Sojourner Posted September 2, 2004 Posted September 2, 2004 [quote name='Brother Adam' date='Sep 2 2004, 09:51 AM'] Maybe, maybe not. Stealing food becuase you are hungry and have no means could fall into grave too in certian circumstances. I guess it's for the Church to decide though. Dang it's good to be Catholic. [/quote] Stealing food to avoid starvation and breaking the law to avoid personal discomfort are two different things, I think. The ethics of driving without insurance should be evaluated in a couple of different ways. Under civil law, driving without insurance is prohibited, and we are bound to follow the civil law unless it is directly contrary to church teaching. As a Christian, because of all the reasons that have already been listed, driving without insurance is not a particularly loving act toward your neighbor. In a twinkle, you could leave someone in serious financial straits. In my view, this is breaking one of the two greatest commandments, and thereby could easily cross into mortal sin.
theculturewarrior Posted September 2, 2004 Posted September 2, 2004 I don't know if it's a grave sin...but it can have grave consequences.
Sojourner Posted September 2, 2004 Posted September 2, 2004 Well, my thinking on calling it a grave sin is that it can cause serious harm to a person. If I am knowingly driving without insurance, and I hit someone's car, and they end up having to submit the claim to their insurance company and their insurance rates rise, and maybe they have to pay a deductible ... isn't that something like stealing from them? I've intentionally engaged in an action that results in loss to another person.
homeschoolmom Posted September 2, 2004 Posted September 2, 2004 And what if the other person's car is totaled? Insurance companies often don't pay enough to actually replace the car, only what it's monetary value was.
BullnaChinaShop Posted September 2, 2004 Posted September 2, 2004 I think everyone is thinking of insurance backwards. Not having it doesn't cause anything bad to happen because the bad has already happened in the form of the accident. Insurance works by reducing the negative side effects of a bad situation. Insurance in and of itself is neither morally good or bad. I agree that is a state mandates it you should have it but if not I don't think you do anything wrong by not having it.
homeschoolmom Posted September 2, 2004 Posted September 2, 2004 I disagree. I agree that if you wish to not cover your vehicle, fine by me. But you should have liability to protect me if you should do damage to my car, health etc. If you cause damage to my car and don't have insurance to pay for it, I will have to pay the deductable on my insurance and probably pay higher premiums. This is not responsible. Driving is a privalage, not a right. If you can't afford to pay for the basic insurance, there are other ways to get around.
Brother Adam Posted September 2, 2004 Author Posted September 2, 2004 Bull has a good perspective. Insurance can only become sinful because it is a civil law, because we are told to obey civil laws. Otherwise, an accident is just that, an accident.
Guest T-Bone Posted September 2, 2004 Posted September 2, 2004 I was in an accident with an uninsured driver. I expirenced severe financial hardship as a result. Driving without insurance is thoughtless, irresponsible, and ILLEGAL. It causes harm to others. As has been said before, driving is a privledge. It is not a neccesty, there are other modes of transportation. It delights me to no end when I see an uninsured driver get his car impounded. If you're not responsible enough to purchase insurance, you're not responsible enough to operate a motor vehicle.
homeschoolmom Posted September 2, 2004 Posted September 2, 2004 [quote name='T-Bone' date='Sep 2 2004, 03:05 PM'] I was in an accident with an uninsured driver. I expirenced severe financial hardship as a result. [/quote] I was as well and so I may come off as harsh. I was under a great financial burden-- and the other driver was not insured.
