Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

one of the 15 Promises of the Rosary


Recommended Posts

Posted

i dunno phat, i'm prolly with justfran here. I *think* i believe the promises, but i'm not going to give them any real weight. I don't want to tell someone that there are all these good things and then be wrong about them in the end. When i talk to non-Catholics i like to be able to point to things they can't dispute, and it's very easy to argue that portions (or even the totality!) of these stories aren't true.

That said, i still try to get 5-10 rosaries in every week. I don't know if the promises or the stories are true, but i *do* trust the faith i've seen in people who recite the rosary. *shrugs* If they're true, it's a bonus, if not I'll still get some grace out of the deal. :)

Peace,
Joe :)

Posted

One thing we can be truly positive about is the importance of the Rosary.

The Holy Rosary is the storehouse of countless blessings. -- Blessed Alan de la Roche

The Rosary is the most beautiful and the most rich in graces of all prayers, it is the prayer that touches most the Heart of the Mother of God ... and if you wish peace to reign in your homes, recite the family Rosary. --- POPE ST. PIUS X

The Rosary is my favorite prayer...marvelous in its simplicity and its profundity. -POPE JOHN PAUL II

Never will anyone who says his Rosary every day become a formal heretic or be led astray by the devil. -- ST. LOUIS DE MONTFORT

Mary is the sure path to our meeting with Christ. Devotion to the Mother of the Lord, when it is genuine, is always an impetus to a life guided by the spirit and values of the Gospel. --POPE JOHN PAUL II

"One Day Through the Rosary and Scapular I Will Save the World."
~ Our Lady to St. Dominic

Even if you choose not to believe in the Promises, Our Lady has expressed her desire for a great devotion to the Rosary at Fatima. Through the Rosary, we gain a better understanding about the Life, Ministry, and Death of Christ.

Posted

[quote name='StColette' date='Jan 23 2005, 03:46 PM'] Even if you choose not to believe in the Promises, Our Lady has expressed her desire for a great devotion to the Rosary at Fatima. Through the Rosary, we gain a better understanding about the Life, Ministry, and Death of Christ. [/quote]
yup! :)

  • 1 year later...
Posted

I know this is an old thread, so feel free to ignore this new post if you like.

[quote name='StColette' post='497380' date='Jan 20 2005, 09:53 AM']We've provided the information from New Advent which says that the vision of Our Lady to St. Dominic is truth and that it was through him that Our Lady gave us the Rosary. New Advent cane be trusted as a truthful source of what the Catholic Church holds as truth and what it does not.[/quote]
One can't help but notice, however, the parts of [url="http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/13184b.htm"]the Catholic Encyclopedia article[/url] that you [i]didn't[/i] quote.

[quote][It] is certain that in the course of the twelfth century and before the birth of St. Dominic, the practice of reciting 50 or 150 Ave Marias had become generally familiar.... [T]he custom of reciting fifty or a hundred and fifty Aves had grown familiar, independently of, and earlier than, the preaching of St. Dominic. On the other hand, the practice of meditating on certain definite mysteries, which has been rightly described as the very essence of the Rosary devotion, seems to have only arisen long after the date of St. Dominic's death.... It is in any case certain that at the close of the fifteenth century the utmost possible variety of methods of meditating prevailed, and that the fifteen mysteries now generally accepted were not uniformly adhered to even by the Dominicans themselves.... To sum up, we have positive evidence that both the invention of the beads as a counting apparatus and also the practice of repeating a hundred and fifty Aves cannot be due to St. Dominic, because they are both notably older than his time. Further, we are assured that the meditating upon the mysteries was not introduced until two hundred years after his death. What then, we are compelled to ask, is there left of which St. Dominic may be called the author?

....[Is] there were any satisfactory evidence to show that St. Dominic had identified himself with the pre-existing Rosary and become its apostle[?] ...here we are met with absolute silence. Of the eight or nine early Lives of the saint, not one makes the faintest allusion to the Rosary. The witnesses who gave evidence in the cause of his canonization are equally reticent. In the great collection of documents accumulated by Fathers Balme and Lelaidier, O.P., in their "Cartulaire de St. Dominique" the question is studiously ignored. The early constitutions of the different provinces of the order have been examined, and many of them printed, but no one has found any reference to this devotion. We possess hundreds, even thousands, of manuscripts containing devotional treatises, sermons, chronicles, Saints' lives, etc., written by the Friars Preachers between 1220 and 1450; but no single verifiable passage has yet been produced which speaks of the Rosary as instituted by St. Dominic or which even makes much of the devotion as one specially dear to his children. The charters and other deeds of the Dominican convents for men and women, as M. Jean Guiraud points out with emphasis in his edition of the Cartulaire of La Prouille (I, cccxxviii), are equally silent. Neither do we find any suggestion of a connection between St. Dominic and the Rosary in the paintings and sculptures of these two and a half centuries. Even the tomb of St. Dominic at Bologna and the numberless frescoes by Fra Angelico representing the brethren of his order ignore the Rosary completely.

