MarysLittleFlower Posted December 25, 2015 Posted December 25, 2015 (edited) There seem to be two views... 1) the formula alone invalidates the Mass. The priest can have a wrong intent but the Consecration still happens if he uses the right formula 2) the formula needs to be correct but also the priest needs to intend to do what the Church does I know sins of the priest don't invalidate it. Or even perhaps doubts. But I was always told its the second option and that the Anglicans lost their Sacraments in this way - they no longer intended what the Church intends. Is there are source that definitively answers the question? Thanks Phuture Priest, we can maybe move that discussion here to keep the other thread on topic I see there are two views so maybe there's a document or catechism that clarifies which view it is. Edited December 25, 2015 by MarysLittleFlower
Nihil Obstat Posted December 25, 2015 Posted December 25, 2015 36 minutes ago, MarysLittleFlower said: There seem to be two views... 1) the formula alone invalidates the Mass. The priest can have a wrong intent but the Consecration still happens if he uses the right formula 2) the formula needs to be correct but also the priest needs to intend to do what the Church does I know sins of the priest don't invalidate it. Or even perhaps doubts. But I was always told its the second option and that the Anglicans lost their Sacraments in this way - they no longer intended what the Church intends. Is there are source that definitively answers the question? Thanks Phuture Priest, we can maybe move that discussion here to keep the other thread on topic I see there are two views so maybe there's a document or catechism that clarifies which view it is. The validity of all sacraments require proper form, proper matter, and proper intent. A defect in one invalidates the entire thing. For the Eucharist, form is the words of consecration, matter is the bread and wine, and intent is the intent "to do as the Church does." From the Catholic Encyclopedia: The Church teaches very unequivocally that for the valid conferring of the sacraments, the minister must have the intention of doing at least what the Church does. This is laid down with great emphasis by the Council of Trent (sess. VII). The opinion once defended by such theologians as Catharinus and Salmeron that there need only be the intention to perform deliberately the external rite proper to each sacrament, and that, as long as this was true, the interior dissent of the minister from the mind of the Church would not invalidate the sacrament, no longer finds adherents. The common doctrine now is that a real internal intention to act as a minister of Christ, or to do what Christ instituted the sacraments to effect, in other words, to truly baptize, absolve, etc., is required. This intention need not necessarily be of the sort called actual. That would often be practically impossible. It is enough that it be virtual. Neither habitual nor interpretative intention in the minister will suffice for the validity of the sacrament. The truth is that here and now, when the sacrament is being conferred, neither of these intentions exists, and they can therefore exercise no determining influence upon what is done. To administer the sacraments with a conditional intention, which makes their effect contingent upon a future event, is to confer them invalidly. This holds good for all the sacraments except matrimony, which, being a contract, is susceptible of such a limitation. As to the recipients of the sacraments, it is certain that no intention is required in children who have not yet reached the age of reason, or in imbeciles, for the validity of those sacraments which they are capable of receiving. In the case of adults, on the other hand, some intention is indispensable if the sacrament is not to be invalid. The reason is that our justification is not brought about without our co-operation, and that includes the rational will to profit by the means of sanctification. How much of an intention is enough is not always quite clear. In general, more in the way of intention will be demanded in proportion as the acts of the receiver seem to enter into the making of the sacrament. So for penance and matrimony under ordinary conditions a virtual intention would appear to be required; for the other sacraments an habitual intention is sufficient. For an unconscious person in danger of death the habitual intention may be implicit and still suffice for the validity of the sacraments that are then necessary or highly useful; that is, it may be contained in the more general purpose which a man has at some time during his life, and which he has never retracted, of availing himself of these means of salvation at so supreme a moment. For the gaining of indulgences the most that can probably be exacted is an habitual intention.
