MorphRC Posted September 12, 2004 Posted September 12, 2004 THey should be made illegal. Along with alcohol.
cooltuba Posted September 12, 2004 Posted September 12, 2004 [quote name='MorphRC' date='Sep 12 2004, 01:35 AM'] THey should be made illegal. Along with alcohol. [/quote] You are trying to use the govt. to impose your moralistic ideals on the masses. It will not work. This is not an assumption, it's been proven. Morph, I respect you, but your ideas on this particular subject lack sound reasoning. To ban smoking and alcohol simply because there are health risks associated with them would mean that you'd have to ban all things that put your health at risk. I guess this all boils down to a political issue. I believe that the govt. should be only as imposing as it has to be to guarantee the basic human rights. You believe that the government should be a moral watch-dog for it's people, not just protecting their basic rights, but restricting it's citizenry to what it deems is "good" for them. Once again, as I stated above, we have to be given the opportunity to choose God over sin, and if the govt. makes all those decisions for us in the form of laws it distracts from the glory of God. That's about all I have to say on the subject, Morph, if you have any new arguments I'd be happy to discuss more, but I'm finished dissecting your previous arguments. Peace in Christ, TIm
MorphRC Posted September 13, 2004 Posted September 13, 2004 [quote name='cooltuba' date='Sep 13 2004, 03:29 AM'] You are trying to use the govt. to impose your moralistic ideals on the masses. It will not work. This is not an assumption, it's been proven. Morph, I respect you, but your ideas on this particular subject lack sound reasoning. To ban smoking and alcohol simply because there are health risks associated with them would mean that you'd have to ban all things that put your health at risk. I guess this all boils down to a political issue. I believe that the govt. should be only as imposing as it has to be to guarantee the basic human rights. You believe that the government should be a moral watch-dog for it's people, not just protecting their basic rights, but restricting it's citizenry to what it deems is "good" for them. Once again, as I stated above, we have to be given the opportunity to choose God over sin, and if the govt. makes all those decisions for us in the form of laws it distracts from the glory of God. That's about all I have to say on the subject, Morph, if you have any new arguments I'd be happy to discuss more, but I'm finished dissecting your previous arguments. Peace in Christ, TIm [/quote] Let me re-re-read that, I couldnt get passed the first line. [quote]You are trying to use the govt. to impose your moralistic ideals on the masses. [/quote] I thought they used us, to impose their 'Moral' ideals. Theres no lack in reasoning. 1 Cigs Kill 2 Cigs are drugs 3 Cigs murder 4 Cigs make big bucks while ppl die. Is there something missing? Like. They dont kill? or something along those lines. ============== [b]BAN THE BONG[/b] ==============
cathoholic Posted September 20, 2004 Posted September 20, 2004 Heard all the arguments for and against, and until the Church comes up with something on the subject I shall remain neutral. I don't like smoke though, so if the majority of people decide to ban those things, then I won't be mad but if they don't it makes no difference.
popestpiusx Posted September 20, 2004 Posted September 20, 2004 Hello again all! Just thought I would chime in on a few things then disappear again for a while. The whole notion of the government making smoking illegal is absurd. I am mostly with Blazr on this one. The facts about smoking are not as clear as some on here are suggesting. Not everyone that smokes dies from it. I know many people who have smoked for fifty years and have far exceeded any previous “life expectancy”. Here is a clip from an article entitled “'Oldest' title no big deal to Ohio woman, 114”: “Dr. Stephen Coles, a UCLA stem cell researcher who is executive director of the Gerontology Research Group, has examined the background of the list's supercentenarians to identify their shared habits. It's been unproductive. "There's hardly anything these people have in common," Coles said. "It's grasping at straws to try to put a story together, like Sherlock Holmes, of anything these people do in their lives to accomplish these records on the outer limits of longevity. ... All of these people are so extraordinary in longevity, but unextraordinary in every other way." Obese people do not make the list, but Frenchwoman Calment was a smoker. Some others were heavy drinkers. Some both drink and smoke, and end up outliving the physicians who advise them to stop if they want to live a long and healthy life.” The second hand smoke thing is loosing credibility. And the suggestion that smoking should be banned in all public places is the most absurd of all. If I own a bar or a restaurant there is no way anyone can justify forcing me to not allow smoking. If people don't want to go, then don't go. If no one wants to go, then I'll go out of business. What is more likely the case is that I will have a pretty solid customer base. In places where smoking in public is banned (like New York City, where you can put up near porn advertisements but cannot smoke in a bar) there are a few courageous bar owners who decided to just pay the fine. They are highly successful. Don't like the smoke, don't go. But don't come in my bar, which I own, and whine about the smoke. I would simply point toward the door. I'm not saying that you should be forced to smell it or sit in it if you don't like it, but you surely cannot tell a person that he cannot allow smoking in his privately owned business. Furthermore, I know several women who have many children (in one case, 10 children) and smoked through every pregnancy. Not a single problem with any of the births, nor with any of the children. The only reason the medical profession condemns smoking while pregnant is due to statistical evidence, not to actual medical evidence. Why? Because it would be unethical as hell (which is pretty unethical) to do human testing. So they say, better safe than sorry. Their links are due to statistics linking premature births and some defects with women who smoked during the pregnancy. This is hardly proving a connection, but merely establishing a possible link. By the way, and for the record, my wife has never smoked during pregnancy. She believes, as I do, that it is better not to risk it. Better safe than sorry. Lastly, the medical profession has known about possible connections (which remain merely possible and not guaranteed) for many many years. Over a century at least. For instance, Ulysses Grant’s death from mouth cancer was immediately linked to his cigar smoking. This was in the 1877. Pier Giorgio died in 1925, a smoker. Pope St. Pius X also smoked, as did Blessed Miguel Pro. This is but a small list. All three died in the 20th Cent. Long after the connection was known. This opposition to smoking is but another hangover from the Puritanism that has so infected the English speaking world. There is no moral, nor any social justification for completely banning smoking. There is much more to say on this (for instance, why a government that has no regard for human life would campaign so stridently against tobacco) but I’ve rambled long enough. In closing, I will simply say, with Denis Roddy of the Post-Gazette: "For now, let us grab what idle pleasures we can. So, if you don't mind, I'm going to buy a cigar. And if you do mind, just cough loudly. It'll remind me to light it."
