the USA). I am completing my doctorate in humanitarian practice and conflict response and I worked in the humanitarian sector; I've studied political economy enough to know different theories on causes of poverty. Saying things like "war causes poverty" is a truism, because what causes war? In the example I gave (the DRC) a major cause is resources, their allocation, and a desire to profiteer. So yes, greed is a factor. I think there is a tendency to try and make the cause of poverty something abstract, something that seems far removed from our personal lives - after all, if it's "political instability" that causes it, it's fine for me to buy what I want, it's not me, I can't change anything anyway. I struggle to understand how Catholics can deploy this reasoning: we understand the havoc that sins such as greed can wreck in our private lives, but suddenly we don't want to recognise that it can exist on a public level? That greed can have global ramifications? At a macroeconomic level greed and the desire to profiteer is neutral. It has existed in every society in every time. It is one of the basic flaws of man. Do you think that the people living in third world countries are any less greedy than the people living here in the USA? Are humans any more or less greedy than we were two or three thousand years ago? Since the fall of Adam we do not seem to have been able to figure out how to reduce greed in man in any practical sense. Yes greed exists and it does have an impact on poverty. But "be less greedy" is not a practical solution to eliminating poverty as far as I am aware. Attempting to spread the increase of democracy, political transparency, and free markets (or whatever particular economic system you believe is best) is something that has produced concrete improvements. I don't have time to respond to your post in full as it's late here, but there is one thing I want to highlight: your comment that the USA used to have sweatshops as part of its industrialisation process. There is no "used to" about it. The global north/developed world still has sweatshops; it's just that they are located in other countries now. We have outsourced sweatshop labour. Most of the things in those factories are consumed by the global north. (In fact, the same could be said of resources generally, not just things made in sweatshops - the USA alone has 5% of the world's population but consumes roughly 25% of the world's energy, to give one example.) It's not putting an end to sweatshops and slavery if you simply relocate them and then try to pass them off as the natural growing pains of a developing economy. This is a useful tool that brings it home. Yes. I think it is well known that many of the sweatshops in other countries are run by US companies. I have seen that tool before, but thank you. Since you sent me a link relating to my slavery footprint, what is your definition of slavery? Slavery in the world does still exist. If you are dealing with a situation where someone is being locked in a room and forced to work, with no ability to leave, I would call that slavery. I would not call it slavery if a job is offered at a very low wage, and then a person is given an opportunity to take the job at the low wage, or decline the job and attempt to make a living by some other means. For all practical purposes, the best alternative that the person might have would be to take the job at the low wage, but I would not call that slavery. Politically my closest fit is with the Catholic Worker movement, but even if you wanted to approach the sweatshop problem from a capitalist perspective, claiming that passing laws to protect sweatshop workers would result in more suffering for them because companies "wouldn't make a profit" shows that the issue is exacerbated by consumers. If they were willing to pay more for that dress or smartphone, companies could still profit (although I think it's entirely reasonable to say that they should settle for less - no CEO "needs" to be a billionaire in order for his/her time on this planet to be worthwhile). But that willingness is not there, partly through ignorance - you are right that lack of education is a major part of poverty. That includes lack of education in the global north, about what poverty is and how intimately we're connected to it. In some situations passing the minimum wage laws might benefit them. In some situations passing minimum wage laws might cause them to lose their jobs altogether and harm them. I would not advocate passing a minimum wage law in the case where it would cause them to lose their jobs altogether. Now, as consumers, if you have to pay more for that dress or smartphone, then it means that you have less money available to pay for a pair of jeans or a T-shirt. It is not as though we all have infinite sums of money to throw around. If a person is forced to pay more money for the dress or the smartphone because of a law that causes the company that makes those things to pay its workers more, it can mean that