DameAgnes Posted May 18, 2016 Posted May 18, 2016 http://aleteia.org/2016/05/18/latin-makes-a-comeback/
Era Might Posted May 18, 2016 Posted May 18, 2016 (edited) I'm an etymology nerd so I frequently look up the roots of words to understand the history of ideas. E.g., yesterday I was reading something about Homer's Iliad which was discussing fate and character (Heraclitus said that character is fate), so I looked up fate and was happy to learn it also had a connection with the word fame...a person's fame, or character, is in a sense their fate, what they are doomed to be, which is why the Greeks (and others) valued honor and reputation so highly, and why they justified a 10 year war to defend the honor of Menelaus after the seduction of his wife Helen. fate (n.) late 14c., "one's lot or destiny; predetermined course of life;" also "one's guiding spirit," from Old Frenchfatefata (source also of Spanish hado, Portuguese fado, Italian fato), neuter plural of fatum "prophetic declaration of what must be, oracle, prediction," thus the Latin word's usual sense, "that which is ordained, destiny, fate," literally "thing spoken (by the gods)," from neuter past participle of fari "to speak," from PIE *bha- (2) "speak" (seefame (n.)). From early 15c. as "power that rules destinies, agency which predetermines events; supernatural predetermination;" also "destiny personified." Meaning "that which must be" is from 1660s; sense of "final event" is from 1768. The Latin sense evolution is from "sentence of the Gods" (Greek theosphaton) to "lot, portion" (Greek moira, personified as a goddess in Homer). The sense "one of the three goddesses (Clotho, Lachesis, and Atropos) who determined the course of a human life" is in English by 1580s. Often in a bad sense in Latin: "bad luck, ill fortune; mishap, ruin; a pest or plague." The native word in English was wyrd (see weird). Edited May 18, 2016 by Era Might
enitharmon Posted May 18, 2016 Posted May 18, 2016 1 hour ago, Era Might said: so I looked up fate and was happy to learn it also had a connection with the word fame...a person's fame, or character, is in a sense their fate, what they are doomed to be While I like your reasoning, the etymology of both words does not really suggest that. Both words are ultimately derived from the Proto Indo-European root *bha, "to speak" (Latin fari) because fate is "that which is spoken (by the gods)" and the English word fame is derived from Old French fame "fame, reputation, renown, rumor" (12c.), from Latin fama "talk, rumor, report" (to cite the etymological dictionary you referenced), i.e. what is spoken of you by the people. The former (fate) implies something that is fixed, because spoken by the gods before you act (or before the acts take fruition), the latter (fame) is what people tell of you after you have acted.
Era Might Posted May 18, 2016 Posted May 18, 2016 (edited) 15 minutes ago, enitharmon said: While I like your reasoning, the etymology of both words does not really suggest that. Both words are ultimately derived from the Proto Indo-European root *bha, "to speak" (Latin fari) because fate is "that which is spoken (by the gods)" and the English word fame is derived from Old French fame "fame, reputation, renown, rumor" (12c.), from Latin fama "talk, rumor, report" (to cite the etymological dictionary you referenced), i.e. what is spoken of you by the people. The former (fate) implies something that is fixed, because spoken by the gods before you act (or before the acts take fruition), the latter (fame) is what people tell of you after you have acted. I don't know that the words are so fixed as that. I'd say fame is not merely a judgement after the fact, but also a sentence that creates a situation in the present. Once you have a rep, or fame, that's who you have to be, it becomes part of your character. With a tragic hero like Achilles, for example, his fate was not merely a sentence from the gods, his fate was his fame as a hero, because a hero must live up to his fame. A contrast would be Jesus, who shunned fame lest he become what the people wanted him to be, rather than what the Father wanted him to be. Edited May 18, 2016 by Era Might
Era Might Posted May 18, 2016 Posted May 18, 2016 Another way to put it is that fate is the sentence of the gods, while fame is the sentence of men...but I think part of the complication explored by Homer and others is that it's hard to tell the difference between gods and men...literally, the gods appeared as men and acted through men.
PhuturePriest Posted May 18, 2016 Posted May 18, 2016 I read an article a while back by a secular British journal saying the Latin Mass community is growing and thriving. It mentioned that the men in particular tend to wear tweed suits, and after looking up their prices, I determined Tridentine Massers are either rich, or they are old men reincarnated and thus know how to hand-craft tweed suits.
truthfinder Posted May 18, 2016 Posted May 18, 2016 49 minutes ago, PhuturePriest said: I read an article a while back by a secular British journal saying the Latin Mass community is growing and thriving. It mentioned that the men in particular tend to wear tweed suits, and after looking up their prices, I determined Tridentine Massers are either rich, or they are old men reincarnated and thus know how to hand-craft tweed suits. I have the feeling they probably frequent the second-hand shops.
