theculturewarrior Posted December 19, 2004 Author Posted December 19, 2004 I'm inclined to agree, Todd. Modernism is a heresy.
popestpiusx Posted December 20, 2004 Posted December 20, 2004 [quote name='Apotheoun' date='Dec 19 2004, 11:13 AM'] These practices also have their roots in Old Testament worship. [/quote] That's part of what I was getting at.
popestpiusx Posted December 20, 2004 Posted December 20, 2004 [quote name='cmotherofpirl' date='Dec 19 2004, 11:03 AM'] If you ever have time came you describe some of these? [/quote] Or better yet, you could attend them yourself. Describing them does them no credit. These are liturgies you must see to appreciate.
popestpiusx Posted December 20, 2004 Posted December 20, 2004 [quote name='Apotheoun' date='Dec 19 2004, 12:02 PM'] Inculturation is not simply about adapting the liturgy to the local culture; rather, it is about incarnating the Gospel itself in to the society that is being evangelized, and this great work requires an acceptance of those elements within the particular society in question that are not inimical to the Gospel, but it also requires a purification of those things which are accepted in order to conform them to a Christian worldview. Moreover, it may require the complete repudiation of elements of the existing culture which cannot be conformed to the Christian faith. Uncritical acceptance of local customs can be a grave danger, for it could devolve into a form of syncretism. That being said, the present situation in modern Western countries is not comparable to that of the newly evangelized parts of the world, because much of what has developed within the West over the last 200 years is inimical to the Catholic faith. In other words, as far as Western countries are concerned, the Church should focus on reviving the previously existing Christian culture, and should not try to [i]inculturate[/i] practices that are not consonant with the Gospel into her Apostolic tradition. God bless, Todd [/quote] Exactly! The difference is quite significant and the two are not comparable. To properly inculturate the liturgy, one must have a culture that is compatible with the Faith. A cultures and customs are not good simply by being a culture or a custom, nor are they made good simply by using them in the liturgy. Traditionally, the Church has allowed them or employed them because they were good. They simply took what was naturally good and advantageous (conducive to the supernatural) and entered it into the realm of Grace.
popestpiusx Posted December 20, 2004 Posted December 20, 2004 [quote name='cmotherofpirl' date='Dec 20 2004, 12:56 AM'] You gonna pay for my plane tickets? [/quote] You don't have to fly to Rome to see those liturgies. There are some here as well. Would you like for me to find the closest ones to you?
popestpiusx Posted December 20, 2004 Posted December 20, 2004 [quote name='p0lar_bear' date='Dec 16 2004, 02:39 PM'] BTW, I thought you were taking a break from posting....don't you have better things to be doing? [/quote] Yes. Would you like me to leave?
popestpiusx Posted December 20, 2004 Posted December 20, 2004 [quote name='Pio Nono' date='Dec 19 2004, 02:31 AM'] I'd be interested in reading a book on the history of the development of the Liturgy. [/quote] Dom Geuranger has an enormous amount of writing on the subject, as well as Fr. Adrian Fortescue. For a more modern look at the subject take a look at the work of Msgr. Klaus Gamber. All are considered experts in the field and are truely brilliant writers. There are also the works of Frs. Jungmann, Parsch, and Bugnini if you would like an insight into the formation of the modern liturgical movement.
Pio Nono Posted December 20, 2004 Posted December 20, 2004 JMJ 12/20 - Fourth Monday of Advent Well, the Ethiopian Liturgy is freshest in my mind...man, it was interesting... Unlike [i]anything[/i] I have ever experienced in my life. I counted thirteen priests, seven deacons, and a few other clergy I had to place in the [i]other[/i] category as I didn't know what they were. I thought this was out of the ordinary, but apparently it's run-of-the-mill, since a [i]quarter[/i] of Ethiopian Catholic males are in holy orders. The Liturgy lasted about two hours, and for the first half hour the clerics all stood in the a circle in front of the sanctuary, chanting back and forth to each other in the liturgical language of the Ethiopian Catholics, called [i]Ge-éz[/i]. The best thing to which I can compare it is the Ents in council during Lord of the Rings II. There is a real sense of the Eucharistic sacrifice being a presbyteral action - the priests all stood around the altar during the anaphora, chanting whatever it was that they were chanting, all the while praying for the holiness of the laity and then there was a ceremony commemorating them bringing the Eucharist out for the people. That's pretty much all I can remember right now, since I didn't have any clue what was going on. I'm going to a Melchite Liturgy next Sunday - I'm pumped about that.
