Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted
4 hours ago, NadaTeTurbe said:

Knew someone with a very severe celiac's disease : once she finished her father's meat, and there was a tiny breadcrumb on it - she was sick for hours, could barely speak and walk. But as said PP, I don't see the problem : if you can't take the Body of our Lord, dring His Blood. 

A tiny fragment of the host is always dropped into the chalice after the consecration. For someone as severely affected as your friend, it sounds as though this would be enough to make her sick. I'd be interested to know what the solution is for this.

Nihil Obstat
Posted
25 minutes ago, beatitude said:

A tiny fragment of the host is always dropped into the chalice after the consecration. For someone as severely affected as your friend, it sounds as though this would be enough to make her sick. I'd be interested to know what the solution is for this.

Frankly I am not sure there is a real solution. At least, there does not seem to be a way around it. I would think perhaps ask the priest to celebrate a private Mass, using only a very low-gluten host, then receive the consecrated wine only, which would minimize exposure (Such an arrangement would probably have to be made privately.) But I see no way to exclude all exposure to gluten.

CatherineM
Posted

The bit is usually only dropped in the priest's chalice. Go to one of the EM's and it might not be an issue. 

Nihil Obstat
Posted
58 minutes ago, CatherineM said:

The bit is usually only dropped in the priest's chalice. Go to one of the EM's and it might not be an issue. 

Lol, I forgot y'all use more than one chalice.

PhuturePriest
Posted
27 minutes ago, Nihil Obstat said:

Lol, I forgot y'all use more than one chalice.

EF Masses typically never use the chalice for parishioners, right?

Nihil Obstat
Posted
16 minutes ago, PhuturePriest said:

EF Masses typically never use the chalice for parishioners, right?

Not just not typically. Never.

Only time I receive from the chalice is st Ordinariate Masses, and then only because there is not a non obtrusive way not to do so. :P 

They hold the chalice for you while you kneel at the rail, so no need even to touch it.

Posted
On 5/28/2016 at 1:50 PM, Era Might said:

I've never seen this addressed. You go to a Catholic church and find pretty colors, nice-smelling incense, chant, etc....but when it comes to the host it tastes like cardboard. Isn't this an aesthetic failure...maybe the restoration of the chalice to the laity has at least moved in a better direction. How can you taste and see that the Lord is good when he tastes like cardboard and is mass manufactured in wafers. There's something to say for real-tasting and looking bread, no?

the Roman rite uses unleavened bread yes but there are other valid rites in the Catholic Church that use leavened bread.

Posted
1 hour ago, vee said:

the Roman rite uses unleavened bread yes but there are other valid rites in the Catholic Church that use leavened bread.

The Eastern rites don't do this because of aesthetic reasons, but because they don't find it necessary to preserve the literal Passover symbolism, and they have symbolism of their own - the idea of Christ as the leaven in our lives. I belonged to an Eastern rite parish when I lived in Palestine, where we would receive the Body intincted in the Blood, and to be honest I didn't really notice the difference in the bread after the first few weeks there. At first I was worried about crumbs dropping on the floor (the host in the Latin rite is made the way it is partly to reduce the likelihood of crumbs) but that fear passed when I got used to receiving in this way. I don't think either way is 'better' - while the host may not be tasty as such, the symbolism in the unleavened bread is still rich, and something can be beautiful without suiting all our tastes.

Posted

co-mingle.  It's really spelled with 2 M's.  Growing up, I remember the hosts were shiny white.  I guess with all of the allergies that didn't seem to be present when I was younger, caused things to change.  One church that I visited in NY seemed to have hosts that were sweetened.  Folks would probably complain about calories............ *sigh*

Posted
10 hours ago, beatitude said:

The Eastern rites don't do this because of aesthetic reasons, but because they don't find it necessary to preserve the literal Passover symbolism, and they have symbolism of their own - the idea of Christ as the leaven in our lives. I belonged to an Eastern rite parish when I lived in Palestine, where we would receive the Body intincted in the Blood, and to be honest I didn't really notice the difference in the bread after the first few weeks there. At first I was worried about crumbs dropping on the floor (the host in the Latin rite is made the way it is partly to reduce the likelihood of crumbs) but that fear passed when I got used to receiving in this way. I don't think either way is 'better' - while the host may not be tasty as such, the symbolism in the unleavened bread is still rich, and something can be beautiful without suiting all our tastes.

