BLAZEr Posted August 29, 2004 Posted August 29, 2004 Morph, this is still a lazy argument. I do not dispute the fact that cigarettes cause all sorts of health problems, including cancer. It is still not responsible (honest or true or even reasonable, for that matter) to say that because someone is against making cigarettes illegal that they are therefore in favor of cancer or, since you seem to dispute that you said that, to say that being in favor of making cigarettes illegal is because you are against "diseases and subtle killing thru passive smoking.ancer" The fact is, you can be against this, and be against smoking cigarettes and still not believe that they should be illegal. Hi! I'm an example of this. I believe smoking cigarettes is bad for people. I discourage it. In fact, I actively try to help people stop. However, I think making them illegal is a ridiculous idea and one that only someone who is a socialist would support. You are from Australia right? And you are only 19. I don't blame you for not understanding this point. You have been raised in a culture and a political system where you are accustomed to the Government being the arbiter of what your moral choices should be. However, as an American and a Catholic, I do not believe this should be the case. I actually think its better for someone to choose not to smoke, even though its legal, because they are making a choice with their will to do something healthy and wise. This is called virtue. It's a good thing. Again, that's called a smack down.
MichaelFilo Posted August 29, 2004 Posted August 29, 2004 Alcohol is needed for consecration. God would not allow the outlaw of Alcohol (US tried, but we saw what happened). Nicotine causes addiction. Having an addiction and not fighting it is a mortal sin. We should not be addicted to anything. Allowing nicotine, which has NO health benefits, but can cause addiction after 2 cigarettes, and that would lead to grave matter(Addiction), is wrong. Comparing nicotine to alcohol is funny thinking. Alcohol has health benefits. Many studies have shown that. In excess, it is wrong. Nicotine has no health benefits. It maybe good for something, but I don't think it's good for anything inside us humans. God bless, Mikey
IcePrincessKRS Posted August 29, 2004 Posted August 29, 2004 [quote name='MichaelFilo' date='Aug 29 2004, 11:35 AM'] JMJ Pio Nono, whilst answering a question on the Q & A board, also answered this one. Anything becomes grave matter (a prerequist for mortal sin) once it becomes addiction. Making it illegal would drive people away from it. Yes, it should be illegal. God bless, Mikey [/quote] No it wouldn't. People would start growing in their back yards and smoking it illegally just like potheads.
MichaelFilo Posted August 29, 2004 Posted August 29, 2004 Somehow, that doesn't show a bright future AFTER the generation to use it. Pot was part of an age that revolted against the norm. Smoking is not looked down upon. I don't see how you can compare the two. Even if people grew it in their back yards, there would be significantly less people smoking. If it was illegal it may replace marijuana as the drug people do because it is illegal. This wouldn't be such a bad thing. Smoking tobacco wouldn't be a very successful practice after it is made illegal because, it is highly addictive, and so, one would only grow as a smoker, until it is obvious, and is then arrested. Weed, however, since it has no addiction or little addiction value, has successfully stayed around even after it was illegal. God bless, Mikey
Ash Wednesday Posted August 29, 2004 Posted August 29, 2004 I voted no. Should smoking be banned in the majority of public places, like restaurants? Absolutely. Reformation of the tobacco industry? Absolutely. But if someone wants to smoke an occasional pipe or a cigar in their home, I think making that illegal is overdoing it. Not to mention the cost and energy in enforcing the law. Good golly!! If we are going to outlaw all guilty pleasures because they are bad for our health, then we should outlaw all fried food like french fries, onion rings, fish n' chips, fried chicken, and all other junk food like Twinkies, Ding Dongs, Krispy Kreme, potato chips, pork rinds, Big Macs.... I don't know what a greater epidemic there is in our country -- smoking and its related health hazards, or obesity and heart disease. I'm inclined to guess the latter. It all boils down to using your head. If you wind up with a cholesterol count of 300 and lung cancer, most likely it's nobody's fault but your own. I'm all for taxing the krap out of tobacco and alcohol products and discouraging frequent use.
Ash Wednesday Posted August 29, 2004 Posted August 29, 2004 [quote name='IcePrincessKRS' date='Aug 29 2004, 03:07 PM'] Not Twinkies!!! [/quote]
IcePrincessKRS Posted August 29, 2004 Posted August 29, 2004 Man, now I have to go out and buy some... I'm drooling just thinking about Twinkies.... the pink kind with the coconut.... mmmmmmmmmmm.......
homeschoolmom Posted August 29, 2004 Posted August 29, 2004 Is that a dancing Twinkie??? I agree with Ash, Blazer, PedroX and <gulp> Phazzan... This is not an issue of law. Government cannot and should not hold your hand through life and wipe your nose all the time. I abhor smoking, but I don't think it should be make illegal. Education is much more effective.
homeschoolmom Posted August 29, 2004 Posted August 29, 2004 I would be realllllly interested to see how the vote broke down by age. Did anyone over 25 vote yes?
