phatcatholic Posted January 19, 2005 Posted January 19, 2005 [quote name='justfran' date='Jan 19 2005, 05:55 AM'] I meant that Bl alan and St Louis de Montfort started up the story of St Dominic and the apparition. from [url="http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/01246a.htm"]http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/01246a.htm[/url] [/quote] i think you are incorrectly interpreting this paragraph. all this is saying is that the visions and sermons of St. Dominic may not have been revealed to Alanus. this does not mean that the vision to St. Dominic did not happen........it just means that the vision to St. Dominic probably wasn't revealed to Alanus. [i][b]his relations[/b][/i] of the event are not to be regarded as historical--NOT the even itself. at any rate, the fact that he is "re-establishing" the rosary means that it must have been present and popular before, but began to fall in prominence among the people. so, it is anti-historical to claim that he was the first one to tell the story of Dominic and the visions he received.
phatcatholic Posted January 19, 2005 Posted January 19, 2005 in defense of the position that the rosary was in general use before Alanus had his vision about its restoration, we find, in your article on Alanus, that "His vision of the restoration of the devotion of the Rosary is assigned to the year 1460". But, the new advent article on st. dominic ([url="http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/05106a.htm"][b]here[/b][/url]) states that, on "[i][b]12 September, 1213[/b][/i], the saint is again found in the council that preceded the battle. During the progress of the conflict, he knelt before the altar in the church of Saint-Jacques, praying for the triumph of the Catholic arms. So remarkable was the victory of the crusaders at Muret that Simon de Montfort regarded it as altogether miraculous, and piously attributed it to the prayers of Saint Dominic. In gratitude to God for this decisive victory, the crusader erected a chapel in the church of Saint-Jacques, which he dedicated, it is said, to Our Lady of the Rosary. It would appear, therefore, that [i][b]the devotion of the Rosary, which tradition says was revealed to Saint Dominic, had come into general use about this time[/b][/i]."
jezic Posted January 19, 2005 Posted January 19, 2005 definitely like those prospects. long live the 20 after 6 rosary. (a.m.
StColette Posted January 19, 2005 Posted January 19, 2005 [quote name='justfran' date='Jan 19 2005, 05:55 AM'] I meant that Bl alan and St Louis de Montfort started up the story of St Dominic and the apparition. from [url="http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/01246a.htm"]http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/01246a.htm[/url] [/quote] I agree with Nick, this paragraph does not speak of Blessed Alan making up the story about St. Dominic and the creation of the Rosary. I really do suggest that you read "Secret of the Rosary" by St. Louis de Monfort. It will give you a historical back ground about the Rosary and also information about the missions of Blessed Alan and St. Dominic. Blessed Alan was called by Our Lady to re-establish devotion to her Rosary not to creat the Rosary, since according to New Advent the creation of the Rosary occured between Our Lady and St. Dominic [quote]"The same lesson for the Feast of the Holy Rosary informs us that when the Albigensian heresy was devastating the country of Toulouse, St. Dominic earnestly besought the help of Our Lady and was instructed by her, so tradition asserts, to preach the Rosary among the people as an antidote to heresy and sin. From that time forward this manner of prayer was "most wonderfully published abroad and developed [promulgari augerique coepit] by St. Dominic whom different Supreme Pontiffs have in various past ages of their apostolic letters declared to be the institutor and author of the same devotion."[b] That many popes have so spoken is undoubtedly true, and amongst the rest we have a series of encyclicals, beginning in 1883, issued by Pope Leo XIII, which, while commending this devotion to the faithful in the most earnest terms, assumes the institution of the Rosary by St. Dominic to be a fact historically established."[/b] [url="http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/13184b.htm"]http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/13184b.htm[/url][/quote] From what I've also read about devotion to the Rosary, historically speaking, it declined about a century after the death of St. Dominic. Given the date 1213 of when the apparition of Our Lady to St. Dominic appeared this would give us around the time in which Blessed Alan would have been alive. Being a Dominican he of course had special devotion to Our Lady and to her Rosary. In the visions that Blessed Alan saw and the messages he received from Our Lady in regards to the Rosary, he was called to re-establish devotion to it because devotion to the Rosary had fallen away. Now in regards to St. Louis de Monfort, it's easy to say that he was most definitely devoted to Our Lady and wrote wonderful works about her, which give us better understanding of her and of the people she has called to do God's will. The bottom line is, the Church recognizes