Interesting.  In the rite Im familiar with that uses leavened bread they also have it intincted.  It is in small cubes in teh chalice of Precious Blood and the priest has a teeny tiny little spoon made out of precious metal that he uses to remove one cube of the Eucharist and drops it in the communicant's mouth.  He is standing on a step so he is taller than most people and the communicant tilts their head back, opens their mouth, and basically receives like a little bird :)

PhuturePriest
Posted (edited)

Blech, intinction. I used to think it was cool until I received by intinction for half a year. I quickly learned the blood drips and very often somehow gets on your cheek while the priest is distributing it, and you have to awkwardly lick it off with your tongue. Far easier to receive just the Host or the Host and then receive the chalice, in my opinion.

Edited by PhuturePriest
Posted

If Jesus humiliated himself to the point of becoming a piece of bread, it's not surprising that His humility is so great that the bread is also bland.

AveMariaPurissima
Posted
7 hours ago, PhuturePriest said:

Blech, intinction. I used to think it was cool until I received by intinction for half a year. I quickly learned the blood drips and very often somehow gets on your cheek while the priest is distributing it, and you have to awkwardly lick it off with your tongue. Far easier to receive just the Host or the Host and then receive the chalice, in my opinion.

Interesting...my parish distributes Communion by intinction, and in the 10+ years I've been going there, I've not once had any issues like you describe.  Though I have noticed (particularly when we have visiting priests) that some priests are more adept at it than others.  I see your point though!

Posted
7 hours ago, PhuturePriest said:

Blech, intinction. I used to think it was cool until I received by intinction for half a year. I quickly learned the blood drips and very often somehow gets on your cheek while the priest is distributing it, and you have to awkwardly lick it off with your tongue. Far easier to receive just the Host or the Host and then receive the chalice, in my opinion.

This is what I don't like about the host, it's helped drive out the messiness of Christianity. It's like the Roman desire for beardless priests. But the history of unleavened bread that others have noted was interesting...I guess the problem isn't mere tastelessness but the lack of resemblance to actual bread, leavened or unleavened.

The reason I started this thread was because I somehow got one of those taste-memories and when I narrowed it down, it tasted like the host. So I made a thread. But I don't receive Communion so it's mainly just an interest in ritual and symbols that makes it an interesting topic for me.

Posted
On 5/29/2016 at 9:01 AM, IgnatiusofLoyola said:

The Jewish people have celebrated Passover by eating unleavened bread for thousands of years. As I understand it, the Last Supper was a Passover meal, so they, too, ate unleavened bread.

Nowadays the unleavened bread eaten at Passover (but available all year) is called matzo bread, and I'd classify it as an acquired taste. I happen to like it, because all my life I have ended up in neighborhoods with a lot of Jewish people, so I've been eating it since I was a child.

But it IS bland.

Note: I don't know if the matzo of today is the same as the unleavened bread in Jesus' time, but I expect the unleavened bread of Jesus' time was also bland, on purpose, to remember the hardships and sacrifices the Jewish people made in the Exodus. 

Jewish culture, at least what I know of it, celebrates the goodness of God, while never forgetting bitter times such as the Exodus and the destruction of the Temple. The Psalms are a perfect example of this. They alternate and combine praise of God with heartfelt pleas for mercy and forgiveness, and remembrance of the the times of the Exile and sadness.

So, in the Eucharist, there is simultaneously the blandness of the bread (remembering the Exodus and the Last Supper), and the joy of being given the gift to partake of the body of Christ. Similarly, wine is a celebration of the richness of the Earth, yet simultaneously the Blood of Christ. and his sacrifices for us.

Note: What I've just written is not taken from anything I've ever read, just thoughts that came to me. So take it for what it is worth, and ignore it if it is not helpful or is incorrect theologically or historically.

