Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Please make me not a church militant


Recommended Posts

Posted
On 10/14/2025 at 4:38 AM, Anastasia13 said:

Why would I want that if the Protestant interpretation says believe and I’ll go to heaven?

Avert the mortal sin or presumption?

I find that protestants often give 'easy' answers...  not trying to be insulting here or anything.  But there's more to it than 'believe'... do you think the devil believes in God?

19 hours ago, Anomaly said:

Fides is wrong.  Google Feenyism.   The correct Catholic answer is outside of the the Church, you lose access to many of the Graces Jesus has won for your redemption, so it is more difficult to obtain salvation. 

I can agree to this...

It is easier to ride into heaven in a car than a bicycle...  but both can get there.  The Church is in a way a tool to help in our salvation, and it's the best around.  Protestantism offers the same destination, but in a smaller vehicle.

Posted
On 10/16/2025 at 3:09 AM, Didacus said:

Protestantism offers the same destination, but in a smaller vehicle.

This is actually heresy, and one of the most prevalent today. It has been condemned by a multitude of popes and encyclicals, by Doctors of the Church, including St. Thomas Aquinas, by the early Church Fathers, and by the great mystics.  Not specifically Protestantism, but any faith outside of the Catholic Church.  

The Church teaches that only the Catholic Church offers the destination of Heaven.  It is possible for non-Catholics to get there, but only through the graces they get through the Catholic Church.  What @Anomaly said does not cross the doctrinal line your statement does.  What he said, even as a non-Catholic, can still be understood in congruence with Church teaching.  This line above cannot.

CCC 846:

Quote

Re-formulated positively, it means that all salvation comes from Christ the Head through the Church which is his Body

Emphasis mine.

Posted
13 hours ago, fides' Jack said:

This is actually heresy, and one of the most prevalent today. It has been condemned by a multitude of popes and encyclicals, by Doctors of the Church, including St. Thomas Aquinas, by the early Church Fathers, and by the great mystics.  Not specifically Protestantism, but any faith outside of the Catholic Church.  

The Church teaches that only the Catholic Church offers the destination of Heaven.  It is possible for non-Catholics to get there, but only through the graces they get through the Catholic Church.  What @Anomaly said does not cross the doctrinal line your statement does.  What he said, even as a non-Catholic, can still be understood in congruence with Church teaching.  This line above cannot.

CCC 846:

Emphasis mine.

I respectfully disagree.

Someone who was born into and follows genuinely their face by seeking Christ cannot be lost on account of the church they attend.

Although I admit that if someone is genuine and labours in their faith, inevitably in time this should bring to the Catholic faith.

Protestants have a share of the Truth, they do not however have the fullness of the Truth.

 

I do abhor the church of England and what they've become.  They have held to so little of the Truth now it is hard to imagine they have any of it.  Looks like they are heading towards another schism too.

 

All protestants are called to return to the one true Church,

Posted
6 hours ago, Didacus said:

I respectfully disagree.

Someone who was born into and follows genuinely their faith by seeking Christ cannot be lost on account of the church they attend.

Although I admit that if someone is genuine and labours in their faith, inevitably in time this should bring to the Catholic faith.

Protestants have a share of the Truth, they do not however have the fullness of the Truth.

 

I do abhor the church of England and what they've become.  They have held to so little of the Truth now it is hard to imagine they have any of it.  Looks like they are heading towards another schism too.

 

All protestants are called to return to the one true Church,

I agree with all of what you said here. 

But that is not the same as saying, "Protestantism offers the same destination."  Protestantism itself does not offer salvation in any way, shape, or form.  Only the Catholic Church offers salvation.  Other faiths cannot be said to offer salvation, in themselves, in even the slightest degree.  I'll reiterate: people of other religions can be saved, but only through special graces that ultimately come to them from Christ, through the Catholic Church.

It is a very important distinction; it's the difference between heresy and orthodoxy.

Posted
18 hours ago, fides' Jack said:

I agree with all of what you said here. 

But that is not the same as saying, "Protestantism offers the same destination."  Protestantism itself does not offer salvation in any way, shape, or form.  Only the Catholic Church offers salvation.  Other faiths cannot be said to offer salvation, in themselves, in even the slightest degree.  I'll reiterate: people of other religions can be saved, but only through special graces that ultimately come to them from Christ, through the Catholic Church.

It is a very important distinction; it's the difference between heresy and orthodoxy.

Maybe I didn't use the correct wording here - I meant to say that Protestantism has the same intent, and they advertise salvation, although admittedly the method is wrong.

What I notice most in protestant services is the the absence of sanctity - go to a couple of services then go to a Catholic Church and you will learn in part the immense value of the Eucharist. 

Posted

I've been considering lately the absence of a sacrifice in Protestant worship.  Catholics and Protestants alike have largely forgotten what true worship is, that it is centered around the Continual Sacrifice.  It's no wonder they think we worship the Blessed Virgin Mary, when their highest form of "worship" is singing songs and gathering in community.  And that goes to show, "Praise and Worship" is a misnomer.  That's not worship.  Not to a Catholic, anyway.

Posted

I agree.

However, I believe we've now high jacked this thread - maybe we should start another?

Posted (edited)

This is an age old topic, here at Phatmass.  Please review what the Church says about Mark 9:38….

Read the CCC 811-870, and especially 818, 819, and 822. 

Edited by Anomaly
  • 2 months later...
Posted

If it’s my responsibility and my consequence if something happens when I take my kid, maybe it’s better to just observe orthodoxy away from the church and keep more peace with the family. Maybe I should never have gone back to an Orthodox Church to begin with.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...