Apotheoun Posted January 19, 2005 Posted January 19, 2005 [quote name='popestpiusx' date='Jan 19 2005, 06:44 AM'] That's certainly true, but it sounds like it may have been a defect in form rather than intention. [/quote] Based on what he has related about his baptism there is no sign of a defect of form or matter. Clearly the priest needs to investigate the issues surrounding his baptism, but if the problem is simply missing records, that problem can be remedied by the testimony of a witness to the baptism, i.e., one or both of his parents, or others who may have been present. [quote name='Good Friday' date='Jan 18 2005, 12:43 PM']Father mentioned that my baptism would still be valid if I was baptized in the name of the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit ([b][i]I was[/i][/b]), if I was baptized with water ([b][i]I was[/i][/b]), and if the minister of baptism intended to do what the Church does.[/quote] God bless, Todd
Good Friday Posted January 19, 2005 Author Posted January 19, 2005 [quote name='Apotheoun']Based on what he has related about his baptism there is no sign of a defect of form or matter.[/quote] That's not entirely true. I did say that the Catholic Encyclopedia says that the Baptists' baptism is called into question because they separate matter from form (they pronounce the form BEFORE the immersion instead of DURING the immersion). I was not baptized Baptist, but I was baptized in the Church of Christ, which also separates matter from form -- the form was pronounced before my immersion. This is not definitive proof that my baptism was invalid, because the question of whether or not this separation of matter and form actually renders baptism invalid has not been definitively resolved; but it does call the validity of my baptism into question, and I would certainly prefer that there be no question. While I don't believe that I would be condemned to hell for not being validly baptized through no fault of my own (in that case I think baptism of desire would take place), I now know of the possible defect, and thus I am responsible for certainty that my baptism is valid. I could not have been held accountable for being invalidly baptized in my ignorance; I can be held accountable for remaining so in full knowledge.
hyperdulia again Posted January 19, 2005 Posted January 19, 2005 [quote name='Good Friday' date='Jan 19 2005, 12:36 AM'] [quote name='hyperdulia again']f you're leaving the Church, why does the Church's opinon of your baptism matter?[/quote] I don't know, but it does. [b]Edit:[/b] I think it's because I'm not leaving the Church because I think it's wrong about everything or even about most things, but because I'm wondering if I was too hasty in my decision of choosing a denomination. Still, I have some level of trust for the Church that leads me to trust the Church on baptism, which after all was hers first and the Protestant churches' later (in the case of the Church of Christ, [i]much[/i] later). I think it would be senseless to say that a church that was founded in the nineteenth and twentieth centuries knows more about the sacrament of baptism (which they do not consider a sacrament -- they do not have sacraments) than the Catholic Church, which has existed for two thousand years, does. Thus, if the Catholic Church says that my baptism may be invalid, I'm inclined to believe that it may be invalid. And as I said in my post, this is all making me wonder if I should be leaving the Church. [/quote] If you can recognize that the other denoms can hold error on something as basic as baptism, why even consider giving them charge of your Immortal Soul?
peach_cube Posted January 19, 2005 Posted January 19, 2005 I thought this quote from St. Teresa of Avila might be helpful (to the whole general situation) [quote]So dearly does He love our souls that He prevents them from rushing into things which may do them harm just at this time when He is anxious to help them. So he calls them to his side at once, and in a single moment reveals more truths to them and gives them a clearer insight into the nature of everything than they could otherwise gain in many years. For our sight is poor and the dust we meet on the road blinds us; but in contemplation the Lord brings us the end of the day's journey without our understanding how.[/quote]
Apotheoun Posted January 20, 2005 Posted January 20, 2005 [quote name='Good Friday' date='Jan 19 2005, 01:14 PM'] [quote name='Apotheoun']Based on what he has related about his baptism there is no sign of a defect of form or matter.[/quote] That's not entirely true. I did say that the Catholic Encyclopedia says that the Baptists' baptism is called into question because they separate matter from form (they pronounce the form BEFORE the immersion instead of DURING the immersion). I was not baptized Baptist, but I was baptized in the Church of Christ, which also separates matter from form -- the form was pronounced before my immersion. This is not definitive proof that my baptism was invalid, because the question of whether or not this separation of matter and form actually renders baptism invalid has not been definitively resolved; but it does call the validity of my baptism into question, and I would certainly prefer that there be no question. While I don't believe that I would be condemned to hell for not being validly baptized through no fault of my own (in that case I think baptism of desire would take place), I now know of the possible defect, and thus I am responsible for certainty that my baptism is valid. I could not have been held accountable for being invalidly baptized in my ignorance; I can be held accountable for remaining so in full knowledge. [/quote] The Catholic Encyclopedia is not an authoritative document of the Church's Magisterium; instead, it simply represents the opinions of the authors of the articles contained within it. I know of many converts to Catholicism from the Southern Baptist Convention and all of their baptisms were accepted as valid by the Church. Some of the concerns of older non-authoritative texts like the Catholic Encyclopedia are overly Scholastic in nature, and if taken to an extreme would lead to bizarre notions, including the idea that Eastern Catholic baptism, which is not done with the words "I baptize you in the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit," is somehow invalid because it doesn't conform to the Latin ritual. But since the Magisterium clearly accepts Eastern Catholic baptism, one must not take an overly Scholastic view of the issues involved in this question, nor should one assume that the Latin Rite is somehow normative for the practice of the faith and the administration of the sacraments. I don't think there is a problem with your baptism, but the decision about the validity or invalidity of your baptism should be left to the proper ecclesiastical authorities, i.e., your parish priest and the local Ordinary. God bless, Todd
Pio Nono Posted January 20, 2005 Posted January 20, 2005 JMJ 1/20 - Second Thursday 1.) Form - so long as he said, "I baptize you in the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit," you're fine. 2.) Matter - if he used water that flowed (a drop'll do ya), you're fine. 3.) Intent - intent is always assumed to be in line with the Church's intent unless it was manifestly otherwise.
