Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

The Ultimate Super-sized XXL Marriage Thread Plus


Recommended Posts

Sponsa-Christi
Posted
1 hour ago, Sponsa-Christi said:

Retroactivly validating a marriage---which is basically what a sanation is---isn't the same thing as saying that an invalid marriage was somehow valid in the period of time before it was actually validated.

Re-reading this, I can see where it could be confusing. 

Yes, a radical sanation is retroactive, which means that post-sanation, we could say that the marriage was "valid all along."

BUT, during the period of time while you are waiting for a sanation that may or may not be granted, you can't say "this marriage is already valid." If it was already valid in the ordinary sense of the term, you wouldn't be seeking a sanation in the first place.

We definitely can't say that a marriage is valid (or even "sort of valid") because we are secretly entertaining the hope that maybe one day the couple might decide to seek a sanation. 

It sort of like how a couple seeking a declaration of nullity needs to behave as if they are married---i.e., they can't seek to marry anyone else---until and if their "annulment" is actually granted, even though a declaration of nullity means that the couple was never truly married in the first place.

5 minutes ago, Maggyie said:

Right, there is no teaching either way. But the possibility of sanation or convalidation is something you can take into account when discerning if attending or not attending better accomplishes the end of evangelizing the couple. If a sanation or convalidation would be impossible (like in Mihil's scenario where he describes a previous bond existing) that's something else to consider. 

True, and this is a good point. 

While not actually disagreeing with you here, I still think that in discerning whether or not to attend an invalid wedding, we should still be realistic about the nature of an invalid marriage. As in, it's one thing to attend with the thought that: "This civil wedding is probably a real first step towards a valid marriage and the couple's full reconciliation with the Church"; and quite another to attend while thinking: "Well, a sanation/convalidation might be a theoretical possibility at some point, so I suppose there's no harm in telling myself that this wedding is already kind of valid-ish..."

Posted (edited)
2 hours ago, Sponsa-Christi said:

We definitely can't say that a marriage is valid (or even "sort of valid") because we are secretly entertaining the hope that maybe one day the couple might decide to seek a sanation.....................

..................While not actually disagreeing with you here, I still think that in discerning whether or not to attend an invalid wedding, we should still be realistic about the nature of an invalid marriage. As in, it's one thing to attend with the thought that: "This civil wedding is probably a real first step towards a valid marriage and the couple's full reconciliation with the Church"; and quite another to attend while thinking: "Well, a sanation/convalidation might be a theoretical possibility at some point, so I suppose there's no harm in telling myself that this wedding is already kind of valid-ish..."

 

 

A Catholic who might attend a presumed invalid marriage with the hope and prayer that somewhere ahead in time the couple would respond to Grace and remedy the situation is not at all of necessity any sort of presuming.  And I am not stating at all that that prayer and hope is the basis of their attending the ceremony.  Rather the reason for attending is in another context entirely.

However, "this wedding is already kind of valid-sh", would be quite a quite wrongful assuming to say the least.  Also "This civil wedding is probably a real first step towards a valid marriage and the couple's full reconciliation with the Church"; is another quite incorrect assumption and nothing, of course, of any sort of "real first step" of necessity at all. 

Both trains of thought or examples are quite incorrect and simply different trains of thought and both are nonsensical.

The examples quoted by Sponsa are only (remote?) potentials......I think......since I cannot recall anyone in this thread making statements anywhere near the two examples given and am presuming they were stated for the purposes of "intellectual argument".

______

In most all I have read (if not indeed all) from sound Catholic sources on a (baptised Catholic) couple marrying in a civil ceremony or in a presumed invalid marriage, it is that latter term that is consistently used by those sources:  i.e. "presumed invalid" - and that says mountains.  Reading some of the posts into this thread the words used to describe a presumed invalid marriage are inflammatory (saying mountains) and do indicate the bias of author. (I am very much aware of my own bias.....I think and hope!........although sometimes it might take control without permission)

Edited by BarbaraTherese
Posted (edited)

 

4 hours ago, Anomaly said:

The baptized Catholic cannot pretend any invalid marriage never existed, as if it was just a sexual relationship, and go to confession and marry a nice Catholic virgin the same day.

4 hours ago, Sponsa-Christi said:

 

Well, maybe not in the same day...but basically, yes, you more or less can do this.

