Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

My Baptism -- Invalid?


Recommended Posts

Posted

I've been accompanying my mother to the Rite of Christian Initiation for Adults (RCIA), which is the process for entering the Roman Catholic Church. I've not yet told my mother or our priest that I've decided to leave Rome (but I have not been receiving any sacraments either), and I've been going with her to RCIA because she'd like me to. Last night, Father asked my mother and the other catechumen about their baptismal records (both have been baptized in other Protestant churches). My mother does not have a baptismal record (and neither did I), and the other catechumen is not sure if he can obtain his. Father then mentioned that if their baptismal records could not be obtained, they would have to receive conditional baptism -- that is, baptism on the condition that the first one wasn't valid -- in order to be sure that they have been validly baptized.

During my RCIA process, Father forgot to ask me for my baptismal records. He asked after I was confirmed, and I told him that I didn't have a baptismal record -- I was baptized by my grandfather, who is an elder in the Church of Christ. He told me that he didn't really know what to do in that situation, and that he would get back to me. He never did. When he didn't get back to me, I assumed that the situation had been resolved on his end and that everything was all right, and I didn't pursue it. So it was only last night, during my mother's RCIA class, that I began to wonder if the situation had ever really been resolved. I asked Father about it, and indeed he had simply forgotten about it -- it had not been resolved. At this point, one might be inclined to blame Father for, first of all, forgetting to ask about my baptismal records and, second, forgetting to resolve the situation afterward. However, one has to understand the circumstances here . . . my parish priest is incredibly busy, with a lot on his plate. We have no paid secretary, only a volunteer who comes in once in a while to help Father with the administrative end. Thus, he does pretty much all of the work for the parish -- the administrative, the liturgical, etc. Additionally, his mother is in a nursing home with Alzheimer's Disease. Things slip his mind easily, and justifiably so. I don't blame him for this, and neither should anyone else.

Father mentioned that my baptism would still be valid if I was baptized in the name of the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit (I was), if I was baptized with water (I was), and if the minister of baptism intended to do what the Church does. That's where things get iffy. Did my grandfather, who has no theological or ministerial training, intend to do what the Catholic Church does when he baptized me? Father told me that's why conditional baptism is often done in cases when records cannot be obtained or when catechumens were not baptized in a mainline denomination -- because the Church must be certain that the baptism was valid, and part of that is being certain that the intention was the same. What Father did not quite say, but what I expect to hear soon, is that I will have to receive conditional baptism and be confirmed, even though I was already confirmed on the Easter Vigil of 2003 -- if my baptism was not valid, and they cannot be sure that it was, then my confirmation would not have been valid either, since no sacrament can be received without first receiving baptism. It would also mean that my acceptance into the Church was not valid -- again, no one can be accepted into the Church without first receiving baptism. In other words, what this means is that even if my interior conversion was valid (and it was), my exterior conversion was invalid -- it is as if I have not been Catholic these two years.

Needless to say, this was all very shocking.

On the one hand, this would seem to be what I wanted. These past few weeks, I've been talking about leaving Rome to explore the other Christian faith traditions, because I'm not sure that I thought about my decision to become Catholic enough. What I've really wanted to do is undo my conversion -- make it as if it never happened, so that I can do it again, either in the Catholic Church or in some other community, the right way. The question, then, is this: Is God giving me what I wanted? By possibly making my whole exterior conversion invalid, by, in effect, undoing these two years of being Catholic -- is God letting me out so that I can do it the way I think I should have done it the first time? But on the other hand, now that I may not have really been truly Catholic these past two years, I almost feel a sense of loss. There is certainly a difference between rejecting the Catholic Church willingly and being unwillingly told that things didn't go right the first time, and they'll have to be done again. Now that I'm out, whether I like it or not, with no opportunity for readmission except conditional baptism -- it doesn't feel as good as I thought it was going to. That leads me to wonder if God allowed this to happen so that I would see how much I truly want to be Catholic, and how much of an impact not being Catholic would have on me if it were more than just my arbitary, immature twenty-year-old decision and were an actual reality that I can't easily escape through the sacrament of reconciliation.