popestpiusx Posted December 20, 2004 Posted December 20, 2004 (edited) Pio, There is an Ethiopan Church in Washington DC that I will be attending in January. I'm looking forward to it. It's one of the oldest rites in existence. Have you been to a Melkite Divine liturgy before? It's impressive. I don't understand the symbolism of all the rituals yet, but it's impressive nonetheless. I've also gone to a Ruthenian Divine Liturgy (with a Baptism/Chrismation/First Holy Communion). Edited December 20, 2004 by popestpiusx
p0lar_bear Posted December 21, 2004 Posted December 21, 2004 [quote name='Apotheoun' date='Dec 19 2004, 01:02 PM'] Inculturation is not simply about adapting the liturgy to the local culture; rather, it is about incarnating the Gospel itself in to the society that is being evangelized, and this great work requires an acceptance of those elements within the particular society in question that are not inimical to the Gospel, but it also requires a purification of those things which are accepted in order to conform them to a Christian worldview. Moreover, it may require the complete repudiation of elements of the existing culture which cannot be conformed to the Christian faith. Uncritical acceptance of local customs can be a grave danger, for it could devolve into a form of syncretism. That being said, the present situation in modern Western countries is not comparable to that of the newly evangelized parts of the world, because much of what has developed within the West over the last 200 years is inimical to the Catholic faith. In other words, as far as Western countries are concerned, the Church should focus on reviving the previously existing Christian culture, and should not try to [i]inculturate[/i] practices that are not consonant with the Gospel into her Apostolic tradition. God bless, Todd [/quote] Part of inculturation isn't just repudiating elements that are foriegn to or even contrary to the Gospel. Inculturation often means giving existing things new meaning. This is how a Celtic symbol for the triple nature of a popular goddess (as virgin, mother, and crone) could be given new meaning as a symbol of the Trinity (the triquerta). A celebration to the sun god could be changed into a celebration of the Son (Christmas day). A creature from pagan mythology could be used as a symbol of the resurrection promised in Christ (the phoenix). None of those could be said to be consistent with the Gospel, but they were all 'baptized,' if you will, and went from being contrary to the Gospel to being a way of spreading and explaining it. Of course, like anything, this can be taken too far. Elements can be incorporated without their meaning being changed. Or elements can be used that cannot be made to fit into the Gospel. However, we can't simply toss out someone's entire culture because it was not Christian. You are right, true inculturation doesn't really happen in the West anymore, but in "developing" countries it does. All the modern examples I've seen on this thread are from those areas.
Apotheoun Posted December 21, 2004 Posted December 21, 2004 [quote name='p0lar_bear' date='Dec 21 2004, 10:51 AM'] [. . .] Inculturation often means giving existing things new meaning. [. . .] [/quote] That's what I meant when I said that ". . . it also requires a purification of those things which are accepted in order to conform them to a Christian worldview." I don't think that there is any substantial disagreement between us on this topic. God bless, Todd
Apotheoun Posted December 21, 2004 Posted December 21, 2004 [quote name='p0lar_bear' date='Dec 21 2004, 10:54 AM'] never mind--misread something [/quote] No problem, Merry Christmas. Todd
p0lar_bear Posted December 21, 2004 Posted December 21, 2004 [quote name='Apotheoun' date='Dec 21 2004, 03:01 PM'] No problem, Merry Christmas. Todd [/quote] The never mind was actually about something else--they weren't talking about the rite I thought they were at first... I don't think we do really disagree, we are just presenting the same thing from different angles.