PhuturePriest Posted December 25, 2015 Posted December 25, 2015 21 minutes ago, Nihil Obstat said: The validity of all sacraments require proper form, proper matter, and proper intent. A defect in one invalidates the entire thing. For the Eucharist, form is the words of consecration, matter is the bread and wine, and intent is the intent "to do as the Church does." From the Catholic Encyclopedia: The Church teaches very unequivocally that for the valid conferring of the sacraments, the minister must have the intention of doing at least what the Church does. This is laid down with great emphasis by the Council of Trent (sess. VII). The opinion once defended by such theologians as Catharinus and Salmeron that there need only be the intention to perform deliberately the external rite proper to each sacrament, and that, as long as this was true, the interior dissent of the minister from the mind of the Church would not invalidate the sacrament, no longer finds adherents. The common doctrine now is that a real internal intention to act as a minister of Christ, or to do what Christ instituted the sacraments to effect, in other words, to truly baptize, absolve, etc., is required. This intention need not necessarily be of the sort called actual. That would often be practically impossible. It is enough that it be virtual. Neither habitual nor interpretative intention in the minister will suffice for the validity of the sacrament. The truth is that here and now, when the sacrament is being conferred, neither of these intentions exists, and they can therefore exercise no determining influence upon what is done. To administer the sacraments with a conditional intention, which makes their effect contingent upon a future event, is to confer them invalidly. This holds good for all the sacraments except matrimony, which, being a contract, is susceptible of such a limitation. As to the recipients of the sacraments, it is certain that no intention is required in children who have not yet reached the age of reason, or in imbeciles, for the validity of those sacraments which they are capable of receiving. In the case of adults, on the other hand, some intention is indispensable if the sacrament is not to be invalid. The reason is that our justification is not brought about without our co-operation, and that includes the rational will to profit by the means of sanctification. How much of an intention is enough is not always quite clear. In general, more in the way of intention will be demanded in proportion as the acts of the receiver seem to enter into the making of the sacrament. So for penance and matrimony under ordinary conditions a virtual intention would appear to be required; for the other sacraments an habitual intention is sufficient. For an unconscious person in danger of death the habitual intention may be implicit and still suffice for the validity of the sacraments that are then necessary or highly useful; that is, it may be contained in the more general purpose which a man has at some time during his life, and which he has never retracted, of availing himself of these means of salvation at so supreme a moment. For the gaining of indulgences the most that can probably be exacted is an habitual intention. So, say a priest is celebrating Mass, but has decided consubstantiation is where it's at. He says the formula exactly as the Church demands and doesn't change any words or actions, but in his heart he doesn't believe in the Eucharist. What would this result in? Or say also that a priest has decided something a penitent has confessed is not mortal, even though it is. Is his absolution valid, even if he doesn't intend to absolve the penitent of that mortal sin?
Nihil Obstat Posted December 25, 2015 Posted December 25, 2015 The absolution is valid as long as the priest intended to absolve, full stop. Immaterial whether he considers the sins mortal or not. The other situation is tricky, and probably depends on how the heretical priest understands "what the Church does". If he believes and intends himself to do what the Church does, even if his idea of what the Church does is silly and heretical, it is probably still valid. But I would lean towards validity being doubtful precisely the way you described it.
MarysLittleFlower Posted December 25, 2015 Author Posted December 25, 2015 Thank you! That's the kind of source I was looking for... So I guess the idea that was rejected is that the priest being in sin would still consecrate the Eucharist validly (though he should not be in sin and that would be serious). But the intent to do as the Church does, that is necessary. I think most priests today do intend that? Unless they believe some Protestant idea but that can't be common I think ?
