Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

What was this picture taken of?


Pick which one is taking place in the picture  

93 members have voted

You do not have permission to vote in this poll, or see the poll results. Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Recommended Posts

Posted

[quote name='rufiokicks' date='Mar 1 2005, 04:19 PM'] It's not like they're grinding up on the altar or something. Maybe the mass is a bit much, but the perspective your getting is just a picture. It's not the whole parish, it's not the whole mass. It's one little clip. What's next? We shouldn't sing in church because it isn't necessary either? I think the complaints about dancing at mass are silly. It's just a form of expression. If you don't like it, don't participate. I do agree though, in this context it does appear to be a spectacle, but it's not like that at every mass that allows dance. [/quote]
Dancing during the liturgy like that takes the entire focus off of Our Lord and puts it on the moving figures of the girls on the "stage". Mass is not a performance. It's the worship of our Almighty and Everlasting God. We should be focusing all of our attention of Him, in His word and in the form of bread and wine in the Eucharist. This type of spectacle has taken the glory from God and transferred it to the congregation. And since when is the Mass a place for us to express ourselves? We are NOT the focus of the Mass.

If we don't speak up about these abuses, however "silly" some people think them, then it won't be long before the Mass becomes one giant concert. Is this what Jesus had in mind at the Last Supper? Or on the cross?

Duc_In_Altum
Posted

[quote]Dancing during the liturgy like that takes the entire focus off of Our Lord and puts it on the moving figures of the girls on the "stage". Mass is not a performance. It's the worship of our Almighty and Everlasting God. We should be focusing all of our attention of Him, in His word and in the form of bread and wine in the Eucharist. This type of spectacle has taken the glory from God and transferred it to the congregation. And since when is the Mass a place for us to express ourselves? We are NOT the focus of the Mass.[/quote]




Well said, Azaelia.^

el paz,

-Joe

Posted

Welcome to "anything goes" America. Where not even many of our churches operate the way they should. This is despicle. It just shows the selfish americans are bored with the silent sacredness that belongs at mass. so they replace it with dancing and entertainment. I've personally seen it and it makes me sick. That's not Catholic. It's Liberalathic.

StPiusVPrayForUs
Posted (edited)

Hey, as long as they are in "union" with Rome...

Just take a look at the stigma below my name here. The file name "noncatholic." Oh wow. Makes we want to leave my traditional community and join the Catholic Mahoney bandwagon.

Edited by StPiusVPrayForUs
Posted

i mean, why cant they just keep things the way they belong. why must the mass be shaped and altared to suit different peoples wants.

Posted

[img]http://www.recongress.org/2005/pix/ydlitb/med_MVC-0212S.jpg[/img]





:unsure:

St. Catherine
Posted

I bet they held hands during the Our Father too (another no, no.)
I have been to one mass that had liturgical dance. It was totally ridiculous. Ruined my whole experience for the weekend conference. :angry:

Posted (edited)

I'm sorry but dont the youth get enough entertainment at home? do they really need it at mass too? Usually mass is an escape from this evil world. It really stinks to see some people celebrating mass in a way that reminds us of the world. I'm just glad i found me a nice orthodox parishes that says mass in latin and is free of abuses., and the Priest is not affraid of speaking the truth.

Edited by MC Just
toledo_jesus
Posted

Where do we draw the line at criticizing our leaders? I think that Cardinal Mahoney has got to know what is right...so why is this happening?

Guest Eremite
Posted

toledo,

We need to exercise restraint when our pastors err. We should point out the unsuitability of this liturgical dance, because the practice of the Church is clear. However, we should not address Mahoney. Let God judge him as a man and as a Bishop.

Posted

[quote name='toledo_jesus' date='Mar 1 2005, 05:48 PM'] Where do we draw the line at criticizing our leaders? I think that Cardinal Mahoney has got to know what is right...so why is this happening? [/quote]
unforunately some of the american authorities in our church are a little confused about what is right and wrong. They break the rules then give wonderful little homilies about love.(Usually the same ol' homilies about love all the time) Then they wonder why catholics arent in the pews.

toledo_jesus
Posted

[quote name='Eremite' date='Mar 1 2005, 06:51 PM'] toledo,

We need to exercise restraint when our pastors err. We should point out the unsuitability of this liturgical dance, because the practice of the Church is clear. However, we should not address Mahoney. Let God judge him as a man and as a Bishop. [/quote]
ok.
I understand restraint.
So do we suffer through these errors, and hope not too many young Catholics are misguided? I mean, that seems like the only option here.

