Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted
9 minutes ago, Jack4 said:

"Abortion=healthcare" is just another rhetoric somersault. 

How does it help the mother's health? It doesn't. But it is always harmful, for the soul.

It is sometimes a traumatic experience for the mother, leaving deep scars emotionally as well.

Abortion as healthcare is easy to understand and is reasonable if you consider the embryo, zygote, or fetus as only tissue.   We remove cysts and tumors without qualms. 

When defining a Person with logic and empathy you can't just rely on a religious interpretation. 

A Person is not defined by ability, dependency, or viability without assistance.  If so, elderly, handicapped, and coma patients would be killed or "aborted".  

KnightofChrist
Posted
On 11/9/2016 at 0:37 PM, Gabriela said:

I'm pretty sure this is a contradiction in terms.

There are plenty of people with college degrees who aren't well educated, and plenty of people without an college degree who are. Depends on the person, not the degree. Although the degree can be helpful.

28 minutes ago, Anomaly said:

Abortion as healthcare is easy to understand and is reasonable if you consider the embryo, zygote, or fetus as only tissue.   We remove cysts and tumors without qualms. 

When defining a Person with logic and empathy you can't just rely on a religious interpretation. 

A Person is not defined by ability, dependency, or viability without assistance.  If so, elderly, handicapped, and coma patients would be killed or "aborted".  

Agreed to a degree, it's a scientific fact that a fetus has his or her own unique a DNA and is a individual living member of the Homo sapiens species aka human beings. Human beings are persons and the only time they are not is when they are unwanted.

Posted
51 minutes ago, KnightofChrist said:

There are plenty of people with college degrees who aren't well educated, and plenty of people without an college degree who are. Depends on the person, not the degree. Although the degree can be helpful.

Right. I agree. But I objected to the use of "non-college educated suburbanites", and I'm pretty sure we can show that almost all suburbanites are college-educated. That's practically part of the definition of "suburbanite". You can't afford to live in the suburbs unless you've got a college degree.

Posted
19 minutes ago, Gabriela said:

Right. I agree. But I objected to the use of "non-college educated suburbanites", and I'm pretty sure we can show that almost all suburbanites are college-educated. That's practically part of the definition of "suburbanite". You can't afford to live in the suburbs unless you've got a college degree.

Lol.  You must be one of the pollsters or pundits that advised Hillary. 

KnightofChrist
Posted
20 minutes ago, Gabriela said:

Right. I agree. But I objected to the use of "non-college educated suburbanites", and I'm pretty sure we can show that almost all suburbanites are college-educated. That's practically part of the definition of "suburbanite". You can't afford to live in the suburbs unless you've got a college degree.

In my life I've met many people living in suburban areas that were poor and/or on some type welfare assistance. There's census data that shows that suburban areas are actually getting poorer over time. For example: http://www.usnews.com/news/articles/2016-07-06/the-new-faces-of-us-poverty

Sure some suburban areas are rich, just like some cities are rich, but then there are poor cities and poor suburban areas also.

Posted

The media-machine has introduced a new demographic this election - uneducated white men. I've not heard that term in previous elections. Previously, they were called blue collar workers or rednecks - the name has changed, but the blame-game remains the same. If I were to paraphrase "uneducated white men," I'd say Stupid White Guys. Ironically, if the media-machine had blamed Clinton's loss on uneducated Black men, people would be going ape-skit!

White men (and women) with red necks and blue collars - walkin', talkin' patriotism!

Posted
2 hours ago, Anomaly said:

A Person is not defined by ability, dependency, or viability without assistance.  If so, elderly, handicapped, and coma patients would be killed or "aborted".

Yes. I don't think I've said to the contrary. 

2 hours ago, Anomaly said:

Abortion as healthcare is easy to understand and is reasonable if you consider the embryo, zygote, or fetus as only tissue.   We remove cysts and tumors without qualms. 

Removing cysts and tumours helps the patient. What about abortion? How does it give health?

And yes, about Person http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/11726a.htm

Posted
7 minutes ago, Jack4 said:

Yes. I don't think I've said to the contrary. 

Removing cysts and tumours helps the patient. What about abortion? How does it give health?

I'm not disagreeing or chastising. I'm sharing the reasonable rational of pro abortion and suggesting a definition of person. 

