Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Ash Wednesday
Posted

I could be completely wrong and off base here (and I'm sorry in advance if I am), but even if you set aside the moral/religious differences -- what I'm reading in your posts is that you feel she's a great person and that you care about her. But I'm not really getting the sense that you love her like a soul mate or potential life partner, or at least moving in that direction. 

I was in a situation where I had a relationship and the guy and I enjoyed each others company and we had a good time together, but we reached a point where we eventually broke up because dating really should be more than just "something to do" -- he was also Catholic and shared my values, but he didn't have marriage remotely on his mind, and I decided I wanted to go to graduate school. So I just didn't see the point of really dating anymore. I cared about him, and some ways even loved him, but didn't love him enough to consider him a soul mate and life partner. He didn't know what to do with his life so once he got over the shock of breaking up, it was actually a relief for him and he was better off when we called it quits. 

When I met my husband, it felt like I went from trying to cram my foot into an ill-fitting shoe to finding the most beautiful and comfortable shoe ever. Everything just fit, there really weren't a lot of questions, and while we had and still have some differences at times -- it was radically different than just trying to date someone and forcing it. 

Avoid dating just for the sake of it. I know that people get to know each other and have to start somewhere. But eventually there does come a point where you realize whether or not the person is truly someone you want to marry and I think that's the point when it's worth asking how much it's worth continuing the relationship. Dating without the goal of seriously discerning marriage is just a waste of time and emotional energy, in my opinion. I learned the hard way. 

Posted
22 minutes ago, IgnatiusofLoyola said:

Huh? How does premarital sex "contaminate" a person more than any other sin? Yes, I guess they could have caught STDs, but unless they were careless, they almost certainly did not. In any case, a simple visit to the doctor at the time of an annual physical could give a clean bill of health. STDs are curable and do not physically contaminate someone forever. Bluntly, I can think of far worse sins than premarital sex.

Why should someone have to make a special "atonement" for premarital sex versus any other sin? If a person were to marry the wrong person so as to not further "contaminate" the dating pool (whatever that means) that would be potentially sentencing them to a lifetime of unhappiness. The couple did not physically assault anyone, or rob someone, or use the host to participate in Satanic rites. I assume a Catholic would go to confession as they would for other sins, and a priest (NOT ANY OF US) would decide the appropriate penance.

Let he who is without sin cast the first stone. 

Iggy, Norseman once suggested that I offer myself up as a bride to a gay man so as to satisfy that gay man's sexual needs.

this one is possessed of some singular ideas.

Ash Wednesday
Posted

That was definitely one of our more memorable moments on phatmass. 

MarysLittleFlower
Posted (edited)
10 hours ago, Norseman82 said:

I'm normally a person who is in the "Catholics shouldn't turn their backs on their own kind" camp, but in this case, I think you should give her another chance for two reasons:

1)  If she truly realizes that she is on "shaky ground", then that could be the Holy Spirit working on her to reform.  Maybe at some point if she sees what abortion really does (I know I did not become fervently anti-abortion until I saw pictures of aborted babies), she may change her view.  In short:  I think the situation is salvageable and there are signs of hope she may embrace Catholicism.  Of course, you still have to follow up (for example, she will need to become against artificial birth control as well, which could be a stumbling block in your marriage and your salvation if she does not follow Church teaching and you do).

2)  Looking at the "big picture", since so much of the dating pool is poisoned (which is why so many good Catholics cannot find compatible spouses), and the two of you have contribued to the contamination through your acts of fornication, then if you break up and seek others, there is a risk that the contamination could affect the non-contaminated parts of the dating pool.  So by trying to staying together, you two could be stopping the contamination from spreading further, and in that way you could atone for what you've done.

I don't really understand your second point. What do you mean by contaminated? The reason many devout Catholics can't find compatible spouses is because few people in general probably want to become saints. If someone sinned and repented and is living a good life now how is that not compatible? Are they now "contaminated" people? I don't think that's how God sees them even with the fact that virginity has a special reward. They can't recover it but they can recover purity and their sin is forgiven and gone. 

If someone sees repentant sinners as "contaminated", perhaps they should remember how Our Lord treated St Mary Magdalene.. Maybe I misunderstood your post, I hope so. 