So, on the one hand, this could be God giving me the opportunity to explore all of the faith traditions and decide which one is right for me, as I wanted to do. This could be God giving me the opportunity to start over again. On the other hand, this could be God giving me the opportunity to know how much I love the Catholic Church and want to be a part of it, and how hurt I am to find that I have not been a part of it and that I am not now a part of it, in reality instead of just by my immature and irrational decision-making. The problem is that I don't know which one God really has in mind -- is God giving me this opportunity to explore again, or is God giving me this opportunity so that I will know that I belong in the Catholic Church after all? I don't know how to discern what's happening here.

What I do know is that these things concern me, and what concerns me most of all is that my baptism may not be valid -- I may not be baptized, and I may not be Christian at all. That gives this whole thing a new sense of urgency. Before, I could take years to explore the other faith traditions and reach a conclusion. What was the hurry? I was baptized, I was a Christian -- I could still find union with God even if I died before reaching a decision on which faith tradition to belong to. But now -- what if my baptism is invalid? What if my grandfather didn't have the proper intention when he baptized me? What if I died tomorrow, without baptism? Call me old-fashioned, but I do believe that baptism is, under normal circumstances, necessary for salvation. On a more personal level, I believe with all my heart that it is necessary for my salvation.

There is another question plaguing me. Is my difficulty with Catholicism, and my difficulty with Christianity in general, a result of not being validly baptized? If I have not been baptized, then I don't have sanctifying grace. Without sanctifying grace, wouldn't it follow that I would have problems with Catholic Christianity? Wouldn't it be impossible to permanently accept any part of Christianity, let alone to live it, without sanctifying grace? This is not to say that I consider myself wrong about all of my opinions . . . but is my general problem with accepting Christianity a result of invalid baptism? I know that baptism isn't a magic formula that makes you a saint on contact -- I'm not a superstitious idiot. But I also know that baptism is the normal means of salvation, that it is the normal means of receiving sanctifying grace -- and that if my baptism was invalid, I do not have sanctifying grace, because unlike people in other parts of the world who baptism is not available to, it is readily available to me.

To make a long story short, I don't know what this all means. Any advice would be appreciated. E-mail me: nnelson323@aol.com.

[b]Update:[/b] I checked the [url="http://www.newadvent.org/"]Catholic Encyclopedia[/url], and it said this -- ". . . the Baptists use the rite only for adults, and the efficacy of their baptism has been called in question owing to the separation of the matter and the form, [i]for the latter is pronounced before the immersion takes place[/i]" (emphasis mine). Although the Church of Christ in which I was baptized is not a Baptist church, the form was pronounced before my immersion.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

You need to take it up with your priest while we pray for you.

Posted

I e-mailed you. Let me know if you don't get it.

Posted

You e-mailed me just now? I didn't get it.

Posted

[quote name='cmotherofpirl']You need to take it up with your priest while we pray for you.[/quote]
Well, yes, and I'm going to take it up with my priest. But I also value the advice of a lot of people here who have helped me before, and would like their advice again. I'm sure their advice will not oppose the advice of my priest, but complement it.

Posted

Get conditional baptised. It will only bring about good.

Posted

Wow. That is pretty heavy.

Based on what you have said I gather that you are unsure of the validity of Catholicism as Christ's One True Church. You seem certain in your faith in Christ. Regardless of your feelings for Catholicism you must be properly Baptised. All(well I guess there are excepetions) of Christendom is unanimous in the belief that it is necessary for salvation. [A good book on that cover the necessity of baptism is Stephen K. Ray's "Crossing the Tiber"]

I think that with that in mind you should go for a conditional baptism. Then see where you go from there. Sanctifying Grace is a very powerful thing. Pray for guidance. Be sure of your choice, then go from there.

