Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

The Ultimate Super-sized XXL Marriage Thread Plus


Recommended Posts

Posted

I just read on Facebook that the Pope said today most marriages are invalid. Something I've said for a long time. 

Posted

I once declined to attend a same-sex wedding.  They were friends with my sister and I didn't know them at all but I was visiting from out of town so they told her to invite me.  My sister was uncomfortable telling them the real reason why I wouldn't go so she made up some story but if I had to tell them directly, I'd tell them that as much as I appreciate their kindness and consideration in inviting me, I couldn't in good conscience attend a wedding which is contrary to my religious beliefs.

I realize that this is not on the same level as your situation Nihil but I should also add that I have a gay cousin and I've wondered what will happen if someday he decides to get "married".  I would have to decline that as well and I have a feeling it would cause big problems in my family.  It's not an easy decision but I would be as polite as possible and tell them the truth.

 

Nihil Obstat
Posted

Ok, I will start responding to a few posts in greater depth now. If I do not reply to your post and you think I should, unless you are Anomaly, please let me know because I probably just missed it.

Posted
2 hours ago, Nihil Obstat said:

It is 'not for me to know' why the last two precepts were neglected. :P  but the Catechism is not and never claimed to be an entirely exhaustive source, to my understanding.

Not in the Catechism. Sounds like a perfectly good loophole to me. No mortal sin because you didn't know.

Nihil Obstat
Posted
3 hours ago, Peace said:

Hmm. If a news reporter attended to report on the wedding, would that be participation? I don't think that being there in and of itself is an endorsement.

I think the situation of a news reporter introduces irrelevant variables into the equation. Attending in a professional capacity in order to work in an occupation that is public by nature, I think that affects moral considerations with regards to attendance and the message that is sent thereby.

3 hours ago, IgnatiusofLoyola said:

I'm sympathetic to Nihil's family dilemma. It must be a big deal to him or he wouldn't have posted about it.

I'm also not sure that a family wedding is the best place to make a theological point. Love for family should be the guiding principle. No one is going to be impressed by a statement of faith that consists of not attending a wedding. If anything, it could give a bad impression of the Roman Catholic Church to all the non-Catholics (and non-practicing Catholics) in attendance. Whether the wedding is valid or not, if you care about the couple and don't want to make a scene at their wedding, I'd vote for laying low and saying nothing. You don't have to make grand statements about supporting the wedding, either. Just say nothing, or say that you hope they are happy and any other non-theological statements you can make without lying.

I DO like the idea of only attending the reception, however. Is there ANY way you could pull this off without being blatant about it? To me at least, a wedding reception is a secular event, separate from the wedding. I assume that if the couple had held a party celebrating their marriage that was completely separate from the wedding, you would have attended.

I'm really sorry you're facing this dilemma, Nihil. I'll pray for you. Unfortunately, I have years of personal experience dealing with a difficult family--including people not attending weddings of other family members on the basis of beliefs and principles. Heck, my mother-in-law didn't even attend MY wedding, even though, (on its face, at least),  it was completely in line with all the Catholic rules, including Bishop permissions, etc. etc.

Hang in there! <hugs>

I agree that a wedding is not the time to make a theological point, but I do not believe that this is what I am doing. Both attending and not attending have moral implications and either choice is a conscious decision on my part. If anything, to attend sends a stronger message because of the public nature of the event and due to the fact that not attending is, more strictly speaking, a lack of action whereas attending is very much an act on my part.

I do not really expect, nor do I need other guests to understand or be impressed by my decision. Frankly I do not think anybody in my family will agree with my choice. Literally not one. However I am very concerned for the soul of the person whose wedding this is, and in the end this person is forcing me to make this choice. Do I attend a public event which is contrary to the teachings of the Church this person has abandoned and in which I believe unconditionally? Or do I follow my conscience, decline to attend, and express to this person my grave and abiding fear for the state of their soul?

It will certainly not be a grand statement. Ideally I would not want anyone to know. Ideally even the couple getting married would not even know I did not come. But such a situation is not realistic, because this is a family, and we are all local to each other.

I forget if I posted this already. I will attend the reception if offered, but I do not believe that will remain an option.

I appreciate your sympathy, Iggy. :) I am sure you understand family drama on a much more intimate level than I do.

3 hours ago, CatherineM said:

I have attended weddings that made me uncomfortable. I've refused to participate in them. I have only refused to attend gay marriages. In all cases I've attended the receptions. If I love someone, I want to wish them well, and complicated marriages need all the help they can get. I won't attend a wedding where the marriage can never be blessed by the Church, but attend those that could possibly be blessed in the future with the couple taking care of their paperwork. 