Provided that all obligations of material support are met for any dependents that may have resulted from a civil union, a Catholic who was married invalid in a civil ceremony CAN essentially just walk away from the civil union. 

If the baptized Catholic has been married in a civil ceremony then the marriage is valid in civil law but presumed invalid in Catholic Law.  Therefore, the Catholic cannot simply walk away from the marriage and marry a Catholic on the same day.........not even in the eyes of The Church (I think ?)......Romans Chapter 13 Vatican Bible "Let every person be subordinate to the higher authorities, for there is no authority except from God, and those that exist have been established by God.  2Therefore, whoever resists authority opposes what God has appointed, and those who oppose it will bring judgment upon themselves.  (This does take up what Jesus said: "Give to Caesar what is Caesar's and to God what is God's")

And I found this in the CCC "2238 Those subject to authority should regard those in authority as representatives of God, who has made them stewards of his gifts: 43 "Be subject for the Lord's sake to every human institution.... Live as free men, yet without using your freedom as a pretext for evil; but live as servants of God." 44 Their loyal collaboration includes the right, and at times the duty, to voice their just criticisms of that which seems harmful to the dignity of persons and to the good of the community."

I also found the following: (Vatican Bible "The New American Bible") I Pet 2:13, 16.

8" Be subject to every human institution for the Lord's sake, whether it be to the king as supreme or to governors as sent by him for the punishment of evildoers and the approval of those who do good.For it is the will of God that by doing good you may silence the ignorance of foolish people.Be free, yet without using freedom as a pretext for evil, but as slaves of God. 17 Give honor to all, love the community, fear God, honor the king."

Edited by BarbaraTherese
Posted

I wonder too if a Catholic can just walk away from a presumed invalid marriage without any sort of permission to do so from a Church hierarchy on some level.  I think (unsure) that there needs to be some sort of official advice that the presumed invalid marriage is now actually invalid (and no longer presumed), meaning the Catholic can then just walk away from the marriage i.e. separation.  In Australian Law after a certain period, to just abandon a valid marriage in civil law becomes "abandonment" and actual grounds for divorce in civil law.  Of course, divorce and remarriage is forbidden in all instances by Church Law.  Once can be divorced, but never remarry.

If one's marriage is declared actually invalid by The Church and under Church Law but yet valid in civil law, then I do wonder if the Catholic does have some sort of moral obligation towards his or her partner who, in good faith, married the Catholic in a civil ceremony and fully intended and invested in the vow "until death do us part"???

PS   My application for annulment from The Church required that I must be divorced in civil law, which my 'husband' had proceeded with anyway and successfully i.e. he divorced me civilly.  I do understand the reasons for the demand for divorce prior to proceeding with the annulment process (I asked why), but that is another subject entirely.

"Once can be divorced, but never remarry." in the first paragraph should read "One can be divorced, but never remarry"

Sponsa-Christi
Posted
1 hour ago, BarbaraTherese said:

If the baptized Catholic has been married in a civil ceremony then the marriage is valid in civil law but presumed invalid in Catholic Law.

If a Catholic marries in a non-Catholic ceremony without a dispensation, the marriage is not presumed to be invalid, it's KNOWN to be invalid.

This is different from situation where there might be a trial for nullity. If someone suspects that their marriage might be invalid because of some defect of consent or intention, they can request that the Church investigate their case in a nullity trial. However, in situations where canonical form (i.e., a Catholic wedding ceremony) is lacking, no investigation is even needed because the facts of the case are already obvious. 

Posted
56 minutes ago, Sponsa-Christi said:

If a Catholic marries in a non-Catholic ceremony without a dispensation, the marriage is not presumed to be invalid, it's KNOWN to be invalid.

This is different from situation where there might be a trial for nullity. If someone suspects that their marriage might be invalid because of some defect of consent or intention, they can request that the Church investigate their case in a nullity trial. However, in situations where canonical form (i.e., a Catholic wedding ceremony) is lacking, no investigation is even needed because the facts of the case are already obvious. 

My bad and my second bad today with a pile of ironing to be done urgently for client and with a vet appointment later today...........and they are not good either in my book!