some of the people who work at the companies who made jeans or T-shirts lose their jobs, because there is now not enough money available to buy those goods and support those industries. What you are doing is essentially picking winners and losers instead of letting true demand drive the manner in which resources are allocated to the production of the various goods. And it seems to me that as a fundamental matter, the goal should be to produce goods as cheaply as possible. A computer costs much less than today than it did twenty years ago. That benefits people here in the USA, it also benefits communities in Africa who may not have been able to obtain a computer at the higher price. The same is true for things like vaccinations, prescription drugs, etc. The goal should be that these goods should be able to be produced cheaply so that everyone around the world can access them. If you want to create a market where things are expensive then we all suffer. It is not economically efficient. The higher prices may cause individual gain for the people who produce the specific items that have been priced higher, but many people who actually need the goods at a lower price are unable to obtain them. It produces poverty on a macroeconomic level. As for a world without sweatshops being an impossible utopia - the kingdom of heaven as Jesus describes it might sound utopian to some, but that's exactly what we're called to work for. We're in his vineyard. I don't think we can watch others bearing our lives on their backs and say, "That's just the way it is, if they didn't have these jobs they'd have nothing!" and then face him. I also agree that we have a personal responsibility for the problem of poverty and that we should work to reduce it. I did not say anything about just saying "That's just the way it is, at least they have jobs" and then doing nothing else. What I am saying is that in an attempt to "do something" you can inadvertently cause more harm than the good that you hope to achieve. You have to weigh the overall consequences. The consequences of setting mandatory wages that are much higher than what the free market could otherwise dictate can in some circumstances cause more harm than the good that is achieved. The goal of reducing poverty is the same. The area in which people can reasonably disagree is the best means of accomplishing that.
Peace Posted November 11, 2015 Posted November 11, 2015 @Peace: I was going to answer you, but I think beatitude did a much better job. I'll just say this: Basically, to me, your view kinda' sums up to, "Well, okay, it's bad, but what can we do about it?" If everyone says that, who takes responsibility? Is really no one responsible? Can no one change this? Well. My view is more like this I think: "We have made a lot of progress and we should expect it to continue. Why not stick with what we know works rather than trying other things that may cause us to start moving back in the wrong direction?" The fact that I linked to above - that somewhere around a billion people have advanced above the global poverty level within the last 20 years, is promising. Rather than radical change at this point, I would advocate staying the course. Also: The fact that unethical employment has always been a part of industrialization of nations in the past doesn't mean it has to continue that way. Why can't we find a better way to industrialize? I am all for trying a better way if there is a better way. What is it? If it is something along the lines of socialism or a state-controlled economy I think history has already shown that produces inferior results.
Gabriela Posted November 11, 2015 Author Posted November 11, 2015 Well. My view is more like this I think: "We have made a lot of progress and we should expect it to continue. Why not stick with what we know works rather than trying other things that may cause us to start moving back in the wrong direction?" The fact that I linked to above - that somewhere around a billion people have advanced above the global poverty level within the last 20 years, is promising. Rather than radical change at this point, I would advocate staying the course. I am all for trying a better way if there is a better way. What is it? If it is something along the lines of socialism or a state-controlled economy I think history has already shown that produces inferior results. No one (Catholic) on a Catholic board would argue for socialism or a state-controlled economy. That's against Church teaching. But in response to this and to what you said above in response to beatitude: We do know of a better way, and a way to limit greed: Convert souls to Christ. The weakness in all your statements is that they take only impersonal macro-economic forces into consideration. The solution begins in each individual's heart, spreads to their lifestyle, and thus to the world. This thread started with that, too. To quote a non-Christian: "Be the change you want to see in the world." That's what we're trying to do in here.