I wish this couple nothing but good, but unfortunately, both for them and for me in different ways, what is best is absolutely contrary to what they believe they want. Because again, this is not a marriage. This is not simply a paperwork issue. This is a marriage which is invalid several times over, and any kind of reconciliation with the Church will take serious effort and major changes in lifestyle. This may as well be a homosexual marriage, although it is not.

3 hours ago, McM RSCJ said:

Some questions to ponder as you decide. . . . Or you may have better questions. . . .

1.  What do you hope to achieve by not going?

  • If your answer is you hope they will understand you do not believe they will be married, then isn't it possible you have already made them aware that is your belief?
  • If you hope to make clear you choose your belief that God does not consider them married over their belief they are indeed marrying, isn't it possible you have already made that clear to them?

2.  You are praying through the intercession of St. Monica.  Have you thought about having a prayerful imaginative conversation with her?  You could ask her if she ruptured family ties with Augustine during those long years?  Why or why not?

3.  Why do you base your decision on your priest's approach?  Can you come to inner freedom and peace in your decision, on the basis of the prompting of your own conscience?

4.  Finally, if you think God wants you to do this, what image or understanding of God are you invoking?  And how can you know that God has not, in his unconditional love and providential care for each of them, brought them into one another's lives as pure gift?

What do I hope to achieve? For myself, nothing. This is not what I want nor does it make me happy. This is a question of living in accordance with Church teaching and my conscience which is formed by it. I will certainly try to have the couple understand my reasons for not attending, however whether they understand or not is immaterial if they persist in carrying out this event. In addition, this is a case where presumably the Catholic half of this couple does know what the Church teaches, therefore does know what I believe, and is choosing to follow through with this anyway. Neither is this an acceptable state of affairs.

"Imaginative conversation" with St. Monica, thank you but no. Sounds like an excellent way to project my own preferences, which are irrelevant and generally unreliable.

In terms of my decisions being based on my priest. Some time ago I made a conscious decision that I will trust my priests' pastoral guidance. Specifically, these priests of the Priestly Fraternity of St. Peter, because in my experience thus far they are trustworthy men with a great love for the Church and Her teachings. So in general I have decided that for myself and my family, when we have difficult moral and religious questions we will bring them to our priests, and consider obedience to their guidance as being in accordance with God's will for us. Within reason of course, because I harbour no illusions that these men are perfect as Christ was. In addition to that, these men are appointed by my bishop as my pastors, and all things being equal I believe that I owe them my obedience in that capacity. They do have legitimate authority over me, and I am attempting to recognize that.

So when my priest teaches me, I listen. I have made a serious effort in my life to do as they have taught.

And yes, when I live in this manner, with this concept of obedience, my conscience is exceptionally clear. This attitude has so far not led me wrong even for a moment.

For the last bit, all I know is this. God cannot contradict Himself, therefore He cannot contradict His own laws. I know, objectively, that this union flatly contradicts God's Law. In that respect, further analysis is not required.

2 hours ago, Maggyie said:

That's a good point Peace. A case can be made that attending a wedding is not necessarily an endorsement. Is there any official teaching (like, document level) on this?

Fr Z provides the following advice (in part)

QUAERITUR: What is our goal in approaching these difficult wedding situations?

We want to stand up for the truth, proclaim the beauty of the Catholic position, remain firm in our own faith, and avoid causing scandal. We want the bride and the groom, if Catholic, to see their wedding as a means of their own sanctification. We want those who are lapsed from the faith to return to a regular practice of it, and those who are outside of the Church to enter Her loving embrace. We want to keep our families and friends close and supportive of each other. We want to avoid tensions and stress and rather enjoy the time of the wedding as a graced time of happiness and love. That’s a pretty tall order.

We need to honestly ask ourselves some questions:

What would it mean if I attended this wedding? What would people think (especially and primarily my children, my spouse, my close family, the bride and groom)? What would avoiding this wedding mean? What would people think/conclude? Will my actions (attending or avoiding) help to draw anyone closer to Jesus Christ? If the marriage situation is less-than ideal, is it something that can be later fixed (e.g., a baptized Catholic couple marrying outside the Church, but who later could have their marriage sanated, versus a same-sex couple who’s “marriage” can never be recognized as such)?

linky http://wdtprs.com/blog/2015/07/ask-father-can-i-attend-this-invalid-wedding/

 

Yes, I read Fr. Z's article a few times, both the last time this came up, and more recently. With references to my priest's own teaching to his parish, I do not have any doubt as to the correct choice in this instance.

3 minutes ago, Peace said:

Not in the Catechism. Sounds like a perfectly good loophole to me. No mortal sin because you didn't know.