What do you mean and where is your idea from? Maybe I misunderstood. 

Edited by MarysLittleFlower
HisChildForever
Posted

 

10 hours ago, Norseman82 said:

I'm normally a person who is in the "Catholics shouldn't turn their backs on their own kind" camp, 

I'm one of the above. A traitor, apparently.

Not A Real Name
Posted

I think you should break up.  Not because she is in the wrong, frankly she doesn't know any better, but because you don't seem to be strong enough to live your faith while you are around her.  You do her zero favors telling her about Catholicism while committing mortal sins.  I know you said you stopped doing the "martial act", but you need to ask yourself if you will be strong enough to resist her demands if she folds on this resolution.  Plus as others have stated, if marriage is not what you are working towards then you have no business being in a relationship. 

Posted
9 hours ago, IgnatiusofLoyola said:

Huh? How does premarital sex "contaminate" a person more than any other sin? Yes, I guess they could have caught STDs, but unless they were careless, they almost certainly did not. In any case, a simple visit to the doctor at the time of an annual physical could give a clean bill of health. STDs are curable and do not physically contaminate someone forever. Bluntly, I can think of far worse sins than premarital sex.

Why should someone have to make a special "atonement" for premarital sex versus any other sin? If a person were to marry the wrong person so as to not further "contaminate" the dating pool (whatever that means) that would be potentially sentencing them to a lifetime of unhappiness. The couple did not physically assault anyone, or rob someone, or use the host to participate in Satanic rites. I assume a Catholic would go to confession as they would for other sins, and a priest (NOT ANY OF US) would decide the appropriate penance.

Let he who is without sin cast the first stone.

Actually, St. Paul in 1 Corinthians 6 singles out fornication as a special class of sin.  He felt so strongly that he used the image of being united to a prostitute. Like the saying goes, when you sleep with someone, you sleep with everyone they slept with, and everyone they slept with, and so on, and so on.  And at Fatima, Mary said that more people would go to hell for "sins of the flesh" than any other sin.  One of the reasons this culture has sunk down the toilet is because people don't take this seriously.enough.  Sure, it happened in the past, but there used to be a sense of shame and guilt about it that kept society in check.

7 hours ago, Peace said:

I got 5 Hail Marys FWIW.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ghq-AOHQBR0

4 hours ago, Lilllabettt said:

Iggy, Norseman once suggested that I offer myself up as a bride to a gay man so as to satisfy that gay man's sexual needs.

this one is possessed of some singular ideas.

If you recall correctly, that was in response to one of your harsh insensitive mocking posts in order to get you to stop.

And it worked.

Posted
1 hour ago, Not A Real Name said:

You don't seem to be strong enough to live your faith while you are around her.

How did you arrive at this conclusion?

Not A Real Name
Posted
Just now, Peace said:

How did you arrive at this conclusion?

Your admission to performing the martial act with your girlfriend. 

Posted
9 minutes ago, Not A Real Name said:

Your admission to performing the martial act with your girlfriend. 

Anything else - or was that it?

Several folks in this thread seem to have asked the question so I may as well clarify - I date in order to get married. That is the end game for any relationship that I am in, including the one that I am in now.

Peace

Not A Real Name
Posted (edited)
32 minutes ago, Peace said:

Anything else - or was that it?

 

Do you think there should be something else?  Are you under the impression that premarital sex isn't a big issue?  What are you going to do differently if your girlfriend asks you to have sex again?  If you knew premarital sex was wrong but did it anyway in the past, what makes you think the next time there is a temptation for premarital sex that you will have the courage to do what you didn't have the courage to do the first time, second time, or third time, or however many a "few" times is in your book?   The fact that you went to her after your confession and asked "Hey, we should cut that our, right?  We should at least try to do what we know is right " would indicate that maybe you haven't been living in a manner which conveys that you are not a person who bends to sin.   Also it looks like you are asking for her approval/permission to not have premarital sex.  Is this the case?  If so what would you do if she said "No, we should not cut that out since I do not see anything wrong with it." You have already expressed that you have gotten the impression from her that she does not want to be abstinent.

Sorry Peace, but it seems prideful to continue to put yourself in a situation where you have already fallen into mortal sin a few times (which is a few times too many). You do know that when you make a confession you promise to avoid occasions of sin? Do you think your relationship has become an occasion of sin for you? Also don't answer me on that question.  I would suggest you reflect on that question and pray about it. 