Peace Posted November 12, 2015 Posted November 12, 2015 I like trash in the street and drunks on the corner. Well. You might consider moving to the Tenderloin. Plenty of drunks and trash there. I am pretty sure that both of these result from some kind of sin, so I don't particularly see why one should be fond of them. I don't like them for themselves, but to me they keep me alive in a sanitized society where everything is clean and orderly. Aren't these qualities that one can associate with Godliness though? When the priest was about to make a sacrifice in the temple he washed up beforehand. Real nice and clean. He didn't exactly roll through a pile of mud. And we have an extremely well ordered universe - courtesy of our Creator. It seems to me that Satan causes disorder, in a general sense. The happiest place I've ever been to was a mountain in Central America where the man I was visiting had no electricity, no bathroom, just a latrine outside. But it was heaven, he had a coffee finca, animals, a gendered culture of cooking, working, etc. It wasn't perfect, especially because it was hard getting the coffee to market. I can appreciate this type of simplicity sometimes. But why exactly was this the happiest place exactly? You mean that this was the place where you felt the happiest, or the place where the people living there were the happiest? The modern vision would be to integrate that family into "developed" society, but the basis of real culture is then lost...culture is the ways in which create self-supporting autonomy, like gendered work or rites of passage. In modern society our culture is sanitized and displaced...our rite of initiation is going to college and getting wasted for 4 years, then working a meaningless job to afford a "nice place" that keeps reality out. LOL. I dunno know if modern culture is really all that sanitized though. Sanitized in what sense? Just watch half an episode of "Empire" if you don't believe me. But that is cool to me if you want to go back to the days before modern technology. There are some things about it that don't vibe well with me either, like spending so much time staring at a screen or a cell phone. . . I didn't get wasted during college though. And I don't consider my job meaningless. All work is good and has meaning I think (except if you are a porn star or something like that, I think). That's an interesting take on wanting to keep "reality out" though I think. I grew up in the hood. A guy got shot dead a block from my house about a year or two ago. I don't see anything wrong with wanting to live in a place that is safe. Do you want your children getting approached by drug dealers on their way to school? If that is keeping reality out then heck yeah I want to keep it out. I guess my overall point was that the problem the poor face is not really a problem of humanity. The poor are great at building self-sustaing culture, but they now exist in a world of industrialized poverty, where culture has been taken over by goods and services. I guess I think that asking about a Christian's "obligation" to the poor, what's more urgent than whether you give up something is whether the life your living has any spiritual value. What the poor need is a human society, something that I dont think modern civilization is able to create, though it's good at creating suburbs and plumbing and institutions for mass man. Anyway, don't take any of this as a personal critique of your life, just as questions that I ask from where I'm standing. My father is from Central America but the world he grew up in was healthy poverty...the world of Central America today is violence and ugliness...this is the price they're paying for "development" (I disliked Jimmy Akin's article especially for glorifying this inhuman idea of development). First I think you need to define what you mean by "a life of spiritual value" and "a human society". Whatever these things are - I would think that the time/civilization in which one finds oneself is neutral in respect to achieving these goals. We have saints from every era and there will be saints from this era as well. Secondly, I think that you might be a little too nostalgic about the past. There are plenty of inhumane things that those pre-modern societies produced as well.
blazeingstar Posted November 12, 2015 Posted November 12, 2015 No one (Catholic) on a Catholic board would argue for socialism or a state-controlled economy. That's against Church teaching. But in response to this and to what you said above in response to beatitude: We do know of a better way, and a way to limit greed: Convert souls to Christ. The weakness in all your statements is that they take only impersonal macro-economic forces into consideration. The solution begins in each individual's heart, spreads to their lifestyle, and thus to the world. This thread started with that, too. To quote a non-Christian: "Be the change you want to see in the world." That's what we're trying to do in here. I think the real thing is to be a good stewart of what you do have, and to be wise to what you need. If you budget $10 for a meal, and you're feeding 2 adults and a small child, then buy the farm rice, local green beans from a a family farm and the free range chicken. If you budget $10 for a meal and you have to feed 3 adults, 5 children and 2 toddlers then you may have to buy Uncle Ben's, frozen veg from a large farm and perdue chicken (or whatever's on sale). I think the question you're asking yourself weither spending $10 for products you know are from people treated humanely and animals that are treated justly, or spending $6 on the cheap stuff for the first family and donating $4 to the food pantry. It is a conundrum. However, the way I see it is that God has given you the $10. Not so you can spend excessively, but so you can spend with a right conscious. A right consciouncous should lead us to make decisions that allow for the care to those we are morally responsible for. As a single person, if you find yourself with $10 for a meal and you realize you only need $4, then morally you should donate the other $6 to feed the poor. In this case, moreso than the others, when one finds themselves having excess, they should be examining the source of the products to ensure that the right parties are getting their money. Those in poverty have a greater moral obligation to their family than the farmer. Don't take this as me saying that the poor should eat the junky food. Poor have just as much right to healthy, nutritious food as everyone else. This is about the moral obligation of the purchaser, because every item does have an effect on the economy.