In either case, the question of precepts in the Catechism is a distraction. Whether or not they are enumerated in that manner, it is clear to me that going against the Church's teachings with regards to marriage is objectively grave matter. Full knowledge will always be subjective, but in this case it is not relevant.

HisChildForever
Posted

If you don't attend and immediate family ostracize you for it, including the couple in question, that sort of ruins any future evangelization opportunities for you and causes family hardship. I think I read somewhere about the fallout of not attending causing greater harm than if you actually attended.

Nihil Obstat
Posted
22 minutes ago, HisChildForever said:

If you don't attend and immediate family ostracize you for it, including the couple in question, that sort of ruins any future evangelization opportunities for you and causes family hardship. I think I read somewhere about the fallout of not attending causing greater harm than if you actually attended.

That is a possibility, but I believe the risk in this case is unavoidable. The risk itself does not seem to justify my own complicity.

PhuturePriest
Posted
1 hour ago, Peace said:

Not in the Catechism. Sounds like a perfectly good loophole to me. No mortal sin because you didn't know.

Uh, no. That's not even kind of how it works. :P If you know, it doesn't matter where it's stated and not stated, the fact is that you still *know*, regardless of where you learned it.

Posted

My understanding is that the omission of the sixth precept from the Catechism was deliberate, given the Church's current position on interfaith marriage (ok with the correct permissions). I think I've read somewhere that there have been different lists of precepts used at different times anyway. Not that this has any bearing on the subject at hand. It's pretty clearly grave matter regardless.

Posted

it seems that the decision has been made to not attend leaving the tricky part of telling that to the couple!  Prayers that you find the right words to tell them that and that they one day clean up all the loose ends of their other marriages. 

Sponsa-Christi
Posted
25 minutes ago, Maggyie said:

My understanding is that the omission of the sixth precept from the Catechism was deliberate, given the Church's current position on interfaith marriage (ok with the correct permissions).

If you marry outside of a Catholic ceremony and you do have the proper permissions, then naturally this is still "obeying the Church's marriage laws."

I'm wondering if this wasn't included in that section of the Catechism because the Church's marriage laws overlap so heavily with basic moral theology. The other precepts of the Church listed there are somewhat more "arbitrary," in terms of not being obligations you could discern on your own simply by pondering the moral law. 

Nihil Obstat
Posted
5 minutes ago, vee said:

it seems that the decision has been made to not attend leaving the tricky part of telling that to the couple!  Prayers that you find the right words to tell them that and that they one day clean up all the loose ends of their other marriages. 

Yes, that is the gist of it. :) Thank you for the prayers.

Posted
1 hour ago, Nihil Obstat said:

I think the situation of a news reporter introduces irrelevant variables into the equation. Attending in a professional capacity in order to work in an occupation that is public by nature, I think that affects moral considerations with regards to attendance and the message that is sent thereby.

Well I was just trying to make the point that attendance does not necessarily mean endorsement. I would guess that in the world you live folks know that you are a practicing Catholic and that you don't endorse it.  I would think that if people saw you there they would think that it is because that you would not want your relatives feelings to be hurt by your absence. 

If I have a kid and he wants to play Football even though I don't approve and think it is too dangerous, I might still go to his game just to show him some general love. It doesn't necessarily mean that I am OK with him playing the sport.

1 hour ago, Nihil Obstat said:

In either case, the question of precepts in the Catechism is a distraction. Whether or not they are enumerated in that manner, it is clear to me that going against the Church's teachings with regards to marriage is objectively grave matter. Full knowledge will always be subjective, but in this case it is not relevant.

I am not convinced that your conclusion is correct, but if you believe that your attendance at the wedding is sin then I can't fault you for not attending. You should follow your conscience.

Nihil Obstat
Posted

Perception of my attending or not attending is only secondary. The primary issue is that attendance seems at least dangerously close to formal cooperation. Declining to attend is first an act of fidelity to church teaching, and only second is it a 'statement'.

Posted (edited)
5 hours ago, Sponsa-Christi said:

But you're right . . .

Music to my ears.

Quote

But when you're questioning whether disobeying the Church's marriage laws is grave matter, do you mean just the act of entering into an invalid marriage per se (like, a Catholic marrying someone civilly "on paper" for immigration purposes?), or are you talking about marriage in the normal full sense of the term?

I mean marriage in the normal full sense of the term. Me and my girlfriend of two years go to Vegas and elope. Am I going to the hothouse for eternity for that?  I don't know. But given the frequency with which this happens, you would think that there would be some official document somewhere that indicates that it is grave matter. You would think that there would be an explicit, clear teaching on the matter. The Church just wouldn't want folks going to their peril unknowingly would She?