Gladius Posted December 25, 2015 Posted December 25, 2015 (edited) 2 hours ago, Nihil Obstat said: The absolution is valid as long as the priest intended to absolve, full stop. Immaterial whether he considers the sins mortal or not. The other situation is tricky, and probably depends on how the heretical priest understands "what the Church does". If he believes and intends himself to do what the Church does, even if his idea of what the Church does is silly and heretical, it is probably still valid. But I would lean towards validity being doubtful precisely the way you described it. What happens when a priest explains away your sins as not being sins? 1 hour ago, MarysLittleFlower said: Thank you! That's the kind of source I was looking for... So I guess the idea that was rejected is that the priest being in sin would still consecrate the Eucharist validly (though he should not be in sin and that would be serious). But the intent to do as the Church does, that is necessary. I think most priests today do intend that? Unless they believe some Protestant idea but that can't be common I think ? If your window is dirty, the sunlight shining through it is not affected. Edited December 25, 2015 by Gladius
Nihil Obstat Posted December 25, 2015 Posted December 25, 2015 8 minutes ago, Gladius said: What happens when a priest explains away your sins as not being sins? If your window is dirty, the sunlight shining through it is not affected. I am not sure that should affect the intent, speaking very strictly. As long as he intends to absolve at all.
Gladius Posted December 25, 2015 Posted December 25, 2015 (edited) 5 minutes ago, Nihil Obstat said: I am not sure that should affect the intent, speaking very strictly. As long as he intends to absolve at all. Sounds too iffy for me. Edited December 25, 2015 by Gladius
MarysLittleFlower Posted December 25, 2015 Author Posted December 25, 2015 Well the priest acts as a judge so we should give him an accurate understanding of the sins. But if after we have done this, the priest decides they are venial or not sins, then either he's right (as in the case of scruples, its important to trust the confessor) or even if there's a mistake, I guess he still intends to absolve? Its a good question... I don't know for sure... But the absolution seems to work in an all or nothing way. If you are contrite and honest, the things you forget are forgiven to, though the priest can't know if they are mortal or venial. So maybe if you are properly disposed, and the priest says the formula intending to absolve, absolutely everything gets absolved - including sins you forgot, those you described badly just from anxiety, etc. I don't know how much understanding the priest needs to have. Its up to the penitent to give him sufficient matter to absolve. But I think absolute perfection isn't the goal, just being sorry and saying everything you remember, and the formula/intent from the priest. Maybe in some manual it answers the question of what happens if there's a mistake regarding the nature of the sin.. Or even existence of the sin. But I think its best not to complicate it too much because we often make mistakes or forget things in Confession (at least I do) and we shouldn't be overcome by doubts and fears
Nihil Obstat Posted December 25, 2015 Posted December 25, 2015 24 minutes ago, Gladius said: Sounds too iffy for me. I am having a tough time thinking of a situation where a priest could say the words "I absolve you" and not intend to absolve the penitent's sins. At least, not by accident. He would, I think, have to actually be intending deception.
Gladius Posted December 26, 2015 Posted December 26, 2015 2 hours ago, Nihil Obstat said: I am having a tough time thinking of a situation where a priest could say the words "I absolve you" and not intend to absolve the penitent's sins. At least, not by accident. He would, I think, have to actually be intending deception. I agree with the point you make. I was thinking more of a priest who might explain away a certain sin or sins and persuade the penitent not to confess them at all. That would make the absolution he gave, more like a general absolution. I would consider that highly questionable. (Cut and paste below.) Following the mandate of Vatican Council II, Pope Paul VI promulgated the Decree on the Rite of Penance (1973) which affirmed, "Individual, integral confession and absolution remain the only ordinary way for the faithful to reconcile themselves with God and the Church, unless physical or moral impossibility excuses from this kind of confession." (This norm was reiterated m the Code of Canon Law, No. 960 and the Catechism, No. 1420ff). Therefore. the Church upholds the traditional practice of the penitent examining his conscience, repenting of sin and feeling sincere contrition for those sins, having the firm amendment not to commit those sins again, confessing those sins to a priest privately and receiving absolution, and then performing the appropriate penance. This spiritual regimen is essential for the pursuit of holiness.
