CatherineM Posted September 12, 2016 Posted September 12, 2016 I don't want this to be a debate about if gay men should be priests. I want to talk about gay men who are already ordained. I was invited to an episcopal ordination for someone who is gay and I'm opting out. Before you ask, yes I know him personally and I know for a fact he is gay. At first I was surprised and as the day approaches I find myself getting angry. I'm not sure if that's an appropriate response, but it's an honest one.
hotpink Posted September 12, 2016 Posted September 12, 2016 I don't see how this is an issue, so long as he stands by and respects the church's values. I've know non-gay priests who were so sympathetic they did convalidation for gay couples. Thats a more of a serious issue. Not only that, the responsibility of those who are ordanining him. If they are aware, and you know they are aware, you cannot be a gatekeeper. There may be something that you are not aware of.
<3 PopeFrancis Posted September 12, 2016 Posted September 12, 2016 (edited) I think it's honest and appropriate. I'll tell you why appropriate. When I have a conflict in going to an event, I say "well would it be beneficial to this or that person/people if I go or more if I do not (perhaps, because I'm angry or unresolved about anything)? Edited September 12, 2016 by <3 PopeFrancis
hotpink Posted September 12, 2016 Posted September 12, 2016 Oh, I also didn't mean to say you should go. I think that you're probably very right in the decision. Either the Bishop doesn't know/has been fooled or he's making a choice to go against church law purposely or he's acting within Church law for some reason that the public doesn't know (but probably should to avoid scandal). I think this would be akin to being invited to a Catholic wedding where you knew one party had a previous marriage. Without being told that that party had it annulled or declared invalid, you shouldn't be going. You know it's wrong. Your level of knowledge precipitates how much duty you have in informing the priest, etc
Quasar Posted September 12, 2016 Posted September 12, 2016 (edited) I think in the context of priesthood, Christ can turn someone's shortcomings into a gift. A gay priest might have a unique understanding of what it means to struggle with sin, or what it means to feel left out. I can see these becoming strengths in a mature, chaste person. Edited September 12, 2016 by Quasar
Makarioi Posted September 12, 2016 Posted September 12, 2016 God calls everyone from all ways and walks of life to follow Him. Above the doors of my church, in capitals, it says 'ALL ARE WELCOME'.
hotpink Posted September 12, 2016 Posted September 12, 2016 4 minutes ago, Makarioi said: God calls everyone from all ways and walks of life to follow Him. Above the doors of my church, in capitals, it says 'ALL ARE WELCOME'. Welcome doesn't mean equal. We don't let children serve at the alter until they receive communion. We don't let people who can't speak be the cantor. We don't allow women to be priests. We don't allow men to be nuns. Men can't give birth to children. Those who are not baptized cannot be a godparent and it many cases diocese also require the person to be confirmed. So welcome =/= to everyone can do whatever they want. The young man is free to attend Mass and be a part of the community, but in ordinary circumstances he's not able to become a priest.
Anomaly Posted September 13, 2016 Posted September 13, 2016 Out of a general curiosity, how can you tell if a priest is gay or not? Aren't all priests supposed to be celibate and not dating or engaging in Public or Private Acts of Affection whether with males, females, or minors?
CatherineM Posted September 13, 2016 Author Posted September 13, 2016 I'm not going to discuss how I know, but I'm sure. I would like too know if the Pope was made aware of it before his promotion.
HisChildForever Posted September 13, 2016 Posted September 13, 2016 Are you not attending because he is a homosexual, or because he is supportive of that lifestyle and would himself be open to a relationship? (This is under the assumption that this particular denomination supports gay marriage and permit married clergy.)
Quasar Posted September 13, 2016 Posted September 13, 2016 Well my understanding was that celibate gay men could be priests. Someone correct me if I'm wrong.
Lefebvre Posted September 13, 2016 Posted September 13, 2016 6 minutes ago, Quasar said: Well my understanding was that celibate gay men could be priests. Someone correct me if I'm wrong. I know that 'my' diocese (Arlington) doesn't allow those with 'disordered sexualities' to become priests...