Perhaps such a document exists. Are you aware of one?

Quote

Because even apart from whether or not obeying the Church's marriage laws is a precept of the Church, a normal invalid marriage is grave matter from a moral theology standpoint. A couple in an invalid marriage are not actually married at all in the Church's eyes, so if they engage in "the marital act" while not actually married, then this is the sin of fornication (or adultery in the case of some second weddings), which itself is grave matter even apart from any other consideration. 

I am not sure if Church approval / non-approval really has any bearing on whether there is a sacramental marriage as far as God is concerned.

From what I understand, the requirement for Church approval has not existed in all points in time. But I don't think that God's requirements for a sacrament can vary with time.

You also have a difference in treatment between Catholics and non-Catholics.  If two non-Catholics go to Vegas and elope, the Church considers that as a valid marriage.  If the husband or the wife was unknowingly baptized as a Catholic at 1 month old, adopted by a nice protestant couple at 2 months old, and lived his/her entire life as a protestant with absolutely no knowledge of his Catholic baptism an living his life as a good Lutheran, the Church would consider that an invalid marriage. But how could the fact of whether the marriage is truly valid in the eyes of God vary depending based on whether a person was baptized by a Catholic or Lutheran priest?

Take the annulment process as another example.  Are these determinations infallible? I do not think so. Plenty of dioceses in the USA hand out annulments like they are candy.  You could have the same exact couple. The same exact set of circumstances.  The husband asks for an annulment in Poland and is denied. A person under identical circumstances asks for an annulment in Florida and has it granted. Now, if the circumstances are exactly the same, how can there be a valid marriage in the eyes of God in one circumstance, but not in another circumstance, because of the personal whims of the particular priests who preside over the annulment process in each country?

What I am trying to get at here, is that I do not think that the Church confers marriage on a couple.  It recognizes marriages.  That is, it makes fallible determinations as to whether a true marriage is present, but those determinations  do not in and of themselves have any bearing on whether there is truly a marriage.

So, moving on to your point, let's say that a Catholic person named A gets "married" to B in a Church, "divorced" and then marries "C".  If a Church official incorrectly makes a determination that A and B were never truly married in the eyes of God and grants an annulment, do A and C commit adultery?  Yes. I think so. But their culpability is reduced because they operated under the assumption that they were not married, based upon what the Church told them.  If A and B were never truly married in the eyes of God but a Church official makes an incorrect determination that they were married and denies their annulment, do A and C commit adultery?  I don't think so, because neither of them was truly married in the first place. In this case you do not have adultery, you have a violation of a precept of a Church. And based on the conspicuous absence of the marriage laws among the precepts listed in the Catechism, there would seem to be some doubt about whether violating that (alleged) precept would be a grave matter at all.

This is all just my speculation on the topic, of course. But I think it is just as good as any of the other speculations going on in this thread.

38 minutes ago, Nihil Obstat said:

Perception of my attending or not attending is only secondary. The primary issue is that attendance seems at least dangerously close to formal cooperation. Declining to attend is first an act of fidelity to church teaching, and only second is it a 'statement'.

OK. If you believe it is an act of fidelity to Church teaching I can respect that. But again, I am not convinced that is the case. But again, you have to follow your conscience on it. I respect that.

Edited by Peace
Posted
9 hours ago, franciscanheart said:

 

I'm genuinely curious what conclusion you came to that makes it okay for you to participate by attendance in some but not others.

A civil marriage could be a first step in a journey that leads closer to the truth, while a polygamous marriage is a step in the opposite direction. 

Nihil Obstat
Posted
56 minutes ago, Peace said:

 

OK. If you believe it is an act of fidelity to Church teaching I can respect that. But again, I am not convinced that is the case. But again, you have to follow your conscience on it. I respect that.

Likewise at least in some sense I think it would be an act of perfidy against church teaching in this case for me to attend. At least in a limited manner.

Posted

It's interesting that a lot of people are saying go to the reception if you don't feel comfortable going to the ceremony. Personally, I would go to both or neither (unless there was some other sort of extenuating circumstance). It just seems rude to me to skip the ceremony, but then show up for the party. 

I don't have any other advice, but you and your family will be in my prayers, Nihil. 

Posted

To quote an aunt of mine, "Go! And give them a rosary for a wedding present!" 

NadaTeTurbe
Posted

You have my prayers. I had to cut off contact with a part of my family because they were too much involved in corrida (a spanish sport where you torture a poor bull for hours, strictly condemned by the Church). It's still hard and what helped me was reading the life of the Saints (specially St Bernadette), who were rejected by their family because of their convictions. 

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...