that the apparition to St. Dominic did in fact occur, and he was given the Rosary by Our Lady. This is all historically recognized by the Church. Pope Benedict XIV (1740-58) was a renowned scholar and a promoter of historical studies and research. When he was an official of the Sacred Congregation of Rites, he was asked about the tradition of St. Dominic and the Rosary. " You ask whether St. Dominic was the first institutor of the Rosary, and show that you yourselves are bewildered and entangled in doubts on the matter. Now, what value do you attach to the testimony of so many Popes, such as Leo X (1521), Pius V (1572), Gregory XIII (1585), Sixtus V (1590), Clement VIII (1605), Alexander VII (1667), Bl. Innocent XI (1689), Clement XI (1721), Innocent XIII (1724) and others who unanimously attribute the institution of the Rosary to St. Dominic, the founder of the Dominican Order, an apostolic man who might be compared to the apostles themselves and who, undoubtedly due to the inspiration of the Holy Spirit, became the designer, the author, promoter, and most illustrious preacher of this admirable and truly heavenly instrument, the Rosary?" Parts from "Secret of the Rosary" [quote]11 It was only in the year 1214, however, that the Church received the Rosary in its present form andaccording to the method we use today. It was given to the Church by St. Dominic, who had received it from the Blessed Virgin as a means of converting the Albigensians and other sinners. I will tell you the story of how he received it, which is found in the very well-known book De Dignitate Psalterii, by Blessed Alan de la Roche. Saint Dominic, seeing that the gravity of people's sins was hindering the conversion of the Albigensians, withdrew into a forest near Toulouse, where he prayed continuously for three days and three nights. During this time he did nothing but weep and do harsh penances in order to appease the anger of God. He used his discipline so much that his body was lacerated, and finally he fell into a coma. At this point our Lady appeared to him, accompanied by three angels, and she said, "Dear Dominic, do you know which weapon the Blessed Trinity wants to use to reform the world?" "Oh, my Lady," answered Saint Dominic, "you know far better than I do, because next to your Son JesusChrist you have always been the chief instrument of our salvation." Then our Lady replied, "I want you to know that, in this kind of warfare, the principal weapon has alwaysbeen the Angelic Psalter, which is the foundation-stone of the New Testament. Therefore, if you want to reachthese hardened souls and win them over to God, preach my Psalter." So he arose, comforted, and burning with zeal for the conversion of the people in that district, he made straight for the cathedral. At once unseen angels rang the bells to gather the people together, and Saint Dominic began to preach. At the very beginning of his sermon, an appalling storm broke out, the earth shook, the sun was darkened, and there was so much thunder and lightning that all were very much afraid. Even greater was their fear when, looking at a picture of our Lady exposed in a prominent place, they saw her raise her arms to heaven three times to call down God's vengeance upon them if they failed to be converted, to amend their lives, and seek the protection of the holy Mother of God. God wished, by means of these supernatural phenomena, to spread the new devotion of the holy Rosary and to make it more widely known. At last, at the prayer of Saint Dominic, the storm came to an end, and he went on preaching. So fervently and compellingly did he explain the importance and value of the Rosary that almost all the people of Toulouse embraced it and renounced their false beliefs. In a very short time a great improvement was seen in the town; people began leading Christian lives and gave up theirformer bad habits.[/quote] [quote] 27 As for Blessed Alan de la Roche, who restored the devotion of the Rosary, he received many privilegesfrom our Lady; she graciously appeared to him several times to teach him how to work out his salvation, to become a good priest and perfect religious, and how to pattern himself on our Lord. He used to be horribly tempted and persecuted by devils, and then a deep sadness would fall upon him and sometimes he would be near to despair. But our Lady always comforted him by her presence, which banished the clouds of darkness from his soul. She taught him how to say the Rosary, explaining its value and the fruits to be gained by it; and she gave him a great and glorious privilege, which was the honour of being called her new spouse. As a token of her chaste love for him, she placed a ring upon his finger and a necklace made of her own hair about his neck and gave him a Rosary. [/quote] [url="http://www.hismercy.ca/content/ebooks/The.Secret.of.the.rosary.PDF"]http://www.hismercy.ca/content/ebooks/The.....the.rosary.PDF[/url]
justfran Posted January 20, 2005 Author Posted January 20, 2005 hmmm, so if Bl. Alan's account is not historical then exactly what bits of it do we take to be true? Are there any actualy primary sources of the apparitions to St Dominic? I'll ask some of the ppl on EWTN about this, they probably would have read heaps more about this that any of us here.
