Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

I know that the Church doesn't have an official stance on tattoos so I want to know your opinion. I've taken a look at the other threads on this subject but since none of them are recent I've decided to start my own. :) I have friends who love them and hate them. What do you think? Does the stigma on tattoos still stand? Do any of you have tattoos? What are they?

bardegaulois
Posted

My personal opinion is that tattoos are self-vandalism. They make beautiful people less beautiful and most have them just because others do. If you're not a sailor or a stripper, you have no business sporting a tattoo.

Posted

I have a tattoo of a lions mane that I got before i came back to the church. now it's Azlan and Jesus lol.

Posted

I like henna art (I was a bridesmaid at the wedding of a Pakistani friend and I loved the designs that we had on our hands and feet) but that's temporary and it lasts a couple of weeks at most. I wouldn't want a permanent tattoo. I don't think it's immoral, but I don't see the appeal of dying something into your skin that will be very painful and expensive to remove should you change your mind ten years down the line. I also don't think they look that nice. To each their own.

Nihil Obstat
Posted

I would say that a tattoo obtained frivolously is necessarily vain and/or imprudent. Probably not mortally sinful, perhaps venially sinful, but I would also speculate that culpability varies a great deal. Many tattoos invite scandal and irreverence, or worse. Such tattoos are mortally sinful. I think that a very small subset of tattoos for religious devotional purposes can be good, but it very much depends on the intentions of the person receiving it and on the particulars involved. For several years I have been considering back and forth the idea of a St. Benedict medal tattooed in a discreet location. I have not reached a conclusion yet. It is certainly not something to be done without a lot of thought.

HisChildForever
Posted

I think it can be done artistically and tastefully.

DominicanHeart
Posted

I don't see the point of it. I mean I've heard that there's something in it that makes you addicted to them and I've actually noticed it from people who get them. As soon as they have one, they start planning for more. And they aren't cheap. I mean, what do you  do when you're 70 or 80 years old in the nursing home with a bunch of tattoos?

Posted

Hate them. I've been around too many aged veterans and see what they look like after 4 or 5 decades and it isn't pretty. I spend up to ten hours a week at the swimming pool, and there are more ugly ones than artistic ones. 

Posted

anything that can not be removed from your skin with soap and water can't be good, in my opinion

Posted

I was playing poker with a guy 4 or 5 years back who had the last supper tattooed on his arm. One of the best tattoo's I ever seen. Whoever did it done it perfectly. Wish I would have snapped a picture.

dominicansoul
Posted

i'd love a tattoo of Bl. Fra Angelico's "The Mocking of Christ" (but only the St. Dominic part of that painting.)  I've wanted that for years and seeing this year is the 800th anniversary of the OP's i'd love to get it this year.  Only problem is there are no tattoo artists in my area who would give that painting justice.  so i might just see about getting it in a realistic temporary version and see if i really like having one.   I'd do it in St Dom's honor, so i hope that's not sinful.  

NadaTeTurbe
Posted

I have one. It's not visible for other people than me, and I've got it because it has special meanings for me and my family history. 

I really thought about getting one of the Lourde grotto, with Bernadette and Our Lady. I feel like I'll never lose my faith if I have Our Lady on me :P More seriously, I've got two things "against" it : it's very expensive, and very

So, of course, I'm not against tattoos. I'm more perplexed by tattoos done for beauty (even if some of them are really pretty !), or who are on visible body parts such as the arms. 

DominicanHeart
Posted

I also want to mention I don't know how many weddings my grandmother has played for where the bridesmaids and even the bride come in strapless dresses with tattoos all over their backs in Church. And their like skulls and stuff. It would be one thing if it was something Religious but most people don't do that. 

Nihil Obstat
Posted
5 minutes ago, DominicanHeart said:

I also want to mention I don't know how many weddings my grandmother has played for where the bridesmaids and even the bride come in strapless dresses with tattoos all over their backs in Church. And their like skulls and stuff. It would be one thing if it was something Religious but most people don't do that. 

My priest actually will not marry a couple if the bride's dress exposes her shoulders. :| 

Posted
5 minutes ago, Nihil Obstat said:

My priest actually will not marry a couple if the bride's dress exposes her shoulders. :| 

Well that's too bad, people are entitled within canonical limits to the sacraments and strapless wedding dresses really don't cause scandal anymore (says the girl who wore long sleeves) 

I've seen really beautiful tattoos. But I don't get it, they're very expensive and can make things like detecting cancer much more difficult depending on size and color. It doesn't seem worth it. 

Sponsa-Christi
Posted

In general, I personally don't like the look of tattoos, but I don't think the Church would ever say they're immoral in and of themselves.

I also think that tasteful religious tattoos are in a different sort of category. For example, there is a custom among Coptic Christians in Muslim to have a small cross tattooed on their wrist. The idea there is that marking themselves with a cross, they are professing their faith in a permanent way---i.e., they couldn't deny their faith even if they were pressured to do so by force or threat of violence. 

DominicanHeart
Posted
1 hour ago, Nihil Obstat said:

My priest actually will not marry a couple if the bride's dress exposes her shoulders. :| 

We had Priests like that before. I'm actually surprised my Pastor hasn't gotten to that point yet. But we don't have that many weddings anyway. And when we do, he stands at the bottom of the steps now during the vows because he was tired of the brides with low cut dresses.

Nihil Obstat
Posted
1 hour ago, Maggyie said:

Well that's too bad, people are entitled within canonical limits to the sacraments and strapless wedding dresses really don't cause scandal anymore (says the girl who wore long sleeves) 

In his capacity as the priest tasked with preparing a couple for holy matrimony, he considers it important for the couple's spiritual well-being that they observe a high standard of modesty. He is well within his rights.

Posted

I have a pretty large tattoo on my right forearm and it shows pretty much all the time cuz it extends down to my wrist. I agree with a lot of the negative things that have been said about tattoos: They're expensive (and more importantly, an unnecessary expense). They can be extremely ugly and they are always extremely ugly in old age. They should be considered for a very long time before getting them, etc.

I had heard that they're addictive, but I think that depends more on the personality of the person and their intentions for getting them.

If I had it to do over again, I would not get the tattoo that I have, but not because of its content. (It's a tree of life, of sorts.) I would not get it simply because the artist did a crappy job. I was young and impatient and so took the first guy who'd tattoo me at 17. Mea culpa.

I do have ideas for other tattoos that I would like to get (of a religious nature), but I don't think I'd ever get another one at this point. It's just a waste of money to me now.

One thing I can say is great about my tattoo: I am openly religious, and a lot of people make negative judgments about me when they discover that (which is usually very soon after meeting me). When they see I have a tattoo, they assume I'm "not one of those judgmental religious people". Which is not true in many cases, and is kind of asinine to assume, frankly, but it does help me to connect with people who would otherwise shut me out because I'm religious. I do not, of course, judge people with tattoos, or piercings, or purple hair or what have you. I had all of those things at one point. (I still have them all but the purple hair.) I'm happy that my appearance—in some ways—makes me relatable to people who would otherwise shun all religious individuals.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...