CatherineM Posted September 14, 2016 Author Posted September 14, 2016 I didn't go. I wasn't missed. The place was more than full of his adoring fans. Funny thing is that my biggest issue with him is that he hates having to deal with or be around the mentally ill. He's being made an auxiliary for an inner city area in a large city with lots of homeless, so of course he won't have to be troubled by any scary schizophrenics.
Gabriela Posted September 14, 2016 Posted September 14, 2016 11 hours ago, Nihil Obstat said: That dossier was round filed the moment Francis sat at his new desk, let us not kid ourselves. You lost me. Can you explain this?
truthfinder Posted September 14, 2016 Posted September 14, 2016 1 hour ago, Gabriela said: You lost me. Can you explain this? "round filed" means tossed in the trash
Gabriela Posted September 14, 2016 Posted September 14, 2016 1 hour ago, truthfinder said: "round filed" means tossed in the trash Aha. Thank you. I did not know that! But which dossier are we talking about? I don't even know which bishop or case we're discussing. Not following news much these days...
Nihil Obstat Posted September 14, 2016 Posted September 14, 2016 19 minutes ago, Gabriela said: Aha. Thank you. I did not know that! But which dossier are we talking about? I don't even know which bishop or case we're discussing. Not following news much these days... That whole 'lavender mafia' dealio that was right at the forefront in the months before Benedict's resignation. There was talk that Pope Benedict had in his possession a very extensive file on the subject which he left for his successor. Never to be mentioned again.
Gabriela Posted September 14, 2016 Posted September 14, 2016 3 minutes ago, Nihil Obstat said: That whole 'lavender mafia' dealio that was right at the forefront in the months before Benedict's resignation. There was talk that Pope Benedict had in his possession a very extensive file on the subject which he left for his successor. Never to be mentioned again. Ooooooohhhhhhh.........
<3 PopeFrancis Posted September 15, 2016 Posted September 15, 2016 On 9/12/2016 at 6:56 PM, hotpink said: Either the Bishop doesn't know/has been fooled or he's making a choice to go against church law purposely or or ... I think the Episcopalian Church believes in homosexuality 11 hours ago, CatherineM said: I didn't go. I wasn't missed. The place was more than full of his adoring fans. Funny thing is that my biggest issue with him is that he hates having to deal with or be around the mentally ill. He's being made an auxiliary for an inner city area in a large city with lots of homeless, so of course he won't have to be troubled by any scary schizophrenics. It's sad because there is a priest that left to pastor a Lutheran Church and he is more in touch with the needy in the community. It is sad for Catholics it is sad for the community There is always a side-effect to this.
ortus Posted September 15, 2016 Posted September 15, 2016 12 hours ago, CatherineM said: I didn't go. I wasn't missed. The place was more than full of his adoring fans. Funny thing is that my biggest issue with him is that he hates having to deal with or be around the mentally ill. He's being made an auxiliary for an inner city area in a large city with lots of homeless, so of course he won't have to be troubled by any scary schizophrenics. This is one of the most appalling threads imaginable. I note that you are a ‘church scholar’ … a ‘scholar’ of what exactly … because your post has nothing to do with the Catholic Church I recognize. You claim to have ‘knowledge’ of this Bishop and stand in judgment of his moral capability. Did you see fit to pass on your ‘knowledge’ to the relevant and competent authorities – the Apostolic Nuncio? The Congregation of Bishops? No, instead of this you decide to post your allegations on a website aimed at young Catholics. Did you think through the implications of what you were doing? You do not even make the most basic attempt to ananomize your statements ... as it would take no more that a few clicks on Google to identify the object of your salacious gossip from the information you have provided. To make matters even worse, you make your scurrilous allegations on the internet so that they will hang around indefinitely. Appalling! Absolutely appalling!!