Edited by Not A Real Name
Posted
1 hour ago, Norseman82 said:

Actually, St. Paul in 1 Corinthians 6 singles out fornication as a special class of sin.  He felt so strongly that he used the image of being united to a prostitute. Like the saying goes, when you sleep with someone, you sleep with everyone they slept with, and everyone they slept with, and so on, and so on.  And at Fatima, Mary said that more people would go to hell for "sins of the flesh" than any other sin.  One of the reasons this culture has sunk down the toilet is because people don't take this seriously.enough.  Sure, it happened in the past, but there used to be a sense of shame and guilt about it that kept society in check.

I am not sure if Paul classifies "fornication" as a special class of sin there. Paul refers to "sexual immorality" and mentions prostitution as a specific example. One might guess that prostitution was the specific sin that many of the Corinthians were engaged in.

But regardless - "sexual immorality" includes more than fornication. It also includes pornography, masturbation, lust, etc. Would it be a safe bet to say that a person of high morals such as yourself has never once found yourself guilty of any of these?

Posted
5 minutes ago, Peace said:

I am not sure if Paul classifies "fornication" as a special class of sin there. Paul refers to "sexual immorality" and mentions prostitution as a specific example. One might guess that prostitution was the specific sin that many of the Corinthians were engaged in.

But regardless - "sexual immorality" includes more than fornication. It also includes pornography, masturbation, lust, etc. Would it be a safe bet to say that a person of high morals such as yourself has never once found yourself guilty of any of these?

Actually, the Bible is explicit in using the word "fornication".

And Not a Real Name has a valid point.  Not cool to tell (or want to tell) a woman that she has loose morals after you sleep with her multiple times when you really don't know her well, per your opening post in this thread.

Posted
1 minute ago, Not A Real Name said:

Do you think there should be something else?  

 I thought that your conclusion was unwarranted by the evidence presented. I do not think the fact that a person has committed a sin is sufficient to warrant a conclusion that the person is not strong enough to live their faith.

1 minute ago, Not A Real Name said:

Are you under the impression that premarital sex isn't a big issue?  

No.

1 minute ago, Not A Real Name said:

What are you going to do differently if your girlfriend asks you to have sex again?  

I plan to say no.

1 minute ago, Not A Real Name said:

If you knew premarital sex was wrong but did it anyway in the past, what makes you think the next time there is a temptation for premarital sex that you will have the courage to do what you didn't have the courage to do the first time, second time, or third time, or however many a "few" times is in your book?

With the grace of God all things are possible.

1 minute ago, Not A Real Name said:

The fact that you went to her after your confession and asked "Hey, we should cut that our, right?  We should at least try to do what we know is right " would indicate that maybe you haven't been living in a manner which conveys that you are not a person who bends to sin.  

Yes. It does indeed take two to tango. I am just as guilty as she was.

1 minute ago, Not A Real Name said:

Also it looks like you are asking for her approval/permission to not have premarital sex.  Is this the case?

No.

1 minute ago, Not A Real Name said:

If so what would you do if she said "No, we should not cut that out since I do not see anything wrong with it." You have already expressed that you have gotten the impression from her that she does not want to be abstinent.

I already stated what I would do in that situation previously in this post. I stated that in that case we would have to split up.

1 minute ago, Not A Real Name said:

Sorry Peace, but it seems prideful to continue to put yourself in a situation where you have already fallen into mortal sin a few times (which is a few times too many).

Maybe you are correct. I will give it some additional thought.

1 minute ago, Not A Real Name said:

You do know that when you make a confession you promise to avoid occasions of sin? 

I think that I have demonstrated an ability to read by responding to your posts. That ability to read would also include reading the act of contrition on the confessional wall. Does that answer your question?

1 minute ago, Not A Real Name said:

Do you think your relationship has become an occasion of sin for you? Also don't answer me on that question.  I would suggest you reflect on that question and pray about it. 

That is a good suggestion. I will.

Posted

Even if you break up with her because you feel she is an occasion of sin, people may still think "he had his fun with her, now he's throwing her by the wayside".