Peace Posted November 12, 2015 Posted November 12, 2015 (edited) But in response to this and to what you said above in response to beatitude: We do know of a better way, and a way to limit greed: Convert souls to Christ. The weakness in all your statements is that they take only impersonal macro-economic forces into consideration. The solution begins in each individual's heart, spreads to their lifestyle, and thus to the world. Well if your solution is to spread the Gospel and try to change people's hearts then you will not hear any objections from me. I think that is something that we can all agree upon. But even for a person whose soul has been converted to Christ certain questions still remain - such as some of the questions you presented in your original post. I think what we are trying to address here is the answer to some of those questions. What specific actions are ultimately better for the poor? This is where economics becomes relevant. I think the real thing is to be a good stewart of what you do have, and to be wise to what you need. If you budget $10 for a meal, and you're feeding 2 adults and a small child, then buy the farm rice, local green beans from a a family farm and the free range chicken. If you budget $10 for a meal and you have to feed 3 adults, 5 children and 2 toddlers then you may have to buy Uncle Ben's, frozen veg from a large farm and perdue chicken (or whatever's on sale). OK - sorry to post-hijack, but that is interesting. Someone in this thread has made that point before I think. I don't see why buying from a local family farm is inherently any better than buying from a large supermarket. You seem to assume that wage exploitation is something that exists only at large stores. I think the owner of a local family farm tries to maximize his profit in the same way that owners of large stores do. Is there an assumption that one is greedier than the other? I bet there are plenty of small business owners who are plenty greedy and desire to pay their employees as little as possible and sell their products for as much as possible. How do I know that part of the additional price I pay for organic eggs is not due to the desire of the local farmer to make money? I don't see why one is inherently better than the other in that respect. If I had the luxury of living close to a small farm and knowing the farmers personally and knowing about their business practices and overall moral values then that might encourage me to buy from them than from a large supermarket. But I don't really have that type of time in my schedule to devote to the choice of where to get my potatoes from. I don't see anything inherent why "large/corporate" = bad and "small/private" = good. I think the question you're asking yourself weither spending $10 for products you know are from people treated humanely and animals that are treated justly, or spending $6 on the cheap stuff for the first family and donating $4 to the food pantry. It is a conundrum. However, the way I see it is that God has given you the $10. Not so you can spend excessively, but so you can spend with a right conscious. A right consciouncous should lead us to make decisions that allow for the care to those we are morally responsible for. As a single person, if you find yourself with $10 for a meal and you realize you only need $4, then morally you should donate the other $6 to feed the poor. In this case, moreso than the others, when one finds themselves having excess, they should be examining the source of the products to ensure that the right parties are getting their money. Those in poverty have a greater moral obligation to their family than the farmer. Here you hit on an interesting question I think. I don't think that you necessarily have to buy the $6 dollar meal and donate the $4 to the poor. If that is what you feel like God is calling you to do in the particular circumstance then you should do it, of course. What if the company that provides the meal for $10 needs customers to continue buying the $10 dollar meals in order to pay the salaries of people who work at the company? If everyone decided that they wanted to buy the $6 dollar meal instead then there is not enough money around to pay their salaries and people get fired. It happens. This is precisely what happens at some companies when people get laid-off is it not? What I am trying to suggest is that the impact of one choice versus another choice is not always so clearly a choice between right and wrong. Edited November 12, 2015 by Peace
Gabriela Posted November 12, 2015 Author Posted November 12, 2015 @Peace: Is the only option for a company either to keep wages low or to shut down? Because that's what you seem to assume. In fact, the wage gap between the lowest-earning employee and the highest-earning executive in most companies is outrageously unjust. Why must all cost increases come at the expense of the lowest-earning? It doesn't always have to come down to laying people off. Sometimes—oftentimes—it could come down to lowering outrageous salaries. But that doesn't happen—because of greed.