Some cysts and benign tumors are removed for minor comfort, looks, etc.. If a person believes (and the belief affirmed by general social understanding and legal status) that a zygote is just tissue like a cyst, why would the put themselves in a more difficult situation and go against the grain to consider "it" a Person going through the natural stages of life?

dominicansoul
Posted
46 minutes ago, Luigi said:

The media-machine has introduced a new demographic this election - uneducated white men. I've not heard that term in previous elections. Previously, they were called blue collar workers or rednecks - the name has changed, but the blame-game remains the same. If I were to paraphrase "uneducated white men," I'd say Stupid White Guys. Ironically, if the media-machine had blamed Clinton's loss on uneducated Black men, people would be going ape-skit!

White men (and women) with red necks and blue collars - walkin', talkin' patriotism!

I spit out my beer when the liberal media pundits on ABC kept saying, "The polls are closing, but I'm sure the heavy Latino population in the precinct haven't voted yet."  :rotfl2:

And yes, they kept mentioning "uneducated white men."  Do liberals even hear themselves talk?  They are the racists of them all...

It was very amusing and entertaining to see the media's meltdown...

Posted
6 hours ago, KnightofChrist said:

Human beings are persons and the only time they are not is when they are unwanted.

That is not an argument that has any weight with abortionists (and most scientists), because they believe that there is a distinction between human beings and human persons. They have criteria for personhood such as cognizance, etc.

You might be better off to prove that all human beings have a right to life, regardless of their personhood.

KnightofChrist
Posted (edited)
55 minutes ago, Peace said:

That is not an argument that has any weight with abortionists (and most scientists), because they believe that there is a distinction between human beings and human persons. They have criteria for personhood such as cognizance, etc.

You might be better off to prove that all human beings have a right to life, regardless of their personhood.

We're both saying the same basic thing though. The only time when the personhood of certain human beings is questioned is when others look for reasons to justify killing or otherwise abusing legal 'nonperson' persons.

Cognizance, human form, independence or the lack therefor has always been used to justify denying personhood to a group of people and that has always been used to enslave, murder, or abuse that particular group of people.

Personally, with friends and family at least, I have found pointing out that their justifications for denying personhood to babies is just recycled  logic that was used to deny personhood to countless other groups of people through out history. Many times the response is something along the lines of "I've never thought of it that way before." Which is something at least. It worked for my father, he went from being strongly pro-choice, which he thought of as pro-woman to being prolife because he has always been against other forms of bigotry (whether that bigotry is based in kkk kind of hate, or coldhearted completely indifferent kind of hate.)

Edited by KnightofChrist
Posted

A quite good commentary from Catholic Culture on the recent election in the USA:
 

Quote

 

http://www.catholicculture.org/commentary/otn.cfm?id=1184

Excerpts: ".............In his important book Coming Apart, Charles Murray showed how the wealthy and privileged tend to isolate themselves from the poor and the middle class. In past generations rich families might have employed servants, and if they were sensitive at all, they learned a bit about the daily struggles of the servants’ families. But today’s rich—living in leafy gated communities, commuting to work in secure high-rise fortresses—rarely encounter the people who are struggling. The stock market is rising, so they think that the economy is healthy, not noticing that for middle-class households, living standards have been steadily falling. Their children are being educated at prestigious schools, and taking their own places in the elite; so they do not understand the anxiety of parents who worry how their children can support a family..............

.............A Hillary Clinton administration would have been a disaster for the causes of life and family and faith. We do not yet know what to expect from a Trump administration. But the time is ripe for change—not just in America but throughout the Western world. Ross Douthat of the New York Times likens the Trump victory to the ascent of Napoleon to power. But Napoleon came to power only after the cataclysmic turmoil of the French Revolution.

For us the turmoil is just beginning.

 

 

Posted (edited)

Let us place our trust in Jesus. He promised he would never leave his church. However, we read In this weekend's gospel, Jesus said there will be tragedies, division, and persecution along the way before He comes again. However, he promised he will never leave us. 

"Jesus, I trust in you!"

Edited by WhiteLily
Posted (edited)

Some scary type comments in articles here:

http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/projects/cp/opinion/election-night-2016/heres-what-happened-with-the-latino-vote

(I found myself thinking, "I hope the media gets it wrong again."  Knowing that media can get things so very wrong is some consolation.  While we are at a sophisticated stage in our evolution in all the sciences and as human beings, we might think that we know it all.  If anything, this election has shown that we do not at all - we only think we do - and just how far off the reality target we can be.)

We can indeed put absolute trust and confidence in Jesus, which does not mean at all that there is not suffering and conflict ahead - and perhaps seriously so.  What it does mean is that despite how things might appear to our human finiteness, "all is well, all is well and all shall be well" (Julian of Norwich).

