Era Might Posted May 28, 2016 Posted May 28, 2016 (edited) I've never seen this addressed. You go to a Catholic church and find pretty colors, nice-smelling incense, chant, etc....but when it comes to the host it tastes like cardboard. Isn't this an aesthetic failure...maybe the restoration of the chalice to the laity has at least moved in a better direction. How can you taste and see that the Lord is good when he tastes like cardboard and is mass manufactured in wafers. There's something to say for real-tasting and looking bread, no? Edited May 28, 2016 by Era Might
AveMariaPurissima Posted May 28, 2016 Posted May 28, 2016 This past year I was a teacher's aide for 2nd grade catechism. One of the things we did with the kids in class to help prepare them for their 1st Communions was to have them practice receiving Communion on the tongue (as is customary in our parish) using unconsecrated hosts. The kids had some interesting reactions...my favorite was one child's description, "First it's like cardboard, then it's like paper, then it's like tissue, then you swallow it."
Era Might Posted May 29, 2016 Author Posted May 29, 2016 25 minutes ago, AveMariaPurissima said: This past year I was a teacher's aide for 2nd grade catechism. One of the things we did with the kids in class to help prepare them for their 1st Communions was to have them practice receiving Communion on the tongue (as is customary in our parish) using unconsecrated hosts. The kids had some interesting reactions...my favorite was one child's description, "First it's like cardboard, then it's like paper, then it's like tissue, then you swallow it." Lol. I believe the Orthodox don't use hosts, still real bread.
DominicanHeart Posted May 29, 2016 Posted May 29, 2016 2 hours ago, AveMariaPurissima said: This past year I was a teacher's aide for 2nd grade catechism. One of the things we did with the kids in class to help prepare them for their 1st Communions was to have them practice receiving Communion on the tongue (as is customary in our parish) using unconsecrated hosts. The kids had some interesting reactions...my favorite was one child's description, "First it's like cardboard, then it's like paper, then it's like tissue, then you swallow it." I remember my reactions when I made my First Holy Communion. I had no idea what it would be like until the day of
Anomaly Posted May 29, 2016 Posted May 29, 2016 (edited) I've eaten lots of unconcencrated hosts as an acolyte in the 60's and 70's. We ate the broken, chipped, and blemished wafers. It's unleavened bread. There isn't much choice of flavors which was the point. The Jews were in a rush and didn't have a lot for the Exodus. I don't think they had "real bread" either. I would think also, they use as few ingredients as possible to avoid allergic reactions or strong flavors. They do make them in white wheat and whole wheat which has flavor. Edited May 29, 2016 by Anomaly
Anomaly Posted May 29, 2016 Posted May 29, 2016 Though I'm sure some were saying: All this manna, dropping a little lox and a schmear would be so difficult?
Not A Real Name Posted May 29, 2016 Posted May 29, 2016 You welcome cardboard after you've practiced with necco wafers.
IgnatiusofLoyola Posted May 29, 2016 Posted May 29, 2016 (edited) The Jewish people have celebrated Passover by eating unleavened bread for thousands of years. As I understand it, the Last Supper was a Passover meal, so they, too, ate unleavened bread. Nowadays the unleavened bread eaten at Passover (but available all year) is called matzo bread, and I'd classify it as an acquired taste. I happen to like it, because all my life I have ended up in neighborhoods with a lot of Jewish people, so I've been eating it since I was a child. But it IS bland. Note: I don't know if the matzo of today is the same as the unleavened bread in Jesus' time, but I expect the unleavened bread of Jesus' time was also bland, on purpose, to remember the hardships and sacrifices the Jewish people made in the Exodus. Jewish culture, at least what I know of it, celebrates the goodness of God, while never forgetting bitter times such as the Exodus and the destruction of the Temple. The Psalms are a perfect example of this. They alternate and combine praise of God with heartfelt pleas for mercy and forgiveness, and remembrance of the the times of the Exile and sadness. So, in the Eucharist, there is simultaneously the blandness of the bread (remembering the Exodus and the Last Supper), and the joy of being given the gift to partake of the body of Christ. Similarly, wine is a celebration of the richness of the Earth, yet simultaneously the Blood of Christ. and his sacrifices for us. Note: What I've just written is not taken from anything I've ever read, just thoughts that came to me. So take it for what it is worth, and ignore it if it is not helpful or is incorrect theologically or historically. Edited May 29, 2016 by IgnatiusofLoyola
truthfinder Posted May 29, 2016 Posted May 29, 2016 Because of this thread, I actually made note today. I wouldn't classify the host as cardboard - if it is, the hosts may actually be stale and father should really get around to replacing them. Also, you'll get the thinner almost melt on your tongue hosts or thicker made with whole wheat ones - these have very different tastes.
PhuturePriest Posted May 29, 2016 Posted May 29, 2016 I honestly really love the taste of wafers. Then again, I love bread in general, and I particularly like plain tastes (For example, my favorite vegetable is cucumber.)
DominicanHeart Posted May 30, 2016 Posted May 30, 2016 We have a number of people in my Parish who have a gluten allergy and we have gluten free hosts for them. I wonder if they taste any different
Nihil Obstat Posted May 30, 2016 Posted May 30, 2016 33 minutes ago, DominicanHeart said: We have a number of people in my Parish who have a gluten allergy and we have gluten free hosts for them. I wonder if they taste any different Gluten free hosts are invalid matter, but they may be very low gluten.
PhuturePriest Posted May 30, 2016 Posted May 30, 2016 15 hours ago, Nihil Obstat said: Gluten free hosts are invalid matter, but they may be very low gluten. I heard a Dominican priest say once that the gluten free host thing is making a mountain out of a molehill anyway, since such people who can't eat gluten could simply drink from the chalice and avoid the problem altogether.
Nihil Obstat Posted May 30, 2016 Posted May 30, 2016 1 hour ago, PhuturePriest said: I heard a Dominican priest say once that the gluten free host thing is making a mountain out of a molehill anyway, since such people who can't eat gluten could simply drink from the chalice and avoid the problem altogether. I have heard that for some people with extremely severe celiac's disease, even the tiny bit of gluten from the commingling is too much. I have not been able to properly verify that though.
NadaTeTurbe Posted May 30, 2016 Posted May 30, 2016 32 minutes ago, Nihil Obstat said: I have heard that for some people with extremely severe celiac's disease, even the tiny bit of gluten from the commingling is too much. I have not been able to properly verify that though. Knew someone with a very severe celiac's disease : once she finished her father's meat, and there was a tiny breadcrumb on it - she was sick for hours, could barely speak and walk. But as said PP, I don't see the problem : if you can't take the Body of our Lord, dring His Blood.
Seven77 Posted May 30, 2016 Posted May 30, 2016 Even on the physical, accidental level the Eucharist is a mystery that must be taken on faith. If the Lord is good, and we are to “taste and see that the Lord is good” then why do the hosts taste neither good or bad? Good question… I think I've asked myself this before. it seems to me that the answer is: In order to elicit a greater act of faith. “How is it that God would make himself so small and vulnerable and risk subjecting himself to the cold indifference of those of us who so often receive him so carelessly?" “Why would he come to reveal God to us and yet allow for the possibility for people not to recognize him at the same time?"
PhuturePriest Posted May 31, 2016 Posted May 31, 2016 4 hours ago, Nihil Obstat said: I have heard that for some people with extremely severe celiac's disease, even the tiny bit of gluten from the commingling is too much. I have not been able to properly verify that though. Commingling?
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now