dUSt Posted June 29, 2016 Posted June 29, 2016 6 hours ago, Ice_nine said: Eh, I hate to be so sensitive but I'm a little salty that the threads were combined. As anomaly said, these are 3 different situations. Mine is still yet unresolved and I'm still fairly tormented over it, so having it devolve into Australian animal memes is kind of irritating Sorry, I split the emu stuff into a different thread.
Sponsa-Christi Posted June 29, 2016 Posted June 29, 2016 (edited) 4 hours ago, franciscanheart said: It sounds super weird to talk about all the paperwork people need to do in order to receive the proper graces from their Creator. I understand this sentiment, but I think we have to follow things back a few steps when we're tempted to make statements like this. It's not paperwork qua paperwork that's important, but what those papers convey or represent. In other words, we're not really talking about paperwork, we're talking about the Church lawfully issuing certain permissions which happens by means of written words on paper. (Or else talking about proper record keeping, which I don't think anyone objects to.) If we're going to reduce our reflection on the Church's role in Catholic marriages to: "Does God REALLY care about a bunch of paperwork?", then we might as well say about baptism: "So Christ only came to save people whose head got wet that one time?" Or about the Mass: "It's weird that we need to follow a certain script in order for God to be made present to us." Edited June 29, 2016 by Sponsa-Christi
Maggyie Posted June 29, 2016 Posted June 29, 2016 34 minutes ago, Sponsa-Christi said: I understand this sentiment, but I think we have to follow things back a few steps when we're tempted to make statements like this. It's not paperwork qua paperwork that's important, but what those papers convey or represent. In other words, we're not really talking about paperwork, we're talking about the Church lawfully issuing certain permissions which happens by means of written words on paper. (Or else talking about proper record keeping, which I don't think anyone objects to.) If we're going to reduce our reflection on the Church's role in Catholic marriages to: "Does God REALLY care about a bunch of paperwork?", then we might as well say about baptism: "So Christ only came to save people whose head got wet that one time?" Or about the Mass: "It's weird that we need to follow a certain script in order for God to be made present to us." Well it's still a bit weird. Baptism is a good analogy because we know it's possible for people who havn't been baptized to be saved.
<3 PopeFrancis Posted June 29, 2016 Posted June 29, 2016 39 minutes ago, Sponsa-Christi said: I understand this sentiment, but I think we have to follow things back a few steps when we're tempted to make statements like this. (Or elIt's not paperwork qua paperwork that's important, but what those papers convey or represent. In other words, we're not really talking about paperwork, we're talking about the Church lawfully issuing certain permissions which happens by means of written words on paper.se talking about proper record keeping, which I don't think anyone objects to.) The reason for this is to confirm, and satisfy the legal end. For the Book of Life? \ 5 minutes ago, Maggyie said:
Sponsa-Christi Posted June 29, 2016 Posted June 29, 2016 19 minutes ago, Maggyie said: Well it's still a bit weird. Baptism is a good analogy because we know it's possible for people who havn't been baptized to be saved. Backing this up a bit more, exactly what kind of paperwork is the "weird" paperwork that we're talking about here? Assuming that the weird paperwork is paperwork that's necessary for the validly of a marriage---e.g., a dispensation for a Catholic to marry a non-Christian, a dispensation of canonical form for a Catholic to marry in a non-Catholic ceremony, or paperwork involving the pastor delegating the wedding ceremony to another priest---the more I think about this, the less weird it actually seems to me. In our society, we regularly use the written word as a means of communication. So when a bishop needs to give special permission for something, he'll generally give it in writing; or if a lawful authority wishes to delegate a task properly, he'll also do this in writing. This means that there is "paperwork" involved, but this sort of written communication seems completely sensible to me. Would it seem weird if a Catholic in a non-literate society who needed a dispensation/permission for something went and met the bishop in person, and then received the dispensation orally from the bishop? Because "paperwork" is essentially the same thing, only conveyed through a different (and arguably more reliable) medium. But if the problem is rather that it seems weird that a Catholic would ever need a bishop's personal permission for anything pertaining to God's grace, then this is getting into much bigger questions on the nature of Apostolic succession, the authority of the Church as a visible institution, and even our whole Catholic sacramental paradigm.