Actually, modern mass-produced industrial matzo is nothing like what Christ and the Apostles would have eaten at the Last Supper. Laafa is more like what they'd have had. I've had unleavened bread for Passover in Israel that was not matzo but was simply flour and water with salt, no leavening. Cooked on the metal cone that Bedouins use, it's actually very tasty.

I also studied professional baking in Israel, specializing in bread. Flour is actually quite flavorful if you know how to use it right. You can achieve a great deal of variation by using different flour blends (winter versus spring wheat, whole wheat versus white with germ but no bran, or with bran but no germ, etc.). The problem with today's hosts isn't that they're just unavoidably bland: It's that they're mass-produced. Industrial production will kill the flavor in anything. That's why manufacturers usually add a ton of salt and sugar to industrial food: cuz otherwise it'd all taste like cardboard.

It is possible to use any unleavened bread of flour and water for the host, and I have had valid hosts that were actual bread, from a real loaf, not wafer-like cracker cardboard things. It was much better. I far prefer the "real bread" variety, but the problem is that such a host is much more perishable and so is impractical for large parishes. It needs baking every day, or every other day. (I had it at the Monastic Family of Bethlehem monastery in New York.)

In my experience, most hosts taste like spongey cardboard, but occasionally I'll get one that actually has a good wheat flavor and real crispness to it. Obviously the latter is better. I'm not sure what makes the difference here, and I don't think it's just staleness, because I've been in a lot of monasteries that bake altar "breads", and many of these had the spongey cardboard type, despite the host having been made right there on site, probably just a few days before. So I do think manufacturing process contributes more to the appeal of the final product than the age or air-exposure of the host does.

Anyone who knows anything about how gluten works can understand this: The more you work it (knead it, mix it, etc.), the "stronger" the gluten network becomes. French sourdoughs tend to be extremely "strong": They're the breads that you have to pull on hard with your jaw to break off a piece. Semolina loaves are especially strong, because semolina is extremely high in gluten so you don't even have to work it that much to produce a very strong loaf. A "shortbread", on the other hand, is very crumbly, because the gluten network has been left deliberately undeveloped (i.e., the gluten strands are left short, rather than long, usually by introducing butter, which makes it impossible for the gluten strands to attach to one another and form the long, strong chains that force you to pull with your jaw on a strong loaf).

But water-to-flour ratio also matters for texture. So my guess about chewy hosts is this: Too much water is added, and the dough is over-processed. Most of the water is baked off (that's what cooking is: the evaporation of water out of a food), but not enough of it, so you get a kind of wet, chewy round. In a good host, the proper amount of water to flour is used, and the dough is minimally worked (just enough to get it to hold together), and it's baked longer, to get it crisper, which also develops the flavor of the flour.

You can see how industrial processing would produce the bad hosts: Water is cheap, but flour is not. So factories add more water to produce more hosts for the money. Then they over-process the dough because it's hard to work with a dough that's too wet and workers don't have the skill to do it right and the manufacturers want to ensure the hosts will hold together, because crumbly hosts have to get tossed, which costs more money. Then they underbake them because heating ovens costs money.

This is probably TMI and TL;DR and whatnot, but I geek out on this stuff, and I agree that the host should be tasty. Simplicity is tasty, but only when it's done right.

On 5/31/2016 at 7:00 AM, Makarioi said:

co-mingle.  It's really spelled with 2 M's.  Growing up, I remember the hosts were shiny white.  I guess with all of the allergies that didn't seem to be present when I was younger, caused things to change.  One church that I visited in NY seemed to have hosts that were sweetened.  Folks would probably complain about calories............ *sigh*

It is strengst verboten to add sweeteners to the host. It invalidates it. However, some wheat flours are naturally sweeter than others, depending on the time of year they were harvested (and also, less so, the variety of wheat). Normally, though, that difference in sweetness is imperceptible to most people. (I notice it because I'm a bread-nerd, but otherwise, probably only foodies would notice it.) I have once had a host that was so sweet that I know the crazy priest serving it added sweetener to it. I was mad and sad and shocked all at the same time.