Guest T-Bone Posted September 2, 2004 Posted September 2, 2004 [quote name='homeschoolmom' date='Sep 2 2004, 03:29 PM'] I was as well and so I may come off as harsh. I was under a great financial burden-- and the other driver was not insured. [/quote] I too, hope that I don't sound too harsh.
jasJis Posted September 2, 2004 Posted September 2, 2004 [quote name='T-Bone' date='Sep 2 2004, 03:05 PM'] I was in an accident with an uninsured driver. I expirenced severe financial hardship as a result. Driving without insurance is thoughtless, irresponsible, and ILLEGAL. It causes harm to others. As has been said before, driving is a privledge. It is not a neccesty, there are other modes of transportation. It delights me to no end when I see an uninsured driver get his car impounded. If you're not responsible enough to purchase insurance, you're not responsible enough to operate a motor vehicle. [/quote] I've been hit a number of times by uninsured motorists. The reasons have been varied. I've been broke and have driven un-insured cars due to money or paperwork problems or for convenience. Some people were taking advantage of the system. Others were struggling. There's a big difference between people driving w/out insurance and making trips as often as you or I, and people who have no insurance and drive the absolute bare minimum that they can't avoid. There's a difference between people having no insurance as a temporary problem, or having no insurance as a cheap way of life. This is a good example how a minor venial sin can become a habit and numb you to allowing yourself to commit serious sin or even mortal sin. To have this become a mortal sin, the person would drive without extra and extreme caution, have no plans to get insurance, care little for the possible harm they would do others, would probably run or commit another scam to avoid liability if they cause damage, and couldn't really justify it with dire financial problems. Unless you've been dead broke. I mean eating mac & coagulated milk broke. It's hard to understand what a difficult situation it is to be able to afford insurance when you need the car to get to work. I've had to do it. Now, I carry uninsured motorist insurance. I'd hate to see anyone lose their car unless the particular situation was due to pure negligence and disregard for others.
Guest T-Bone Posted September 2, 2004 Posted September 2, 2004 [quote]I've been hit a number of times by uninsured motorists. The reasons have been varied. I've been broke and have driven un-insured cars due to money or paperwork problems or for convenience. Some people were taking advantage of the system. Others were struggling. There's a big difference between people driving w/out insurance and making trips as often as you or I, and people who have no insurance and drive the absolute bare minimum that they can't avoid. There's a difference between people having no insurance as a temporary problem, or having no insurance as a cheap way of life.[/quote] I rarely drive my car, execpt to and from work/Mass, and to my grandmother's house, to do maintainence/yard work. Insurance isn't that expensive, if you can afford the gas to drive, then you should be able to affford insurance. [quote]This is a good example how a minor venial sin can become a habit and numb you to allowing yourself to commit serious sin or even mortal sin. To have this become a mortal sin, the person would drive without extra and extreme caution, have no plans to get insurance, care little for the possible harm they would do others, would probably run or commit another scam to avoid liability if they cause damage, and couldn't really justify it with dire financial problems.[/quote] People who drive without insurance are putting thier desires above the needs of others. They do not care about the damage they could inflict on innocent persons. [quote]Unless you've been dead broke. I mean eating mac & coagulated milk broke. It's hard to understand what a difficult situation it is to be able to afford insurance when you need the car to get to work. I've had to do it. Now, I carry uninsured motorist insurance. I'd hate to see anyone lose their car unless the particular situation was due to pure negligence and disregard for others. [/quote] I've been that broke. You do not need a car to get to work. You can bike, you can take public transportation, you can walk. People who drive without insurance are selfish, arragont, and lazy.
homeschoolmom Posted September 2, 2004 Posted September 2, 2004 The situation that we were given by Bro. Adam was a ten minute drive vs. a 60 minute walk. While I certainly wouldn't want to walk for an hour after working, it is certainly not impossible to do so. He also said that it was within 35 mile zones, so the person in question would not be in unnecessary danger of walking along the freeway. Driving is a luxury (certainly one that we take for granted). But if the law requires insurance, then it is wrong to advise someone in the above situation to disregard the law (I am not agruing the merit of mortal sin or not...). Would you advise someone who could not afford to renew his driver's license to drive without one?
Pete-ster Posted September 3, 2004 Posted September 3, 2004 Driving without insurance is wrong. There is no excuse.