Impressed by this conspiracy of silence, the Bollandists, on trying to trace to its source the origin of the current tradition, found that all the clues converged upon one point, the preaching of the Dominican Alan de Rupe about the years 1470-75. He it undoubtedly was who first suggested the idea that the devotion of "Our Lady's Psalter" (a hundred and fifty Hail Marys) was instituted or revived by St. Dominic. Alan was a very earnest and devout man, but, as the highest authorities admit, he was full of delusions, and based his revelations on the imaginary testimony of writers that never existed (see Quétif and Echard, "Scriptores O.P.", 1, 849). His preaching, however, was attended with much success. The Rosary Confraternities, organized by him and his colleagues at Douai, Cologne, and elsewhere had great vogue, and led to the printing of many books, all more or less impregnated with the ideas of Alan. Indulgences were granted for the good work that was thus being done and the documents conceding these indulgences accepted and repeated, as was natural in that uncritical age, the historical data which had been inspired by Alan's writings and which were submitted according to the usual practice by the promoters of the confraternities themselves. It was in this way that the tradition of Dominican authorship grew up. The first Bulls speak of this authorship with some reserve: "Prout in historiis legitur" says Leo X in the earliest of all. "Pastoris aeterni" 1520; but many of the later popes were less guarded.

Two considerations strongly support the view of the Rosary tradition just expounded. The first is the gradual surrender of almost every notable piece that has at one time or another been relied upon to vindicate the supposed claims of St. Dominic. Touron and Alban Butler appealed to the Memoirs of a certain Luminosi de Aposa who professed to have heard St. Dominic preach at Bologna, but these Memoirs have long ago been proved to a forgery. Danzas, Von Löe and others attached much importance to a fresco at Muret; but the fresco is not now in existence, and there is good reason for believing that the rosary once seen in that fresco was painted in at a later date ("The Month" Feb. 1901, p. 179). Mamachi, Esser, Walsh, and Von Löe and others quote some alleged contemporary verses about Dominic in connection with a crown of roses; the original manuscript has disappeared, and it is certain that the writers named have printed Dominicus where Benoist, the only person who has seen the manuscript, read Dominus. The famous will of Anthony Sers, which professed to leave a bequest to the Confraternity of the Rosary at Palencia in 1221, was put forward as a conclusive piece of testimony by Mamachi; but it is now admitted by Dominican authorities to be a forgery ("The Irish Rosary, Jan., 1901, p. 92). Similarly, a supposed reference to the subject by Thomas à Kempis in the "Chronicle of Mount St. Agnes" is a pure blunder ("The Month", Feb., 1901, p. 187). With this may be noted the change in tone observable of late in authoritative works of reference. In the "Kirchliches Handlexikon" of Munich and in the last edition of Herder's "Konversationslexikon" no attempt is made to defend the tradition which connects St. Dominic personally with the origin of the Rosary. Another consideration which cannot be developed is the multitude of conflicting legends concerning the origin of this devotion of "Our Lady's Psalter" which prevailed down to the end of the fifteenth century, as well as the early diversity of practice in the manner of its recitation. These facts agree ill with the supposition that it took its rise in a definite revelation and was jealously watched over from the beginning by one of the most learned and influential of the religious orders. No doubt can exist that the immense diffusion of the Rosary and its confraternities in modern times and the vast influence it has exercised for good are mainly due to the labours and the prayers of the sons of St. Dominic, but the historical evidence serves plainly to show that their interest in the subject was only awakened in the last years of the fifteenth century. [/quote]

[quote name='StColette' post='497380' date='Jan 20 2005, 09:53 AM']Even in 1883 Pope Leo XIII issued an encyclical in which he attributed the devotion of the Rosary to St. Dominic.[/quote]
The protection of the Church from error is affirmed only in regard to doctrines of faith or morals.

blovedwolfofgod
Posted

[quote name='justfran' post='497186' date='Jan 20 2005, 04:30 AM']
hmmm, so if Bl. Alan's account is not historical then exactly what bits of it do we take to be true? Are there any actualy primary sources of the apparitions to St Dominic?
I'll ask some of the ppl on EWTN about this, [i]they probably would have read heaps more about this that any of us here.[/i]
[/quote]

you'd be suprised by some of these phatmassers...

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...