  I'm not disagreeing with you, Sponsa, because the more I read the more confused I get but no time to quote some confusing matters from both EWTN and also the USCCB website on mixed marriages and Nuptial Mass or wedding Mass permissions for mixed marriages. Have noted the sites however and will return at some point.  Sites addresses: https://www.ewtn.com/library/MARRIAGE/MIXED.TXT and http://www.foryourmarriage.org/catholic-marriage/church-teachings/interfaith-marriages/

However, despite what the above sites state, no such statements at all from our Australian Catholic bishops that I could find.

A query only :  If a Catholic marries a non-Catholic in a non-Catholic ceremony and did not know that they could do so with a dispensation, although they knew in a vague sort of way (never been well educated in the Faith) that marrying outside The Church was wrong, is the marriage still not valid rather than presumed not valid?  Surely the disposition of the Catholic would speak to the issue of possible "presumed of invalid" - or is that also incorrect?

It is a confusing issue for sure and on such an important subject.

Were I considering marriage outside The Church and after what I have recently read, I would be asking advice from my bishop, rather than my pp I think.  I would probably be told to refer to my pp - and if so, I would first be consulting a canon lawyer who is also a priest and hopefully armed with sound and correct information when I consulted my pp as instructed.

I am sure that I signed nothing before I married, but my fiancé had to do so.

All the sites I read have stated that it is the Catholic who must sign - not the non Catholic.

I remember that it was my fiancé (non Catholic) who had to sign because he refused to do so and so I stated that we could not get married.  He eventually said he would sign but that it meant nothing to him.....later that is after the marriage.

HisChildForever
Posted

Barbara, it used to be that the non-Catholic party had to sign. Now it is on the Catholic. The non-Catholic just has to understand the Catholic's responsibilities when it comes to practicing the faith and raising children. It makes more sense this way, in my opinion.

Sponsa-Christi
Posted
4 minutes ago, BarbaraTherese said:

A query only :  If a Catholic marries a non-Catholic in a non-Catholic ceremony and did not know that they could do so with a dispensation, although they knew in a vague sort of way (never been well educated in the Faith) that marrying outside The Church was wrong, is the marriage still not valid rather than presumed not valid?  Surely the disposition of the Catholic would speak to the issue of possible "presumed of invalid" - or is that also incorrect?

If a Catholic marries in a non-Catholic ceremony without a dispensation, then the marriage is known to be invalid, full stop.

If the Catholic party only had a vague sense that this was something frowned upon, but didn't realize that this made the marriage invalid---then the marriage is still invalid, although the Catholic party might be less culpable due to their lack of understanding (e.g., subjectively they might be guilty of a venial rather than a mortal sin).

If the Catholic party didn't realize that it was possible to get a dispensation to marry validly outside the Church, then the marriage is still known to be invalid. 

If a Catholic somehow had no idea that marrying outside a Catholic ceremony was a problem, then they MIGHT be subjectively innocent of any sin (although one might ask why they didn't take more trouble. to learn about the faith on their own). However, the marriage is still known to be invalid. 

Basically, there aren't any scenarios when the Church would presume a marriage to be invalid. We might KNOW a marriage is invalid in certain circumstances, such as when canonical form isn't followed or after a declaration of nullity is issued. Individuals might SUSPECT that a marriage is invalid if they feel they have a case for a nullity trial.

But when the Church is presuming anything, it's presuming the validity of marriages where the canonical form is properly observed. That is, if everything is outwardly in order (i.e., a Catholic was either married in a Catholic ceremony or had a dispensation), the Church presumes the marriage is valid until it's proven otherwise. 

 

21 minutes ago, BarbaraTherese said:

Were I considering marriage outside The Church and after what I have recently read, I would be asking advice from my bishop, rather than my pp I think.  I would probably be told to refer to my pp - and if so, I would first be consulting a canon lawyer who is also a priest and hopefully armed with sound and correct information when I consulted my pp as instructed.

Not to be mean, but why would any good Catholic consider marriage outside the Church? Any Catholic thinking of marrying in any way at all really should be talking to their pp in any case.

If there was a special circumstance where marrying in a non-Catholic ceremony has some sort of pastoral advantage---like, you were marrying a Jew or a Muslim whose family was very opposed to the union---then a decent pp would certainly help you get the proper dispensations from the bishop.

That being said, though, it is the Church's very strong preference that Catholics marry other Catholics in a Catholic ceremony. If you're building a life with someone, it's only sensible to have a shared faith as the foundation of the union. 

Posted (edited)

Thank you, Sponsa (no props left just now).