franciscanheart Posted June 30, 2016 Posted June 30, 2016 On 6/29/2016 at 2:19 PM, Sponsa-Christi said: Backing this up a bit more, exactly what kind of paperwork is the "weird" paperwork that we're talking about here? Assuming that the weird paperwork is paperwork that's necessary for the validly of a marriage---e.g., a dispensation for a Catholic to marry a non-Christian, a dispensation of canonical form for a Catholic to marry in a non-Catholic ceremony, or paperwork involving the pastor delegating the wedding ceremony to another priest---the more I think about this, the less weird it actually seems to me. In our society, we regularly use the written word as a means of communication. So when a bishop needs to give special permission for something, he'll generally give it in writing; or if a lawful authority wishes to delegate a task properly, he'll also do this in writing. This means that there is "paperwork" involved, but this sort of written communication seems completely sensible to me. Would it seem weird if a Catholic in a non-literate society who needed a dispensation/permission for something went and met the bishop in person, and then received the dispensation orally from the bishop? Because "paperwork" is essentially the same thing, only conveyed through a different (and arguably more reliable) medium. But if the problem is rather that it seems weird that a Catholic would ever need a bishop's personal permission for anything pertaining to God's grace, then this is getting into much bigger questions on the nature of Apostolic succession, the authority of the Church as a visible institution, and even our whole Catholic sacramental paradigm. I'd like to, as a fairly ignorant Catholic, like to hear your thoughts on the later -- maybe in a different thread.
Sponsa-Christi Posted July 1, 2016 Posted July 1, 2016 On 6/30/2016 at 4:06 PM, franciscanheart said: I'd like to, as a fairly ignorant Catholic, like to hear your thoughts on the later -- maybe in a different thread. Yes, this might be better in a different thread, but to try to give a very quick answer... God created us as body and soul (read: we're not nothing-but-spirit like the angels are), and as such we human beings relate to and come to understand reality primarily through material things. That is, a large portion of our knowledge about anything comes from our five senses. Knowing this, God became incarnate to save us from sin---i.e., our savior Jesus is "the Word made flesh." Jesus only walked the earth for thirty-something years, but He intended His saving ministry to continue on earth until the end of the world. To do this, Jesus established a Church which is a visible institution, and not simply an abstract concept or a purely spiritual reality. He gave the authority to run the Church to the Twelve Apostles, and the mission of the Twelve included teaching (authoritatively proclaiming what is true about God), sanctifying (administering the sacraments), and governing (ensuring good order in the Church). The famous scriptural passage on this is Matthew 16:18, when Jesus calls Peter "the rock on which I will build My Church" and tells him: "What you bind on earth will be bound in heaven, and what you loose on earth will be loosed in heaven." Or in other words, Jesus was basically giving Peter the power to dispense God's grace. "Apostolic succession" is our belief that today's bishops (and by extension, the priests who assist them) are the direct successors of the Apostles, with the same mission and therefore the same "powers" as the original Twelve. So, when the Church makes laws about things which she is competent to make laws about (like marriage and the other sacraments), we believe that the bishops who do this are doing so in their capacity as "Apostles," and thus that they are doing so with Christ's own authority. Sort of like how when we go to Confession, the priest is involved but we are really confessing our sins to God rather than to Fr. Joe Smith personally; when a person needs a dispensation from a bishop to be married they are, in a sense, really asking Christ for His permission. Of course, there are loads of nuances and caveats I could get into here, but this is the basic idea of why it's important to obey the Church's "paperwork" rules, and why we can't go by just "what we feel in our hearts."
franciscanheart Posted July 5, 2016 Posted July 5, 2016 On 7/1/2016 at 5:27 PM, Sponsa-Christi said: Yes, this might be better in a different thread, but to try to give a very quick answer... God created us as body and soul (read: we're not nothing-but-spirit like the angels are), and as such we human beings relate to and come to understand reality primarily through material things. That is, a large portion of our knowledge about anything comes from our five senses. Knowing this, God became incarnate to save us from sin---i.e., our savior Jesus is "the Word made flesh." Jesus only walked the earth for thirty-something years, but He intended His saving ministry to continue on earth until the end of the world. To do this, Jesus established a Church which is a visible institution, and not simply an abstract concept or a purely spiritual reality. He gave the authority to run the Church to the Twelve Apostles, and the mission of the Twelve included teaching (authoritatively proclaiming what is true about God), sanctifying (administering the sacraments), and governing (ensuring good order in the Church). The famous scriptural passage on this is Matthew 16:18, when Jesus calls Peter "the rock on which I will build My Church" and tells him: "What you bind on earth will be bound in heaven, and what you loose on earth will be loosed in heaven." Or in other words, Jesus was basically giving Peter the power to dispense God's grace. "Apostolic succession" is our belief that today's bishops (and by extension, the priests who assist them) are the direct successors of the Apostles, with the same mission and therefore the same "powers" as the original Twelve. So, when the Church makes laws about things which she is competent to make laws about (like marriage and the other sacraments), we believe that the bishops who do this are doing so in their capacity as "Apostles," and thus that they are doing so with Christ's own authority. Sort of like how when we go to Confession, the priest is involved but we are really confessing our sins to God rather than to Fr. Joe Smith personally; when a person needs a dispensation from a bishop to be married they are, in a sense, really asking Christ for His permission. Of course, there are loads of nuances and caveats I could get into here, but this is the basic idea of why it's important to obey the Church's "paperwork" rules, and why we can't go by just "what we feel in our hearts." I sincerely hope that your last statement was as general as the ones that preceded it. So, how does the Church explain all the rules and regulations that have changed over time -- including, most recently, how annulment petitions are reviewed -- if Jesus is basically giving the go-ahead on all of this? Is there no room for human error in the red tape of the Church's human structure?