Era Might Posted November 12, 2015 Posted November 12, 2015 Well. You might consider moving to the Tenderloin. Plenty of drunks and trash there. I am pretty sure that both of these result from some kind of sin, so I don't particularly see why one should be fond of them. I'm a degenerate, and prefer the company of my own kind. No other reason.
Peace Posted November 12, 2015 Posted November 12, 2015 (edited) @Peace: Is the only option for a company either to keep wages low or to shut down? In some cases that might be the only option. It depends on the particular circumstances of the companies involved. You see everything across the spectrum, from CEO salaries getting lowered, to employee salaries getting cut, to lay-offs or bankruptcy. Because that's what you seem to assume. In fact, the wage gap between the lowest-earning employee and the highest-earning executive in most companies is outrageously unjust. Why must all cost increases come at the expense of the lowest-earning? It doesn't always have to come down to laying people off. Sometimes—oftentimes—it could come down to lowering outrageous salaries. But that doesn't happen—because of greed. Some of the salaries that corporate executives make seem excessive to me as well. And I do think that greed often comes into play. I would guess that there are many cases where the salaries or jobs of lower earning workers are sacrificed, where the salaries of higher paid employees could have been cut instead. In some situations cutting CEO salaries might be the solution. In some cases I think it is pretty clear that would not be a viable solution to the problems that some companies face. Do you remember that huge auto-bailout that we had a few years back? There were a lot of reasons why the US companies were on the brink of bankruptcy while foreign auto-makers fared much better. One of the reasons for that had to do with the employee contracts that most of the US companies were bound to, while their competitors in Japan were not. Lets say that the salary of the CEO of Ford was $50 million dollars. If you need to save money you can cut that down to $1 million and save $49 million dollars. But the price disadvantage the US companies faced was far greater than that. I think that after the bail-out the union contracts were redone such that the average US worker made about $10 more per hour than the average Japanese worker. Before the bailout the difference was much greater from what I understand. So if you lowball the math it looks something like: 200,000 employees x 40 hours / week x 48 weeks/year x $10 per hour = 3.84 billion dollars / year extra in labor costs. That is just a rough estimate, but it is very tough for a company to stay afloat if you are paying that much more in labor costs than your competitors. I think Toyota had a cost advantage of something like $500 dollars per vehicle when salary differences, benefits, etc. were all taken into account. You can cut the $50 million CEO salary and some other high salaries but you are tying to make up a deficit that is much greater than that. So it is no surprise that they were about to go belly-up until the government bailed them out. I think in this case they had to cut the worker salaries, which is what they ultimately did. I think there is also another way of looking at the difference in salaries between executives and regular employees though. Must it always be just or right to cut higher salaries first? I mean - I can kind of take myself as an example. My family was pretty poor as a child. I think the year I graduated high school my mom brought in about $15k a year in income and that was for 3 kids. We received welfare benefits and other forms of assistance at times. The neighborhood that I grew up in was extremely violent. It still is. I had to work my butt off and make a huge number of sacrifices to be where I am at today. There were years where I barely even saw the light of day I was studying so much. On top of that I worked during college, and I had to take out a loan of about $150,000 to pay for law school. I am not even half way done paying it off today and I graduated over 10 years ago. Right now I make a lot more than the staff at the law firm that I work at. If the firm was not doing well and salaries need to get cut, my initial reaction is not going to be "Well, because I make more my salary should get cut first." Is it really wrong or greed for me to think that way? There is a reason I make more. Part that is because of what you might call luck or the opportunities that I was blessed with. But part of the difference is also that I was diligent and worked much harder than some other people (such as my siblings, for example). One day I would like to send my children to a good school. I like to help my family out. I like to take vacations and other things. I don't think it would be an act of pure greed on my part if I were to not be happy at the idea of my salary getting cut. I don't think anybody is particularly happy at the idea of their salary getting cut and we each have our own circumstances that factor into the salaries that we have. . . I don't think that believing that my salary should be higher must necessarily translate into greed, so I would be a bit reluctant to label someone else as greedy for not wanting their salary cut either, unless I knew their particular circumstances and motivations . . . Edited November 12, 2015 by Peace
tinytherese Posted November 14, 2015 Posted November 14, 2015 Where do we find products that aren't made in sweatshops and the like anyway?