Ash Wednesday Posted December 26, 2015 Posted December 26, 2015 Let me make this clear: criticism of the Novus Ordo mass is NOT allowed on this phorum. Please see the phorum guidelines on catholic vs. catholic bickering.
chrysostom Posted December 26, 2015 Posted December 26, 2015 (edited) I think this calls for Fr Hunwicke: "Catholic teaching, since the anti-Donatist controversy, has been firmly on the side of believing that it is very difficult for a minister to invalidate a sacrament by his own sin or stupidity or schism or even heresy or total unbelief ... as long as he Does the Red and Says the Black with at least a habitual intention of Doing Stuff (and not, for example, of performing a didactic demonstration or a blasphemous parody). And all this is ultimately based upon a very simple truth: the Sacraments are not ours, but the Sacraments of the Lord Christ." And Fr Adrian Fortescue: "People who are not theologians never seem to understand how little intention is wanted for a sacrament (the point applies equally to minister and subject). The 'implicit intention of doing what Christ instituted' means so small and vague a thing that one can hardly help having it ... numbers of Catholics confused intention with faith. Faith is not wanted. It is heresy to say that it is (this was the error of St Cyprian and Firmalian against which Pope Stephen I, a.d. 254-7, protested). A man may have utterly wrong, heretical and blasphemous views about a sacrament, and yet confer it or receive it validly." And St. Robert Bellarmine: "There is no need to intend what the Roman Church does; but what the true Church does, whatever that True Church is. Or what Christ instituted. Or what Christians do. Because these all amount to the same thing. You ask: What if someone intends to do what some particular and false church does, which he himself believes to be the true one - for example, the church of Geneva; and intends not to do what the Roman Church does? I answer, even that suffices. Because the man who intends to do what the church of Geneva does, intends to do what the universal Church does. For he intends to do what such-and-such a church does, because he believes it to be a member of the true Universal Church, granted that he is mistaken in recognising the True Church. For the error of the minister about the Church does not take away the efficacy of the Sacrament. Only defect of intention does that." Edited December 26, 2015 by chrysostom
MarysLittleFlower Posted December 26, 2015 Author Posted December 26, 2015 16 hours ago, chrysostom said: I think this calls for Fr Hunwicke: "Catholic teaching, since the anti-Donatist controversy, has been firmly on the side of believing that it is very difficult for a minister to invalidate a sacrament by his own sin or stupidity or schism or even heresy or total unbelief ... as long as he Does the Red and Says the Black with at least a habitual intention of Doing Stuff (and not, for example, of performing a didactic demonstration or a blasphemous parody). And all this is ultimately based upon a very simple truth: the Sacraments are not ours, but the Sacraments of the Lord Christ." And Fr Adrian Fortescue: "People who are not theologians never seem to understand how little intention is wanted for a sacrament (the point applies equally to minister and subject). The 'implicit intention of doing what Christ instituted' means so small and vague a thing that one can hardly help having it ... numbers of Catholics confused intention with faith. Faith is not wanted. It is heresy to say that it is (this was the error of St Cyprian and Firmalian against which Pope Stephen I, a.d. 254-7, protested). A man may have utterly wrong, heretical and blasphemous views about a sacrament, and yet confer it or receive it validly." And St. Robert Bellarmine: "There is no need to intend what the Roman Church does; but what the true Church does, whatever that True Church is. Or what Christ instituted. Or what Christians do. Because these all amount to the same thing. You ask: What if someone intends to do what some particular and false church does, which he himself believes to be the true one - for example, the church of Geneva; and intends not to do what the Roman Church does? I answer, even that suffices. Because the man who intends to do what the church of Geneva does, intends to do what the universal Church does. For he intends to do what such-and-such a church does, because he believes it to be a member of the true Universal Church, granted that he is mistaken in recognising the True Church. For the error of the minister about the Church does not take away the efficacy of the Sacrament. Only defect of intention does that." Do you think that the Anglicans lost the Sacrament because they no longer intended to do what the Church does, since they separated from it? That seems to be the reason I was told before .. They lost the priesthood too
chrysostom Posted December 27, 2015 Posted December 27, 2015 (edited) 1 hour ago, MarysLittleFlower said: Do you think that the Anglicans lost the Sacrament because they no longer intended to do what the Church does, since they separated from it? That seems to be the reason I was told before .. They lost the priesthood too I am by no means an authority on the matter of Anglican Orders (or the lack thereof), which can get a little complicated - just consult the Catholic Encyclopedia's article on the subject. Intention is discussed there a little bit, but the main issue spoken of was a defect of form, I believe. A proper intention - easy as it is for anyone to have one - will do no good without the proper matter and form. Edited December 27, 2015 by chrysostom
PhuturePriest Posted December 27, 2015 Posted December 27, 2015 I really think we need to define "to intend what the Catholic Church intends" even means. The Church intends to do many things -- save everyone, absolve people of their sins, give people peace, celebrate the Mass anywhere and everywhere, etc. Can you define for me what that phrase means? I think that will make this a lot more helpful. In the case of the Anglicans, I think what snagged them was their formal rejection of transubstantiation in favor of consubstantiation, and if I'm not mistaken they changed their Eucharistic prayer that made this clear. I'm not an expert, but I think a validly ordained Catholic priest could believe in consubstantiation and still validly consecrate the Host so long as he uses proper form.