<3 PopeFrancis Posted September 15, 2016 Posted September 15, 2016 10 minutes ago, ortus said: a ‘scholar’ of what exactly … She sounds like a compassionate person to me. Jesus sat and ate with sinners and came to heal the sick not the well
dominicansoul Posted September 15, 2016 Posted September 15, 2016 (edited) 3 hours ago, ortus said: This is one of the most appalling threads imaginable. I note that you are a ‘church scholar’ … a ‘scholar’ of what exactly … because your post has nothing to do with the Catholic Church I recognize. You claim to have ‘knowledge’ of this Bishop and stand in judgment of his moral capability. Did you see fit to pass on your ‘knowledge’ to the relevant and competent authorities – the Apostolic Nuncio? The Congregation of Bishops? No, instead of this you decide to post your allegations on a website aimed at young Catholics. Did you think through the implications of what you were doing? You do not even make the most basic attempt to ananomize your statements ... as it would take no more that a few clicks on Google to identify the object of your salacious gossip from the information you have provided. To make matters even worse, you make your scurrilous allegations on the internet so that they will hang around indefinitely. Appalling! Absolutely appalling!! CatherineM is a highly respected member of phatmass. Who are you? Perhaps she started this thread to vent to friends? I too am wondering how a homosexual could be made a bishop when I'm pretty sure Pope Benedict said homosexuals shouldn't be allowed in the priesthood. Was this guy "grandfathered" in? I'm pretty sure Catherine is appalled by lack of obedience more so than this mans sexual orientation... Edited September 15, 2016 by dominicansoul
IgnatiusofLoyola Posted September 15, 2016 Posted September 15, 2016 Factoid: Quite a few of us on Phatmass are not "young" and a couple of us are not even Catholics. CatherineM has spoken many times of her training in theology. I find what she writes to be both clear and edifying. Have you read any of CatherineM's books? This particular post was CatherineM expressing her feelings. As I understand it, the Catholic Church allows that.
MIKolbe Posted September 15, 2016 Posted September 15, 2016 9 hours ago, ortus said: This is one of the most appalling threads imaginable. I note that you are a ‘church scholar’ … a ‘scholar’ of what exactly … because your post has nothing to do with the Catholic Church I recognize. You claim to have ‘knowledge’ of this Bishop and stand in judgment of his moral capability. Did you see fit to pass on your ‘knowledge’ to the relevant and competent authorities – the Apostolic Nuncio? The Congregation of Bishops? No, instead of this you decide to post your allegations on a website aimed at young Catholics. Did you think through the implications of what you were doing? You do not even make the most basic attempt to ananomize your statements ... as it would take no more that a few clicks on Google to identify the object of your salacious gossip from the information you have provided. To make matters even worse, you make your scurrilous allegations on the internet so that they will hang around indefinitely. Appalling! Absolutely appalling!! Your Excellency, is that you?
dominicansoul Posted September 15, 2016 Posted September 15, 2016 1 hour ago, MIKolbe said: Your Excellency, is that you?
<3 PopeFrancis Posted September 15, 2016 Posted September 15, 2016 9 hours ago, dominicansoul said: CatherineM is a highly respected member of phatmass. Who are you? Perhaps she started this thread to vent to friends? I too am wondering how a homosexual could be made a bishop when I'm pretty sure Pope Benedict said homosexuals shouldn't be allowed in the priesthood. Was this guy "grandfathered" in? I'm pretty sure Catherine is appalled by lack of obedience more so than this mans sexual orientation... 12 hours ago, ortus said: This is one of the most appalling threads imaginable. I note that you are a ‘church scholar’ … a ‘scholar’ of what exactly … because your post has nothing to do with the Catholic Church I recognize. You claim to have ‘knowledge’ of this Bishop and stand in judgment of his moral capability. Did you see fit to pass on your ‘knowledge’ to the relevant and competent authorities – the Apostolic Nuncio? The Congregation of Bishops? No, instead of this you decide to post your allegations on a website aimed at young Catholics. Did you think through the implications of what you were doing? You do not even make the most basic attempt to ananomize your statements ... as it would take no more that a few clicks on Google to identify the object of your salacious gossip from the information you have provided. To make matters even worse, you make your scurrilous allegations on the internet so that they will hang around indefinitely. Appalling! Absolutely appalling!! I think she dealt with them very prudently even agonized over her friend. How would you have handled it? Would you as an "adoring fan" said congratulations to him, enjoyed the food and the party, then talk about how horrible it is for this priest to be "GAY" or maybe worse? Do you think that the fact that she felt "she wasn't missed" felt good? Your sympathies are misappropriated. 12 hours ago, ortus said: This is one of the most appalling threads imaginable. Indeed it is, but not Catherine M's.