EmilyAnn Posted September 13, 2016 Posted September 13, 2016 A Church of England bishop recently came out as gay. The CofE had known before his ordination and requires homosexual clergy to be celibate. Assuming the context of a celiibate priesthood, why does it matter? Surely having the witness and example of a gay person living a holy, celibate life is a good thing for gay people that might be struggling with their faith and sexuality.
MIKolbe Posted September 13, 2016 Posted September 13, 2016 You say you find yourself getting angry. Expand on this...
Maggyie Posted September 13, 2016 Posted September 13, 2016 I think technically gay men are not to be ordained due to any "effective immaturity" in their sexuality. I don't think this is a hard and fast rule and there are plenty of fine gay priests I'm sure. Definitely takes extra discernment on the part of the candidate and diocese etc. But the priesthood is demanding enough without having to also balance that cross. The episcopacy, definitely. From what Catherine is saying I can deduce that this is probably not a situation where the person is simply privately bearing their cross. There's something more there. But I understand not getting into it on a public forum. FWIW there's a situation I've run into in a parish I belonged to, where it was kind of an open secret about things that had happened and were in fact still happening. I was always upset about it and wondered if anyone had told the bishop. I thought they must have, because not just we in the parish but the rest of the town "knew." I was finally clued in by a non Catholic friend who had done some business with the pastor. if they made that fellow a bishop I would be quite angry.
CatherineM Posted September 13, 2016 Author Posted September 13, 2016 I guess I'm angry because Pope Francis was supposed to be getting rid of the supposed gay mafia in the Vatican. Making a gay man a bishop isn't going in the right direction.
Anomaly Posted September 13, 2016 Posted September 13, 2016 My point was intended to not differentiate between gay or hetero, if one is discussing a priest. Either you are celibate and act properly chaste, or not! What your temptations are is irrelevant. All humans are tempted to do things we know you shouldn't. Either you are mostly successful at it, or not. It's BS to think you're allowed a different standard for your "special" wants I can't imagine why a priest needs to make known their sexual temptations as an important part of their identity. It should be irrelevant. It is a bit disgusting that this is a point of debate within the Catholic Church, but not surprising to me.
Amppax Posted September 13, 2016 Posted September 13, 2016 23 hours ago, CatherineM said: I don't want this to be a debate about if gay men should be priests. I want to talk about gay men who are already ordained. I was invited to an episcopal ordination for someone who is gay and I'm opting out. Before you ask, yes I know him personally and I know for a fact he is gay. At first I was surprised and as the day approaches I find myself getting angry. I'm not sure if that's an appropriate response, but it's an honest one. 2 What are you angry about in this situation? Of all the people on this forum, I would trust you to handle this better than most, so don't be hard on yourself. When you say he's gay, do you mean he's in a relationship or acting on his orientation? If that is the case I can certainly see it as a problem, or even if he particularly identifies with it. I'm assuming that the problem is something of that nature? I can see why that would make you angry, as Maggyie said.
Nihil Obstat Posted September 14, 2016 Posted September 14, 2016 8 hours ago, CatherineM said: I guess I'm angry because Pope Francis was supposed to be getting rid of the supposed gay mafia in the Vatican. Making a gay man a bishop isn't going in the right direction. That dossier was round filed the moment Francis sat at his new desk, let us not kid ourselves.
WhiteLily Posted September 14, 2016 Posted September 14, 2016 On September 12, 2016 at 5:03 PM, CatherineM said: I don't want this to be a debate about if gay men should be priests. I want to talk about gay men who are already ordained. I was invited to an episcopal ordination for someone who is gay and I'm opting out. Before you ask, yes I know him personally and I know for a fact he is gay. At first I was surprised and as the day approaches I find myself getting angry. I'm not sure if that's an appropriate response, but it's an honest one. If you find yourself becoming angry or you don't have any peace with the situation, you do not need to be there. You do not need to give an explanation. The best thing you can do is pray for him and his conversion. Ask our Blessed Mother to intercede for him and offer your penance for him. He needs your prayers.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now