phatcatholic Posted January 20, 2005 Posted January 20, 2005 (edited) [quote name='justfran' date='Jan 20 2005, 06:30 AM'] hmmm, so if Bl. Alan's account is not historical then exactly what bits of it do we take to be true? Are there any actualy primary sources of the apparitions to St Dominic? I'll ask some of the ppl on EWTN about this, they probably would have read heaps more about this that any of us here. [/quote] the only thing that is not historical is that Alan received a vision calling for the renewal of the rosary. the apparition to St. Dominic IS historical. the church long before and after alan was and remains unanimous in their belief that Mary did in fact appear to Dominic. that said, what suffices for you as a "primary souce" or one that you will believe? Edited January 20, 2005 by phatcatholic
justfran Posted January 20, 2005 Author Posted January 20, 2005 (edited) Well I supposed that St Dominic or someone else who was around at the same time he was would have left behind a few writings on the stuff. All I've read about it has been written hundreds of years after the supposed thing occurred. who knows what could have happenned in that time. The problem is, we're dealing with private revelation here, anything any Popes or Saints have written would be their own POV. *shrug* Edited January 20, 2005 by justfran
StColette Posted January 20, 2005 Posted January 20, 2005 We've provided the information from New Advent which says that the vision of Our Lady to St. Dominic is truth and that it was through him that Our Lady gave us the Rosary. New Advent cane be trusted as a truthful source of what the Catholic Church holds as truth and what it does not. Even in 1883 Pope Leo XIII issued an encyclical in which he attributed the devotion of the Rosary to St. Dominic. There's not much else we can say on the matter other than the Church completely holds the origin of the Rosary from St. Dominic as truth. As for Blessed Alan, I'm not as versed in my knowledge about him as I am with St. Dominic. I do know however, that the Church recognizes that Blessed Alan did in fact revive the devotion of the Holy Rosary. Considering that the Church does not speak out against the apparitions that occured with Blessed Alan, I would grant that they are true. The Church takes alligations of apparitions of the Blessed Mother very seriously. Seeing as Blessed Alan is considered a "Blessed" by the Church and is recognized as a holy man I doubt that he would make up stories about Our Lady appearing to him so that the devotion to her Rosary would be revived. Blessed Alan's words have been collected in " Secret of the Rosary " by St. Louis de Monfort, in which it is recorded that Our Lady appeared to Blessed Alan for the revivial of the Rosary. Now considering St. Louis de Monfort is also a canonized Saint in the Church, someone who is to be respect and held in esteem. I highly doubt that he would lie in his writings about what Blessed Alan said or what occured. Remember not every single thing about the Church and what She holds to be truth can be found on the internet.