MarysLittleFlower Posted December 27, 2015 Author Posted December 27, 2015 I found this... "The intrinsic reason for which Anglican Ordersare pronounced invalid by the Bull, is the "defect of form and intention". It sets forth that "the Sacraments of the New Law, as sensible and efficient signs of invisible grace, ought both to signify the grace which they effect, and effect the grace which they signify". Therite used in administering a sacrament must be directed to the meaning of that sacrament; else there would be no reason why the riteused in one sacrament may not effect another. What effects a sacrament is theintention of administering that sacrament, and the rite used according to that intention. TheBull takes note of the fact that in 1662 theform introduced in the Edwardine Ordinal of 1552 had added to it the words: "for the office and work of a priest", etc. But it observes that this rather shows that the Anglicansthemselves perceived that the first form was defective and inadequate. But even if this addition could give to the form its due signification, it was introduced too late, as a century had already elapsed since theadoption of the Edwardine Ordinal; and, moreover, as the hierarchy had become extinct, there remained no power of ordaining. http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/01644a.htm
CatherineM Posted December 27, 2015 Posted December 27, 2015 I think about a lot of things during mass, but watching for issues that might invalidate the mass, is absolutely not one of them. I find discussions about nit picking apart the sacraments on Phatmass on the same level as state park portable toilets during chilli contests. They are smelly and messy and we should avoid them at all costs. Why not focus your attention on what's right with the mass?
chrysostom Posted December 27, 2015 Posted December 27, 2015 7 hours ago, MarysLittleFlower said: I found this... http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/01644a.htm So the point with that statement simply seemed to be that the form of Anglican ordination at one point seemed to be defective. I don't see much value in continuing with that discussion. The form of Catholic ordination, of course, has never been in question, so don't worry about it. FP, I think the saint quotes on intention completely suffice. "Proper intention" need never be on any Catholic's list of worries. You can firmly trust that it will always there. The sacraments are Christ's, not ours. In the Church's motherly embrace we can put our full confidence. CM, right on. I guess I should just sign off on this thread now.
Lilllabettt Posted December 27, 2015 Posted December 27, 2015 10 hours ago, CatherineM said: I think about a lot of things during mass, but watching for issues that might invalidate the mass, is absolutely not one of them. I find discussions about nit picking apart the sacraments on Phatmass on the same level as state park portable toilets during chilli contests. They are smelly and messy and we should avoid them at all costs. Why not focus your attention on what's right with the mass? Well, good for you if you don't have to be watching for issues. That's one of the benefits of having a regular parish. I was traveling and attended Mass a couple months ago in a different place, and the priest there changed the words of consecration. I was in such shock I don't even know what he said. But it was definitely not "this is my Body" and "this is my Blood." He used synonyms for those words. Now, that is a crime. A crime perpetrated on the laity by an elitist cleric who has kept his flock blind and/or ignorant enough that he may continue violating them in this fashion unhindered by anyone "watching for issues." Not speaking about phatmass, but in general I think the last 15 years have taught us that the Church needs more lay people "watching for issues" not fewer.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now