LittleWaySoul Posted July 6, 2016 Posted July 6, 2016 @franciscanheart to prevent further derailing of this already-somewhat derailed thread, that's an excellent question to pose in the Q&A section. I'm currently helping out at a tribunal so I may at least have some answers for you on Pope Francis's recent motu proprios concerning annulments. @Sponsa-Christi could go into further detail over there as well to help answer your question more fully.
Sponsa-Christi Posted July 7, 2016 Posted July 7, 2016 On 7/5/2016 at 0:24 PM, franciscanheart said: So, how does the Church explain all the rules and regulations that have changed over time -- including, most recently, how annulment petitions are reviewed -- if Jesus is basically giving the go-ahead on all of this? Is there no room for human error in the red tape of the Church's human structure? In my earlier posts about "paperwork," I was thinking mostly of the Church's right to make "arbitrary" (in scare quotes because those laws aren't truly arbitrary in the sense of being without reason or purpose) marriage laws, such as the the requirement of a Catholic wedding for Catholics. Theologically you can indeed look at obedience those laws as obedience to Christ in His representatives. But, I don't think the specifics of the process of a trial to determine marriage nullity are really comparable to questions of whether or not Catholics really need to observe canonical form. The rules for a nullity trail are purely of human origin, and they are subject to change over time in ways which ensure that justice is most efficiently rendered in light of contemporary societal conditions. But I certainly don't think this means that such rules are simply "red tape." They're ultimately meant to facilitate Christian living in a sensible way according to human prudence. When you have an "annulment" trial, you're setting out to prove that a marriage never occurred because of some defect of consent or because of an fundamental inability to enter into marriage. Even though it can seem complicated, the rules for a nullity trial are actually mostly basic common-sense practices for determining the truth about a situation while respecting the rights of everyone involved. For example, Jesus didn't literally say: "you must cite the respondent [i.e., inform the other spouse that an annulment trial is taking place and give them an option to participate]." But anyone with a basic sense of fairness would understand why it's important to contact and involve the other party! This might sound silly, but I think a parallel might be a parish first Communion program. First Communicants have to take preparatory catechetical classes, which usually involves some paperwork with the parish (like having emergency contact numbers on file, etc.) The kids also have to learn a lot of arbitrary "rules" for the big day, like how to line up, which pew to sit in, how to process back to their seat after they receive communion, etc. But just because (for example) being seated in alphabetical order is something that's obviously not divinely inspired doesn't mean that the DRE is wrong to arrange things that way, or that it's somehow creating a barrier to the grace of the sacrament. It just means that the DRE just needs a sensible way to direct schoolchildren through a ceremony. Likewise, having to fill out forms for a child to attend catechetical classes is a way to ensure everyone's safety and to make sure that everyone's expectations are clear---again, that specific paperwork is not divinely inspired per se but it's still a wholly legitimate thing to be doing. 1 hour ago, LittleWaySoul said: @Sponsa-Christi could go into further detail over there as well to help answer your question more fully. I'm neither a Church scholar nor Church militant, so I can't post in the forum.
LittleWaySoul Posted July 7, 2016 Posted July 7, 2016 14 minutes ago, Sponsa-Christi said: I'm neither a Church scholar nor Church militant, so I can't post in the forum. Wait, don't you have a licentiate in Canon Law? @dUSt, get this woman a Church Scholar tag!