Gabriela Posted November 14, 2015 Author Posted November 14, 2015 Where do we find products that aren't made in sweatshops and the like anyway? 'Murica. Or Europe. Cost top-dollar, though. (And 'Murica has sweatshops, too, so you still have to be careful.)
Ice_nine Posted November 14, 2015 Posted November 14, 2015 (edited) very cool discussion guys. I wish I was able to participate more, but I've at least read it all. I really wish I had the time to respond more personally because despite the recent kvetching about how "there are no more good threads on phatmass" I'd like to see and be involved in more discussions like these. I will say I'm glad that God judges the heart and I believe love is a real force that, while cannot be measured by economists, has the power to transform things. I'm disheartened by globalization mainly because it creates too many moving pieces and it is far, far too complicated to offer viable solutions. A change in one part of the contraption might hurt this part over there, it might help this part which in turn combines with another part to cause problems for something else. I can get really overwhelmed with the enormity of it all and wind up freezing, staying up late, and being too beaver dam tired to do anything. Then I'm back at square one. So I've pretty much resolved to try to do things with a pure heart and hope God will bless my efforts in some mystical way that I may not even realize. Kind of like when I give a bum some dollars. Maybe it's just going to his crack fund, or maybe he'll use it to kill the hunger pangs. Maybe it would be better to do other things (donate to a homeless shelter e.g.) but to offer the man nothing seems inadequate and my small gesture is all I'm capable of. I realize to people who do not believe in God will find this philosophy worthless, and maybe believers will too, but it's all I got. The alternative is worrying and then proceeding to do nothing. Like Peace had mentioned, "doing something" may actually do more harm than good, but this is where faith enters the equation. Like peace I also ask myself "how much do I need," and "can I be a good Christian and still buy this, or live this particular way." I recently started a full time job and right now I'm trying to throw most of my money at the government to pay off my debts (can one really be considered to have surplus wealth when they are indebted? Is debt a reality of modern life? Has it always been so?) but I do spend money on things I don't particularly need and on activities that I enjoy. Is this ok? Even now I wonder if perhaps I'm rationalizing and seeking validation for my choices. It's vexing. Again I try to still give something and hope God will have mercy on me if I'm not giving enough. While greed has been here since the beginning I find many aspects of modernity present a unique challenge. The collapse of the community and isolationalism are particularly concerning for me. It's like subsidiarity is a thing of the past, and while it may make things easier (responsibilty is shifted to centralized power away from us plebes) it's also decimated the systems we need to maintain our humanity and social health. Also the fact that what you buy determines who you are. I guess signs of wealth have always been important, but I think it's fairly recent history where the solution to our problems is "go shopping!" Remember after 9/11 we were told we must keep shopping, by God, to show the terrorists they haven't won! What about grieving and taking a break from commerce for a hot minute? Even so much of the discussion here revolves around how to buy things, what to buy, and from whom we should buy. That's all I got for now, I hope the discussion continues. Edited November 14, 2015 by Ice_nine
Era Might Posted November 14, 2015 Posted November 14, 2015 (edited) I recently started a full time job and right now I'm trying to throw most of my money at the government to pay off my debts (can one really be considered to have surplus wealth when they are indebted? Is debt a reality of modern life? Has it always been so?) but I do spend money on things I don't particularly need and on activities that I enjoy. Is this ok? Even now I wonder if perhaps I'm rationalizing and seeking validation for my choices. It's vexing. Again I try to still give something and hope God will have mercy on me if I'm not giving enough. It's become a trope in the media that the "Millennial" generation is unable to grow up and enter adult life. What I find interesting about this argument is the assumption that adult life is worth growing up into. David Foster Wallace, a writer who I really like (not a Millennial but generations are just shorthand here), was really insightful on this. He said, "I think that if there is a sort of sadness for people under 45, it has something to do with pleasure, and achievement, and