Brother Adam Posted September 3, 2004 Author Posted September 3, 2004 That can still be like saying stealing bread is wrong, there is no excuse. If the situation was that you cannot get to work without driving a car, but you cannot afford insurance for a short period of time, then you don't earn money and go even further into debt. If you can't afford food and there is no other means to get it, you have to steal it. (Not saying that this would apply to anyone who has a computer and the internet ). Also, while I'm playing on this side of the fence, whoever said insurance doesn't cost that much, is full of carp. I have friends who are white males between 18 and 24, that the cheapest they can get their insurance is 1,600 every six months. That is a lot of money. The cheapest I've ever been able to get it is $850. Often times it leaves me feeling like the government and these businesses are blood sucking vultures. Finally, I'm not sure who everyone here is arguing with, as I searched for a post that said "Driving without insurance isn't a risk" or something. Everyone here believes it is a danger and could possibly become mortally sinful. So I'm not sure what is up with that.
homeschoolmom Posted September 3, 2004 Posted September 3, 2004 [quote name='Brother Adam' date='Sep 3 2004, 09:36 AM'] That can still be like saying stealing bread is wrong, there is no excuse. If the situation was that you cannot get to work without driving a car, but you cannot afford insurance for a short period of time, then you don't earn money and go even further into debt. [/quote] But you said the person [i]could[/i] get to work-- but it's an inconvenient 60 minute walk. BTW, you still haven't said whether or not it's required by law in this person's state.
Sojourner Posted September 3, 2004 Posted September 3, 2004 [quote name='Brother Adam' date='Sep 3 2004, 09:36 AM'] That can still be like saying stealing bread is wrong, there is no excuse. If the situation was that you cannot get to work without driving a car, but you cannot afford insurance for a short period of time, then you don't earn money and go even further into debt. If you can't afford food and there is no other means to get it, you have to steal it. (Not saying that this would apply to anyone who has a computer and the internet ). [/quote] As I said earlier, stealing food to avoid starvation and breaking the law to avoid personal discomfort are two different things. You'll have to go a long way to convince me that your friend will die if she can't drive to work. As Hsmom has said, driving is a privilege, and is not essential to the continual functioning of life. There are other ways your friend could get to work that would not involve breaking the law, and would not put her in a position of endangering herself and others. [quote]Finally, I'm not sure who everyone here is arguing with, as I searched for a post that said "Driving without insurance isn't a risk" or something. Everyone here believes it is a danger and could possibly become mortally sinful. So I'm not sure what is up with that.[/quote] You asked us to give opinions on the gravity of driving without insurance, and then you characterized the situation as being "highly unlikely that they would put any lives or property in danger." Although you admitted that there would still be a risk, you made it clear from this statement (at least to me) that you didn't believe it to be a grave risk. So, I and others answered accordingly. Also, I'm wondering about your statement that this "could possibly become mortally sinful." Are you implying that driving without insurance would only become mortally sinful if something bad happened? To me, that's like saying that randomly firing a gun into the air is only bad if it kills someone. The moral goodness or badness of an act is not determined by the outcome of the act -- it's determined by the nature of the act itself.
jasJis Posted September 3, 2004 Posted September 3, 2004 You people need to relax. The question was whether or not driving without insurance as a Mortal Sin. There is no debate about it being wrong. The discussion was evaluating it's graveness to consider if it was grave enough to be considered Mortal and to consider if the person is realizing the gravity and doing it anyway. A Sin, in and of itself, isn't automatically "Mortal". Read the Catechism. You also have to consider the purpose of the person commiting the sin to consider whether it's a major venial sin or a Mortal sin.
Didacus Posted November 19, 2008 Posted November 19, 2008 [quote name='homeschoolmom' post='338409' date='Sep 2 2004, 10:53 AM']Frankly, I don't think an hour walk merits driving w/o insurance. I used to have to walk to work (in the MN winter) in my polyester uniform... don't ask...[/quote] I agree. Except for the polyester thing and no, I'm not asking.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now