Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Please make me not a church militant


Recommended Posts

Anastasia13
Posted

@dUSt Please make me not a church militant any more. I don’t trust that there is a place for me right now. Thank you.

Posted

There is always a place.. wether you realize it or not.  It will forever wait for you if needed.

Anastasia13
Posted
10 hours ago, Didacus said:

There is always a place.. wether you realize it or not.  It will forever wait for you if needed.

I’m struggling with trusting that right now.

Posted

No one walks this world alone - may the Lord support you in your struggles until you find your place anew.

Be blessed.

Archaeology cat
Posted

Seconding Didacus. 

Posted

What is this church militant. I thought it was just how many posts you have made. Sorry you're not feeling great. Some days I don't have any faith at all. 

Posted
14 hours ago, GraceUk said:

What is this church militant. I thought it was just how many posts you have made. Sorry you're not feeling great. Some days I don't have any faith at all. 

>If you have Church Militant the site recognizes that you are faithful and active in defending the Church.  duSt can be more specific than me on the matter.

Anastasia13
Posted
On 7/2/2025 at 3:36 AM, Didacus said:

No one walks this world alone - may the Lord support you in your struggles until you find your place anew.

Be blessed.

Thank you. I hope that’s true. I’m worried honesty will disqualify me from conservative Christianity. It’s also been an intense spring. Lots going on. Lots that may or may not happen the way we hope.

Posted
8 hours ago, Anastasia13 said:

Thank you. I hope that’s true. I’m worried honesty will disqualify me from conservative Christianity. It’s also been an intense spring. Lots going on. Lots that may or may not happen the way we hope.

It's not like conservatives give out membershipo cards - lol...  What the Lord asks is a sincere heart that seeks His face.  If you do this, liebral/conservative/other does not matter.  Seek Him, pay no head to distractions, and He will find you when you need to be found.  Trust Him...  not us.  HIm.

And yes, it is true, no one walks alone.  We are many who know this to be a fact, hard as rock, no one is alone.

Anastasia13
Posted (edited)

Right. Just try saying you don’t like Trump around anyone who goes to Bible study. I would be lucky to be a simple libtard. 

Thank you though.

Edited by Anastasia13
Credo in Deum
Posted

Thankfully the only thing you need to be in the Catholic Church is orthodox. Titles like conservative or liberal mean nothing, and liking President Trump isn’t a requirement to be an orthodox Catholic.  Sadly the state of politics is a croutons shoot in the United States, but don’t lose heart. Our home is Heaven.  We’re simply on pilgrimage here in this beautiful purgatory.

 

Anastasia13
Posted
6 hours ago, Credo in Deum said:

Thankfully the only thing you need to be in the Catholic Church is orthodox. 

I’ve missed enough liturgy over the last couple years drifting with family and location and stuff, and they are Protestant. I want to go back, but it doesn’t feel that easy anymore.

Anastasia13
Posted

Someone tell me something, please? I know I smell of elderberries.

Posted (edited)

It may not feel that easy, but it actually is. 1- Unless you're going back to your old church, no one will recognize you when you walk in. You don't have a sign on your forehead that says "I've been away for a while." And you don't have to go back to your old church. You can walk into any Catholic church and attend Mass. You don't even have to show a membership card to anyone! 2- You will not be struck by lightning. I've been there and done that - if I had been struck by lightning, I'd have the T-shirt. 3- You know how to behave at Mass - when to stand, sit, kneel - so you won't stick out like a sore thumb. 4- You'll be glad you went. (5- If you really do smell of elderberries, you may want to spray on some eau de cologne before going.)

Edited by Luigi
Anastasia13
Posted

I have already been twice and have a father of confession who is out of town at the moment. The smelling of elderberries is Phatmass moderating my language. I still feel like I am living in two diverging paths of myself.

1 hour ago, Luigi said:

It may not feel that easy, but it actually is. 1- Unless you're going back to your old church, no one will recognize you when you walk in. You don't have a sign on your forehead that says "I've been away for a while." And you don't have to go back to your old church. You can walk into any Catholic church and attend Mass. You don't even have to show a membership card to anyone! 2- You will not be struck by lightning. I've been there and done that - if I had been struck by lightning, I'd have the T-shirt. 3- You know how to behave at Mass - when to stand, sit, kneel - so you won't stick out like a sore thumb. 4- You'll be glad you went. (5- If you really do smell of elderberries, you may want to spray on some eau de cologne before going.)

 

Credo in Deum
Posted (edited)
On 7/14/2025 at 11:30 PM, Anastasia13 said:

I’ve missed enough liturgy over the last couple years drifting with family and location and stuff, and they are Protestant. I want to go back, but it doesn’t feel that easy anymore.