popestpiusx Posted December 21, 2004 Posted December 21, 2004 [quote name='p0lar_bear' date='Dec 21 2004, 01:51 PM'] You are right, true inculturation doesn't really happen in the West anymore, but in "developing" countries it does. All the modern examples I've seen on this thread are from those areas. [/quote] On this we disagree. This stuff has gotten rediculous even in developing countries. Reports coming out of India and Africa indicate that in many cases the Mass is indestinquishable from pagan rituals. This stuff then gets imitaed in the west and everyonr thinks its lovely because its "cultural". This is why I was pointing out earlier in this thread that in these third world countries traditionalism (in all its flavors) is spreading. People are getting sick and tired of the nonsense. Much of it is forced inculturation (liturgies created by white or western black "liturgists" who think they know best what the poor tribal folks in africa want). There are already properly inculturated liturgies from Africa, and have been for centuries (Ge'ez rite, Coptic, etc.). Leave the Roman Rite alone. We don't need a bunch of middle class black folks dressing up in what they think resembles african tribal wear and dancing the Mambo down the center isle and around the altar with flaming bowls of incense streamers and whatever else they are jumping around with. I know that you are not defending this, but the line becomes awfully thin when the inculturation is the product of meetings and committes made up of "litugical experts", rather than having developed organically over the course of many centuries.
Pio Nono Posted December 21, 2004 Posted December 21, 2004 JMJ 12/21 - St. Peter Canisius The Ethiopian Catholics "inculturated", if you will, the ancient chant rhythms of their fathers; their chant modes are pre-Christian and are absolutely beautiful. Russian chant is beautiful as well - all four-part harmonies.
popestpiusx Posted December 21, 2004 Posted December 21, 2004 [quote name='Pio Nono' date='Dec 21 2004, 02:18 PM'] JMJ 12/21 - St. Peter Canisius The Ethiopian Catholics "inculturated", if you will, the ancient chant rhythms of their fathers; their chant modes are pre-Christian and are absolutely beautiful. Russian chant is beautiful as well - all four-part harmonies. [/quote] I am aware of this and am quite fond of both, although the Ethiopian chant modes can be a little harsh to western ears. Even so, it is quite facinating.
p0lar_bear Posted December 21, 2004 Posted December 21, 2004 [quote name='popestpiusx' date='Dec 21 2004, 03:17 PM'] On this we disagree. This stuff has gotten rediculous even in developing countries. Reports coming out of India and Africa indicate that in many cases the Mass is indestinquishable from pagan rituals. This stuff then gets imitaed in the west and everyonr thinks its lovely because its "cultural". This is why I was pointing out earlier in this thread that in these third world countries traditionalism (in all its flavors) is spreading. People are getting sick and tired of the nonsense. Much of it is forced inculturation (liturgies created by white or western black "liturgists" who think they know best what the poor tribal folks in africa want). There are already properly inculturated liturgies from Africa, and have been for centuries (Ge'ez rite, Coptic, etc.). Leave the Roman Rite alone. We don't need a bunch of middle class black folks dressing up in what they think resembles african tribal wear and dancing the Mambo down the center isle and around the altar with flaming bowls of incense streamers and whatever else they are jumping around with. I know that you are not defending this, but the line becomes awfully thin when the inculturation is the product of meetings and committes made up of "litugical experts", rather than having developed organically over the course of many centuries. [/quote] Goodness gracious! I said that it could be taken too far. I said that it was not all good. The fact remains that legitmate inculturation does take place.
popestpiusx Posted December 21, 2004 Posted December 21, 2004 [quote name='p0lar_bear' date='Dec 21 2004, 02:23 PM'] Goodness gracious! I said that it could be taken too far. I said that it was not all good. The fact remains that legitmate inculturation does take place. [/quote] I know you said that. That's why I said at the end that I know you are not supporting that stuff, but there is a very fine and very dangerous line when dealing with the Roman Rite. It's a very slippery slope. The modern version of inculturation seems to be little more than de-romanizing the Mass, which, in effect, makes it cease to be and something entirely new is created. I've seen very little legitimate inculturation in recent years. I've seen alot of nonsense.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now