Brother Adam Posted November 7, 2004 Posted November 7, 2004 Since this is just an inquiry and not really up for a debate, I'll post it in open mic. Let's say Joe Catholic commits a mortal sin and while he means to confess the sin, by the time confession comes around he forgets to confess the sin. Joe then ends up forgetting all about the mortal sin before the next chance he has confession. Since Joe has a mortal sin on his soul and forgets not only to confess it, forgets he committed it all-together can Joe Catholic ever be forgiven? Or is this forgotten mortal sin doomed to haunt him all the way to hell?
DancesforLove Posted November 7, 2004 Posted November 7, 2004 Hmm, thats an interesting question. I'd assume Joe Catholic wouldn't be forgiven until he repented and to repent you should confess and if you confess your sins then you remember it. So basically as long as you don't repent it's still a stain on your soul. Correct me if I am wrong?
phatcatholic Posted November 7, 2004 Posted November 7, 2004 i would say that he is headed towards eternal separation from Christ. the fact is that his relationship w/ Christ has been severed. forgetting not only to confess the sin, but about the sin altogether, could hint at an absense of genuine remorse. this is a serious offense in and of itself. this is why it is important to preclude a confession w/ a prayer to the Holy Spirit that he will bring to mind all of your sins and to end a confession with ".......and for any other sins that i have forgotten." btw, posts like these are better suited for the Apo board
DancesforLove Posted November 7, 2004 Posted November 7, 2004 psst I think I was right about apologetics for a first lol, phatcatholic said basically what I said just less concise *happydance*
DancesforLove Posted November 7, 2004 Posted November 7, 2004 hehehe (I'm terrible at apologetics it's quite sad)
Brother Adam Posted November 7, 2004 Author Posted November 7, 2004 *breaks out in cold sweat* what if [b]I[/b] have ever fogotten a mortal sin?
Guest Aluigi Posted November 7, 2004 Posted November 7, 2004 forgetting to confess your sin is not a sin. if you are contrite, but forget to mention it in the confessional (mental lapse, nervousness, anything that's not conscious hiding of it) you are absolved. the only way you would invalidate the priest's absolution is if you either were not truly sorry, did not truly intend to amend your life, or purposefully hid the sin from the priest. sorry phatcatholic, but that was too harsh. it's not true, you would too be forgiven of your sin regardless of whether you made the prayer "and for all others that i forget"
phatcatholic Posted November 7, 2004 Posted November 7, 2004 [quote name='Brother Adam' date='Nov 6 2004, 11:27 PM'] *breaks out in cold sweat* what if [b]I[/b] have ever fogotten a mortal sin? [/quote] just do this, bro: [quote name='"phatcatholic"']....preclude a confession w/ a prayer to the Holy Spirit that he will bring to mind all of your sins and to end a confession with ".......and for any other sins that i have forgotten."[/quote]
Guest Aluigi Posted November 7, 2004 Posted November 7, 2004 that is a very pious practious that I too would recomend, but again I stress that is not a necessity for forgiveness of a forgotten sin!
Brother Adam Posted November 7, 2004 Author Posted November 7, 2004 okay cool. That's something that could screw a guy up for life.
Brother Adam Posted November 7, 2004 Author Posted November 7, 2004 And I think its important for stuff like this to be on the open mic sometimes. I'm pretty well rounded in theology and I had never even thought of this before today.
Guest Aluigi Posted November 7, 2004 Posted November 7, 2004 don't i know it! which is why i'm so concerned about what phatcatholic is saying...
Brother Adam Posted November 7, 2004 Author Posted November 7, 2004 Phatcatholic is an awesome brother in Christ though.
phatcatholic Posted November 7, 2004 Posted November 7, 2004 [quote name='Aluigi' date='Nov 6 2004, 11:30 PM'] forgetting to confess your sin is not a sin. if you are contrite, but forget to mention it in the confessional (mental lapse, nervousness, anything that's not conscious hiding of it) you are absolved. the only way you would invalidate the priest's absolution is if you either were not truly sorry, did not truly intend to amend your life, or purposefully hid the sin from the priest. sorry phatcatholic, but that was too harsh. it's not true, you would too be forgiven of your sin regardless of whether you made the prayer "and for all others that i forget" [/quote] well, the forgiveness you mention depends on rather or not the person in the hypothetical situation is contrite. we were not given any information to determine this. therefore, i assumed that since the person forgot both to confess the sin, and about the sin itself, that he was not contrite. so, he would not be forgiven. see what i mean?
Dave Posted November 7, 2004 Posted November 7, 2004 If you deliberately fail to confess a mortal sin, you're not forgiven and also commit the additional sin of sacrilege. If you genuinely forget to confess a mortal sin, then you're still forgiven of it. The absolution covers even sins you forgot. However, if you remember it afterward, you'll need to make sure to confess it at your earliest opportunity. But in the meantime, it won't make you unable to receive the Eucharist.
Guest Aluigi Posted November 7, 2004 Posted November 7, 2004 you are never damned for a bad memory. pray constantly to the Holy Spirit to make you aware of your past sins, but even if you forget the sin itself it doesn't invalidate the Sacrament. Bro Adam said the person intended to confess but forgot. intending to confess is contrition.
Dave Posted November 7, 2004 Posted November 7, 2004 [quote name='Aluigi' date='Nov 7 2004, 12:38 AM'] Bro Adam said the person intended to confess but forgot. intending to confess is contrition. [/quote] I know what he said. I was just echoing your point that the only time a person wouldn't be forgiven is if he deliberately failed to mention a mortal sin.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now