IMHO, the best thing would be to do what you already started to do: to take the moral leadership (which you will need to do as a husband anyway, so this will be a good practice for that future role). Say bluntly "no more sinning". Mean it. Follow through with it. Don't give in. Then, if she can't handle it, she will have the option to break up with you, but it will be her action that she will have to be accountable for on judgment day.  And you won't be the "bad guy".

Posted
13 minutes ago, Norseman82 said:

Actually, the Bible is explicit in using the word "fornication".

OK. The translation (ESV) I am using says "sexual immorality" but I will take your word for it. You don't think that what Paul is talking about in that chapter would include things like masturbation, lust, watching pornography, etc.? These also seem to be sins against a person's own body, which appears to be the "special class" that Paul is referring to:

Shun immorality.[h] Every other sin which a man commits is outside the body; but the immoral man sins against his own body. 19

13 minutes ago, Norseman82 said:

And Not a Real Name has a valid point.  Not cool to tell (or want to tell) a woman that she has loose morals after you sleep with her multiple times when you really don't know her well, per your opening post in this thread.

Yeah. My morals were loose too. There is no denying that. I want to change it.

Not A Real Name
Posted (edited)
15 minutes ago, Peace said:

 I thought that your conclusion was unwarranted by the evidence presented. I do not think the fact that a person has committed a sin is sufficient to warrant a conclusion that the person is not strong enough to live their faith.

 

With the grace of God all things are possible.

 

I would agree if you had only committed "A" sin, but that is not what happened.  You admitted you have done this sin a few times which shows there is a problem. Given now that you are wounded by this sin, you are even weaker now than you were before in your ability to fight against it. 

"With the grace of God all things are possible."  Yes, all things are possible when they lead to virtue and avoiding sin.  However, God does not continue to give you graces when you put yourself back into an occasion of sin. In fact putting yourself in an occasion sin is itself a mortal sin.  

Proverbs 26:11

Edited by Not A Real Name
Posted
12 minutes ago, Peace said:

OK. The translation (ESV) I am using says "sexual immorality" but I will take your word for it. You don't think that what Paul is talking about in that chapter would include things like masturbation, lust, watching pornography, etc.? These also seem to be sins against a person's own body, which appears to be the "special class" that Paul is referring to:

Shun immorality.[h] Every other sin which a man commits is outside the body; but the immoral man sins against his own body. 19

Yeah. My morals were loose too. There is no denying that. I want to change it.

Yes, those things are sins, too.  However, fornication crosses the line because there is a physical union that the other sins do not have, hence St. Paul's warning about "uniting with a prostitute".

My source was a parallel version translation in www.awmach.org

Posted
2 minutes ago, Not A Real Name said:

I would agree if you had only committed "A" sin, but that is not what happened.  You admitted you have done this sin a few times which shows there is a problem. Given now that you are wounded by this sin, you are even weaker now than you were before in your ability to fight against it. 

I see. So if I commit a sin 1 time then I am OK. If I commit the sin twice then I am in trouble? I would be willing to bet that I have broken most of the commandments many more times than 2 so I guess that I am in some serious trouble. Perhaps I am.

As for my being weaker now. I am not so sure if that is true. I think that people become stronger with frequent participation in the sacraments. By frequent confession, going to Mass, etc., the temptation to commit those sins should decrease. That is what my priest said, at least.

2 minutes ago, Not A Real Name said:

 However, God does not continue to give you graces when you put yourself back into an occasion of sin.

I do not think this is correct. Otherwise, how is it that some people who commit terrible sins consistently year after year find their way back to confession? We know that we can do no good without God. It seems that God must give even those people some amount of grace such that they repent and go to confession.

Whether being in a relationship with her is a near occasion of sin is something that I will need to think about. My inclination is to answer that question with a no, but I will think about it.

2 minutes ago, Not A Real Name said:

In fact putting yourself in an occasion sin is itself a mortal sin.  

Proverbs 26:11

I was not aware of that, nor am I certain that this is correct. Can you point me to the paragraph of the Catechism that says that?

Posted
1 minute ago, Peace said:

 

I was not aware of that, nor am I certain that this is correct. Can you point me to the paragraph of the Catechism that says that?

I have been taught the same thing consistently by several very holy and very intelligent priests.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...