popestpiusx Posted September 21, 2004 Posted September 21, 2004 This is one of my favorite poems: Whene'er I take my pipe and stuff it And smoke to pass the time away My thoughts, as I sit there and puff it, Dwell on a picture sad and grey: It teaches me that very like Am I myself unto my pipe. Like me this pipe, so fragrant burning, Is made of naught but earthen clay; To earth I too shall be returning, And cannot halt my slow decay. My well used pipe, now cracked and broken, Of mortal life is but a token. No stain, the pipe's hue yet doth darken; It remains white. Thus do I know That when to death's call I must harken My body, too, all pale will grow. To black beneath the sod 'twill turn, Likewise the pipe, if oft it burn. Or when the pipe is fairly glowing, Behold then instantaneously, The smoke off into thin air going,' Til naught but ash is left to see. Man's fame likewise away will burn And unto dust his body turn. How oft it happens when one's smoking,T he tamper's missing from it's shelf, And one goes with one's finger poking Into the bowl and burns oneself. If in the pipe such pain doth dwell How hot must be the pains of Hell! Thus o'er my pipe in contemplation Of such things - I can constantly Indulge in fruitful meditation, And so, puffing contentedly, On land, at sea, at home, abroad, I smoke my pipe and worship God. Johann Sebastian Bach - 1725 (1685-1750)
DemonSlayer Posted September 21, 2004 Posted September 21, 2004 Yes it should be illegal, at least it should be banned in public or around babies, young children and pregant women, etc.
CreepyCrawler Posted September 21, 2004 Posted September 21, 2004 Smoking stinks and I would never smoke. But it cannot be made illegal logistically and logically. Just because something is bad for your health does not mean that it should be banned. Trans-fatty acids are SO HORRIBLY AWFUL FOR YOUR HEALTH but they are found in nearly all junk food and PEANUT BUTTER and it doesn't look like they're gonna be illegal ever. And what about coffee? It has caffeine which is highly addictive and is not good for your health but that's not illegal either. People need to be educated to make good choices but you can't make everything illegal b/c people won't even know why they're not doing it in the first place. I agree w/ Kilroy that there needs to be tougher regulations on what goes into cigarettes and I think that smoking in enclosed areas needs to be regulated, too. But I don't think that smoking is a mortal sin. It's smelly and bad for you, but not a sin.
popestpiusx Posted September 21, 2004 Posted September 21, 2004 [quote name='DemonSlayer' date='Sep 20 2004, 09:59 PM'] Yes it should be illegal, at least it should be banned in public or around babies, young children and pregant women, etc. [/quote] Read my statement above on banning smoking in public places.