 

On 5/31/2016 at 10:13 AM, vee said:

Interesting.  In the rite Im familiar with that uses leavened bread they also have it intincted.  It is in small cubes in teh chalice of Precious Blood and the priest has a teeny tiny little spoon made out of precious metal that he uses to remove one cube of the Eucharist and drops it in the communicant's mouth.  He is standing on a step so he is taller than most people and the communicant tilts their head back, opens their mouth, and basically receives like a little bird :)

I had this once at a Byzantine Mass. It was really gross. Shame to say that about the host, but it was just so... soggy. Never again. In general, I find intincture seems like a good idea in theory, but in practice, it's just... soggy. Eww. No, thank you.

It's also funny that, today, Ultra-Orthodox Jews avoid wetting the matzo on Passover because they're worried it might cause it to rise (which is absurd, but so are they in their world of "fences"). They will go to some serious extremes to avoid wetting their Passover matzo. And yet here we are dropping the host into wine. :|

Whatever, I guess.

Tab'le De'Bah-Rye
Posted

usually tastes a little sweet to me whether i drink the blood or not. Doesn't matter which parish i'm at either. Perhaps you don't truly believe that the LORD is Good therefore he doesn't taste good to you. <shrugs> Idk.

On 6/1/2016 at 5:57 AM, dUSt said:

If Jesus humiliated himself to the point of becoming a piece of bread, it's not surprising that His humility is so great that the bread is also bland.

yeah our LORD was famed for being plain and straight forward.

On 6/1/2016 at 11:31 AM, Era Might said:

This is what I don't like about the host, it's helped drive out the messiness of Christianity. It's like the Roman desire for beardless priests. But the history of unleavened bread that others have noted was interesting...I guess the problem isn't mere tastelessness but the lack of resemblance to actual bread, leavened or unleavened.

The reason I started this thread was because I somehow got one of those taste-memories and when I narrowed it down, it tasted like the host. So I made a thread. But I don't receive Communion so it's mainly just an interest in ritual and symbols that makes it an interesting topic for me.

so the host has a distinct taste to you, that is kinda unique isn't it?

Just a heads up also, the only eternal sacrifice mentioned in holy scripture is in one of the prophets books in the O.T and that is the daily sacrifice of the bread, oil and lamb. Our host is all 3, i really disagree with adding or taking away from the word of God, the host should remain simply bread with a touch of oil, perhaps the oil can have various flavors,unsure, one would have to look at the jewish sacrifice to know whether we can or can't. But of course i'm not the holy magesterium and my opinion is just my opinion and there opinion is that which we all must follow. It is the only law in the old testament that is described as an eternal one as far as i'm aware, all other laws of the O.T reached there fulfillment on the cross, but this particular one i believe is indissoluble, it is a great verse to bring up with protestants, just bible search 'eternal sacrifice'.

Onward christian souls.

GodblesS.

God iz Good!

CatherineM
Posted

Our hosts back home weren't mass produced. They were made by Carmelite nuns. 

PhuturePriest
Posted
4 hours ago, Gabriela said:

Actually, modern mass-produced industrial matzo is nothing like what Christ and the Apostles would have eaten at the Last Supper. Laafa is more like what they'd have had. I've had unleavened bread for Passover in Israel that was not matzo but was simply flour and water with salt, no leavening. Cooked on the metal cone that Bedouins use, it's actually very tasty.

I also studied professional baking in Israel, specializing in bread. Flour is actually quite flavorful if you know how to use it right. You can achieve a great deal of variation by using different flour blends (winter versus spring wheat, whole wheat versus white with germ but no bran, or with bran but no germ, etc.). The problem with today's hosts isn't that they're just unavoidably bland: It's that they're mass-produced. Industrial production will kill the flavor in anything. That's why manufacturers usually add a ton of salt and sugar to industrial food: cuz otherwise it'd all taste like cardboard.

It is possible to use any unleavened bread of flour and water for the host, and I have had valid hosts that were actual bread, from a real loaf, not wafer-like cracker cardboard things. It was much better. I far prefer the "real bread" variety, but the problem is that such a host is much more perishable and so is impractical for large parishes. It needs baking every day, or every other day. (I had it at the Monastic Family of Bethlehem monastery in New York.)