StColette Posted January 20, 2005 Posted January 20, 2005 [quote name='justfran' date='Jan 20 2005, 07:58 AM'] The problem is, we're dealing with private revelation here, anything any Popes or Saints have written would be their own POV. *shrug* [/quote] If we always held this type of view, the many dogmas and truths that the Church teaches today would not be around. Since they all started as someones personal view or private revelation. The fact is we are dealing with very holy men, whom the Church recognizes as so.
StColette Posted January 20, 2005 Posted January 20, 2005 The first clear historical reference to the rosary, however, is from the life of St. Dominic (died in 1221), the founder of the Order of Preachers or Dominicans. He preached a form of the rosary in France at the time that the Albigensian heresy was devastating the Faith there. Tradition has it that the Blessed Mother herself asked for the practice as an antidote for heresy and sin. One of Dominic's future disciples, Alain de Roche, began to establish Rosary Confraternities to promote the praying of the rosary. The form of the rosary we have today is believed to date from his time. Over the centuries the saints and popes have highly recommended the rosary, the greatest prayer in the Church after the Mass and Liturgy of the Hours. Not surprisingly, it's most active promoters have been Dominicans. [url="http://www.ewtn.com/Devotionals/prayers/rosary/"]http://www.ewtn.com/Devotionals/prayers/rosary/[/url] The tradition of St. Dominic and the Rosary was more or less universally accepted, especially in documents of many popes, until the work of the Bollandists in the l7th century. This was a group of learned scholars (Belgian Jesuits) who were charged with the work of publishing the "Acta Sanctorum" covering the life of Christ and of the saints included in the liturgical calendar. These were men of undeniable scholarship who set out to rewrite the lives of the saints, so as to preserve in them all that could be established by historical sources, and to weed out legends that surround the lives of many saints. This group concluded that there was not sufficient evidence to support the tradition of St. Dominic and the Rosary, that this tradition stemmed only from the testimony Alan de Rupe, O.P. (d. 1475), and that his claims (written 250 years after St. Dominic) cannot be substantiated by any documents dating from the time of St. Dominic. Yet, it appears that this argument of silence put forth by the Bollandists did not seem to outweigh (in the mind of succeeding Popes) the impact of the centuries-old tradition concerning St. Dominic and the Rosary; for Popes coming after the 17th century continued to refer to St. Dominic in connection with the beginnings of the Rosary. ALAN DE RUPE [b]History well documents the fact that Alan de Rupe (also Alan de la Roche) (1428-1475) was a great apostle of the Rosary.[/b] There must be some basis for his claims that St. Dominic's connection with the Rosary is proved "both from tradition and from the testimony of writers." I find it hard to believe that he just made it up. [b]He was not a dreamer.[/b] He was a Master of Sacred Theology, wrote a commentary on the Sentences of Peter Lombard, lectured in Paris, was visitator of his Order in central Europe, wrote his APOLOGIA for the Rosary, and preached in widely spread places. He founded the Rosary Confraternity in 1470 in Douai, and did much to popularize the Rosary. [b]It could well be that sources to which Alan de Rupe had access did not exist in later centuries. Even if documents did originally exist connecting St. Dominic and the Rosary, countless religious houses and convents were destroyed (with their libraries) in the wars of religious persecution that ravaged Europe over the centuries. [/b] We find this thought clearly expressed by John S. Johnson in his book THE ROSARY IN ACTION. (Ch.3) [b]"The critics relied mainly on the argument of silence to question the ancient tradition that the Blessed Virgin gave the Rosary to St. Dominic. They should have known that many documents referred to by Alan de Rupe may have existed, but did not survive the burning scourge of the Hugenots, who destroyed convents, monasteries, libraries among the countless institutions they committed to the flames. The critics went so far as to say that Alan had invented the Rosary devotion.. and had attributed it to St. Dominic to tie it in with a famous name. But the two persons Alan relies on for his story of the origin of the Rosary had their "Mariales" preserved at the Convent of Gand: which library was burnt during the wars on religion. There are other documents which have been discovered in later years which were from before Alan de Rupe's time. The long poem "ROSARIUS" antedates him by 100 years or so, and clearly refers to St. Dominic and the battle of Muret. This removes Alan from al suspicion of inventing his sources. The elements were all in place at the time of St. Dominic,, how did they get together In the Rosary?"