Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

what invalidates a Mass


Recommended Posts

PhuturePriest
Posted
3 minutes ago, Lilllabettt said:

Well, good for you if you don't have to be watching for issues. That's one of the benefits of having a regular parish.

I was traveling and attended Mass a couple months ago in a different place, and the priest there changed the words of consecration. I was in such shock I don't even know what he said. But it was definitely not "this is my Body" and "this is my Blood." He used synonyms for those words.

Now, that is a crime. A crime perpetrated on the laity by an elitist cleric who has kept his flock blind and/or ignorant enough that he may continue violating them in this fashion unhindered by anyone "watching for issues." 

Not speaking about phatmass, but in general I think the last 15 years have taught us that the Church needs more lay people "watching for issues" not fewer.

That's certainly a major issue and probably invalidated the consecration. But I must ask, did you speak with the priest afterwards and share your concern? Did you contact the local bishop and tell him of this grave offense? I don't ask that to belittle or make you feel bad, but I've never met a person who actively watches for liturgical abuses who actually brings up these issues to the offending party or his superior, and this is my main issue with people who think themselves abuse watchers. 

Human nature is funny in that we automatically find issues, but for whatever reason actually bringing them up to the guilty party is not our automatic response. I say that having the same tendency myself.

There is certainly merit in sharing these things and letting people know they happen so that they can be aware it is a problem at this or that parish. But I do have a problem when people take one parish or diocese and extend it to every Novus Ordo parish or diocese in existence, which is what I've seen many trads do. "I saw a priest change the words of the consecration/perform a liturgical dance/say this heresy in his homily/etc.! It's the fault of the Novus Ordo as a whole!" 

Ignoring the fact that the Tridentine Mass has been notoriously abused throughout its existence (to the point that Saint Robert Bellarmine actually made it a practice to pose as a laymen at masses to watch for liturgical abuses and then go into the sacristy afterwards to point each one out to the offending priest, and there were liturgical abuses going on in it through Vatican II,) one liturgically abusive priest or diocese as a whole does not mean it's the fault of the Novus Ordo. This blanket statement syndrome among many trads boggles my mind.

For the record, I'm aware you're not one of these people. This is just a rant I've needed to get off my chest for a while and you provided the opportunity. :P

Posted
Just now, PhuturePriest said:

That's certainly a major issue and probably invalidated the consecration. But I must ask, did you speak with the priest afterwards and share your concern? Did you contact the local bishop and tell him of this grave offense? I don't ask that to belittle or make you feel bad, but I've never met a person who actively watches for liturgical abuses who actually brings up these issues to the offending party or his superior, and this is my main issue with people who think themselves abuse watchers. 

Human nature is funny in that we automatically find issues, but for whatever reason actually bringing them up to the guilty party is not our automatic response. I say that having the same tendency myself.

My friend did bring it up with the priest after Mass. Not in an accusatory tone, but as a question, "Hey Father, I noticed you changed the words. Why did you do that?" The answer was something like "it was in my heart" - something like that.  My friend thought it made more sense to tell him it was distracting and hindering to participation, rather than inform him of the Church's teaching on what invalidates a Mass, which he almost certainly knows and does not believe.

Human nature does not like being critical of other people to their face; it is even slower to criticize power/authority figures. Who am I to say anything to them? Or, my response: who am I, a traveler passing through and a stranger in this place, to say anything to them? Clerical elitists exploit this - and there is no shortage of them on the left or right.

MarysLittleFlower
Posted

Just to clarify, I made this thread not because I'm questioning the validity of the Mass or because I analyze the validity of Masses I attend. I made this thread to check that my understanding of Church teaching is correct or not, and to find out what the Church teaching is, since it was mentioned in another thread. 

PhuturePriest
Posted
48 minutes ago, Lilllabettt said:

My friend did bring it up with the priest after Mass. Not in an accusatory tone, but as a question, "Hey Father, I noticed you changed the words. Why did you do that?" The answer was something like "it was in my heart" - something like that.  My friend thought it made more sense to tell him it was distracting and hindering to participation, rather than inform him of the Church's teaching on what invalidates a Mass, which he almost certainly knows and does not believe.

Human nature does not like being critical of other people to their face; it is even slower to criticize power/authority figures. Who am I to say anything to them? Or, my response: who am I, a traveler passing through and a stranger in this place, to say anything to them? Clerical elitists exploit this - and there is no shortage of them on the left or right.

I've certainly experienced that. I absolutely hate confrontation. I'm bad at debates in real life, which is why I always make it clear it has to take on the tone of a discussion if I'm going to take part. It's greatly exacerbated if it's a religious figure like a priest.

Ash Wednesday
Posted
1 hour ago, MarysLittleFlower said:

Just to clarify, I made this thread not because I'm questioning the validity of the Mass or because I analyze the validity of Masses I attend. I made this thread to check that my understanding of Church teaching is correct or not, and to find out what the Church teaching is, since it was mentioned in another thread. 

Don't worry, I don't think anyone gets that impression. I posted my warnings because sometimes the Catholic vs. Catholic bickering comes up when people discuss the mass and there were some recent phorum rules violations going on with it, so I had to put my Meanie Mediator hat on.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...