Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Rome wakes up to find city full of anti-Pope Francis posters


Recommended Posts

Posted
20 minutes ago, Peace said:

Prayer.

Well that and, apparently, a formal correction to be written by those same cardinals. Deo volente.

Posted
9 hours ago, truthfinder said:

I have to wonder to what degree that fact that this is apparently a longstanding Roman tradition and that the posters are in the Roman dialect. Francis is pope, but he is also the bishop of Rome - and these posters seem to be coming from his direct parishioners. 

They could be. Or certain curialists, for obvious reasons unwilling to speak on record, could be alarmed by what they see as Francis's abuse of power and see no recourse except direct public appeal. Romans about their daily errands are far more likely to see these posters than Francis or anyone within his close circle is. Moreover, the posters are written in the local idiom. We can, of course, not tell for sure, but the possibility that this could be an appeal by curialists (or other clergy or Knights of Malta or such) with little other recourse merits some examination.

Posted
50 minutes ago, bardegaulois said:

They could be. Or certain curialists, for obvious reasons unwilling to speak on record, could be alarmed by what they see as Francis's abuse of power and see no recourse except direct public appeal. Romans about their daily errands are far more likely to see these posters than Francis or anyone within his close circle is. Moreover, the posters are written in the local idiom. We can, of course, not tell for sure, but the possibility that this could be an appeal by curialists (or other clergy or Knights of Malta or such) with little other recourse merits some examination.

Sorry - could you explain what you mean by 'curialists' - I'm not sure if something's being lost in translation, but I'm not sure who you're referring to.

Posted
1 hour ago, Nihil Obstat said:

Well that and, apparently, a formal correction to be written by those same cardinals. Deo volente.

Lo, but if only the cardinals were correct!

Posted
22 minutes ago, Peace said:

Lo, but if only the cardinals were correct!

You've been extra snarky lately. Phatmass got you down? 

Posted
45 minutes ago, truthfinder said:

Sorry - could you explain what you mean by 'curialists' - I'm not sure if something's being lost in translation, but I'm not sure who you're referring to.

Sorry to be vague. I mean priests and prelates working in the Roman Curia. In this context, it might be expanded to include those teaching in Pontifical Universities and priests regular on duty in the generalates of their orders.

Spem in alium
Posted (edited)

Hmm. I have my own feelings about the whole situation with the Order of Malta. I'm intimately connected with the Order and so have been quite involved in what's been going on. In some ways, I think the Pope was right to intervene and that Fra' Festing showed great humility and obedience in resigning. I don't feel it's Cardinal Burke's role to be involved so much in those matters -- so in my view he's not been sidelined or stripped of a job. It is certainly a frustrating situation, though, and putting up posters is certainly a less harmful way of getting a message across. It's clear that the Church needs prayer.

 

Edited by Spem in alium
Posted
49 minutes ago, bardegaulois said:

Sorry to be vague. I mean priests and prelates working in the Roman Curia. In this context, it might be expanded to include those teaching in Pontifical Universities and priests regular on duty in the generalates of their orders.

Thanks. I'm just wondering to the extent that those in the curia would do this. I mean it's not impossible but it would be easy to track this sort of thing back to them if they did, and it certainly wouldn't do them any favours. 

Posted
2 hours ago, Spem in alium said:

Hmm. I have my own feelings about the whole situation with the Order of Malta. I'm intimately connected with the Order and so have been quite involved in what's been going on. In some ways, I think the Pope was right to intervene and that Fra' Festing showed great humility and obedience in resigning. I don't feel it's Cardinal Burke's role to be involved so much in those matters -- so in my view he's not been sidelined or stripped of a job. It is certainly a frustrating situation, though, and putting up posters is certainly a less harmful way of getting a message across. It's clear that the Church needs prayer.

 

Legally speaking Pope Francis had no right to do what he did. Am I misinformed?

Posted
3 hours ago, Nihil Obstat said:

Legally speaking Pope Francis had no right to do what he did. Am I misinformed?

I'm puzzled too. 

Posted

To me, it looks clear that there is a lack of communication. When something/someone goes against things you hold dear, it is natural to desire an explanation.  The fact this rift is going on is very sad. I personally would like to see the Pope make an effort to reaching to the disgruntled and attempt to reconcile. It is not about who is right, who wrong or liberal vs conservative vs traditional vs progressive.... It should be about making things right.

Posted
11 hours ago, Nihil Obstat said:

Legally speaking Pope Francis had no right to do what he did. Am I misinformed?