It is very difficult in the extreme, I know, if one is Catholic and has fallen in love with a non Catholic who is saying all the right things to one and wants seemingly so much to marry.  I fell in love again and vv after my annulment but decided (with tremendous heartbreak and over a really long period far more than a year if I recall) in favour of private vows and ceased all contact with him though he begged me not to do so and almost 'stalked' me for a long time but I refused any and all attempts at contact. It broke my heart very literally. He was Catholic though not practising.  I still think of that man (now dec'd) with real appreciation to God for the type of person that he was.  I still love that man on a certain level.  He developed cancer which affected his ability to walk and eventually committed suicide (nothing to do with me, rather his inability to walk unaided).

Having been through all that including the pain of annulment (and to my children) no way would I ever consider marriage again without talking to a priest over a period, whether the man be Catholic or not - and this would be my strong advice to any person who asked me my opinion on the subject of Catholicism and marriage.  I have heard positive and negative reports about pre Cana courses and therefore I cannot comment.   Initially, my children thought that the annulment meant that they were born (one is a foster son) out of wedlock until once our relationship was restored in their twenties- my ex and family turned them against me due to mental illness and other factors including Catholicism (as human institution only) - when I was able to explain to them what the annulment actually meant for them and for and to me - and their Dad, with whom I now maintain a friendly type of relationship .  He remarried probably 20 years ago now and I am quite friendly with his wife nowadays - both non Catholic.  At the time, my children were too young not to be influenced by close and therefore powerful adults in their lives on the subject of mental illness as we now understand it - not back then culturally including in Catholic culture generally speaking.

Thankfully and gratefully, I got to know a priest religious and theologian who set me straight on so very much.

Please excuse me as no offence whatsoever is intended in the slightest- rather to state something important I think.   I think that one has to have fallen in love and know the agony of needing to refuse marriage to understand with absolute compassion, understanding and empathy of falling in love with a non Catholic knowing that ideally one is best to marry a faithful Catholic.  I do not think that those who have been lifelong celibates can fully grasp this if they have never fallen in love, let alone been married 15years with an active intimate life and (falsely) under the impression they were happily married.........not the actual extreme emotional content anyway coupled with the overwhelming psychological and indeed spiritual conflict.  I had a verbal 'tackle' with a Church Monsignor (priest) on this point (he was on the Annulment Tribunal) and eventually he conceded because he was a lifelong celibate and wanted to sprout Church Law at me full stop.  Of course, I desire and strive to live according to all Church teachings and laws and always have..........but at times the human element could make it extremely difficult indeed I now know very well indeed.  In fact, I never would have married my husband, but for my pp who intervened on his behalf and I took my pp's advice being none the wiser back then - i.e. "Yes, Father - how high, Father" in absolute sincerity and obedience to the letter.  Back in my Catholic home and education in my teens we were told to look upon our priests as Jesus walking on earth.

The above is certainly only my experience and therefore limited not general - but I certainly can compassionately look upon and embrace with empathy anyone with anything remotely similar.....reminds me of a saying of my dear Dad (dec'd) "Life is long and full of pitfalls" (similar to"mourning and weeping in this valley of tears" Hail Holy Queen prayer)

1 hour ago, HisChildForever said:

Barbara, it used to be that the non-Catholic party had to sign. Now it is on the Catholic. The non-Catholic just has to understand the Catholic's responsibilities when it comes to practicing the faith and raising children. It makes more sense this way, in my opinion.

 

Thanks, HCF! No props left just now.

 I really was wondering on the point since my dispensation came through insofar as I am aware through my Archbishop back then.  I read in recent research that the signed document by a Catholic had to be submitted to him at the time of requesting a dispensation.  But I didn't sign anything, but my fiancé had to do so. Now I know I had been told some things by my pp and priest who married me which were not quite correct theologically.  Hence I went into marriage with some 'wacky' type of information. Years down the line and while married, I consulted another priest and he confirmed what my pp had told me, as I was beginning to doubt things, to not understand. Hence I thought my doubts and not understanding were unfounded.

Edited by BarbaraTherese
Posted (edited)

I'm going to add this because I think it is some importance too.

I usually make my Easter Confession a reflection over the past year.  Not long before my serious psychotic bipolar episodes ceased though I did not realise then it would be ongoing in its' absence, I made my Easter Confession to a visiting priest I did not know who was hearing Confessions (unusually) before and after Mass too.  As I had been instructed I first stated I had a mental illness and had also made private vows:

It went like this:

"What on earth did you do that for?" (his literal statement)

"What Father?"