As an aside, I think that God knows how to speak to each of individually. Sometimes He is subtle and sometimes not quite so. God may just be forcing your hand in this matter. He is forcing you to make a very difficult decision. God has often spoke to me through Mary. When I am going through difficult times or sorrows, she always seems to pop up. It encourages me to always seek to do what God wants as well as really helps me to feel God's love (which I have had difficulty feeling in the past). Others that I know seem to get "signs" (for a lack of a better word) in other ways. Be open God may be trying to tell you something.

I will be praying for you and asking for the intercession of Our Lady for you.

Posted

Hi Nate,

We don't always see eye to eye on things, but I've always liked you. I'll pray for you.

God bless,

Jen

Posted

If your baptism was not valid, I do imagine that it is to no fault of your own, and maybe it is your big stumbling block. Maybe God, in his all knowing ways, is indeed leading you to the Christian life, in such a way that you are actually a Christian (fully internal and external). It all maybe in god's plan and I do favor the idea. I don't think God would lead you away from Catholicism, and I think you may feel the same way too.

God bless,
Mikey

hyperdulia again
Posted

f you're leaving the Church, why does the Church's opinon of your baptism matter?

Posted (edited)

[quote name='hyperdulia again']f you're leaving the Church, why does the Church's opinon of your baptism matter?[/quote]
I don't know, but it does.

[b]Edit:[/b] I think it's because I'm not leaving the Church because I think it's wrong about everything or even about most things, but because I'm wondering if I was too hasty in my decision of choosing a denomination. Still, I have some level of trust for the Church that leads me to trust the Church on baptism, which after all was hers first and the Protestant churches' later (in the case of the Church of Christ, [i]much[/i] later). I think it would be senseless to say that a church that was founded in the nineteenth and twentieth centuries knows more about the sacrament of baptism (which they do not consider a sacrament -- they do not have sacraments) than the Catholic Church, which has existed for two thousand years, does. Thus, if the Catholic Church says that my baptism may be invalid, I'm inclined to believe that it may be invalid. And as I said in my post, this is all making me wonder if I should be leaving the Church.

Edited by Good Friday
Posted

you've been leaving the Church before hyper, i think you know.

anyway, I would say it is God reminding you how much you really do love the Catholic Church no matter how much some people in it anger you. Follow God's Will, I think you'll turn out great. I am particularly hopeful and confident that your planned study through the Early Church Fathers will be fruitful. If you make the decision to remain in the Church, I urge you like I did last time you were posting about progress into Catholocism: don't let fear be your motivator. You've too often left and told me that you were only in there out of an unhealthy fear of hell and peer pressure. Find God, find His Church, and if God Willing you truly do, undergo that conditional baptism and confirmation and then don't worry about whether any other sacrament you ever received was valid, take a clean slate and move forward with Christ.

I'm not going to sit here and tell you that all your troubles with Catholocism were the direct result of not being validly baptized. That'd be too easy, every Catholic struggles with Catholocism especially if they are converted out of something in which they used to be so harshly opposed to the Catholic Church. No one ever fully ceases to have trouble following Catholic Teaching, but it time you become a seasoned veteran of the battle against satan and you've seen it all, he can no longer intimidate you no matter what he throws at you, you'll always run right to the joy of Christ.

Posted

btw, i can't figure out your sig but i started thinking you might be refering to the graphic i made for you once? perhaps you have the url wrong or somethin? or perhaps it means something completely different that i dont understand. anyway, this is where the graphic i gave you before is [url="http://img.villagephotos.com/p/2004-9/837215/GFnathan2.JPG"]http://img.villagephotos.com/p/2004-9/837215/GFnathan2.JPG[/url]

Posted

[quote name='Good Friday' date='Jan 18 2005, 12:43 PM ']Did my grandfather, who has no theological or ministerial training, intend to do what the Catholic Church does when he baptized me?[/quote]
The person administering the sacrament of baptism doesn't have to have any theological training, nor does he have to believe in God, or in baptismal regeneration, or in the efficacy of the sacraments, etc.; instead, he simply has to have the intention (actual or virtual) to do what the Church does.