Yes, I am of that mind too. This was a blatant violation of the sovereignty of the Order, something that, were it to happen between two sovereign entities of greater scale, could lead to armies massing on borders. As the matter in question was not canonical, international law governs the transactions between these two parties. Please tell me how what happened here was not a breach of the law of nations.

Posted

We should be talking about the moral dimension of this Maltese debacle too. As far as I am aware, the primary reason for Boeselager's dismissal was his complicity in and direction of distribution of condoms during Malteser relief efforts. My understanding is that other issues with Boeselager were secondary to this condom distribution.

His dismissal then, especially if it were enacted in accordance with the laws of the Sovereign Military Order of Malta, seems to be an act of justice. It seems that other avenues were persued first, and he was dismissed only after other options were exhausted.

So Boeselager's dismissal then is - is it not? - an act of justice which promotes Catholic orthodoxy. What then are we to think when this dismissal is vacated and Festing, who is responsible for this just and orthodox act, is himself dismissed/compelled to resign? Especially when he was compelled by a force which lies outside the structure and laws, and in particular the sovereignty of the order of Malta.

I think it can reasonably be suggested that justice is either on one side, or on neither. Ditto for doctrinal integrity.

Posted
1 hour ago, Nihil Obstat said:

We should be talking about the moral dimension of this Maltese debacle too. As far as I am aware, the primary reason for Boeselager's dismissal was his complicity in and direction of distribution of condoms during Malteser relief efforts. My understanding is that other issues with Boeselager were secondary to this condom distribution.

His dismissal then, especially if it were enacted in accordance with the laws of the Sovereign Military Order of Malta, seems to be an act of justice. It seems that other avenues were persued first, and he was dismissed only after other options were exhausted.

So Boeselager's dismissal then is - is it not? - an act of justice which promotes Catholic orthodoxy. What then are we to think when this dismissal is vacated and Festing, who is responsible for this just and orthodox act, is himself dismissed/compelled to resign? Especially when he was compelled by a force which lies outside the structure and laws, and in particular the sovereignty of the order of Malta.

I think it can reasonably be suggested that justice is either on one side, or on neither. Ditto for doctrinal integrity.

Lol, "pursued". Whoops.

Posted
1 hour ago, Nihil Obstat said:

We should be talking about the moral dimension of this Maltese debacle too. As far as I am aware, the primary reason for Boeselager's dismissal was his complicity in and direction of distribution of condoms during Malteser relief efforts. My understanding is that other issues with Boeselager were secondary to this condom distribution.

His dismissal then, especially if it were enacted in accordance with the laws of the Sovereign Military Order of Malta, seems to be an act of justice. It seems that other avenues were persued first, and he was dismissed only after other options were exhausted.

So Boeselager's dismissal then is - is it not? - an act of justice which promotes Catholic orthodoxy. What then are we to think when this dismissal is vacated and Festing, who is responsible for this just and orthodox act, is himself dismissed/compelled to resign? Especially when he was compelled by a force which lies outside the structure and laws, and in particular the sovereignty of the order of Malta.

I think it can reasonably be suggested that justice is either on one side, or on neither. Ditto for doctrinal integrity.

Not sure if it would be an act of justice. I do not know if the facts are true, but at least from what I read, the condoms were distributed to women who had been forced to work as prostitutes, to protect them from AIDS and other diseases.

Whether things like that would violate the moral law is an open question, and has been debated elsewhere on this forum I think.

Posted
1 hour ago, Peace said:

Not sure if it would be an act of justice. I do not know if the facts are true, but at least from what I read, the condoms were distributed to women who had been forced to work as prostitutes, to protect them from AIDS and other diseases.

Whether things like that would violate the moral law is an open question, and has been debated elsewhere on this forum I think.

Do you have a link to that information?

KnightofChrist
Posted
7 minutes ago, Peace said:

It seems likely the AP just omitted the part about also being used as birth control. Not really different, only one has info than the other.

Also using condoms to prevent AIDS/HIV is not regarded by the Church as a real or moral solution.

Posted
5 minutes ago, KnightofChrist said:

It seems likely the AP just omitted the part about also being used as birth control. Not really different, only one has info than the other.

Sure, but it could be complicated. The guy who was ousted, how much did he know, for what purpose did he believe they were used for, etc.

5 minutes ago, KnightofChrist said:

Also using condoms to prevent AIDS/HIV is not regarded by the Church as a real or moral solution.

In general I would agree, but I am not so sure that She would rule it out in every circumstance, especially where you are talking in the context of fornication, rape, homosexual sex, etc. Been debated on the forum already though.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...