"Make private vows and by the way I have psychiatric treatment regularly too."

"I had advice first Father and from a priest who knew me well."

"And what would you do if you fell in love?" (I didn't tell him I had done so already and chosen my private vows)

Quote

My reply was like this: "It seems to me, Father, that to fall in love is a great gift of God since God is Love.  I would not know just by reflection what I would do but I know I would be in tremendous conflict on all levels."

"Mmmm" but no other comment.

I then went on to make my Confession.

At the end of my Confession, absolution & Penance, Father added "Well you seem to have your head screwed on to me. God bless and go in Peace" (literally - some things not even advanced age and breaking down brain cells can cause one to forget)

I had a giggle after and shared with my friend from next door who used to take me and bring me home from Sunday Mass and said to him after relating in confidence what had happened in the Confessional. Laughing I said: "What do you think?  Maybe we are both crazy!"  My pal knows my journey in full. He is now married in the Church - and his wife has now converted to Catholicism.  What a great day it was!!! They have a son now too.  They are very faithful Catholics and a beautiful family. We maintain contact and he and his wife and son were at my Home Mass to renew private life vows.

When I first met my pal next door, he was only 15yrs old.  I was out watering the garden and had no idea they were Catholics though not practising.  He came up to me and said very shyly (now he is the most outspoken person I know) "You go to Mass on Sunday, don't you".  I replied in the affirmative and then I used to walk to Mass and back.  "Could I come with you, I am saving for a car and we could go together".  I was delighted.  What a wonderful man he has grown into!

A funny story about him.  He is very money savvy and is about to purchase another house for investment.  When he was about 6 years old, his Dad told me that he had planted 5cents in the back garden to see if he could grow a money tree, because they were a poor family and his Dad was always saying "I don't have a money tree out the back".  I love that story.  Eventually after Mass I would join the family (his Mum and Dad and him) and we would have a cooked breakfast of bacon and eggs..........and the conversation was always about Catholicism.  Our parish had him pegged for the priesthood - me too actually, he was so devout and committed.  Then one day at Mass someone came up to me a little shocked and horrified "I saw ........... the other night kissing a girl out the front of his home."  That girl is now his wife and mother of his son.

They are still a very devout and totally committed practising Catholic family.  His Mum and Dad deceased.

Edited by BarbaraTherese
Posted

Thanks all for your replies. I've taken them to heart. When I initially wrote the post I was coming off of a 19 hour overnight shift so that sort of affects emotion and such. I feel a little bit better now, and more ready to take the necessary steps to address this. It's just needing to muster up the courage to talk about things.

Honestly, I think if I'm being selfish I would rather die than have this conversation. Not that I'd ever off myself, but if God were to give me the option of dying a noble death, I'd consider it. I feel like my existence hurts people, but my non-existence would be worse. Damned if I do, damned if I don't.

@Sponsa-Christi @Gabriela @Credo in DeumI hate to be that person to say "wah this is MY thread," and normally I don't care about threads going off topic, but as this topic is very personal to me, I don't really want it devolving into a debate about what marriages are real vs. valid and annulments and all of these other theoretical things that matter very little when the situation hits close to home.

I am acutely aware on the passages of the gospel about religion vs. family and taking up your cross and being hated for following Christ. Bringing them up to argue amongst yourselves about ethics is not helpful to me really. And again, I'm going to be selfish but I created this thread because it's hard finding people who share a similar worldview and I needed to discuss it online before taking it to the real world.

I don't mean to single you three out as the "bad apples" of the thread, because your responses have helped too, but I just think it's something to keep in mind when people talk about personal situations about what is a helpful response and what is not. I know there's the temptation to get in an argument about morality, but this is not the place and time. I don't need clarification on what an invalid marriage is. I get it. It's just like rubbing salt in the wound. I know that, because nobody knows my sister, it's easy to have the mental representation of her as being a "modernist/relativist/liberal" but people are more complex and while she espouses (no pun intended) some of these things there's also part of her that sees some of it as crazy. That's why I'm not so offended by the characterization. It's kind of funny how online we can sometimes assume we know more about people than we do. I do it too.