Sponsa-Christi Posted July 7, 2016 Posted July 7, 2016 Just now, LittleWaySoul said: Wait, don't you have a licentiate in Canon Law? Yes, I finished my J.C.L. in 2014. (I also have a Master's in theology, for whatever it's worth.) Thanks for remembering!
truthfinder Posted July 7, 2016 Posted July 7, 2016 4 minutes ago, LittleWaySoul said: Wait, don't you have a licentiate in Canon Law? @dUSt, get this woman a Church Scholar tag! Yeah! Goodness! I second that
franciscanheart Posted July 7, 2016 Posted July 7, 2016 14 hours ago, Sponsa-Christi said: In my earlier posts about "paperwork," I was thinking mostly of the Church's right to make "arbitrary" (in scare quotes because those laws aren't truly arbitrary in the sense of being without reason or purpose) marriage laws, such as the the requirement of a Catholic wedding for Catholics. Theologically you can indeed look at obedience those laws as obedience to Christ in His representatives. But, I don't think the specifics of the process of a trial to determine marriage nullity are really comparable to questions of whether or not Catholics really need to observe canonical form. The rules for a nullity trail are purely of human origin, and they are subject to change over time in ways which ensure that justice is most efficiently rendered in light of contemporary societal conditions. But I certainly don't think this means that such rules are simply "red tape." They're ultimately meant to facilitate Christian living in a sensible way according to human prudence. When you have an "annulment" trial, you're setting out to prove that a marriage never occurred because of some defect of consent or because of an fundamental inability to enter into marriage. Even though it can seem complicated, the rules for a nullity trial are actually mostly basic common-sense practices for determining the truth about a situation while respecting the rights of everyone involved. For example, Jesus didn't literally say: "you must cite the respondent [i.e., inform the other spouse that an annulment trial is taking place and give them an option to participate]." But anyone with a basic sense of fairness would understand why it's important to contact and involve the other party! This might sound silly, but I think a parallel might be a parish first Communion program. First Communicants have to take preparatory catechetical classes, which usually involves some paperwork with the parish (like having emergency contact numbers on file, etc.) The kids also have to learn a lot of arbitrary "rules" for the big day, like how to line up, which pew to sit in, how to process back to their seat after they receive communion, etc. But just because (for example) being seated in alphabetical order is something that's obviously not divinely inspired doesn't mean that the DRE is wrong to arrange things that way, or that it's somehow creating a barrier to the grace of the sacrament. It just means that the DRE just needs a sensible way to direct schoolchildren through a ceremony. Likewise, having to fill out forms for a child to attend catechetical classes is a way to ensure everyone's safety and to make sure that everyone's expectations are clear---again, that specific paperwork is not divinely inspired per se but it's still a wholly legitimate thing to be doing. I'm neither a Church scholar nor Church militant, so I can't post in the forum. That seems like a weak and confusing parallel, but perhaps we should split into a new thread. No time now as my plate is creeping toward full, but soon. Thank you for your thoughtful responses.
Lil Red Posted July 8, 2016 Posted July 8, 2016 On June 18, 2016 at 8:30 AM, Ice_nine said: It's extremely precarious because she seems like she wants to get married in the church, eventually even if not right now. I don't want to close that door. She hates when religious people seem self-righteous and it very well may come off that way. I am torn. Absolutely torn. Out of my immediate family, 40 or so cousins, my dozen aunts and uncles I think not a single one of them will understand let alone support my decision (still haven't decided yet) to not attend my only sister's wedding. They will all think I'm the biggest ass on the planet, or they will be devastated (which is worse) IMO. I just don't know what to do :/. It's possible she could still have a church wedding but her fiancé seems opposed. I don't know Is there a way that your mom/dad could broach the subjection of a dispensation in marrying a non-Catholic? I mean, it is their job as a parent to guide their children in the Faith (even if their children are adults). When my sister was remarrying, my mom asked if she would get an annulment so she could be married in the Church (which she did get and they did marry in the Church). I wanted to make sure my sister was "legit" in the eyes of the Church, but I left that up to my parents to help my sister.
Sponsa-Christi Posted July 8, 2016 Posted July 8, 2016 On 7/7/2016 at 0:24 PM, franciscanheart said: That seems like a weak and confusing parallel, but perhaps we should split into a new thread. Fair enough, it probably was! The point I was trying to make, though, is that just because the Church's procedural law wasn't literally written word-for-word by Jesus Himself, it doesn't therefore follow that the Church doesn't have the authority to determine what is and what isn't a sacrament.