Additional posts on baptism from the "Questions and Answers about Catholicism" forum:

[url="http://phorum.phatmass.com/index.php?showtopic=27418&view=findpost&p=488801"]Another baptism question[/url]

[url="http://phorum.phatmass.com/index.php?showtopic=27461&view=findpost&p=490196"]Baptism question #2[/url]

[url="http://phorum.phatmass.com/index.php?showtopic=27395&view=findpost&p=488706"]Valid Baptism[/url]

God bless,
Todd

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Apotheoun' date='Jan 19 2005, 04:59 AM'] The person administering the sacrament of baptism doesn't have to have any theological training, nor does he have to believe in God, or in baptismal regeneration, or in the efficacy of the sacraments, etc.; instead, he simply has to have the intention (actual or virtual) to do what the Church does.

Additional posts on baptism from the "Questions and Answers about Catholicism" forum:

[url="http://phorum.phatmass.com/index.php?showtopic=27418&view=findpost&p=488801"]Another baptism question[/url]

[url="http://phorum.phatmass.com/index.php?showtopic=27461&view=findpost&p=490196"]Baptism question #2[/url]

[url="http://phorum.phatmass.com/index.php?showtopic=27395&view=findpost&p=488706"]Valid Baptism[/url]

God bless,
Todd [/quote]
That's certainly true, but it sounds like it may have been a defect in form rather than intention.

Edited by popestpiusx
Posted

I would think it would be very difficult to know your fathers intent and how he performed the baptism. However if he was a member of the Church of Christ, they believe in baptism as neccessary for salvation as I understand it. I am sure that he did it believing that it was what Christ intended though he may not have had a completely Catholic understanding of it. I would recommend conditional baptism myself but don't know that it is neccessary.

Brother Adam had a similar thread a week or so ago. In it I posted some things from St. Thomas Aquinas and others with regard to what intent means and who can validly baptize and who should be baptized. You might want to look that one over.

Also, I can look up what Amberose said on the issue in his Catechesis series. Regarding the Catechumen (which you are if you were baptized), he basically says not to worry to much about it. In those days martyrdom was a great concern but he assures the Catechumens that they are okay if they are martyred. This fits with todays teaching of the Church with regard to baptism of desire and blood etc. You are on the path and regardless of how you may or may not have been baptized that is what is important. Rest easy, stay on the path, trust in God and you will be fine.

Here is Brother Adams thread

[url="http://phorum.phatmass.com/index.php?showtopic=27419&hl=valid"]http://phorum.phatmass.com/index.php?showt...=27419&hl=valid[/url]

Here is the link to Aquinas who is about as authoritative as you can get and deals with these issues at great length.

[url="http://www.newadvent.org/summa/406808.htm"]http://www.newadvent.org/summa/406808.htm[/url]

If you have any questions on this ask and I will try to help by my understanding.

I will look up Amberose as well.

Hope that helps.

Posted

As I said, I think the possible defect is in form, not intention, in this case.

Posted

Something else to think about in your case. I would suggest you read Acts 10. It is about Cornelius and his family. He was the first Gentile convert to the faith. BEFORE he was baptized God was looking out for him and he was said to be "a God fearing and righteous man". God heard his prayer and sent Peter to him to give him the Gospel and be baptized. Peter said, "I see the gentiles are acceptable before God". Even if you were not baptized, God has been looking out after you and has heard your prayer. He has predestined you to be a member of his Church. I do not think it really matters whether you were Christian up to this point or not. The conditional baptism would be the recommended way to go from my perspective. But God wants you to be a part of his Church and in some sense at least you already are because your heart and desire is with the Church.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...