Peace Posted October 3, 2020 Posted October 3, 2020 18 minutes ago, fides' Jack said: The Catechism of the Catholic Church is a book. The teachings in it were part of the Ordinary Magisterium when they were accompanied by the papal pronouncement defining them that way. Any change that is not accompanied with another pronouncement do not carry the same weight. And any change that is accompanied with another pronouncement that differ from established Church teaching on faith or morals is to be flatly rejected by the faithful. To be a theologian it is not necessary to have any kind of degree or acknowledgement from the Church. And having one in this age is probably more of an indication that you're not in line with the Church than otherwise. But ordinarily, yes, I think this is correct. Unless you have reason not to do so (which we certainly do on this matter), if a spiritual superior is teaching a matter of faith or morals that's not contrary to established Church teaching, you are obliged to believe. The problem is that just about everything is very clearly defined at this point, so it should be super easy to confirm anything they say. (I say 'should' because there's just as much misinformation out there as solid Catholic teaching, and if you're not solid in your understanding you will likely be led astray - and if you are solid there won't be much you'll have to look up, anyway) Also, the idea that just because a bishop says something, or the pope adds something to the Catechism, or in an encyclical, that it is to be believed by all Catholics is a heresy, and anyone who holds to this idea will certainly not keep the faith for long in these times. On the specific subject of the death penalty, it's pretty easy to see what the Church taught in the past. And since it is a matter of morals that the established Church teaching is that the death penalty is acceptable in the right circumstances, then it's actually a heresy for a priest or bishop to declare otherwise (i.e. that it's never ok). All that being said, I should probably learn from you and keep my silence more. Clearly I wrote too much here... There isn't much I would want to remove, though... Just to head off an argument here, I'm not saying that if you're solid you already know everything or even a significant portion of the deposit of faith. I'm saying that since many priests and bishops are not solid, it's pretty easy to see when they're wrong, because they're not going to delve too deeply into authentic Church teaching. It's only my opinion because that's the position of the Church. Otherwise my opinion would be different. Yes, Yes. We should just all ignore the pope, our bishops, the Catechism, and turn to you to teach us the one true Catholic faith.
cutenickname Posted October 4, 2020 Posted October 4, 2020 Please delete my account or ban me. If you do not simply comply with the request I will have to take disruptive and objectively un-Christian measures to make you do so. God bless. I understand your desire to not actually delete accounts so as not to interfere with the flow of conversation, so banning without deleting is fine. @dUSt
fides' Jack Posted October 4, 2020 Posted October 4, 2020 (edited) I guess defending Trump gets people riled up. Well, I already knew that. 8 hours ago, Peace said: Yes, Yes. We should just all ignore the pope, our bishops, the Catechism, and turn to you to teach us the one true Catholic faith. That's a bit of a straw man... It does sound bad when you say it like that. It really puts the truth into perspective - that a normal Catholic can't possibly stay Catholic in this world unless they get extraordinary grace to look deeper to understand the Church's true position. Truly, though, you don't have to ignore all of the bishops, or the Catechism. You just have to know which bishops are worth listening to and how to properly digest the Catechism. Although, Sacred Scripture told us this would happen to the Church, so we really shouldn't be surprised... Edited October 4, 2020 by fides' Jack Saw another post and wanted to respond more fully.