There is a remote possibility that maybe my sister will work something out so that I can in good conscience participate. She and her fiancé are both Catholic, but his attitude is sort of "well we're not practicing so why have a Church wedding, plus it's inconvenient etc" So I don't know. The wedding date is over a year away. That gives me a little breathing room to sort this out. Thanks again everyone for your words and especially your prayers.

Posted
On 6/18/2016 at 2:51 PM, Anomaly said:

Ice, 

I don't think it's good for you, or is respectful of your relationship with your sister to boycott the wedding . . .  You should get experienced and competent advice.   Don't expect that from Internet personas.  

I'm worried that it would come off this way. Look, people don't consult me very often, or ever, when making their life decisions. There are very few times I discuss my beliefs because 90% of the time people are not open to it and I don't want to waste oxygen (although when people are open, they can usually respect my more nuanced beliefs more than what they thought I believed). But anyway my point is that I usually keep my mouth shut, unless people ask my opinion. In which case, since I always have an opinion, I'm more than happy to share.

However, asking me to participate or go to a wedding which I essentially believe is not "real" is asking me to bear witness to something. It's about me being honest about what I believe. Acting like nothing is wrong, that doesn't sit well with me. I'm usually a coward, but I can blame minor lapses in everyday life as weakness/anxiety. But I have to sit with this decision for over  a year. I can't tell God "oops flight of the moment decision sorry I didn't stand up for what I believe in because fight-or-flight and . . . sorry).

But good advice otherwise.

On 6/18/2016 at 4:24 PM, little2add said:

truth hurts. 

yep.

On 6/18/2016 at 5:23 PM, dUSt said:

If I was in your shoes I'd tell my sister why I couldn't stand up in the wedding, but will be there in attendance to support her as my sister (not the ceremony).

That seems worse. What bothers me more is I already said I would be her maid of honor. I was kind of put on the spot as it was in front of other people when she asked me (not intentionally so, I think it was just assumed I would say yes). So having to renege on that just makes me feel more like a pos.

On 6/19/2016 at 10:43 AM, Anomaly said:

Gabriela, 

 Nihil's situation, since he is a healthy and independent adult, is much different than Ice's situation with her sister. 

HEY! I'm a semi-independent, sort of healthy adult.

On 6/19/2016 at 4:53 PM, beatitude said:

I think this is a really difficult decision to have to make. Ice, you have my prayers.

You're awe.some

On 6/19/2016 at 9:44 PM, Norseman82 said:

As I pointed out in Nihil's thread, a version of the Baltimore Catechism contained the admonition that we are not to attend weddings of Catholics who were married by non-Catholic ministers, nor should we even give gifts.

Yeah and Church law didn't used to require canonical form for validity. Now she does. If I really wanted to go retro there wouldn't be any conflict here in the first place.

IgnatiusofLoyola
Posted

I'm glad to hear that you have a year until the wedding. This gives you more time to pray about it, and more time to talk with your family about the issues. Since you have a year, that gives you time to prepare your sister for the fact that you might not stand up with her at her wedding, and help her understand the reasons why.

This is a really tough situation. To me, it's made even more tough by the fact that, in at least a couple of cases, Jesus broke the "rules" in order to show love. For example, I know that for at least some of us, breaking the law of kosher (as Jesus did when he shared meals with prostitutes) doesn't seem an issue that is close in importance to potentially being viewed as supporting a non-sacramental/invalid marriage. But, in Jesus' time and in his community, keeping kosher was HUGELY important. Even today, orthodox Jews who keep kosher will not eat at a home that doesn't keep kosher, even if it is the home of a family member. And, Jesus was heavily criticized by the Pharisees for breaking the kosher laws.

From my non-Catholic viewpoint, I would at least consider the option that love for your sister trumps the "rules" in this situation. Anyone who knows you knows your beliefs, and you can explain your decision to anyone who asks. This is your sister's WEDDING. One view is that the attention should be focused on the couple, not on your beliefs. Your absence will be noticeable, and may not necessarily make the positive statement about the importance of your beliefs that you intend it to make. It might be different if this was a friend or a distant relative, but this is your SISTER.

I've been trying to think of a similar situation......For example, what would be your response if your sister got pregnant out of wedlock? I can't imagine that you would shun your sister because of this, but would continue to love her and love your new niece or nephew. Your views on having children out of wedlock wouldn't change, but that wouldn't keep you from acting in a loving way.