entertainment—like a sort of emptiness at the heart of what they thought was going on." Wallace killed himself a few years back at the age of 46. He has another essay on our inability to understand Kafka's humor, he writes: "A crude way to put the whole thing is that our present culture is, both developmentally and historically, adolescent. And since adolescence is acknowledged to the be the single most stressful and frightening period of human development--the stage when the adulthood we claim to crave begins to present itself as a real and narrowing system of responsibilities and limitations (taxes, death), and when we yearn inside for a return to the same childish oblivion we pretend to scorn--it's not difficult to see why we as a culture are so susceptible to art and entertainment whose primary function is escape, i.e., fantasy, adrenaline, spectacle, romance, etc. What is really at stake in the "Millennials won't grow up" narrative is the very legitimacy of the American way of life...the careerism, the commercialism, the automatism, the institutionalization, etc. This isn't new...Herman Melville's famous story "Bartleby, the Scrivener" is subtitled "A Story of Wall Street"...Bartleby decides one day that he would prefer not to work...he doesn't leave the office, doesn't respond to threats of firing, doesn't react when they tell him to leave...he just drops out of life. He baffles the people he works with...how can a man refuse to work? Doesn't he have debts, hobbies, etc. that he needs to finance? Family to take care of?...the real scandal here is not that he refuses to work, but that in doing so he questions the legitimacy of the society he lives in...whether the things he is supposed to be working to uphold is worth upholding. One of the fascinating things about the Catholic Worker was that its heyday was during the Great Depression, when people had nothing to give. The Catholic Worker wasn't just a relief society, but a different way of life that challenged the entire American system, economic, political, social, intellectual, historical. If Millennials refuse to grow into the society they've been given...who stands to lose the most? The older generations that bought wholeheartedly into that society, and for whom the Millennials represent the possibility that they gave their hearts to a false dream, like a wife who can't even consider the possibility the possibility that her husband has been cheating on her for years. The possibility is too hurtful, not for the marriage, but because it shatters the entire illusion of the wife's life. That was part of the fear of Occupy Wall Street, the questioning of a system where we become indentured servants of loans, institutions, etc. in order to prop up that system and keep it running. But, as you hint at, this is nothing new in America...Thoreau was a real-life Bartleby: Most men, even in this comparatively free country, through mere ignorance and mistake, are so occupied with the factitious cares and superfluously coarse labors of life that its finer fruits cannot be plucked by them. Their fingers, from excessive toil, are too clumsy and tremble too much for that. Actually, the laboring man has not leisure for a true integrity day by day; he cannot afford to sustain the manliest relations to men; his labor would be depreciated in the market. He has no time to be anything but a machine. How can he remember well his ignorance—which his growth requires—who has so often to use his knowledge? We should feed and clothe him gratuitously sometimes, and recruit him with our cordials, before we judge of him. The finest qualities of our nature, like the bloom on fruits, can be preserved only by the most delicate handling. Yet we do not treat ourselves nor one another thus tenderly. Some of you, we all know, are poor, find it hard to live, are sometimes, as it were, gasping for breath. I have no doubt that some of you who read this book are unable to pay for all the dinners which you have actually eaten, or for the coats and shoes which are fast wearing or are already worn out, and have come to this page to spend borrowed or stolen time, robbing your creditors of an hour. It is very evident what mean and sneaking lives many of you live, for my sight has been whetted by experience; always on the limits, trying to get into business and trying to get out of debt, a very ancient slough, called by the Latins aes alienum, another's brass, for some of their coins were made of brass; still living, and dying, and buried by this other's brass; always promising to pay, promising to pay, tomorrow, and dying today, insolvent; seeking to curry favor, to get custom, by how many modes, only not state-prison offenses; lying, flattering, voting, contracting yourselves into a nutshell of civility or dilating into an atmosphere of thin and vaporous