RandomProddy Posted September 21, 2004 Posted September 21, 2004 (edited) [quote name='MorphRC' date='Aug 28 2004, 06:49 PM'] Yes they should. And they should be deemed a mortal sin, since they are a drug. [/quote] Jesus drank wine. Besides, if you banned all alcohol, how would you have Mass? Edited September 21, 2004 by RandomProddy
popestpiusx Posted September 22, 2004 Posted September 22, 2004 (edited) :smoker: :pipe: Edited September 22, 2004 by popestpiusx
ironmonk Posted September 22, 2004 Posted September 22, 2004 Making tabacco products illegal will never happen. The government makes far to much money from it. Over $3 per pack is taxes. It is similar to [b]Prov. 31:6 [/b]Give strong drink to one who is perishing, and wine to the sorely depressed; [b]7 [/b]When they drink, they will forget their misery, and think no more of their burdens. Some people use them as an escape. Yes they are addictive, but so is alcohol to some people. just my 2 cents. God Bless, ironmonk
ironmonk Posted September 22, 2004 Posted September 22, 2004 [quote name='MorphRC' date='Sep 13 2004, 04:13 AM'] Let me re-re-read that, I couldnt get passed the first line. I thought they used us, to impose their 'Moral' ideals. Theres no lack in reasoning. 1 Cigs Kill 2 Cigs are drugs 3 Cigs murder 4 Cigs make big bucks while ppl die. Is there something missing? Like. They dont kill? or something along those lines. ============== [b]BAN THE BONG[/b] ============== [/quote] Cigs do not kill everyone who smokes them. I knew a lady who smoked from age 15 to 95... she died of old age. They are not murder. They will never be illegal, and should not be. They are a simple pleasure to some, to some they are a monkey on their back.... just as with so many things in life. Alcohol, drugs, sex, food, etc.... If the logic you posted is to be used, it must be used with all things that can be addictive and cause death.... Food kills people and people get addicted to food, gain hundreds of pounds and get their arteries clogged... we should make food illegal because people surely can't control themselves with it and it's for their own good. God Bless, ironmonk
Christ's Knight Posted September 22, 2004 Posted September 22, 2004 Whats up with all the "Anti-smoking"? I would say it (cig. smoking) is by no means good for you but it can be pleasurable. I would also venture to say that if you have never smoked you really can not comment on this. The addiction is the bad thing. But being human, we are all culpable of an addiction of some sort... alcohol being also very addictive (or should I say the intoxication being addictive). Which one could argue is worse as it lowers your inhibitions and may very well lead to SIN. Yes and even sex is addictive to that type of personallity. That is not good (pre-marital & extra-marital and also marriages based soley on sexual activity). So are we to "outlaw" everything we fear??? The tobacco companies should "clean" up the cigarettes and make them less dangerous, because nic-o-teen is not harmful but it is what smokers chase with each passing cigarette. Unfortunately, the habit gets the better of them and they begin to light up more often. I know a few people that burn 1 or 2 a day to relax in the evening or only socially. By the way, anyone that made a reference to secondhand smoke being a killer is in grave error. Just because you can smell smoke does not mean you are taking in the toxins in the cigarette itself. (Blowing smoke at someone is a different story, but how often does that happen?) My point number 2! The biast, rampant, liberal media (you know the on that supports abortion, makes no effort to give any facts on the many Christians be murdered in the Middle East, keeps the Jewish holecost close at mind but NEVER reminds us of how the Christians were persecuted for their beliefs & believe me I could go on & on & on but anyway) yeah they are totally against cigarettes & smoking. That alone almost makes me want to go to start burning the tobacco.
Guest T-Bone Posted September 22, 2004 Posted September 22, 2004 [quote]I would also venture to say that if you have never smoked you really can not comment on this.[/quote] The same could be said about pot, LSD, PCP, cocaine, heroine.......
Christ's Knight Posted September 22, 2004 Posted September 22, 2004 he same could be said about pot, LSD, PCP, cocaine, heroine....... True but they are illegal!
Christ's Knight Posted September 22, 2004 Posted September 22, 2004 But you are also missing my point.... I cant say nothing -good- comes from LSD and the like, because I have not tried it! I dont recomend it or smoking cigarettes but dont say it is useless as I dont know. Apparently some people find it has positives....
ironmonk Posted September 22, 2004 Posted September 22, 2004 [quote name='Christ's Knight' date='Sep 22 2004, 05:27 AM'] But you are also missing my point.... I cant say nothing -good- comes from LSD and the like, because I have not tried it! I dont recomend it or smoking cigarettes but dont say it is useless as I dont know. Apparently some people find it has positives.... [/quote] Bro, You are pulling at straws here for the logic that you are trying to use. We can say things about these even if we haven't tried them. We can learn from observing and drawing logical conclusions. Nothing good can come from LSD - PCP - etc... People that find that those have positives, are not smart people, and are foolish for even saying such things. but, they are already illegal... Cigs are bad... they help some people relax with minimal side effects, and has been used for centuries. This world is not for our pleasure... this world is to sanctify us. We should be very cautious in seeking any creature comforts and pleasures. As for the drugs, take a few organic chemistry classes... cover what these drugs do... you will change your tune. This is about cigs. and we can say things. I don't smoke. I tried a cig when I was 13, just to see what it was like. One can never touch a cig and know from the basic knowledge of tabacco that it is bad and they can make statements about them. Cigs are bad... some people suffer from them... Should they be illegal... simply put... no, because the side effects do not effect everyone and they take a long time to happen, taxes, people have been doing it for centuries, people don't turn to a life of crime to satisfy their habit. God Bless, ironmonk
toledo_jesus Posted September 22, 2004 Posted September 22, 2004 common sense here people. You won't live one extra day no matter what you do. Does that mean you should go crazy and develop a bunch of bad habits? No...and cigs unfortunately are the easiest way to abuse tobacco. But you can't make a blanket tobacco ban. Pipe tobacco is awesome and too much work to be anything but a hobby. Alcohol has had as many sanctions placed against it as I think is reasonably possible. age limits, legal limit for driving, etc. People will get in trouble for violating these things so that's that.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now