I thought this quotation from St Vincent de Paul had something important to state too about the Doctrine of Divine Providence and absolute trust in Jesus:

Quote

"“I beg you to consider all things in the designs of Providence and, while humbly and carefully doing your share to contribute to success, leave the rest to the good pleasure of God.” – St. Vincent de Paul"

We must and are called to do our part humbly and peacefully yet diligently insofar as we are able while leaving success or the lack of it to Jesus with trust and confidence.

I can be rich in praise of The Lord when all is well to my taste - but not so loud, mea maxima culpa, in rich praise when things are not at all as I would have them.  Might not be as I would have them, but Faith tells me that I am wrong and that The Lord and His Will, His Goodness, is triumphing nevertheless (Doctrine Divine Providence).

Think tank.  I wonder if a benevolent dictator is the answer rather than democracy? Or will absolute power always corrupt absolutely? 

Did a quick Google and really surprised to see so many links about the subject.  No time to do any research just now.

Edited by BarbaraTherese
Posted
On 11/11/2016 at 3:52 PM, Peace said:

That is not an argument that has any weight with abortionists (and most scientists), because they believe that there is a distinction between human beings and human persons. They have criteria for personhood such as cognizance, etc.

You might be better off to prove that all human beings have a right to life, regardless of their personhood.

If you take a strictly materialist atheistic view of life, and don't believe in a soul or spiritual nature to man, all human beings are ultimately nothing more than clusters of cells, pieces of tissue, etc.  Its just that some of these clusters of cells are more developed and have more complex functions than others.

Also, from the strict materialist standpoint, the only logically consistent position would be that all human rights, including the right to life, are completely human inventions, and rest on no higher authority than the human beings that create and grant them.  If it is man that grants rights, man can just as easily take them away.  The same is true for the concept of "personhood."

The question of the right to life and "personhood" is outside the scope of the material sciences, and cannot be settled by material science.  Rights (including the right to life) are not physical things that can be scientifically observed or measured.  You can't test for rights in the lab, or see them through a microscope or telescope.

 

This is why ultimately the issue of the right to life is a spiritual one, and converting those stuck in a utilitarian pro-abortion mindset will require spiritual conversion.

I'm not sure if there's really any argument to use with those who insist that some human beings are not persons, and thus have no right to life.  Probably the best you can do is use "slippery slope" arguments - if "personhood" is denied to some humans, whom might be denied it next? - but not all will find that convincing.  They will first have to change their godless and perverse philosophy.

Posted

Soc,

I think you would be surprised if you dig a little more into defining "personhood".  An atheist is not a synonym for sociopath.    There are lots of reasonable arguments for determining personhood. 

Are you even aware that the Church at one time, considered the embryo as mere tissue until "ensoulment?"    That the baby needs to breathe to receive the "breathe of life" as described in Genesis?

Being anti-abortion or trying to determine personhood and protecting them with laws is not solely the realm if diests.  Don't be so quick to disregard potential allies.  

Posted

In other news he appoints a white nationalist as one of his most influential cabinet members.

 

Posted
11 hours ago, Socrates said:

If you take a strictly materialist atheistic view of life, and don't believe in a soul or spiritual nature to man, all human beings are ultimately nothing more than clusters of cells, pieces of tissue, etc.  Its just that some of these clusters of cells are more developed and have more complex functions than others.

Also, from the strict materialist standpoint, the only logically consistent position would be that all human rights, including the right to life, are completely human inventions, and rest on no higher authority than the human beings that create and grant them.  If it is man that grants rights, man can just as easily take them away.  The same is true for the concept of "personhood."

The question of the right to life and "personhood" is outside the scope of the material sciences, and cannot be settled by material science.  Rights (including the right to life) are not physical things that can be scientifically observed or measured.  You can't test for rights in the lab, or see them through a microscope or telescope.

 

This is why ultimately the issue of the right to life is a spiritual one, and converting those stuck in a utilitarian pro-abortion mindset will require spiritual conversion.

I'm not sure if there's really any argument to use with those who insist that some human beings are not persons, and thus have no right to life.  Probably the best you can do is use "slippery slope" arguments - if "personhood" is denied to some humans, whom might be denied it next? - but not all will find that convincing.  They will first have to change their godless and perverse philosophy.

I generally agree that athiests don't have any solid basis for holding certain basic ideas such as "it is wrong to kill" or what have you.

But most people, whether believers or athiests, do agree to a large extent on certain basic moral principles, and have a basic moral sense of right and wrong. That moral sense comes from God in both cases. The athiest just refuses to acknowledge it.

Since most athiests have a moral sense and hold many of the same moral principles as we do, solid pro-life arguments can be made, based on these principle, without making an appeal to religion. You have plenty of "Godless" pro-life athiests such as Anomaly as the proof that this is possible.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...