Basilisa Marie Posted September 15, 2016 Posted September 15, 2016 Idk I just don't see how one's orientation matters if you have a mature and healthy understanding of your sexuality. I'd be more interested in a bishop's personality and pet projects than who he feels attracted to. Being gay doesn't automatically mean you promote certain things. That being said CatherineM isn't being unreasonable. She's expressing her feelings.
Amppax Posted September 15, 2016 Posted September 15, 2016 Of all the people on this forum, CatharineM is probably the person whose judgment I would most trust in this scenario.
CatherineM Posted September 15, 2016 Author Posted September 15, 2016 I was lecturing at the seminary, group of seminarians and the lay formation class, on dealing with the mentally ill, and I caught myself thinking about 30 years ago when I was going to young people's funerals instead. Being one of the few attorneys willing to take on clients with AIDS back when we weren't sure how you could catch it, I did lots of wills for twenty year olds who were preparing to die. Believing that every person has equal human dignity, I never closed my door to a gay person, or a trans, or an inter-sexed person. They all understood that as a faithful Catholic, I didn't believe their choices were healthy, but I wasn't going to condemn them. I can still see their faces alive and later in their caskets. I posted this because I felt powerless. Being a priest is an incredibly difficult life choice. It's not surprising that priests have a higher rate of things like alcoholism than the general public. Having same sex attraction is a very heavy cross. Adding that on top, and now the stress of being a bishop is more stress than most humans are capable of handling without cracking. When priests or bishops crack and turn to unhealthy activities to endure the stress, it tends to make the press, which harms the entire Body of Christ. A regular Joe gets caught exposing himself in an adult theatre, or drunk driving, or gambling away the company payroll, and no one cares. If that person wears a collar, then it's headline news. As far as I am aware, he is celibate. I don't know, and seriously don't want to know. He does have health issues, and isn't a young man anymore. When I compare him to the excellent men who run our archdiocese, I have to shake my head. Compared to the other bishops that have been elevated recently in dioceses that I have lived in or have contact with, again, I'm stunned. I have a pretty good idea why this man was picked, and I hope he ends up being a real asset to the area he will administering to. Ultimately, I believe that the magisterium is led by the Holy Spirit, and have faith this is a good choice. It's just not a choice I'd have made. Honestly, at times like this, I'm really glad the choice isn't in my hands no matter how irritated I am. I posted this here because my friends are here. People who know me, and can understand my concerns. My public position here is such that I can't really vent my frustrations to local friends without causing potential scandal. That's one thing we've had enough of already.
Gabriela Posted September 15, 2016 Posted September 15, 2016 19 hours ago, ortus said: This is one of the most appalling threads imaginable. I note that you are a ‘church scholar’ … a ‘scholar’ of what exactly … because your post has nothing to do with the Catholic Church I recognize. You claim to have ‘knowledge’ of this Bishop and stand in judgment of his moral capability. Did you see fit to pass on your ‘knowledge’ to the relevant and competent authorities – the Apostolic Nuncio? The Congregation of Bishops? No, instead of this you decide to post your allegations on a website aimed at young Catholics. Did you think through the implications of what you were doing? You do not even make the most basic attempt to ananomize your statements ... as it would take no more that a few clicks on Google to identify the object of your salacious gossip from the information you have provided. To make matters even worse, you make your scurrilous allegations on the internet so that they will hang around indefinitely. Appalling! Absolutely appalling!! ProTip: Never walk into a forum as a noob and presume to question the credibility of a veteran. Everyone knows them, and nobody knows you. It just makes you look like an ass. Also, chill the flip out. Exaggerated (self-)righteous indignation doesn't get anyone on your side.
<3 PopeFrancis Posted September 15, 2016 Posted September 15, 2016 4 hours ago, CatherineM said: Honestly, at times like this, I'm really glad the choice isn't in my hands no matter how irritated I am. Amen! It must be so hard. Thank you for sharing your story.
IgnatiusofLoyola Posted September 16, 2016 Posted September 16, 2016 14 hours ago, Gabriela said: ProTip: Never walk into a forum as a noob and presume to question the credibility of a veteran. Everyone knows them, and nobody knows you. It just makes you look like an ass. Also, chill the flip out. Exaggerated (self-)righteous indignation doesn't get anyone on your side. I'm not yet convinced that this is isn't someone who used to be a Phatmasser trolling us. Who says "appalling" nowadays? This troll knows us well enough that we took the bait--including me.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now