homeschoolmom Posted January 20, 2005 Posted January 20, 2005 [quote name='Pio Nono' date='Jan 20 2005, 09:58 AM'] 2.) Matter - if he used water that flowed (a drop'll do ya), you're fine. [/quote] What does this mean, you can't use ice or steam?
ironmonk Posted January 21, 2005 Posted January 21, 2005 Bro, I just saw your post on asking me to read this. Thank you. It sounds like you already know what it means. I believe that the loss you feel is because you know that the Catholic Church is the right Faith, built by Christ. I do believe God is talking to you and showing you that you belong in His Church. Satan is very real and he will tempt you. He doesn't want you to be Catholic. If God is real, and He is, then there will be definite facts about Him. Christ built One Faith... There is One Way. Christ's way is the Catholic Church. Remember the story of the woman that was following the Apostles saying that they teach "a" way... she was rebuked because the Apostles didn't teach "a" way, they taught "The" Way. God calls out to all of us. This is why you know and feel the calling to Christ. It is the tempter that tries to subtly turn you for the right path. Sometimes something that was programmed into us long ago or over a long period of time that we want to be true, or that we where not raised in the Church properly (like me) makes it hard to be a good Catholic. Many other faiths are easy... things worth having take work on our part. We must work on our faith, piety, and knowledge of Christ's teaching in Scripture and Tradition. There will be things that we think are wrong because we don't understand them totally or we were 'programmed' wrong. Sometimes we must force ourselves to think differently. Sometimes our feelings get in the way of our responsibilities. We can almost always count on our feelings to change. With effort we can work on changing our feelings to the way we want to feel. This takes time... I did it. If I can do it, I think anyone can. I'm nothing special. It takes time and work on our part. Sometimes I want to just give up. I know that feeling will be temporary, so I continue through the motions and meditate on Scripture and the truths that I know... such as Fatima - more than 70,000 witnesses do not get away with a lie, so we know this has to be fact. St. Pio, a man that gave up everything, prayed without ceasing. St. Pio was once asked how many Rosaries he prayed a day, he said around 60. The miracles of St. Pio baffled scientists and doctors... he had thousands of witnesses. These things help my faith when I doubt. It's a slow process. This life is so short and we don't know if we'll live a day or seventy more years... it will be all for nothing if we do not make it to Heaven. I'm not going to go on what I think or what I want, I'm going to go on the wisdom of the Church that God left us to get me to Heaven. The truths about God can be compared to mathematics. Mathematics are exact, there are clear lines between the right way to find an answer and a wrong way when solving problems. As with God, God is factual, there are right and wrongs. One could say that those who don't know the truth will get graded on a curve, but those of us that do will have to pass the test straight up. Maybe at times that it's harder for you it could be because you are a great writer. Those who are great at writing tend to have a tougher time with mathematics, and vice versa... I'm not saying that you are bad at mathematics - just that you have a different way of thinking - I excel at mathematics and feel I'm a poor writer. That could explain some of our debates in the past and why I can't understand how you drew certain conclusions to my writings when I didn't mean it the way you took it, and vice versa. I will be Catholic until it can be proven wrong and another Church shown as the Church established by Christ because I want to be right. I'm saying this because I think this will help you in your journey. Catholicism isn't a destination, it's the vehicle that takes us to Heaven, because Heaven is the destination. There have been many times over the past few years that I've prayed asking God what He wanted of me. I begged for a sign. Something blatant. Something I would know without doubt. I prayed that I would not take action without a sign. So I was stagnating.... thinking I would never get a sign. Now, looking back, I think He gave me multiple signs, I was just to blind to see them. I believe the sign came from some people on this board - one of whom was you. Maybe the reason why you felt compelled to ask my advice with this is because God is telling you he wants you Catholic. God is calling to you. Sometimes from people you don't want to hear it from, sometimes from people you don't expect it from. Love in Christ & Mary, max
BLAZEr Posted January 21, 2005 Posted January 21, 2005 Good Friday, you know you're Catholic, stop running. You're gonna wear yourself out, boy. Be a horrible sinner, whatever, but please please stop pretending your not Catholic.
hyperdulia again Posted January 21, 2005 Posted January 21, 2005 it is so much simpler to accept the fact that the catholcism is inseperabe from one's self than to constantly try to apostasize, but just not be able to.
Neal4Christ Posted January 21, 2005 Posted January 21, 2005 [quote][b]I know of many converts to Catholicism from the Southern Baptist Convention and all of their baptisms were accepted as valid by the Church. [/b][/quote] That's what I wanted to know. Another question: suppose a baptism was invalid, but your priest judged it to be valid. Are we then held responsible for not demanding a conditional baptism? What about salvation? Is that in jepordy?
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now