Peace Posted October 4, 2020 Posted October 4, 2020 (edited) 8 hours ago, fides' Jack said: I guess defending Trump gets people riled up. Well, I already knew that. That's a bit of a straw man... It does sound bad when you say it like that. It really puts the truth into perspective - that a normal Catholic can't possibly stay Catholic in this world unless they get extraordinary grace to look deeper to understand the Church's true position. Truly, though, you don't have to ignore all of the bishops, or the Catechism. You just have to know which bishops are worth listening to and how to properly digest the Catechism. Although, Sacred Scripture told us this would happen to the Church, so we really shouldn't be surprised... LOL. Yes man I know that is not exactly what you meant, but it does start to sound that way to me sometimes. I and others have had the same debate on this site in the past. Like, if Pope Francis stood up one day and said "Rape is a good thing. Please go out and rape" my response would be, "Well, the pope has gone mad, and that certainly cannot be reconciled with Christianity, so I will ignore those words and adhere to what the Church has taught in the past." I think that is essentially what you are doing, although with different statements by the pope. But I think there can be a slippery slope back into Protestantism with that, where essentially each man interprets Scripture and tradition for himself, wherein essentially God ordained authorities in the church become nothing more than "Yes men." If they agree with your own personal conclusion on issue X, then we are to follow them. If they disagree with your own personal conclusion on issue X, then they are to be ignored. If that is what we are doing all the time we are essentially Protestants. So if you are 100% clear in your own mind that that pope is wrong on issue X, I guess you have to follow your conscience and reject the teaching. I am 100% clear that rape is wrong, so I would have to reject that teaching. But if we have a situation where we are like "Well I am 99% certain that the pope is wrong, but there is a 1% chance that he could be correct" I think our duty as Catholics is to assent to the teaching. I think that we can have faith, that in the long run, the bishops will sort any errors out among themselves and correct the teaching. I don't think it is up for individual laity to take it upon themselves to correct the clergy all the time. I view our role as following what the living clergy teaches, and finding various ways to engage in the life in the church through good works, and engaging with the secular world. Edited October 4, 2020 by Peace
fides' Jack Posted October 5, 2020 Posted October 5, 2020 10 hours ago, Peace said: But I think there can be a slippery slope back into Protestantism with that, where essentially each man interprets Scripture and tradition for himself, wherein essentially God ordained authorities in the church become nothing more than "Yes men." If they agree with your own personal conclusion on issue X, then we are to follow them. If they disagree with your own personal conclusion on issue X, then they are to be ignored. If that is what we are doing all the time we are essentially Protestants. So if you are 100% clear in your own mind that that pope is wrong on issue X, I guess you have to follow your conscience and reject the teaching. I am 100% clear that rape is wrong, so I would have to reject that teaching. But if we have a situation where we are like "Well I am 99% certain that the pope is wrong, but there is a 1% chance that he could be correct" I think our duty as Catholics is to assent to the teaching. I think that we can have faith, that in the long run, the bishops will sort any errors out among themselves and correct the teaching. I don't think it is up for individual laity to take it upon themselves to correct the clergy all the time. I view our role as following what the living clergy teaches, and finding various ways to engage in the life in the church through good works, and engaging with the secular world. I get what you're saying, and I agree with the sentiment. I think the difference lies where we would draw that line. I'm 100% certain that the Church has always taught that the death penalty is allowed is some circumstances. That's Church teaching, not my opinion. My opinion is that it should probably be used much, much more, but I will defer on that point to Pope St. JPII and Pope Emeritus Benedict XVI who both seemed to think that in the 1st world, there should be no need for it. But again, that's clearly a matter of opinion. As for correcting the clergy, I used to be of the same opinion, but I'm starting to wonder if part of the current crisis in the Church is because people have been too afraid to speak up due to a false understanding of politeness. The few bishops who are speaking up and are speaking out in protection of life and liberty are also saying that it's the role of the laity to correct their bishops when their bishops go astray. I'm not 100% on that, though, so I'm a little weary of doing it myself, still. I pray God has mercy on me if that's something He wants me to do and I'm not doing it.
HumilityAndPatience Posted October 9, 2020 Author Posted October 9, 2020 On 9/29/2020 at 3:11 PM, phatcatholic said: I strongly disagree w/ Fr. Altman's video. I outline my reasons here: https://phatcatholic.blogspot.com/2020/09/response-to-fr-james-altmans-video-you.html This view (which we share) is in a significant minority.. to the point where it is a strange phenomenon. What do you make of it?