That's the great thing about being Catholic is our feelings don't determine our Catholicity.  If I only did what I felt, I would never pray.  I can't tell you a time I looked at my rosary and said, "Ooh I can't wait until I get to pray that today".  That reaction doesn't mean I hate the rosary, it simply means my fallen nature is not inclined to pray it.   It's the same with confession and contrition.  The Church recognizes I don't have to feel sorry in order to be sorry. I don't have to wait until I have a feeling in order to approach the sacrament of reconciliation.  What matters is my desire to be reconciled and to have a firm purpose of amendment. Many saints have spoken about how in their spiritual life they went through tons of spiritual aridity, and they recognized this processes as necessary to purify their hearts of any attachment to self.  They understood that they could get attached to the good feelings from being virtuous and that if they were attached to those, they could easily end up seeking out virtue for their own self rather than for the love of God.   In that same way I would look at your situation as an invitation from God to practice true selfless love towards Him. 

 

If your issue is that you're having a crisis of faith, meaning you don't believe in God anymore, then that would be a different issue. 

Edited by Credo in Deum
Anastasia13
Posted (edited)
52 minutes ago, Credo in Deum said:

That's the great thing about being Catholic is our feelings don't determine our Catholicity.  If I only did what I felt, I would never pray.  I can't tell you a time I looked at my rosary and said, "Ooh I can't wait until I get to pray that today".  That reaction doesn't mean I hate the rosary, it simply means my fallen nature is not inclined to pray it.   It's the same with confession and contrition.  The Church recognizes I don't have to feel sorry in order to be sorry. I don't have to wait until I have a feeling in order to approach the sacrament of reconciliation.  What matters is my desire to be reconciled and to have a firm purpose of amendment. Many saints have spoken about how in their spiritual life they went through tons of spiritual aridity, and they recognized this processes as necessary to purify their hearts of any attachment to self.  They understood that they could get attached to the good feelings from being virtuous and that if they were attached to those, they could easily end up seeking out virtue for their own self rather than for the love of God.   In that same way I would look at your situation as an invitation from God to practice true selfless love towards Him. 

 

If your issue is that you're having a crisis of faith, meaning you don't believe in God anymore, then that would be a different issue. 

I believe in God and Jesus, but not confident what I believe about them other than the basic Christian stuff. I feel different strengthening pulls in my life and am coming of recent trauma/mental health stuff and I do not cope in healthy and Godly ways, coupled with evaluating some ingrained and learned scrupulosity.

Edited by Anastasia13
Credo in Deum
Posted
1 hour ago, Anastasia13 said:

I believe in God and Jesus, but not confident what I believe about them other than the basic Christian stuff. I feel different strengthening pulls in my life and am coming of recent trauma/mental health stuff and I do not cope in healthy and Godly ways, coupled with evaluating some ingrained and learned scrupulosity.

That makes sense and it's great you can see that about yourself.  As someone who's experienced trauma (molested as a child) I can empathize with what you're talking about.   I don't have a magic fix. This is a cross that will take time to carry, and I think for myself that journey is lifelong, but it's become more hopeful and God has helped me see he's not some Divine bean counter waiting to smite me whenever I fall.  Some helpful things I found in this journey of relationship with God has been to focus on things like the Prodigal Son, Christ Passion, and the Incarnation.  These things show a loving and merciful God who makes Himself vulnerable in order to have a relationship with us.  Even more so when you think about Him in the Eucharist.   I would encourage spending some time reflecting on those things and if possible grab the book "He and I" written by Gabrielle Bossis.  It's a diary style book, much like Divine Mercy, where Jesus talks to Gabrielle all the way until her death.  It's a very powerful book which has helped me a lot in my relationship with Jesus and I think it could help you as well. 

Anastasia13
Posted
On 7/17/2025 at 2:11 PM, Credo in Deum said:

That makes sense and it's great you can see that about yourself.  As someone who's experienced trauma (molested as a child) I can empathize with what you're talking about.   I don't have a magic fix. This is a cross that will take time to carry, and I think for myself that journey is lifelong, but it's become more hopeful and God has helped me see he's not some Divine bean counter waiting to smite me whenever I fall.  Some helpful things I found in this journey of relationship with God has been to focus on things like the Prodigal Son, Christ Passion, and the Incarnation.  These things show a loving and merciful God who makes Himself vulnerable in order to have a relationship with us.  Even more so when you think about Him in the Eucharist.   I would encourage spending some time reflecting on those things and if possible grab the book "He and I" written by Gabrielle Bossis.  It's a diary style book, much like Divine Mercy, where Jesus talks to Gabrielle all the way until her death.  It's a very powerful book which has helped me a lot in my relationship with Jesus and I think it could help you as well. 

Do you think this this is true about trauma?

IMG_8018.jpeg

tinytherese
Posted

Sadly, I don't have easy solutions, just stepping stones really. I often feel like an outsider in the faith. Each time Trump has run for office I've voted third party. Most of my political beliefs line up with The American Solidarity Party. I've been through trauma too. Not everybody reacts the same way. Regarding scrupulousity, I've found https://scrupulousanonymous.org/ to be a good resource. 

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...