Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

IgnatiusofLoyola
Posted (edited)
3 hours ago, Nihil Obstat said:

My priest actually will not marry a couple if the bride's dress exposes her shoulders. :| 

At the time I got married (post Vatican II but before most Phatmassers were born) if I memory serves, this was the rule for the entire Archdiocese of Los Angeles (where I was married). (Not that I wanted a strapless dress in any case.) Personally, I think that it is fine if a bride wants a strapless dress, but for the Mass she can wear a simple "bolero" style jacket to cover her upper arms. But don't get me started about the appropriateness of very low-cut or backless bridal gowns in church. Then, if she wants, the bride can take off the jacket for the reception afterwards.

 

Edited by IgnatiusofLoyola
Nihil Obstat
Posted
21 minutes ago, IgnatiusofLoyola said:

At the time I got married (post Vatican II but before most Phatmassers were born) if I memory serves, this was the rule for the entire Archdiocese of Los Angeles (where I was married). (Not that I wanted a strapless dress in any case.) Personally, I think that it is fine if a bride wants a strapless dress, but for the Mass she can wear a simple "bolero" style jacket to cover her upper arms. But don't get me started about the appropriateness of very low-cut or backless bridal gowns in church. Then, if she wants, the bride can take off the jacket for the reception afterwards.

 

Yes, my wife wore that sort of jacket. To me that is equivalent to a dress which covers the shoulders on its own; the jacket is basically the same garment as far as I am concerned.

A good friend of mine actually purchased a strapless dress and had a seamstress add shoulders and a higher neckline. Frankly, not that it is relevant, I think the dress looked better like that anyway.

Posted
2 hours ago, Nihil Obstat said:

Yes, my wife wore that sort of jacket. To me that is equivalent to a dress which covers the shoulders on its own; the jacket is basically the same garment as far as I am concerned.

A good friend of mine actually purchased a strapless dress and had a seamstress add shoulders and a higher neckline. Frankly, not that it is relevant, I think the dress looked better like that anyway.

That's what I did - bought strapless and had a dressmaker fix it. At that time there was just about 1 dress with sleeves available on the market. I've noticed that since the wedding of Kate and William there are a lot more options with sleeves. 

Nihil Obstat
Posted
29 minutes ago, Maggyie said:

That's what I did - bought strapless and had a dressmaker fix it. At that time there was just about 1 dress with sleeves available on the market. I've noticed that since the wedding of Kate and William there are a lot more options with sleeves. 

Americans be jelly because they left the Commonwealth.

Posted (edited)

I wouldn't and I would also discourage others. I don't understand why anyone would have a big flashy tattoo, especially if they were a Christian. Marking the body is frowned upon in the Bible, although for slightly different reasons, but the criticisms aren't that difficult to apply to current trends.

It seems akin to spraying a church with graffiti, although at least that is easier to get off. Our bodies should be a place for the indwelling of the holy spirit and shouldn't be marked with icons and, in some respects, fairly awful images.

That being said I wouldn't make a big deal out of it in RL with people who already have them as people make mistakes, change their lives around etc and shouldn't feel shamed for things that are long forgiven. The penance surely is having to live with them unless they can get them removed, probably at great expense and pain.

Edited by Benedictus
Posted

might as well get "property of Satan" tattooed on youj if you're going to get any ink.

Not A Real Name
Posted

I dont know of any tattoos I would want. Plus we've come to a point where not having a tattoo makes you one of the rebels, so I got that going for me.;)

Posted

3f544db913e71de536bb795751c704cb.jpg

 

Ta moko is part of maori culture. Its their business what they do with their body. Not my place to judge. 

Posted

Thanks for your replies guys! I used to hate tattoos and never understood why people got them. As I got older, I started meeting people who had them and they told me their reasoning behind getting them. While I still don't completely like tattoos, I can see why some people get them. Now I probably will never get one but every now and then I wonder what I would get if I ever did. I definitely would not mind getting a religious tattoo but haven't found one I like yet. Maybe a Sacred Heart, Divine Mercy, or Marian symbol of some sort. It would be in a discrete place of course since my mom would probably have a heart attack or worse if she ever saw it. Besides she made it very clear that if she saw me with a tattoo on my wedding day it would ruin the entire day for her. She would not be a happy camper. Thankfully I love dresses with sleeves anyway. :)

Posted
On 4/2/2016, 7:28:29, beatitude said:

I like henna art (I was a bridesmaid at the wedding of a Pakistani friend and I loved the designs that we had on our hands and feet) but that's temporary and it lasts a couple of weeks at most. I wouldn't want a permanent tattoo. I don't think it's immoral, but I don't see the appeal of dying something into your skin that will be very painful and expensive to remove should you change your mind ten years down the line. I also don't think they look that nice. To each their own.

I've had a henna tattoo before and they are pretty cool! It would probably be a good way of test running the design you want before you actually get it done by a tattoo artist.

Some friends and I are going to a festival in a couple of weeks where there will be a person doing henna tattoos and I really hope I can get something like this done. If I were to ever get a frivolous tattoo done, this would be along the lines of something I would get. I absolutely love bows! Thankfully the henna is not permanent.