In my experience, most hosts taste like spongey cardboard, but occasionally I'll get one that actually has a good wheat flavor and real crispness to it. Obviously the latter is better. I'm not sure what makes the difference here, and I don't think it's just staleness, because I've been in a lot of monasteries that bake altar "breads", and many of these had the spongey cardboard type, despite the host having been made right there on site, probably just a few days before. So I do think manufacturing process contributes more to the appeal of the final product than the age or air-exposure of the host does.

Anyone who knows anything about how gluten works can understand this: The more you work it (knead it, mix it, etc.), the "stronger" the gluten network becomes. French sourdoughs tend to be extremely "strong": They're the breads that you have to pull on hard with your jaw to break off a piece. Semolina loaves are especially strong, because semolina is extremely high in gluten so you don't even have to work it that much to produce a very strong loaf. A "shortbread", on the other hand, is very crumbly, because the gluten network has been left deliberately undeveloped (i.e., the gluten strands are left short, rather than long, usually by introducing butter, which makes it impossible for the gluten strands to attach to one another and form the long, strong chains that force you to pull with your jaw on a strong loaf).

But water-to-flour ratio also matters for texture. So my guess about chewy hosts is this: Too much water is added, and the dough is over-processed. Most of the water is baked off (that's what cooking is: the evaporation of water out of a food), but not enough of it, so you get a kind of wet, chewy round. In a good host, the proper amount of water to flour is used, and the dough is minimally worked (just enough to get it to hold together), and it's baked longer, to get it crisper, which also develops the flavor of the flour.

You can see how industrial processing would produce the bad hosts: Water is cheap, but flour is not. So factories add more water to produce more hosts for the money. Then they over-process the dough because it's hard to work with a dough that's too wet and workers don't have the skill to do it right and the manufacturers want to ensure the hosts will hold together, because crumbly hosts have to get tossed, which costs more money. Then they underbake them because heating ovens costs money.

This is probably TMI and TL;DR and whatnot, but I geek out on this stuff, and I agree that the host should be tasty. Simplicity is tasty, but only when it's done right.

It is strengst verboten to add sweeteners to the host. It invalidates it. However, some wheat flours are naturally sweeter than others, depending on the time of year they were harvested (and also, less so, the variety of wheat). Normally, though, that difference in sweetness is imperceptible to most people. (I notice it because I'm a bread-nerd, but otherwise, probably only foodies would notice it.) I have once had a host that was so sweet that I know the crazy priest serving it added sweetener to it. I was mad and sad and shocked all at the same time.

 

I had this once at a Byzantine Mass. It was really gross. Shame to say that about the host, but it was just so... soggy. Never again. In general, I find intincture seems like a good idea in theory, but in practice, it's just... soggy. Eww. No, thank you.

It's also funny that, today, Ultra-Orthodox Jews avoid wetting the matzo on Passover because they're worried it might cause it to rise (which is absurd, but so are they in their world of "fences"). They will go to some serious extremes to avoid wetting their Passover matzo. And yet here we are dropping the host into wine. :|

Whatever, I guess.

Soggy bread. Something so vile and repulsive I should add it to the list of excommunicable offenses. I had several friends who loved their bread soggy. "Had" being the key word. It was impossible to watch them consume their ruined bread without the strong urge to vomit.

Posted
3 hours ago, CatherineM said:

Our hosts back home weren't mass produced. They were made by Carmelite nuns. 

Nuns mass produce the hosts. I just suspect that some pay more attention to flavor and texture than others. In general, though, their methods—or at least, their machinery and work process—appear to be largely the same as any large industrial factory. It's the only way they can keep the hosts affordable.

CatherineM
Posted
9 hours ago, Gabriela said:

Nuns mass produce the hosts. I just suspect that some pay more attention to flavor and texture than others. In general, though, their methods—or at least, their machinery and work process—appear to be largely the same as any large industrial factory. It's the only way they can keep the hosts affordable.

They are a cloistered order, but I got to see them making them. Flour, water, and rolling pins. 

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...