(p. 26) [/b] TESTIMONY OF THE POPES Pope Benedict XIV (1740-58) was a [b]renowned scholar and a promoter of historical studies and research.[/b] When he was an official of the Sacred Congregation of Rites, he was asked about the tradition of St. Dominic and the Rosary. The following is his response, a century after the work of the Bollandists: [b]"You ask whether St. Dominic was the first institutor of the Rosary, and show that you yourselves are bewildered and entangled in doubts on the matter. Now, what value do you attach to the testimony of so many Popes, such as Leo X (1521), Pius V (1572), Gregory XIII (1585), Sixtus V (1590), Clement VIII (1605), Alexander VII (1667), Bl. Innocent XI (1689), Clement XI (1721), Innocent XIII (1724) and others who unanimously attribute the institution of the Rosary to St. Dominic, the founder of the Dominican Order, an apostolic man who might be compared to the apostles themselves and who, undoubtedly due to the inspiration of the Holy Spirit, became the designer, the author, promoter, and most illustrious preacher of this admirable and truly heavenly instrument, the Rosary."[/b] After quoting the above, Fr. Anthony N. Fuerst, in his well documented book, THIS ROSARY, states: To reject this tradition in its entirety, without strong arguments would be very rash." (p. 20) To the above list of Popes accepting the tradition of St. Dominic and the Rosary could be added many more coming after the time of Benedict XIV. But this is not the main argument supporting the tradition. It is the coming together of many pieces of a puzzle pertaining to the essentials of the tradition as handed down. For example: 1) given the fact that the members of the Militia of Jesus Christ founded by St. Dominic, or by a Dominican of his day, prayed the 150 Hail Marys daily.... 2) given the fact of St. Dominic's devotion to Mary and his ardent prayer in combatting the great heresy of his day ... along with the testimony of ALAN DE RUPE that St. Dominic did receive some communication from the Mother of God as to how to combat the errors of his time.... [b](If Our Lady at Fatima gave us a remedy In this century for overcoming Communism and obtaining peace - which remedy included the Rosary - does it not seem probable that she would have intervened in the 13th century offering a means of combatting the devastating heresy of Albigensionism - as tradition assures us she did.)[/b] 3) given the fact that, as some of his biographers explain, a common manner of preaching of Dominic was the frequent alternating of his instruction on the mysteries of our faith with prayer.... 4) given the fact that the first beginning of this devotion in the time of Dominic was vastly different from its present structure, that then there was no set sequence of the mysteries, and that even the name (Rosary) had not yet been established.... 5) given the fact that many convents with their libraries were destroyed in the religious persecutions that followed the 13th century.... In the light of the above, it seems to me that the negative argument (the absence of documents) is outweighed by the presence of the essential components that constitute the heart of what the Rosary is. It seems to me, not merely possible, but very probable, that the Mother of God (as Alan de Rupe testified) did use St. Dominic in some way to give this devotion to the Church. [url="http://www.cin.org/histros.html"]http://www.cin.org/histros.html[/url]
justfran Posted January 21, 2005 Author Posted January 21, 2005 (edited) hang on, i know St Dominic revived the praying of the Rosary as did Bl Alan (sry I made you do all that). But what aboput the Promises? Edited January 21, 2005 by justfran
