phatcatholic Posted November 7, 2004 Posted November 7, 2004 aluigi.............we are in agreement bro our answers were different b/c the contrition of the person was particularly nuanced, and we each read it differently.
Guest Aluigi Posted November 7, 2004 Posted November 7, 2004 :just to clarify: forgetting about the sin doesn't make you noncontrite
StColette Posted November 7, 2004 Posted November 7, 2004 Interesting topic My priest told our youth group if this ever happens, if we do accidentally forget about a certain sin and we remember it later after Confession then we should mention it in our next Confession.
Brother Adam Posted November 7, 2004 Author Posted November 7, 2004 And another good pointer *when in doubt: do tell*
phatcatholic Posted November 7, 2004 Posted November 7, 2004 [quote name='Aluigi' date='Nov 6 2004, 11:45 PM'] :just to clarify: forgetting about the sin doesn't make you noncontrite [/quote] well, i think it depends on why u forgot
Guest Aluigi Posted November 7, 2004 Posted November 7, 2004 yeah, but that wouldn't be forgetting that'd be hiding, denying, forgetting is different
StColette Posted November 7, 2004 Posted November 7, 2004 215. Q. Is our confession worthy if, without our fault, we forget to confess a mortal sin? A. If without our fault we forget to confess a mortal sin, our confession is worthy, and the sin is forgiven; but it must be told in confession if it again comes to our mind. [url="http://www.catholic.net/Catholic Church/Catechism/4/bk4ls19.html"]http://www.catholic.net/Catholic Church/Catechism/4/bk4ls19.html[/url]
phatcatholic Posted November 7, 2004 Posted November 7, 2004 hehe, its funny how u and i always get into debates like this i could run w/ it, but i'll let u have the "W"
God Conquers Posted November 7, 2004 Posted November 7, 2004 [quote]i would say that he is headed towards eternal separation from Christ. the fact is that his relationship w/ Christ has been severed. forgetting not only to confess the sin, but about the sin altogether, could hint at an absense of genuine remorse. this is a serious offense in and of itself. this is why it is important to preclude a confession w/ a prayer to the Holy Spirit that he will bring to mind all of your sins and to end a confession with ".......and for any other sins that i have forgotten." [/quote] What!? Sorry phat my man.... I'm pretty confident if you forget a mortal sin then it wasn't mortal. You can not forget something for which you have full knowledge. You may be able to "forget it". But you will not truly forget something like a mortal sin. There is no way someone is going to hell for that. God speaks to us like you said through our consciences and the Holy Ghost. If someone were to with full knowledge commit a mortal sin and then forget it even after frequent confession they definately don't care much for their faith. If this is the case... well maybe they will be eternally removed from Grace. If they are going to confession in good faith then it is likely our Lord would honor that and speak clearly enough to bring His son home.
StColette Posted November 7, 2004 Posted November 7, 2004 [quote name='God Conquers' date='Nov 6 2004, 11:55 PM'] If someone were to with full knowledge commit a mortal sin and then forget it even after frequent confession they definately don't care much for their faith. If this is the case... well maybe they will be eternally removed from Grace. [/quote] Believe me it's possible to forget a mortal sin out of complete nervousness, I know when I was younger and Confession made me nervous I would be so completely nervous that I would in fact forget some things every now and then, and after I got home I and calmed down I would remember them and then have to go back to Confession as soon as possible. So believe me it can happen. I care very much for my faith and always have, but sometimes this does happen out of nervousness, if it didn't then the Church wouldn't speak on the matter of accidentally forgetting.
phatcatholic Posted November 7, 2004 Posted November 7, 2004 [quote name='God Conquers' date='Nov 6 2004, 11:55 PM'] If someone were to with full knowledge commit a mortal sin and then forget it even after frequent confession they definately don't care much for their faith. If this is the case... well maybe they will be eternally removed from Grace. [/quote] i assumed that the person forgot b/c he didn't really care. i was thinking to myself, "how can a person both forget to confess a sin and forgot about the sin altogether, especially if it is mortal?" to me that meant that it didn't really bother him that he had committed a mortal sin. from this i came to the conclusion that he was not truly contrite and thus unable to recieve forgiveness.
phatcatholic Posted November 7, 2004 Posted November 7, 2004 also, let me point out that i understand that there are valid reasons for forgetting. i may have came to the wrong assumption about the person in the hypothetical (we really didn't have alot of information to work from) but my theology is sound
Brother Adam Posted November 7, 2004 Author Posted November 7, 2004 I left it intentionally "bare" to get lotsa feedback.
God Conquers Posted November 7, 2004 Posted November 7, 2004 You're right.... BUT if they forget due to lack of caring.... did they even know it was mortal. If a sin is mortal I think it necessitates your remebrance in order for it to be so. You don't forget mortal sins, you ignore them.
StColette Posted November 7, 2004 Posted November 7, 2004 You're right Nick in the case that you presented, if the person forgot a mortal sin because the sin didn't bother them etc. then I could see where that Confession would not hold up.
phatcatholic Posted November 7, 2004 Posted November 7, 2004 [quote name='God Conquers' date='Nov 7 2004, 12:06 AM'] You're right.... BUT if they forget due to lack of caring.... did they even know it was mortal. If a sin is mortal I think it necessitates your remebrance in order for it to be so. You don't forget mortal sins, you ignore them. [/quote] well, a hardened heart could cause a person to forget a mortal sin, even tho he KNEW that it was mortal.
phatcatholic Posted November 7, 2004 Posted November 7, 2004 [quote name='StColette' date='Nov 7 2004, 12:06 AM'] You're right Nick in the case that you presented, if the person forgot a mortal sin because the sin didn't bother them etc. then I could see where that Confession would not hold up. [/quote] shew! i'm glad u got my back! i was starting to feel outnumbered
StColette Posted November 7, 2004 Posted November 7, 2004 This is the most productive Open Mic thread I've ever seen lol
StColette Posted November 7, 2004 Posted November 7, 2004 [quote name='phatcatholic' date='Nov 7 2004, 12:12 AM'] shew! i'm glad u got my back! i was starting to feel outnumbered [/quote] lol don't I always lol
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now