Posted

I have a confession to make.

There was a liturgical dancer at my baptism. I've heard the stories.

Guest Eremite
Posted

[quote]So do we suffer through these errors, and hope not too many young Catholics are misguided? I mean, that seems like the only option here.[/quote]

Well, we can bring to light the authentic Liturgical practice of the Church, we can explain why this is not allowed in (and disrespectful to) the Holy Sacrifice, we can write to Cardinal Mahoney if we feel it will help, etc. There's a lot we can do that doesn't involve foaming at the mouth against a Bishop.

toledo_jesus
Posted (edited)

[quote name='Eremite' date='Mar 1 2005, 08:02 PM']
Well, we can bring to light the authentic Liturgical practice of the Church, we can explain why this is not allowed in (and disrespectful to) the Holy Sacrifice, we can write to Cardinal Mahoney if we feel it will help, etc. There's a lot we can do that doesn't involve foaming at the mouth against a Bishop. [/quote]
well I hardly think anybody was foaming, but what can lay people do to influence a cardinal? It's a legitimate question. I could write a hundred letters and I don't believe one would make a difference to somebody so high-ranking.

Edited by toledo_jesus
Guest Eremite
Posted (edited)

toledo,

You have unlimited access to the King of Kings. If he can't get something done, noone can :D

ps: I was speaking generally, not about this thread.

Edited by Eremite
Mrs. Bro. Adam
Posted

[quote name='Cesar624' date='Mar 1 2005, 01:51 PM'] Who's to say what American culture is? Who's to say dancing isn't a part of it? Dancing plays a large role in my culture as in a matter of fact, so maybe that's why I see no problem with it. And no we're not at Mass to have fun - I know that - but what's wrong with having a little fun while worshipping God like ONCE in a blue? [/quote]
If ya wanna dance, become Penecostal.

Mrs. Bro. Adam
Posted

[quote name='rufiokicks' date='Mar 1 2005, 03:19 PM'] It's not like they're grinding up on the altar or something. Maybe the mass is a bit much, but the perspective your getting is just a picture. It's not the whole parish, it's not the whole mass. It's one little clip. What's next? We shouldn't sing in church because it isn't necessary either? I think the complaints about dancing at mass are silly. It's just a form of expression. If you don't like it, don't participate. I do agree though, in this context it does appear to be a spectacle, but it's not like that at every mass that allows dance. [/quote]
The Liturgy and Dancing:


[quote][i]Notitiae (Instructions for Sacraments and Divine Worship) Vol. XI, (1975) pp. 202-205 state:[/i]

"Dance has never constituted an essential part in the official liturgy of the Latin Church.  If local Churches have introduced the dance, at times even in the temples, this was on occasion of feasts in order to show feelings of jubilation and devotion.  But the dance always took place [b]outside the liturgical actions.[/b]  Conciliar decisions have often condemned the religious dance, as not befitting worship, and also beacuse it could degenerate into disorders...hence, it is not possible to introduce something of that sort in the liturgical celebration; it would mean bringing into the liturgy one of the most [b]desacrilized[/b] and [b]desacrilizing[/b] elements: and this would mean the same as introducing an atmosphere of [b]profanity[/b], which would easily suggest to those present [b]worldly places[/b] and [b]profane situations[/b]."[/quote]


That's from an official, infallible document. Meaning, there is to be no argument with it.




*Bold emphasis mine*

Micheal5403
Posted

[quote]I bet they held hands during the Our Father too (another no, no.)[/quote]

It is? :huh: Why?

MichaelFilo
Posted

IT's funny, this reminds me of a quote in a Marian apparition

"The bottom of hell is littered with the bones of bishops and priests"

God bless,
Mikey

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...