StColette Posted January 21, 2005 Posted January 21, 2005 (edited) Sites loyal to the teachings of the Magisterium that view the Promises as truth. [url="http://www.tldm.org/misc/rosary.htm"]http://www.tldm.org/misc/rosary.htm[/url] (Given to St. Dominic and Blessed Alan) Imprimatur: Patrick J. Hayes, D.D. Archbishop of New York [url="http://www.catholic.net/Catholic Church/Indices/Inspirations/rosary.html"]http://www.catholic.net/Catholic Church/Indices/Inspirations/rosary.html[/url] (Revealed to St. Dominic and Blessed Alan) Again from EWTN a program of the Holy Rosary, in which it listed the 15 Promises [url="http://www.ewtn.com/tv/G1Radvance4.htm"]http://www.ewtn.com/tv/G1Radvance4.htm[/url] "MYSTERIES OF THE ROSARY: JOYFUL MYSTERIES (30:00) NEW The Joyful mystery begins with a scrolling list of the 15 promises of Mary given to St. Dominic and Blessed Alan for anyone with a faithful devotion to the Rosary. Religious imagery is used from stained glass windows and paintings and statues." lol you can even order the tape with it on there. There are quite a few more, but considering that EWTN, who is always loyal to the Magisterium, and would never teach anything that the Church would disapprove of, has a tape with these Promises on there. And EWTN lists the program saying that the Promises were given to St. Dominic and Bl. Alan. Then taking into consideration that the Archbishop of New York, approves of the Promises as being truth. And by looking up information about Archbishop Hayes I found out that he was later evelated to Cardinal. [url="http://www.catholic-hierarchy.org/bishop/bhayesp.html"]http://www.catholic-hierarchy.org/bishop/bhayesp.html[/url] Catholic.net also supports these Promises and where they came from. In addition Catholic.net is loyal to the Church. Review by Catholic Culture: [url="http://www.catholicculture.org/sites/site_view.cfm?recnum=37"]http://www.catholicculture.org/sites/site_view.cfm?recnum=37[/url] Edited January 21, 2005 by StColette
jezic Posted January 21, 2005 Posted January 21, 2005 you guys are very good at making this confusing. That is great though. I like simple stuff, God said it, Mary said it. Ok so it is cool. People are vey ready to doubt today. That is a good thing in some cases because the devil is very good at lying.
StColette Posted January 21, 2005 Posted January 21, 2005 [quote name='jezic' date='Jan 21 2005, 01:54 PM'] you guys are very good at making this confusing. That is great though. I like simple stuff, God said it, Mary said it. Ok so it is cool. People are vey ready to doubt today. That is a good thing in some cases because the devil is very good at lying. [/quote] lol Believe me I like things to be very simple as well. But for others is not that simple, so that's what we're here for. To do what is in our power to help explain why we believe what we believe and where it came from.
justfran Posted January 22, 2005 Author Posted January 22, 2005 (edited) um posting a link to tldm is a very bad idea if you ask me...it promotes the apparitions at Bayside in NY which I'm pretty sure the Church has well and truly condemned. (look it up on Catholic Culture) I'm pretty sure it's okay to ask questions if it gets people to discover new things about the faith, both the asker and the answerer. How can one find if one doesn't seek? And I know CatholicCulture is loyal to the Church...but don't you think that these people are doing a bit of shameless plugging by placing a review of their own site, *on* their own site? I read that review and it kinda made me think it was like "Snady discussed the contents of her own site with herself, and gave it a five star review" ...okay i should get a bit of sleep now. Edited January 22, 2005 by justfran
phatcatholic Posted January 22, 2005 Posted January 22, 2005 [quote name='justfran' date='Jan 22 2005, 09:48 AM'] And I know CatholicCulture is loyal to the Church...but don't you think that these people are doing a bit of shameless plugging by placing a review of their own site, *on* their own site? I read that review and it kinda made me think it was like "Snady discussed the contents of her own site with herself, and gave it a five star review" [/quote] ad hominem attack. criticizing the source over something as trivial as this has no bearing whatsoever on the content that is being presented. that said, i think we have forgotten one important point: since this is a subject of private revelation, you are not obliged to believe it. but, i feel that it is only on this point that you are allowed to disagree. the reliability of the apparition to st. dominic and the promises is attested to by the consistent testimony of the Church. you may not agree................but don't tell us that we can't, especially when we have every reason to believe in them.