Maximilianus Posted May 18, 2016 Posted May 18, 2016 Don't call it a comeback, it's been here for years.
Luigi Posted May 19, 2016 Posted May 19, 2016 I hear that Latin's making a comeback even in pop music! http://www.mentalfloss.com/article/77479/learn-sing-adeles-hello-latin Who's next, Justin Bieber?
PhuturePriest Posted May 19, 2016 Posted May 19, 2016 21 hours ago, truthfinder said: I have the feeling they probably frequent the second-hand shops. Impossible. My dichotomy clearly illustrates there are only two possible answers.
PhuturePriest Posted May 19, 2016 Posted May 19, 2016 2 hours ago, PhuturePriest said: Impossible. My dichotomy clearly illustrates there are only two possible answers. This was my 16,500th post. I feel proud.
Anomaly Posted May 19, 2016 Posted May 19, 2016 2 hours ago, PhuturePriest said: Impossible. My dichotomy clearly illustrates there are only two possible answers. Excelentyay ointpay!
Luigi Posted May 19, 2016 Posted May 19, 2016 35 minutes ago, PhuturePriest said: This was my 16,500th post. I feel proud. And of that 16,500, something like FOUR have been worthwhile. But keep posting. Next up - 17,000, of which perhaps FIVE will have been worthwhile.
BarbTherese Posted May 20, 2016 Posted May 20, 2016 I love the Mass in English, but would love to have some Latin in with the English too.
CountrySteve937 Posted May 20, 2016 Posted May 20, 2016 12 hours ago, BarbaraTherese said: I love the Mass in English, but would love to have some Latin in with the English too. Like this https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OkxvFeQNbvA&list=PLC32FB20B381F1727&index=57
BarbTherese Posted May 20, 2016 Posted May 20, 2016 Thank you for the post, CS - probably not as much Latin as in the video for my preference, although I do not have time to watch the whole video but will when I return from interstate. I think it is vitally important that all can understand the prayers of The Mass (especially of course newcomers to our Mass) hence the vernacular. It is different if one is a product of pre V2 where one could understand much of the Latin and had a Missal with Latin and alongside a translation into English. I'd like say The Sanctus, Agnus Dei, Gloria sung in Latin, plus a very few other short prayers......with prayer sheets available with the Latin and alongside the English translation. I used to love The Credo sung in Latin too with Father intoning the first few words: "Credo in Unum Deium"........just something about it for me. But The Mass is always The Mass in any language whatsoever.
PhuturePriest Posted May 20, 2016 Posted May 20, 2016 (edited) I've always wondered why people advocate so vociferously for reciting the Creed in Latin in the Ordinary Form. What's the point of professing belief in something if you don't understand what you are professing belief in? The Liturgy is the source and summit of our faith and deserves our very best, which certainly includes the official language of the Church, but at some point there has to be a practical reality to it. Professing belief in a plethora of integral nuanced doctrines is far different than praying the Pater Noster or Agnus Dei -- one is a profession of ideological adherence to core doctrines, which requires at least some mental understanding ("some" taking into account age and that we cannot ever fully comprehend the infinite), and the others are prayers said to glorify God that do not necessarily require understanding, as so long they are said with love they still please God. Certainly this distinction can be appreciated by liturgical enthusiasts? Edited May 20, 2016 by PhuturePriest
Gabriela Posted May 21, 2016 Posted May 21, 2016 6 hours ago, PhuturePriest said: I've always wondered why people advocate so vociferously for reciting the Creed in Latin in the Ordinary Form. What's the point of professing belief in something if you don't understand what you are professing belief in? The Liturgy is the source and summit of our faith and deserves our very best, which certainly includes the official language of the Church, but at some point there has to be a practical reality to it. Professing belief in a plethora of integral nuanced doctrines is far different than praying the Pater Noster or Agnus Dei -- one is a profession of ideological adherence to core doctrines, which requires at least some mental understanding ("some" taking into account age and that we cannot ever fully comprehend the infinite), and the others are prayers said to glorify God that do not necessarily require understanding, as so long they are said with love they still please God. Certainly this distinction can be appreciated by liturgical enthusiasts? I appreciate this, but think we could also always just teach people Latin. Or not. 'Murica?
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now