Ice_nine Posted July 9, 2016 Posted July 9, 2016 6 hours ago, Lil Red said: Is there a way that your mom/dad could broach the subjection of a dispensation in marrying a non-Catholic? I mean, it is their job as a parent to guide their children in the Faith (even if their children are adults). When my sister was remarrying, my mom asked if she would get an annulment so she could be married in the Church (which she did get and they did marry in the Church). I wanted to make sure my sister was "legit" in the eyes of the Church, but I left that up to my parents to help my sister. err, my dad is not practicing and my mom did encourage her to get married in the church (she's mostly practicing but ignorant about Catholicism in many ways), but didn't want to step on my sister's toes. I don't know if she fully understands the importance of it. Also, the guy my sister wants to marry is also a Catholic, just not practicing really. He's pretty passive and doesn't seem absolutely dead-set against a church wedding but I can safely say he is not at all interested in it either. It's really killing me. I filled out a contact form that my parish had on their website and no one got back to me. The pastors' emails are listed but I don't know, should I try emailing one of them? What if they don't answer too? Every time I have to see her or someone else talks about the wedding I get some pretty violent thoughts directed at myself. gaaaaaaaaaaaah.
LittleWaySoul Posted July 9, 2016 Posted July 9, 2016 15 hours ago, Ice_nine said: err, my dad is not practicing and my mom did encourage her to get married in the church (she's mostly practicing but ignorant about Catholicism in many ways), but didn't want to step on my sister's toes. I don't know if she fully understands the importance of it. Also, the guy my sister wants to marry is also a Catholic, just not practicing really. He's pretty passive and doesn't seem absolutely dead-set against a church wedding but I can safely say he is not at all interested in it either. It's really killing me. I filled out a contact form that my parish had on their website and no one got back to me. The pastors' emails are listed but I don't know, should I try emailing one of them? What if they don't answer too? Every time I have to see her or someone else talks about the wedding I get some pretty violent thoughts directed at myself. gaaaaaaaaaaaah. Hey, I know what that's like (the violent thoughts), but this isn't your fault, I promise. I'm sorry you're feeling this way. Do you have anyone you can talk to about your mental/emotional health right now? That's pretty important in this situation too. I think you're absolutely justified in outright emailing the priests, if only for confidential guidance on the situation. You could simply say in your email that you're in a tough situation right now and really need help discerning what to do. Then when you meet with one of them, you'll be able to explain the situation to him much better than to us, and he'll probably give better guidance anyway. I really hope someone would answer your email, but if they don't, just remember that it's still not your fault, nor is it because of anything that you did wrong. Just take it one step at a time and try to encourage yourself for each step you take. Please know that I'm praying for you, and I hope you can find some peace through all of this.
Ice_nine Posted July 27, 2016 Posted July 27, 2016 so . . . for anyone interested I talked to both my therapist and a priest about this whole situation. I didn't want any part of it, and my anxiety was through the freaking roof, but I did it. I know that my traditionalist-minded posters will probably not agree, but in short the priest told me I shouldn't not participate in the wedding for a few good reasons. He didn't think I was just yielding to peer pressure, and he told me I should do my best to gently correct my sister, which for me is not an easy thing to do because I usually go into a panic when talking about my beliefs or anything personal to me. He also talked about all the couples he counsels for marriage prep. How many just marry in the church for social, traditional, or even superficial reasons (e.g. the church is a beautiful setting) and how there's some level of integrity for those who don't marry in the church because they don't believe or are not committed to her. Honestly I'd rather have my sister and her fiancé go through the motions. An illicit, but valid, wedding is better than one that is both illicit and invalid. Maybe that's the wrong way to look at things. When my mom more or less forced me to be confirmed in the Church at a time I didn't believe in it, I was very bitter. After my reversion I often wonder if it "counted" and how my conscience would be a little more at ease had I been confirmed when I wanted to and when I was in a state of grace. I see something similar here. I feel like I'm the only, or one of the few, actually practicing Catholics in my family. Thus I'm a live resource for them to learn about the Church that they would only know about through the media (which usually paints an ugly picture). I genuinely don't think that by not participating in the wedding, or not going, that I would help bring about any conversion. Don't get me wrong, I don't think participation in itself is an evangelizing opportunity either, but I think it keeps that door open where as not going might slam it shut. Also the fact that she expresses a desire to get the marriage "blessed" i.e. convalidated. If not participating is me "taking a stand" which direction will that push her? I do better with absolutes and finality. In many ways it would be easier for me to say "I'm not going because I don't believe in what you're doing," and deal with the fallout. It would be torturous yes, but so is living in the constant tension of trying to share my faith in ana effective way. I'll have to have discussions with my sister about things I'd rather not (simply because my mental/social health is kind of shiitake mushroom). I've consigned myself to the fact that I will not feel OK about any decision I'd have to make. Often times I would think "maybe if I die in a car crash or something, it wouldn't be the worst thing." I'm thinking about that less now. I just think my level of stress was so high and neither decision seemed good, the idea of escape was attractive. I didn't mean for the post to be that long, My bad. Continued prayers are always appreciated. Thanks fam.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now