IcePrincessKRS Posted August 29, 2004 Posted August 29, 2004 Its a dancing banana but we can pretend its a Twinkie!
toledo_jesus Posted August 29, 2004 Posted August 29, 2004 [quote name='Ash Wednesday' date='Aug 29 2004, 03:04 PM'] If we are going to outlaw all guilty pleasures because they are bad for our health, then we should outlaw all fried food like french fries, onion rings, fish n' chips, fried chicken, and all other junk food like Twinkies, Ding Dongs, Krispy Kreme, potato chips, pork rinds, Big Macs.... [/quote] Boo-yah! Come on folks, alcohol is good in moderation, as is cheesecake or burgers. If you drink too much alcohol or eat too much cheesecake or burgers, health is affected. Likewise with tobacco. The key words here are moderation and too much. As an aside, those Truth ads make me want to smoke.
Phazzan Posted August 30, 2004 Posted August 30, 2004 [quote name='BLAZEr' date='Aug 29 2004, 01:41 PM'] You are from Australia right? And you are only 19. I don't blame you for not understanding this point. You have been raised in a culture and a political system where you are accustomed to the Government being the arbiter of what your moral choices should be. However, as an American and a Catholic, I do not believe this should be the case. [/quote] That's about the dumbest thing I've read all day. That's about as incoherent and illogical as MorphRC's comments regarding smoking. So WTF would you, as an American, and as a Catholic know about Australian culture and politics? Morph was right, get off your high horse.
BLAZEr Posted August 30, 2004 Posted August 30, 2004 [quote name='Phazzan' date='Aug 29 2004, 11:41 PM'] That's about the dumbest thing I've read all day. That's about as incoherent and illogical as MorphRC's comments regarding smoking. So WTF would you, as an American, and as a Catholic know about Australian culture and politics? Morph was right, get off your high horse. [/quote] Hey Phazzan . . . I probably know more about Australian culture and politics than you think, either way the statement was made to highlight the fact that most people who grow up in socialized governments (or semi socialized as is the case in Australia) where legislation is used to "educate" the populace about their social and moral responsibility, one becomes accustomed to assuming that the way to deal with a problem is through legislation . . . making something "illegal" becomes the way to say something is unacceptable, or innapropriate and exceedingly in liberal (in the classic sense) societies. In fact, more and more in these societies (Europe is the prime example, as well as Candada) what is legal is what is moral and what is illegal is what is immoral. More and more the idea of subsidiarity is excised from the society. This is happening in the United States and is, quite honestly, the goal of the Democratic party. However, since the United States is not a socialist country (although more and more it is becoming one) the idea that Government is the method through which undesirable aspects of society are eliminated is not quite so ingrained. We also have the relatively recent history of the Prohibition movement which was an unparalleled attempt to legislate moral choices. The fact that he is 19 is just used to illustrate that his socio-political formation has occurred within the last 10 years and therefore does not have a memory of a less socialized system, nor has he probably had the opportunitty to really question whether this method is a good one or not. Just so you know where I'm coming from. JA
Ash Wednesday Posted August 30, 2004 Posted August 30, 2004 Yeah, I thought the dancing banana looked kinda like a twinkie....
Phazzan Posted August 30, 2004 Posted August 30, 2004 [quote name='BLAZEr' date='Aug 30 2004, 12:41 AM'] Just so you know where I'm coming from. JA [/quote] Are you Australian? Have you lived here?
BLAZEr Posted August 30, 2004 Posted August 30, 2004 No, but when I was in college and still a govt. major (before I switched) I took a class on the Politics of Oceania which was mainly Australia, New Zealand, and the Phillipines. I would not claim to be an expert on your political system, but I know a fair amount. I'm rather a fan of John Howard though, take that as you will.
MorphRC Posted August 30, 2004 Posted August 30, 2004 [quote name='Phazzan' date='Aug 30 2004, 04:48 AM'] Morph, the same arguements could be used against the use of alcohol. i.e. Alcohol causes destruction of liver, alcohol causes car accidents, alcohol destroys lives bla bla bla. Fact is, it's not alcohol and cigerettes that cause illness, death, fatality, destruction whatever, it's how people choose to use (and abuse) it. [/quote] Only thru over-drinking. Moderate drinking doesnt. I dont know if wine is under the alcohol banner, but health doctors actually ask people to have a class of red wine a day. I cant remember why, but apparently its good for your system. Tobacco, causes all the above, whether you have 1 or 100.
Ash Wednesday Posted August 30, 2004 Posted August 30, 2004 I think I'm going to go have a glass of my dad's homemade elderberry wine. It's gooooood!
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now