Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Is Driving Without Insurance A Mortal Sin?


Recommended Posts

Posted

It depends upon how grave you understand it to be. You are risking causeing incredible hardship on your wife if you were injured. Consider if you damage another's car or injure them and cannot pay for them to recover their loss you are responsible for. Are you driving alot, or very little, only when it's absolutely necessary and for short distances? Why don't you have insurance?

Posted

It's not me driving w/o insurance.

Thought it is very short distances (as far as driving is concerned) for the person to get to work. And they can't afford it.

homeschoolmom
Posted

What's the law in Michigan? Here the law requires it.

Posted

The speed limit for this person to get to work is 25-35 MPH zones. So it is highly unlikely that they would put any lives or property in danger. Though it is still a risk.

Posted

[quote name='Brother Adam' date='Sep 2 2004, 09:39 AM'] It's not me driving w/o insurance.

Thought it is very short distances (as far as driving is concerned) for the person to get to work. And they can't afford it. [/quote]
Then they should walk, ride or alternatively... stay home and watch television.

Posted

I don't think I'd call it 'Mortal'. You know the qualifications. But it could be very serious. That person should seize the opportunity for Grace, and start bumming rides, or walking, or riding a bike. Life's an adventure. Who knows who they will meet or what will happen.

Bro Adam. I'm going to send you an e-mail. I've got a question for you.

homeschoolmom
Posted

If it's a very short distance, walk.

Posted

Right, but one qaulification is "grave" in nature. That is what I was questioning.

Posted

People get in accidents all the time at low speeds. I've been hit 4 times, none of them my fault, and all of them in speed zones less that 30 mph.

Driving without insurance is a bad idea for a number of reasons, not the least of which is that it's illegal. Your friend is putting himself/herself at risk, and the investment she/he put into a car -- what if someone who is uninsured hits him/her? (This has happened to me and to a couple of friends of mine -- in that case, your insurance covers any damage to you or to your car).

Or, what if he/she hits someone else? He/she is personally liable for damage to persons or property. What if a child runs in front of this person's car? What if a bicyclist comes out of nowhere? This is why we have insurance.

If they can't afford insurance, then they can't afford to be driving a car. Get a motor scooter or a bike, esp. since it's really short distances.

Posted

Right right. For this gal it would be a hour walk or 10 minute drive. Anyways, you answered my question Jasjis. Thanks all. Problem solved.

Posted

As far as the sinfulness of it ... you're disobeying a law of the state, and it could have serious consequences. Not sure where that falls in the moral scheme of things ... but it's not a good idea, that's for sure.

homeschoolmom
Posted

You are putting other people in possible danger. If someone doesn't have insurance and the injured party's insurance doesn't completely cover all the medical bills, that person might have to file bankruptcy! I would say that's pretty grave, don't you?

Posted

[quote name='homeschoolmom' date='Sep 2 2004, 09:47 AM'] You are putting other people in possible danger. If someone doesn't have insurance and the injured party's insurance doesn't completely cover all the medical bills, that person might have to file bankruptcy! I would say that's pretty grave, don't you? [/quote]
Yeah, I was thinking about that ... I mean, we're talking about potential harm, and I don't know where that falls into the scheme of things.

Posted

Maybe, maybe not. Stealing food becuase you are hungry and have no means could fall into grave too in certian circumstances. I guess it's for the Church to decide though. ;)


Dang it's good to be Catholic.

homeschoolmom
Posted

Frankly, I don't think an hour walk merits driving w/o insurance. I used to have to walk to work (in the MN winter) in my polyester uniform... don't ask...

Posted

That would be pretty cold.

I've walked to work in the middle of the winter too. I walked everywhere for a long time.

BullnaChinaShop
Posted

I don't think it is prudent to drive without insurance but I think whether it would be a sin or not would have to do with the way the person drove.

Ash Wednesday
Posted

I don't know about it being mortal in all cases, but it certainly is a huge and foolish gamble. It certainly would be some sort of sin if done on a regular basis and someone just didn't care.

If I didn't have insurance I'd ride my bike, and only drive if it was an emergency.

Posted

Can this person take public transportation or get a ride from someone?

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...