51a578afe2a235c2a05c5bd24c69bc19.jpg

PhuturePriest
Posted (edited)

From an aesthetic point of view, I think tattoos are really ugly. Any person's beauty is diminished by them, in my opinion. But diminishing beauty =/= sin, it just means I don't find it attractive, and I would prefer it if my hypothetical wife did not have one.

If I were to ever get a tattoo, it would be a sort of Catholic branding on my left arm. For those who don't know (meaning they've never even seen Gladiator, which means they should stop reading this and immediately watch Gladiator), Roman legionaries would get SPQR tattooed on their upper left arm as a type of brand, showing they belonged to the Empire. So I might entertain something like a simple "nun" (letter for 'Nazarene'), but nothing else.

Edited by PhuturePriest
Nihil Obstat
Posted

I do quite like the Coptic custom of a small Coptic cross on the right(?) wrist. Obviously there is a lot more behind that than simply as a fashion statement.

Coptic-Cross-Tattoos.jpg

Posted
On 4/3/2016, 1:24:22, Sponsa-Christi said:

In general, I personally don't like the look of tattoos, but I don't think the Church would ever say they're immoral in and of themselves.

I also think that tasteful religious tattoos are in a different sort of category. For example, there is a custom among Coptic Christians in Muslim to have a small cross tattooed on their wrist. The idea there is that marking themselves with a cross, they are professing their faith in a permanent way---i.e., they couldn't deny their faith even if they were pressured to do so by force or threat of violence. 

10 minutes ago, Nihil Obstat said:

I do quite like the Coptic custom of a small Coptic cross on the right(?) wrist. Obviously there is a lot more behind that than simply as a fashion statement.

Coptic-Cross-Tattoos.jpg

16 minutes ago, PhuturePriest said:

From an aesthetic point of view, I think tattoos are really ugly. Any person's beauty is diminished by them, in my opinion. But diminishing beauty =/= sin, it just means I don't find it attractive, and I would prefer it if my hypothetical wife did not have one.

If I were to ever get a tattoo, it would be a sort of Catholic branding on my left arm. For those who don't know (meaning they've never even seen Gladiator, which means they should stop reading this and immediately watch Gladiator), Roman legionaries would get SPQR tattooed on their upper left arm as a type of brand, showing they belonged to the Empire. So I might entertain something like a simple "nun" (letter for 'Nazarene'), but nothing else.

I do like these ideas! With Christianity under attack nowadays, it's time to make a stance for what you believe in.

 

Not A Real Name
Posted
1 hour ago, Nihil Obstat said:

I do quite like the Coptic custom of a small Coptic cross on the right(?) wrist. Obviously there is a lot more behind that than simply as a fashion statement.

Coptic-Cross-Tattoos.jpg

I like tattoos like these and your idea of a St. Benedict medal. I love rosary tattoos and I feel if something happened where I was without one, then I could use my tattoo as a reference. 

PhuturePriest
Posted
1 hour ago, Nihil Obstat said:

I do quite like the Coptic custom of a small Coptic cross on the right(?) wrist. Obviously there is a lot more behind that than simply as a fashion statement.

Coptic-Cross-Tattoos.jpg

I was thinking of them specifically, actually. The Coptic cross really is quite beautiful, and this is a very amazing way to "brand" yourself in a way which is minimalistic and doesn't cover up natural beauty.

Posted

They are very beautiful. Sometimes simplicity all that is needed. My cousin has a small cross tattoo on her wrist and she says it has definitely helped her witness to what Christ has done in her life. I like this one a lot.

6617d86110079e70353620154d4a5c3f.jpg

truthfinder
Posted
4 hours ago, Nihil Obstat said:

I do quite like the Coptic custom of a small Coptic cross on the right(?) wrist. Obviously there is a lot more behind that than simply as a fashion statement.

Coptic-Cross-Tattoos.jpg

I've actually seen a few (older) women here who have this tattooed on their foreheads. I'm not sure which church they belong to but I would assume it's Coptic.

There's been some work done on medieval pilgrims getting tattoos much like they'd also pick up pilgrim badges/symbols.

But broadly speaking, seeing people with tattoos tends to make me think of them just a little differently. I grew up with the only people having tattoos were bikers and truck drivers - anyone who gets sleeve tattoos that aren't in these groups or similar just is wrong to me. 

Posted

Only gang signs and ex-girlfriends are permissible. Roses, Chinese characters, and Looney Tunes are strictly forbidden by the Church.

Posted
3 hours ago, truthfinder said:

I've actually seen a few (older) women here who have this tattooed on their foreheads. I'm not sure which church they belong to but I would assume it's Coptic.

There's been some work done on medieval pilgrims getting tattoos much like they'd also pick up pilgrim badges/symbols.

But broadly speaking, seeing people with tattoos tends to make me think of them just a little differently. I grew up with the only people having tattoos were bikers and truck drivers - anyone who gets sleeve tattoos that aren't in these groups or similar just is wrong to me. 

In Israel, there are a TON of Ethiopian Christians with those crosses tattooed on their foreheads. It looks quite nice, I think.

truthfinder
Posted
8 minutes ago, Gabriela said:

In Israel, there are a TON of Ethiopian Christians with those crosses tattooed on their foreheads. It looks quite nice, I think.

In this godless society, it's certainly a witness of faith. But I also think the practice is rooted in a particular culture, and it would be weird for others to start doing this. They always make me smile when I see them. 

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...