The reason I decided to post this was not to diss your beliefs and the great difficulties you are facing in figuring out what to do. I simply wanted to express that not standing up for your sister might send the non-Catholics in the congregation a negative message about Catholicism. Sometimes actions that make perfect sense to someone who is well-versed in Catholic theology seem strange, or judgemental, to someone who is not familiar with, or doesn't share these beliefs. As a long-time Phatmass member, I have learned to ask the theological reasoning behind certain actions because it helps the actions make more sense to me. But, I'm not a typical non-Catholic in that way.

As for me, I won't bring this up again, and I will support you and pray for you WHATEVER you decide to do. This decision is ONLY between you and God (and your family), and anyone else who knows you well whose opinion you want to solicit (such as a trusted priest or other spiritual advisor).

<Hugs>

Posted (edited)

A decision either way could have any result or results whatsoever.  Being involved in the actual circumstances and close relationships with people intimately involved may give the one who is deciding more accurate information than one commenting as a complete outsider, insofar as the potential affect and effect on people actually intimately involved in a situation are concerned. But it would be only ever be "potential effect".  :I "expect the unexpected" whenever I set about anticipating the future/predicting the future.

  I try to be wary too of manipulating or attempting to do so, even with the best of results as the objective of manipulation.   There might also be other results entirely on those outside the circumstances or the 'observers', the community of participating observers outside those intimately involved.  We have no control over these things and manipulations often do not have the results one had hoped to bring about.

In actuality it must be a 'lonely decision' accepting sole responsibility and accountability......seeking wise advice/opinion is always a good move - but advice/opinion is all it can be......

I agree with Ignatius.............

On ‎23‎/‎06‎/‎2016 at 8:05 AM, IgnatiusofLoyola said:

I will support you and pray for you WHATEVER you decide to do. This decision is ONLY between you and God (and your family), and anyone else who knows you well whose opinion you want to solicit (such as a trusted priest or other spiritual advisor).

:like2:

Edited by BarbaraTherese
Nihil Obstat
Posted

Fallout so far has been bad. Might get worse. But, "I can do all these things in him who strengtheneth me."

Posted
6 hours ago, Nihil Obstat said:

Fallout so far has been bad. Might get worse. But, "I can do all these things in him who strengtheneth me."

Praying for you, brother.

Nihil Obstat
Posted

So far this is rather like how sometimes a broken bone has to be re-broken in order to prevent it from healing in a worse condition than before. Hopefully the healing does actually follow the re-breaking. We shall see.

Posted

It can be hard to tell the emperor that he has no clothes. 

Posted (edited)

Isn't a unofficial marriage a vast  improvement over living together?  Sure it's not blessed but it is a big step in the right direction.   

There is the real possibility of children born out of wedlock, what about them?

being each other's maid of honor is a presious thing and it would be a shame to not follow your heart.   Not to say that you should bite your  tongue  and not tell her how you feel ...

speak your mind, oviiously you love your sister and what best for her.

Edited by little2add
Posted (edited)

Probably only those who have to make the big decision I.e to attend or not attend are aware of the perhaps quite personal circumstances as to why a child might choose to marry outside The Church.  These circumstances could be many and varied depending on the person getting married for one - and their partner.  If a child chooses to marry outside The Church because they reject their Catholicism outright, might be different from the one who does not.  Why would a person who does not reject his or her Catholicism marry outside The Church ?.......... again the reasons might be many.

Falling in love can be a risky business putting a person in a vulnerable position and falling in love is not a decision of the will, it just happens.  While the result of that falling in love is a decision of one's will (possibly under stress).  I think personally that falling in love is an apt statement.  It is very easy to write that a person should choose their Faith over and above all things - it is another matter entirely when one is actually in a 'damned if I do and damned if I don't' type of situation,faced with the need to choose. For some life is black and white and that can be the easy way at times, while some might need to find their way in the grey where all is murky and unclear, without real clarity to resolve.

Indeed: "Who am I to judge?" anyone else at all.............I have enough problems of my own which will meet Judgement by The Divine Judge, who is all Love and Mercy is our informed Hope. 

Quote

Psalm 51 - Miserere  - http://www.usccb.org/bible/psalms/51 - "That you may be justified when you give sentence and be without reproach when you judge. O see, in guilt was I born, a sinner was I conceived."

 

Edited by BarbaraTherese

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...