MeteorShower Posted November 5, 2020 Posted November 5, 2020 (edited) It's been a while since this thread was updated and I'm not interested in debating, but I just wanted to say that I strongly disagree with Fr. Altman. It's nice to know that I am not completely alone in that. It is because of people like Fr. Altman why I no longer openly or actively practice Catholicism. Anyway, I'm Canadian so it's a moot point. No one's told me that I'm going to hell for being Catholic and NDP or Catholic and Liberal. Edited November 5, 2020 by MeteorShower
Lilllabettt Posted November 5, 2020 Posted November 5, 2020 1 hour ago, MeteorShower said: It's been a while since this thread was updated and I'm not interested in debating, but I just wanted to say that I strongly disagree with Fr. Altman. It's nice to know that I am not completely alone in that. It is because of people like Fr. Altman why I no longer openly or actively practice Catholicism. If that is true, that is weak. Think better of yourself. Although I understand the impulse, as I am not a traditionalist specifically because of "people." However if I were convinced in conscience traditionalism were required to practice true religion, I like to think I am good enough, I would not scorn God for "people." I would hold my nose and learn the Latin mass and so on. I am glad it is not required. Btw, I did not listen to Fr Altman and don't care to; a priest opining at length in this way is embarrassing and repellant, especially at Mass, and risky to himself personally as far as salvation is concerned.
MeteorShower Posted November 5, 2020 Posted November 5, 2020 38 minutes ago, Lilllabettt said: If that is true, that is weak. Think better of yourself. Although I understand the impulse, as I am not a traditionalist specifically because of "people." However if I were convinced in conscience traditionalism were required to practice true religion, I like to think I am good enough, I would not scorn God for "people." I would hold my nose and learn the Latin mass and so on. I am glad it is not required. I'm sure your intentions were good but I don't consider myself weak and I HIGHLY resent being called that. Nor have I ever purposely intended to "scorn" God, but my beliefs are just different now. Anyway, I clearly shouldn't have commented in the first place so I apologise.
Peace Posted November 5, 2020 Posted November 5, 2020 33 minutes ago, MeteorShower said: I'm sure your intentions were good but I don't consider myself weak and I HIGHLY resent being called that. Nor have I ever purposely intended to "scorn" God, but my beliefs are just different now. Anyway, I clearly shouldn't have commented in the first place so I apologise. LOL. I dunno if her intentions were good. Don't give her that much credit! Well, if what you meant was that you don't openly or actively practice Catholicism simply because of people like Fr. Altman, I would consider that to be pretty weak reason too. It's all good though. We all call each other out like that here. Heck, I am practically beholden to Satan according to @fides' Jack. But we still get along. Probably what you meant was something more like "People like Fr. Altman make it more difficult for me to openly practice my faith" but you didn't phrase it quite the right way?
Lilllabettt Posted November 5, 2020 Posted November 5, 2020 31 minutes ago, MeteorShower said: I'm sure your intentions were good but I don't consider myself weak and I HIGHLY resent being called that. Nor have I ever purposely intended to "scorn" God, but my beliefs are just different now. Anyway, I clearly shouldn't have commented in the first place so I apologise. I didn't say you were weak, but the stated reason for giving up your religion was. But it sounds like other people are not the reason you don't practice Catholicism? Rather your beliefs "are just different now." A change of beliefs is a perfectly decent reason not to practice a religion. More power to you. If you feared torture, death or permanent separation from family those might be good enough reasons for me, or at least comprehensible. If you believed a religion was true but gave it up because of dumbutts that would be weak sauce. You may as well give up Canadian citizenship... Canadia has relatively fewer dumbutts belonging to it than most, but there are still enough. The question of which religion is true is too important to let dumbutt mortals get in the way. I think God shares my pov (naturally)
Peace Posted November 5, 2020 Posted November 5, 2020 2 minutes ago, Lilllabettt said: If you feared torture, death or permanent separation from family those might be good enough reasons for me, or at least comprehensible. I dunno I think it would depend on the type of torture. Are we talking about the comfy chair?
Lilllabettt Posted November 5, 2020 Posted November 5, 2020 32 minutes ago, Peace said: I dunno I think it would depend on the type of torture. Are we talking about the comfy chair? Cake or death my friend, cake or death
fides' Jack Posted November 5, 2020 Posted November 5, 2020 36 minutes ago, Peace said: Heck, I am practically beholden to Satan according to @fides' Jack. But we still get along. I've been away for a bit - lot's going on. I would never say anyone here is beholden to satan. I would say that everyone here is under his influence to various degrees. Probably everyone in the world is. If it's not obvious to people that satan is behind the demoncrat party right now, I wouldn't even know how to make it more obvious. I guess the only thing left is for them to come out and just state it. But that would undermine some of the progress he's made, so that's not going to happen.