generosity, that you may persuade your neighbor to let you make his shoes, or his hat, or his coat, or his carriage, or import his groceries for him; making yourselves sick, that you may lay up something against a sick day, something to be tucked away in an old chest, or in a stocking behind the plastering, or, more safely, in the brick bank; no matter where, no matter how much or how little. Or, as Paul Goodman was writing in the 50's about young men in the organized system, who either become Organization Men, Beats, or Delinquents: In our society, bright lively children, with the potentiality for knowledge, noble ideals, honest effort, and some kind of worthwhile achievement, are transformed into useless and cynical bipeds, or decent young men trapped or early resigned, whether in or out of the organized system. My purpose is a simple one: to show how it is desperately hard these days for an average child to grow up to be a man, for our present organized system of society does not want men. They are not safe. They do not suit.[/quote Here's a recent interview/article with an updating of Goodman's thesis for contemporary times: http://www.thestraddler.com/201412/piece7.php Instead, most education is determined by the problem of discipline in schools. How do you make people do homework? How do you make people be there in a way that you can control them? Most of the paraphernalia of school is just to keep people in line. That’s good training for the job market. It’s very close to prison, because there’s so much make-work in it. But if you see kids who aren’t trained that way, and you see how lit up they are most of the time, that’s a lesson, too. The whole idea of the perfect liberal education is no longer the classics, it’s knowing something about computers. It’s having all your rough edges rubbed off so that you’ll fit in your next job when you move, or when they move you.[13] Today, when kids are baffled by what the teacher is telling them, it’s because they haven’t got a framework to put it in, it doesn’t relate to anything in their world. To learn something about your culture you need some basis in your actual experience. Goodman used to like to quote a study that said the average ten-year-old boy in Harlem had never been more than three blocks away from home. But that didn’t mean that boy had a neighborhood. It just meant he had no experience of nature, or of how food comes to exist, for example. Such a circumstance kills the sense that, as human beings, every one of us ought to have: a sense of confidence in ourselves that we will be able to survive without services—that we could do what needed to be done. Edited November 14, 2015 by Era Might
Ice_nine Posted November 14, 2015 Posted November 14, 2015 Era where do you get all this time to read all these books? I have trouble finding the energy to read much between the hours of indentured servitude to the system and being a "contributing member of society" Also Bartleby sounds like the dude from Office Space.
Era Might Posted November 14, 2015 Posted November 14, 2015 Era where do you get all this time to read all these books? I have trouble finding the energy to read much between the hours of indentured servitude to the system and being a "contributing member of society" Also Bartleby sounds like the dude from Office Space. For the moment I've become Bartleby myself...I've more or less dropped out of the system, and am not sure whether I intend to go back, so I spend my days in the library reading lol.
Ice_nine Posted November 14, 2015 Posted November 14, 2015 good for you. Pretty sure I don't have the spine or nerve to do that but props to those who do.
Gabriela Posted November 14, 2015 Author Posted November 14, 2015 For the moment I've become Bartleby myself...I've more or less dropped out of the system, and am not sure whether I intend to go back, so I spend my days in the library reading lol. Era, have you considered writing your ideas down and sending them to publications? You have a lot of outstanding insights. You could make some money that way—on your own terms. Or would that be "living too much in the system"? I was freelance for a while, and I hated it, but I need to feel financially secure. You seem fine without it. Maybe it would be a good arrangement for you. You certainly have the brain for it.
Credo in Deum Posted November 15, 2015 Posted November 15, 2015 Are all Christians called to be (materially) poor? Nope. All Catholics are called to be saints. Not every saint was a poor monk, nun, or priest. There have been saints who were rich lords, princes, and kings. Wealth itself is not evil, however, an attachment to wealth is evil. Pray to be detached from wealth, so if God's will says "Peace, go and give all you have to the poor and follow me" you will say "Amen!"
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now