StColette Posted January 22, 2005 Posted January 22, 2005 lol I didn't mean to post the tldm.org site, lol I had a number of them listed and I deleted the wrong one and kept the one I meant to delete lol anyway. The point I'm trying to make on that site is this information below: The Fifteen Promises of Mary to Christians Who Recite the Rosary 1. Whoever shall faithfully serve me by the recitation of the rosary shall receive signal graces. 2. I promise my special protection and the greatest graces to all those who shall recite the rosary. 3. The rosary shall be a powerful armour against hell, it will destroy vice, decrease sin, and defeat heresies. 4. It will cause virtue and good works to flourish; it will obtain for souls the abundant mercy of God; it will withdraw the hearts of men from the love of the world and its vanities, and will lift them to the desire of eternal things. Oh, that souls would sanctify themselves by this means. 5. The soul which recommends itself to me by the recitation of the rosary shall not perish. 6. Whoever shall recite the rosary devoutly, applying himself to the consideration of its sacred mysteries shall never be conquered by misfortune. God will not chastise him in His justice, he shall not perish by an unprovided death; if he be just he shall remain in the grace of God, and become worthy of eternal life. 7. Whoever shall have a true devotion for the rosary shall not die without the sacraments of the Church. 8. Those who are faithful to recite the rosary shall have during their life and at their death the light of God and the plentitude of His graces; at the moment of death they shall participate in the merits of the saints in paradise. 9. I shall deliver from purgatory those who have been devoted to the rosary. 10. The faithful children of the rosary shall merit a high degree of glory in heaven. 11. You shall obtain all you ask of me by the recitation of the rosary. 12. All those who propagate the holy rosary shall be aided by me in their necessities. 13. I have obtained from my Divine Son that all the advocates of the rosary shall have for intercessors the entire celestial court during their life and at the hour of death. 14. All who recite the rosary are my sons, and brothers of my only son Jesus Christ. 15. Devotion of my rosary is a great sign of predestination. [b](Given to St. Dominic and Blessed Alan) Imprimatur: +Patrick J. Hayes, D.D., Archbishop of New York [/b] Now if you wanted to see it on a more credible site: [url="http://www.catholic.org/clife/prayers/rosary.php"]http://www.catholic.org/clife/prayers/rosary.php[/url] The imprimatur who gave the information was a Archbishop of the Church, who in fact later became a Cardinal. This information from him I've found on several sites that are loyal to the Church. The researching to see the time in which he lived, I found that he had live much earlier between the 1860s- to around 1930. This time period is not like we see today. Liberalism had not entered the Church, and the members of the Church both laity and Clergy gave their loyalty to the Church. And as Nick said, yes we're dealing with private revelation, and you're not required to believe it. But the Church has not come forward and said that we are not to believe in the Promises or of the apparition of Our Lady to St. Dominic. Nick makes another good point. That criticizing the source has no bearing on the credibility of the information that is given there. I mean I can find a number of sites that aren't very loyal to the Church and find encyclicals of a number of popes and writings of Early Church Fathers, but that wouldn't diminish the credibility of the work. Again it's your decision to believe in this or not, it's a private revelation and you're not required to believe it.
justfran Posted January 23, 2005 Author Posted January 23, 2005 (edited) thanks. i dunno, but i still don't really believe it as yet because everything that's been posted just says "given to St Dominic and Blessed Alan", even "Secrets of the Rosary" (so far) of which I've read a little bit... I'll give it a rest I think. and sry i didn't mean criticise the source ceredibility with that, i just meant that it was funny to me that they would do something like give a five star review of their own site... Edited January 23, 2005 by justfran
phatcatholic Posted January 23, 2005 Posted January 23, 2005 justfran.................after all that has been presented, i wonder why you would still not consider it reliable, but i suppose not believing in this apparition is your perogative.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now