Peace Posted November 6, 2020 Posted November 6, 2020 16 hours ago, fides' Jack said: I've been away for a bit - lot's going on. I would never say anyone here is beholden to satan. I would say that everyone here is under his influence to various degrees. Probably everyone in the world is. If it's not obvious to people that satan is behind the demoncrat party right now, I wouldn't even know how to make it more obvious. I guess the only thing left is for them to come out and just state it. But that would undermine some of the progress he's made, so that's not going to happen. If Satan is behind the Dems, I suppose you think that God is behind Trump and the GOP?
Aloysius Posted November 6, 2020 Posted November 6, 2020 demonic influences certainly affect all centers of power, there's a reason one of the things satan is known as is ruler of this world. why do you think we're supposed to pray for our leaders? it's not just about their health or that they'll do the right thing. heavy is the head that wears the crown--with responsibilities and with the pressures of demonic forces, dominions and principalities that only Christ the King can truly conquer. be thankful every day that you don't have so much power in this world. satan works through both the democrats and the gop. individual leaders may be better or worse at resisting him than others. it does very little good to try to point out which leaders have splinters in their eyes and which ones have logs in their eyes--unfortunately the modern democratic order encourages everyone to do so. whatever side you were on, you should be at peace that whatever small role you took in the outcome by voting, that it was done in an attempt to be faithful to your conscience and to God and with the best interests of everyone else in mind. take off that heavy crown democracy places on you every election--it's out of your hands now. pray, hope, and don't worry.
fides' Jack Posted November 19, 2020 Posted November 19, 2020 On 11/6/2020 at 7:17 AM, Peace said: If Satan is behind the Dems, I suppose you think that God is behind Trump and the GOP? I've been asking myself this question a lot lately, particularly regarding Trump. My natural inclination is to say, "No, of course not!" But I think that's a fear response, because right now you can lose your job if you support Trump. And if you say he has God behind him, it's actually easier to dismiss you than just saying you're a Republican. I don't know if you heard about this: I don't know if I believe it. I want to believe it. We know from Sacred Scripture that God often uses the least-expected people to bring about His plans. That's been true since Genesis, all the way through the Old Testament, through the New Testament, even to modern-day apparitions and politics. If it's true that God works in mysterious ways, it's far more true that God works in unexpected ways. I never liked Trump. But to anyone with an open mind, it's clear he's done better for the country than any president for some time. I still don't like him. I don't like people who see him as a messiah-figure, and I really don't understand that position. I am confident in God, though. I know that God can use whoever He sees fit for any purpose. Our Lord is the true Messiah, and He is certainly capable of using someone like Trump. It's also true that the Republican base is becoming more religiously conservative again, so in a way, this "prophecy" has already proven true. Republican politicians, not so much. Certainly this is a matter of good vs evil. That's very painfully clear. And it's true that the evil side is behind the Demoncrat party currently. But Republicans are not the opposite of Democrats. It's interesting that truth and goodness are more easily found in the average American conservative right now than in the hierarchy of the Catholic Church. Bishops are supposed to be spiritual, and not of this world, but the more closely they align themselves with this world, the more God moves worldly people to Himself. TLDR: I think it remains to be seen. There's a lot of evidence that's more or less the case. I would say, more specifically conservatives than Republicans. I don't identify as a Republican (even though I am). I identify as a conservative.
HumilityAndPatience Posted November 21, 2020 Author Posted November 21, 2020 On 11/19/2020 at 8:48 PM, fides' Jack said: It's interesting that truth and goodness are more easily found in the average American conservative right now than in the hierarchy of the Catholic Church I think the heresy of Americanism is actually beginning to rear it's head in a way which is floating under many people's radars.
fides' Jack Posted November 21, 2020 Posted November 21, 2020 8 hours ago, HumilityAndPatience said: I think the heresy of Americanism is actually beginning to rear it's head in a way which is floating under many people's radars. Define the heresy of Americanism.
HumilityAndPatience Posted November 21, 2020 Author Posted November 21, 2020 9 minutes ago, fides' Jack said: Define the heresy of Americanism. The definition of Pope Leo is sufficient for sure, on this. My view is that this heresy is flying under the radar via a false Traditionalism.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now